Summary: Matt is a powerful angel; Tai is a human. Matt has kidnapped Tai from Earth and taken him to the angel-kingdom where he intended to rape Tai. But Matt felt guilt and couldn't rape Tai in the beginning. Things changed as Tai became interested in another male-angel and angered Matt. Now Matt isn't going to let guilt stop him from taking what he wants…
Hi guys! Here's another installment of Wouldn't It be Nice to Choose. I still haven't told Sierra that this RP is up as a fic on – I have accepted that I'm a bad person… : (. But she still gets due credit because she wrote the uke character (Tai).
So Sierra wrote as Tai. Flame (me) wrote as Matt.
Tai's blood ran cold as he was pinned by the stare. His body went frigid and his heart began to beat faster and faster. The human knew that he was in danger even as the words that he barely understood rushed over his body and caused him to shiver in fear. The look on Matt's face was pleasant, his smile was disarming and his eyes filled with a cold rage.
Tai knew that he had done something very, very wrong with the growing fear he felt and the anger coming from Matt in thick waves. Was he was grabbed and tossed, he froze, eyes widening in complete fear as the angel removed his own tunic-lean muscles now on display and began to untie the string holding his pants up.
The human's body was taunt, tense, breathing uneven gulps of air, his chest easing. "Matt?" He whispered, slowly sitting up. "Why mad?" Each word was slow and measured the best that he could. His mind and body told him to run while Matt undressed, but he could barely move. "Matt?" He tried again and scooted to the edge of the bed, slowly moving to stand up and run once he got the chance.
O.O.O.O.O
Matt smirked as he heard the confused terror in Tai's voice. He shook his head, laughing lightly – amazed that the brunette honestly did not seem to understand why Matt might be upset. "So stupid… It's not just the language barrier that's keeping you from understanding… Never mind though. You have your lovely, lovely face..." His eyes drifted over those beautiful, delicate features – the barely controlled hysteria was obvious in those dark eyes but Matt ignored it.
His grin widened as he saw Tai try to stand up from the bed – the little brunette actually thought Matt was going to go away. "It seems I have spoilt you too much – I gave you respect and you threw it back in my face. Now it's time to see how angels really treat their slaves."
Lightning fast, he wound an arm around Tai's waist and threw him back onto the bed, this time covering the slender body with his own heavy frame. His strong fingers ripped through Tai's tunic, pushing aside the tattered clothing. "You're still wearing too much, beautiful...," he murmured into Tai's neck. The pants were off just as fast, the material giving away after just a few little tugs.
O.O.O.O.O
An arm was around his waist and then he was thrown back, his body pinned to the bed by Matt's weight an his clothes ripped from his body. Small scratches littered his body with each press of Matt's fingers against the material, ripping and tearing until nothing was left. Tears stung his eyes as he wiggled and pushed against the angel's weight, trying to push him off.
"Stop!" He cried out, thrashing and bucking as much as he could. "Stop! No want! No want!" The human was wailing now, tears cascading down his face and voice a loud cry. A plea. In another time it might have been possible for him to enjoy Matt's weight pushing and pinning him down-now, now he was hysterical with his screaming and crying. Chocolate eyes were blinded by tears, his vision blurred but the icy blue of Matt's eyes was still noticeable.
O.O.O.O.O
Matt ignored Tai's struggling as if it meant nothing – instead his hands forced those slender thighs apart so he could slide in between them comfortably. "Ahh… just where I was meant to be," he grinned. He was already aroused; his pants hung loosely around his hips & his already dripping arousal poked out through the fly to grind against Tai's quivering thigh.
"Truth be told love – all this thrashing around you're doing is quite irritating," he murmured as he used the shreds of Tai's discarded clothing to tie those slender wrists together and pushed the brunette's arms up above his head so they were useless. "Not nearly as irritating as those tears though." He muttered as he stared into deep brown eyes – shimmering with tears. Even now, a small part of him reasoned with him to try to understand – but he found this time he could easily drown that voice with lust and anger. "But cry as much as you like sweetheart… tonight, there's no escape."
