A/N: this chapter starts off with the killer and Rachel, you'll get a clue on who the killer is, and if he has anyone else (;
Disclaimer: I dont own glee.
Warning: sex, self-harm, and attempt of suicide.
"Why did you make me do that? Blaine was one of my best friends, let alone my best friends' boyfriend!" Rachel screamed at the figure in front of her as she entered the small hut deep within the woods.
"hey, it ain't my fault. Guy had it coming." The figure said as he pulled Blaine's body into the nearby room.
"Why the hell are you doing this anyway? It's me you want, so leave my goddamn friends alone." Rachel protested. "Besides, why are you keeping the bodies?"
"Because I have plans for them. Besides, it's fun to watch you suffer." The killer said to Rachel with a wink.
"Just please, don't harm Santana or Finn. They care about me the most."
"All the more reason to keep this game going." The Killer said, walking up to Rachel and setting their hands on her hips.
"You're so devious." Rachel whispered.
"But you love it." The Killer whispered before leaning in and capturing Rachels' lips in their own.
Santana started pacing furiously.
"no. no no no no no. This can't be happening! Can it? Finnocence, tell me this isn't happening!" she screamed.
"Santana, Santana calm down!" Finn tried to calm the Latina down.
"Never tell a girl to calm down Finn! I just learned that I have to have sex with Brittany in order to save her-not that I'd protest, I love ya Britt," Brittany smiled.
"Knowing that that jackass is watching!" Santana finished.
"Sanny, it's okay. We don't have to have sweet Lady times, it's alright." Brittany comforted the brunette.
"Britt you don't understand. If, if we don't have sex, you'll die." Santana explained.
The groups' thoughts were interrupted when they heard someone walking down the small pathway that led to the house.
"What the hell do you want Smythe?" Kurt snapped, still crying and seeking comfort in Mercades.
"Kurt, please calm down. I understand you're all under a lot of stress. I heard about what happened from Rose." Sebastian explained.
"How? How do you know?" Tina asked.
"My Uncle owns that Mansion." Sebastian pointed to said mansion.
"But why exactly are you here? Blaine's dead." Mike said just above a whisper so Kurt wouldn't get even more upset.
Sebastian slumped a little more hearing that fact. "I know. I want to help you guys."
"Wait a second," Puck started. "Remember Michael Jackson week? Santana went to Dalton to talk to Smythe about the slushy thing."
"And they ended up singing.." Tina started.
"Smooth Criminal." Santana and Sebastian said in unison.
"And the way we sang it seemed like we were trying to maul each others' clothes off." Sebastian added.
"So Brittany and Santana aren't supposed to have sex. It's supposed to be Santana and.." Quinn started.
"Sebastian." The whole group minus Sebastian said in unison.
"What the hell?" Sebastian asked.
"this killer guy said that we have to relieve the sexual tension in the group in order to save Brittany. We thought it was Santana and Brittany, but it seems to make more sense that you and Santana would have to do it." Finn stated, seeming more smart than usual.
"By when?" Sebastian asked.
"He didn't say."
"So wait, Santana and I have to have sex, in order to save the dullest crayon?" Sebastian stated.
There was a synchronization of nodding heads.
"All right. C'mon." Sebastian said, grabbing Santana's hand. Santana followed and the group began crying all over again, everyone hugging Brittany.
"Where are we? I haven't seen this room before." Santana asked, pulling off her top.
"This is my room. My uncle lets me stay here whenever." Sebastian responded, pulling off his pants. "You sure you're okay with this? I know you're a lesbian and all."
"I have to do this in order to save Brittany." Santana told him.
"All right. Just pretend I'm whichever girl you want wearing a strap on." Sebastian said, making Santana laugh.
As soon as Sebastian entered Santana, the lights went out. Santana felt a warm breath on her chest, then she felt Sebastian ripped out of her and she heard him scream.
"Sebastian!" she called out, no answer. The lights flicked on and Santana rushed to find her clothes.
