The song "Shake It Out" by Florence and the Machine began to play. The lights came up slowly on what appeared to be the hallway in the back of a stage. In front of a dressing door stood Sam Winchester, dressed in a tux and looking anxious. Dean Winchester stood in front of a similar door slightly down the hall, dressed in similar attire and filled with anticipation. They each held a bouquet of roses; they wanted everything to be perfect. The doors they stood in front of had stars on them. They each knocked on their respective door; it opened, and a look of sheer rapture came across their faces. Jessica was on the other side of Sam's door, looking more beautiful than she ever had before in a lovely lace gown. She leapt into Sam's arms as he began to cry joyfully. On the other side of Dean's door stood Kassie, dressed to the nines. With tears in his eyes, Dean held her and they kissed.
Once they're finished with her initial hellos, Sam took Jessica by the hand and Dean held Kassie's hand as the four of them walked down the hall. They stopped in front of another door with a star on it and knocked. The door was open by the Winchester's mother and father Mary and John. The boys rushed into the arms of their parents, embracing them as they had never embraced anyone before. Soon they were introducing both their parents to their girlfriends. Now the happy group had one more door to stop in front of, which was just a little further down the hall. Bobby stood behind the door with his wife Karen, who was killed so long ago. Once again everyone hugged. Everyone was dressed up, even Bobby. Next Cas beckoned to group to a stairway. He led the happy group up the stairwell and through a trap door. As the music transitioned, the trapdoor led up to a bare stage out in the middle of the Milky Way.
The group stood in amazement looking all around them, surveying the surroundings. It was like standing in the middle of the most intense, most magnificent fireworks display that any of them could've ever imagined, with stars and comets whirling around them. Any mere mortal would have been fricasseed; but for these godlike individuals, it was completely safe for them to drink in the majesty of the scene. Each man kissed and caressed the woman that he loved as the lights danced behind them in the distance. They could all see Earth. With their infinite vision they could see a juxtaposition of all of the people that they had loved and all the people that they have saved, peaceful and safe, frozen in time on October 31, 2005…the date Sam and Dean began hunting together as adults.
They saw images of Ellen Harvelle and Ash talking in the Road House while Jo Harvelle listened to her favorite song on the juke-box. Adam Milligan was ecstatically hugging his mom because he just found out he would be inheriting a classic Chevy Impala from his long lost father. Meg Masters was shopping at the mall with her sister, for she had not yet been possessed by any demons.
On the mystical stage in the center of the galaxy, a lovely Latino female angel materialized, who was Castile's part-time companion in Heaven. All the couples danced…even Bobby, who wasn't a very good dancer. The brothers each took a turn dancing with their mother. Then they lifted their girlfriends off the ground and twirled them around. All the men removed their dress jackets. Everyone goofed off and had fun.
Thanks to Dean's doing on Earth, Lisa and Ben Braeden were having breakfast with Lisa's attentive new boyfriend, which both of them liked. Thanks to Sam's influence, Chuck Shurley and Becky Rosen were snuggling on the couch watching a movie. Sheriff Jody Mills was at the park with her healthy son and husband. Frank Devereaux was safe, as well as Kevin Tran and Pamela Barnes. All the other people the brothers had saved or failed to save weren't in danger at this point; and all the monsters were as the humans, frozen in time indefinitely.
Sam, Dean and Cas began to slam dance; eventually John and Bobby joined in. Soon John and Bobby locked arms and began to dance the Dosey Doe. All of them were laughing and enjoying themselves and singing along to the music. Eventually Cas indicated that it was time to leave, to go on another magnificent adventure somewhere out in the depths of space. Each of the men took their mate by the hand and nodded to Cas that they were ready. A comet passed by the imaginary camera in space, in front of the stage. Once the comet was gone, everyone from the stage had disappeared. As the song ended, the stage faded from view.