With that he lowered his mouth to maul those sweet lips – tongue forcing its way inside. A long few minutes later, he was pulling away to nibble his way down that delicately curved jaw, biting roughly at the throat and then travelling even lower down until he pulled a dusky nipple in between his teeth and then settled into a gentle suckling motion.
O.O.O.O.O
Tai fought harder once his thighs were pried apart and the feel of Matt's thick and very erect cock pressed against his thigh. His entire body was shaking. His voice nothing more than a whimper as his tears fell faster and faster. The angel was pressed against him with his lean body between his thighs-Tai really had no chance for escape any longer. If Matt really wanted this...it would happen.
He was trapped! With his hands tied and above his head and his body pinned by Matt's weight..he was trapped in a nightmare. Tai sucked in a deep, shuddering breath. Once harsh lips meet his own, he closed his eyes and willed away his tears. There was no way that he would give Matt his tears along with his virginity. A tongue was shoved into his mouth and ravaged his own tongue and pallet, tasting him and violating his mouth. He wanted to bite him..but he wasn't sure if Matt would hit him as well as violate him.
Bile rose in his throat as he was forced into a long and bruising kiss. Saliva pooled from the corner of his mouth as Matt pulled away from their kiss and and mouthed at his jaw. Tai tried to pull away from his kisses and bites. Pain blossomed in on his throat with every possessive and claiming kiss, marks left inn their wake. Without his want, Tai's body arched and a sharp moan left his bruised lips before he could stop himself, the bite made his body jerk, once a dark nipple was caught and sucked. "Stop," he tried again, trying to shift away from the sucking.
O.O.O.O.O
Matt's arousal throbbed as soft little moan left Tai's throat. Obviously involuntary & unwanted. But it brought a satisfied smirk to Matt's lips and he renewed his efforts on the other nipple. "You may not want this baby…," he said as he laved his tongue around the tiny nub. "But your body is going to sing for me to claim it."
His hands traced their way down that smooth dark skin – it was flushed hot from the brunette's struggles. Matt idly noticed that Tai wasn't thrashing around anywhere near as much as before – his body was still quivering with unwanted desire and fear. But the tears had ebbed and instead there was a determined strength in his demeanor. Matt smiled – as angry as he was, he was still rather impressed with the small show of defiance. "Ahh… perhaps you have some spirit after all, sweetheart. Not that it makes up for the rest of your problems…"
He kissed his way down the flat stomach, laving the navel with his saliva and then regretfully pulling away to give the brunette a moment's rest. Silently, he dipped his fingers into a bag of salve he always kept at his bedside and then pulled his pants off to completely free his erection. Finished, he once again took his rightful place in between those long brown legs.
"I don't want to hurt you, love," he murmured, kissing his way back up to Tai's bruised mouth. His hand found their way in between Tai's thighs and then he was encircling the tiny pucker with his slicked fingers. His heavy arousal rocked against the brunette.
O.O.O.O.O
Tai bit his bruised bottom lip and squeezed his eyes shut as he tried to keep in another moan from having his other nipple sucked. In the times that he did bring himself off to release via his left hand, he had found out very early on that his nipples were sensitive and he did enjoy playing with them himself. What he hated..was the fact that Matt would now know that because, despite his best efforts, he couldn't hold in the whimpers or stop himself from arching into Matt's sucking.
Every line that was created from the angel touching his skin was like fire filling his veins and making his already flushed body hot. His cheeks were tined a dark pink and his chest heaving with every breath he took in. The human's lips hurt, throbbed and bruised from the kisses he had been forced into. What hurt him the most was the fact that his body did enjoying this. His body wanted him to want this and his mind screamed rape.
Soft lips trailed down his body and made a brighter and more potent flame build just beneath his already too-hot skin. Each kiss and touch made his cock fill more and more, until he was half-hard and ashamed for his arousal.