(happening the same time as the Sebastian/Santana scene)
"What do you thinks gonna happen?" Mercades asked.
"I don't know." Quinn replied, snuggling into Puck.
The group had made their way into the living room in the mansion. The lights flicked off and was followed by Sebastian screaming, which was followed by Santana.
"Sebastian!" She screamed.
"Sounds like they're having fun." Finn relieved the tension somewhat.
The lights flicked on and Santana ran down the stairs, frantically trying to button her jeans.
"have fun?" Puck asked.
"the lights flicked off and he was ripped from inside of me." Santana searched the room. "Where's Britt?" She asked, scared.
"Bathroom." Mercades said warily.
"You dumbasses left her alone?" Santana screamed and ran to the bathroom. She opened the door and saw her best friend, lying on the ground with a knife through her chest, lifeless.
"NO!" Santana screamed and fell to her knees. The group soon followed her and instantly began crying. Santana picked up the note and read aloud.
"'your attempt at relieving the sexual tension was not good enough for me. You thought it was Sebastian and Santana? You were right the first time. I have added young Warbler to my clan, the one with young Rachel Berry. 6 down. 11 to go. Here's the riddle:
I have not revealed myself yet, nor have I revealed clues. Clue #1 says that you do know me, and that I have had interaction with you all. I have taken one cheerleader, number 2 is next to join your friends. If you do wish to save her, and do not want your fashionista to actually join them along with her, they must share a duet with the song of Rachel's choice: For Good. Rachel said that she and Kurt sang this in New York, am I correct? If you do not please my beauty with your duet, both of you will join your disabled, trouty mouth, songless, irish, blond, and slicked hair friends. Be warned, you have a traitor amongst you.' The fuck does this mean?" Santana said in between cries. She shoved the note into Kurt's hands and ran out.
Santana had had enough. She ran all the way to the cliff, which was to the right of the mansion. She wanted to end this; to end it all. She had lost Brittany, if they didn't sing good enough she'd loose Quinn, and she may loose Rachel. She was loosing herself.
"Why are you making me go through this? What's the point? I know you're watching me, so tell me, why are you putting me through this?" Santana screamed.
No Answer.
"If you wanted me to have sex with a girl, you should've just given me Rachel! I would have gladly given myself to her!" Santana screamed again.
No Answer.
Santana had enough. She pulled the razor from her pocket and dragged it across her wrist.
"Is this what you want Rachel?" She screamed, and dragged the razor across her wrist once more.
"Fine!" Santana screamed and approached the edge. She looked over the edge and saw the water. One jump and the pain would be gone. She'd join Brittany, and Quinn and Rachel would follow soon after. She would be happy.
"I suppose you should hear my amazing voice once more." Santana decided before singing.
"Don't know why
I'm surviving every lonely day
When there's got to be
no chance for me
My life would end
And it doesnt't matter how I cry
My tears of love a waste of time
if I turn away
Am I strong enough to
see it through?
Go crazy is what I will do
If I can't have you
I don't want nobody, baby
If I can't have you, uh-huh, ah
If I can't have you
I don't want nobody, baby
If I can't have you, uh-huh, ah
Can't let go
And it doesn't matter how I try
I gave it all so easily
to you my love
To dreams that never
will come true
Am I strong enough to
see it through?
Go crazy is what I will do
If I can't have you
I don't want nobody, baby
If I can't have you, uh-huh, ah
If I can't have you
I don't want nobody, baby
If I can't have you"
Santana looked over the edge one last time, dragging the razor across her wrist the entire time she sang.
"I love you Rachel."
She jumped, not knowing that Rachel was watching.
A/N: mwahaha. This was really hard to write, but I just had to. Song Used was If I Can't Have You by Barry Gibb. I just loved the way Santana sang it in Saturday Night Glee-ver, so I had to put It in this :p
Kill Counter:
Killed:
Artie Abrams
Sugar Motta
Sam Evans
Rory Flanagan
Blaine Anderson
Brittany S. Pierce
Missing:
Rachel Berry
Sebastian Smythe