"I can't believe you didn't tell me, Rach." Finn's face was twisted into a combination of anger, sadness and disappointment. There was also confusion there, but then, there always was. "You let me believe I was the first."
"I know, it was wrong to lead you on, but... Quinn shouldn't be telling people my business either." She looked around her, and spotted David Karofsky leaning against a locker, just a few feet away, looking bored. "It's not something I want to think about, Finn. As far as I'm concerned, you're my first."
"I'm sorry, Rach. But you lied to me." He turned and walked away, leaving Rachel in the hallway.