He had only a moment without a touch from the angel before the angel was right back to where he was before. As he was kissed, his body clenched, tightened, drumming with fear so palpable he was sure he could taste it. A finger was touching his quivering entrance, ready to breach him and force him open for the angel about to rape him. "STOP!" He screamed and tried to twist his wrists out of the binds around them. "STOP," he cried out and pushed himself back into the back, away from the finger and the thick cock pressing into him-ready to open him up. "STOP! Please," because he was so close to begging in every language he knew if Matt would just stop!
O.O.O.O.O
"Stop…?" Matt asked with a smirk – holding the delicate chin in one hand so that Tai was forced to look at him. "Why should I? Why should I care about what you want when you are so ready to throw my efforts back into my face?" He wanted a real answer but didn't expect one as he lowered his mouth down to kiss Tai again.
Then he sliding down the slender body until he reached Tai's arousal, pleased to see that no matter how much the brunette might hate this, his body wanted Matt. But is that enough… Didn't you want to see that beautiful smile again? Matt viciously pushed those useless thoughts out of his head – he was never again going to let guilt stand in the way of his desire. Especially not when it came to this weak, ungrateful human. Good for nothing but the dark hole in between his legs that waited to be filled with Matt's long, hard dick.
He pushed doubt of his head and took his time to nibble at the tendons at the junction between Tai's inner thighs and groin, laving his small balls and then taking the slender cock in between his lips. Simultaneously, he pushed one finger into the tiny hole – oh god… it's so tight… It wouldn't be possible unless … unless Tai was a virgin.
He paused for a second from sucking Tai's cock. "Are you untouched sweetheart? No other man has had you before?" He asked even though he already knew the answer. Eagerly, he pushed the finger deeper inside before adding a second, wiggling them around. His dick was throbbing in anticipation. He would be the first to feel that incredible silky heat pressing all around him. What incredible luck!
O.O.O.O.O
Wide chocolate eyes looked into blue as his chin was caught and he was forced to look up. He tried to pull away from the kiss, his struggling renewed with the kiss and the feeling of Matt's finger pressed against his entrance.
Nibbling caught his attention as he forced himself to blank his mind and not think of what was happening to him now that he was free of the kiss. Tai's thighs were jumping, shaking with each slight bite into his skin and lick to his balls. A shudder of pure pleasure wracked his body as his cock was taken into Matt's hot and wet mouth. A groan left his mouth and his thighs fell a part as the finger rubbing him pushed inside of him. There was no pain, just an immense discomfort that he tried to wiggle away from.
A question was asked and he defiantly glared down at the angel, refusing to answer even if he knew what was asked of him. He whimpered as a second finger forced it's way inside of him. Pain laced up his spine and he arched from the bed, trying to worm his way up the bed and away from the questing fingers inside of him. "Stop," panting he hissed and bit into his lip again. This is not how he imagined his first time. It wasn't that he had imagined it to be full of romance and soft kisses..but never rape. He at least wanted to enjoy his first time!
O.O.O.O.O
"Oh no you don't," Matt growled, using his much heavier frame to pin Tai firmly into the bed as the brunette tried to draw away from him. "You're not getting away so easy. Not this time." Still it was not his intention to hurt the brunette – he was already quite large at 8' and very thick.
He renewed his efforts in sucking the brunette's cock, letting his free hand drift up to rub a thumb against one of those stiff nipples. He hoped it would be enough to distract the brunette from the feeling of a third finger breaching him. Once all three were inside, he started scissoring motions – stretching the passage so that Tai would be able to accommodate him with the least possible discomfort. "I'm going to make you enjoy this," he promised with a smirk, as his long fingers brushed a spongy spot inside that tiny passage that Matt knew would soon bring Tai to screaming pleasure. He gently brushed the spot again – finally satisfied that he had prepared the brunette enough, he pulled his hand away and settled himself again so that they were once again laying chest to chest.
