A/N: the title was too long, but it's called: I Threw My (Ex)Girlfriends Engagement Ring Down A Well, And Now She Hates Me
"Can you hear me?" Silence. And then,
"Yeah." Her voice echoed back to him.
Finn felt his hands burning from the rope, his fingers slipping slowly as he felt himself losing his grasp. "Oh." Finn mumbled out as he tried to catch the rope before it fully fell through his fingers.
A shriek. And then,
"Are you trying to kill me?" Her voice vibrated off the stone walls, the melody of it reaching his ears.
"Sorry." He called out to her. He lowered the rope further down the well, smiling to himself as He listened to the lovely tune Rachel was singing. Her angelic voice filling the gaping hole that happened to have her in it. He decided to sing along, their voices meshing together.
She stopped suddenly. And then,
"What are you doing?" She asked him.
He didn't know how to respond. Can't a guy, even one as tone deaf as him, get to sing a beautiful song with his girlfriend, sorry, ex-girlfriend, while she's climbing down a well looking for her engagement ring that he might have thrown in there, during a fit of rage because the love of his life was rambling on and on about her new fiance? Sheesh.
"Sorry." Finn said again. "I just-" He paused. "It's our song, you know?"
More silence. And then,
"Not anymore."
She's right. It's their song now. "Rach?" He said softly. He waited. For a second, he thought she didn't hear him, and then.
"Yeah." Her voice came out quietly, so quiet he could barely hear her.
"I miss you." Nothing. Complete silence. And then,
she went back to singing their song.
His smile coming back as he softly sang with her.