His dick now rocked against those round globes and then pressed against the tiny entrance. "Remember this, sweetheart?" He asked, rocking his hips back and forth so his arousal just pushed against the entrance without quite breaching. "We were here before – but there's no stopping this time."
O.O.O.O.O
Hips arching from the bed and into Matt's mouth, Tai groaned and let his head fall back for a moment. The feeling of a mouth wrapped a sucking on him was amazing-he had never known that pleasure before. Even if his family was alright with him being only interested in males, they had still wanted him to keep pure for his future relationship. He had been all too happy to accommodate that thought. The human never really had any interest in spoiling himself before he found a person that he really wanted to be with and give himself to.
His nipple was being rubbed as his cock sucked and he knew that the damned angel was trying to distract him. His thrashing had subsided by now and now his body was pushing up and trying to get more of the pleasure that Matt was bringing him. The angel seemed to know what he was doing as he added a third finger, Tai barely noticed and only realized that his ass was being spread open more once the fingers scissored inside of him.
Suddenly, Tai's eyes were wide and he was shouting in pleasure, writhing and pushing against the fingers inside of him. His cock twitched in Matt's mouth as his pants grew louder and his hips pushed as much as they were allowed. A whimper left him as that spot was pressed against again.
Soon, a lean chest was pressed against his own and the fingers pulled out of him. Matt's thick cock slid and rocked between the globes of his ass and teased him, pressing against his twitching entrance. With every push of the blunt but wide head of his cock against his entrance, more and more fear grew. He just wanted him to get over with it! Fuck him already because he hated the waiting more than anything else. Tai turned his head and closed his eyes, breathing in a shaking breath and letting a few tears fall as he waited.
O.O.O.O.O
"Look at me, sweetheart," Matt murmured, keeping his voice as gentle and soft as he could. Even as entitled as he felt in doing this… even though this was his right, he still hated seeing tears in those beautiful eyes. But the feeling of that slender body lying so helpless underneath him was just too much, legs spread wide open to accommodate him. Tai was meant for him – that he was sure of.
He kissed Tai softly, nibbling at the swollen lips as the head of his dick pushed into the tiny passage. That heat! It had been incredible around his fingers but this was nothing like he had felt before. Groaning in lust, he thrust his hips shallowly, forcing himself to keep his pace slow in order to not tear Tai. His tongue found its way into Tai's mouth again, unconsciously following the same thrusting rhythm of pushing inside and pulling back out as his lower body. It was hard to keep from just pounding Tai straight into the bed – but that would come later. Instead, he focused his attention on angling his slow thrusts so that his arousal pushed against that tiny spot inside Tai again.
"Do you like?" He asked in simple Anglerian with a small smirk, as he finally managed to push his full 8' inside the brunette. He settled his hips into slow and deep thrusting, pulling himself out all the way before pushing back inside. "Ahh… godss…" he groaned again, roughly suckling at the long dark neck as he threaded one arm under Tai's knee to lift the leg up so he could penetrate even deeper.
O.O.O.O.O
He refused to look at the angel even as he was kissed softly, his bottom lip nibbled on while the head of Matt's cock pushed inside of him. Tai cried out, his tears coming faster and his body tensing. Pain raced through him as he pulled away from the kiss and whimpered. His eyes were clenched shut and his body was now forced to relax as the angel kept pushing and pushing into him. He was kissed again, the angel's tongue now in his mouth and thrusting the same way as his cock.
Each push inside of him brushed that spot that made him cry out before and lessen the pain. There was a constant whimper that he couldn't stop himself from making. Tears were leaking down his face as he lay through being penetrated for the first time.
Raped for the first time.
The first real thrust inside of him, Matt's cock brushing against his walls and pushing back inside of him to claim that spot, made him shiver and moan to in pleasure-sucking in a harsh breath and trying hard not to moan again. There would be a a spot on his neck once Matt was done with him. A gasp left him as his knee was lifted and Matt slid even deeper inside of him, nudging that spot and making him push his hips into the angel's own.
O.O.O.O.O
"Gods… you make a lovely picture…," Matt muttered as he stared down at Tai. The brunette joggled on the bed helplessly from the force of the thrusts – his head was thrown back in ecstasy, those slender hands clenched at the sheets above his head. Matt frowned, annoyed that Tai refused to look at him. It was not Tai's right to decide that – Matt had claimed him and Tai would acknowledge it. With his free hand, he grasped the brunette's jaw and forced him to turn his head back so that he was looking into deep chocolate eyes as he claimed Tai for himself.
Matt couldn't keep the triumphant smirk off his face as he felt Tai lift his hips up, inadvertently spreading his legs wider so that Matt had even better access. "Ahh… what did I tell you sweetheart? Your body will begin to crave this…," he promised as he picked up the momentum of his thrusts, plowing over and over into that bundle of nerves. The pressure was incredible – the tiny passage was undulating all around him, sucking his cock in deeper and deeper. Knowing that he was almost ready to release his load, he released Tai's jaw and snaked the freed hand to the brunette's arousal, stroking it to force even more pleasure into his beautiful prisoner.
O.O.O.O.O
His head was turned but his eyes remained closed for several long seconds before he dared to look into blue eyes. Within blue eyes he saw the triumph in claiming him. He saw the lust and nearly insatiable want that the angel had for him and he stared back. Glared back in nothing but defiance even as tears slipped from the corners of his eyes and his hips rutted against the angel's.
The thrusts grew in force, the pleasure more powerful as he was fucked into and forced to feel everything that the angel wanted to give him. Tai clenched around the angel and pushed his hips into the hand now around his full arousal. Each touch of that spot inside of him drove him closer and closer towards and orgasm that he didn't want. He grit his teeth and refused to moan and groan, show his pleasure from the abuse that spot was taking or from the pleasure swelling in his cock.
O.O.O.O.O
Those eyes… So much anger in those beautiful eyes. It somehow made them even more startlingly beautiful and sent a jolt of pure pleasure into his dick. He knew he could not last – not with the heat squeezing him so tightly. He was thrusting at top speed now and stroking Tai off at the same rate– his hips pistoned in and out, the head now pounding that spongy spot with every thrust in. He was sure neither of them could last much longer – not with the way Tai was letting out those soft, reluctant and incredibly sexy moans.
And then the knot in his stomach untied itself and he knelt down to take Tai's lips in a final bruisingly possessive kiss as he released deep inside the brunette – aiming so that his release directly stimulated Tai's prostate as he claimed the last vestiges of his innocence. Then he let himself collapse on top of Tai's slender body – his weight pushing Tai's frame deep into the soft piles of fur underneath them. He buried his face in the junction between his new lover's neck and shoulder, easily nibbling the sinews as his hands ran up and down Tai's thighs.
O.O.O.O.O
Tai let out a loud cry as the thrusting grew harder and harder and more and more sparks of pleasure raced up and down his spine. He let go at that moment, eyes slipping shut and hips arching into Matt. He pushed back, riding out the angel's thrusts and moaning with each push into his spot. Hot tears spilled from his eyes as he tightened around the angel's thick cock and for once kissed back while he was possessed with lips and tongue.
The pleasure grew to be too much and long ropes of white release shot from his cock and coated his chest in four strings. He came with a whimper and pulled back once he realized what he had done. Tears began to blur his sight of his now open eyes as he stared at the ceiling of his forced home. Matt was on top of him now, pinning him as he nibbled at his neck.
"I hate you," he told him in his language, closing his eyes as the weight of what had just happened crashed down on him.
O.O.O.O.O
Matt may not have understood exactly what Tai had just said. But the despair in his voice and the tears glittering at the corner of those deep eyes left little doubt that the brunette was devastated. Matt sighed – this was expected, ofcourse. He had hoped however that the physical pleasure might blind Tai from the rest of the situation.
"You're angry," he said in simple Anglerian, hoping Tai would understand him. He could try to placate him – try to make him feel better. But he had showed respect for Tai's feelings in the past and it had gotten him nowhere. Matt found he had very little guilt remaining once he reminded himself of the smile on Tai's face as he talked about Raeson. "Get used to it," he muttered nonchalantly as he ground his hips against Tai.
"I'm going to take you again," he said, as he turned Tai's face towards him again, running his thumb over a swollen red lower lip. In a show of tenderness, he brushed silky soft brown strands away from Tai's face and then pressed a kiss to his forehead. "Are you hurt?" He asked softly, genuinely concerned about his new lover's state – he had been as careful as he could possibly be. And in all likelihood, Tai would not tell him even if he was hurting… but Matt would still give it a shot.
O.O.O.O.O
Tai didn't answer him. He continued to lay under him and stare at the ceiling. His skin was covered in sweat and his heart clenched in pain as silent tears fell onto the fur beneath them. He swallowed thickly and took in the scent of the room, nothing but sex. "Get away from me," was all the human could say in a raspy voice.
The grinding of Matt's hips against his own made him feel nauseous. Why wasn't the angel pulling out of him? Isn't that what happened after sex? He knew that was what happened...but why wasn't he? He wouldn't be so cocky that he would stay inside of him all night...would he?
Chocolate eyes narrowed as a tender kiss was placed on his forehead and strands of his sticking hair were brushed back. He glared at the angel then. How dare he play nice after stealing something so important from him! He simply stared into his eyes with nothing but anger in his own and growled low in his chest. "Don't touch me."
O.O.O.O.O
"Get away from you? Don't touch you?" Matt asked, repeating Tai's sentences back to him with a bark of laughter. "I don't think you understand what your position in life is, beautiful." To illustrate his point, he began a shallow thrusting of his hips against the brunette's once again. "Feel that? That's me hardening inside you – it's 'cus I can kiss you, fuck you any time I want to in any way that I want to– that is MY right." He paused – he had just taken Tai's virginity. No matter how much he wanted to have him again, he knew he could not do it so soon without danger of really hurting Tai.
In all honesty, he was a little frustrated – he had just shared the most intense experience of love-making with this beautiful, beautiful human. The proof of Tai's pleasure was coated on both their stomachs – and contrary to his character, Matt wanted to stay with this new lover. But this idiot of a human refused to even look at him, choosing to look for answers on the ceiling instead.
He will get used to it, Matt decided. "Get comfortable," he muttered, shifting positions so that Tai lay spooned against him. Deciding to be reasonable, he told Tai what to expect. "I am going to take you again tonight – several times, probably. I like being inside you so I am going to stay." He kept the worlds simple so Tai would understand but they felt clunky and awkward on his tongue because they were so crass. But it was the truth – he slung his pale hand over Tai's dark stomach and pulled him into his warmth. He was asleep seconds later.
O.O.O.O.O
Tai wished that he couldn't understand the angel and at the same time he was thankful for his words...no matter how much they stung him. He was a full possession now. The human's only purpose in life was now to please the kidnapping angel and spread his legs when it was required of him. There was no love involved. Only honest desire from the angel and his growing hate for him.
He was moved by the angel and turned to press his back into his chest, the angel still growing harder inside of him..And he just had to deal with it. There was nothing more that he could do in this situation. The sweat and cooling cum on his body filled him with worry just like the throbbing between his thighs. His passage was throbbing with every breath he took and once the angel finally pulled out of him, he would feel nothing but used and pain. Not that the angel cared at all, all he had to do was keep his legs spread for him and the angel would be appeased-or so he thought.
For now, he lay with eyes staring blankly ahead of him and heart heavy in his chest. His body was still sensitive and his throat slightly sore from his shouting. Sleep didn't claim him for a long time.