AN: Hiiiiii! I hope you guys like this one... I'm so happy with all the reviews you gave me 3 You all are the best!
On with the story!
"Hey, have you guys seen that new girl?" Rory asked. "Shes smokin hot!"
"She looks familiar though..." Sarah said.
"Yeah. It's weird. The last new kid we had was aria." Ethan commented.
Benny nodded. It was true, even Benny thought she was hot. Shamefully, of course, since he was completely faithful to Aria. But still. That straight dark brown hair that hung down to her waist topped with a red crotched beanie, red skinny jeans, a black tank top and a sleeveless red letterman hoodie vest. It was undeniable that this girl was sexy.
"Speak of the devil, here she comes now." Benny said to his friends.
And to their surprise, the new girl walked right up to their little group. "Hey Sarah, Hey Ethan. Hiya Rory." she smiled at them and gave Rory a small hug, to his delight. "Hey Benny." She gave Benny a special smile and leaned up and kissed him. Right. On. The. Lips.
"Whoa!" they yelled, Benny just stood there, surprised.
"I uh, I have a girlfriend." he said, voice cracking a little.
She gave him a confused smile "Well, yeah, no duh. Who do you think is kissing you?"
That's when Benny noticed the sparkling little A hanging on a chain around her neck, and the recognizable green of her eyes. "Aria?!" he asked in disbelief.
"Yeah! Who did you think I was?" she asked with a laugh.
Sarah, Ethan, and Rory looked at the girl in shock as well. "We all kinda thought you were a new kid." Ethan said honestly.
Aria laughed and slipped her hand in Benny's. "I only changed my hair! Do I really look that different?"
"A little bit." Sarah smiled.
-Aria P.O.V.-
"Anyways, what are you two all dressed up for?" I asked my boyfriend and Ethan, who were wearing dress shirts and clip on ties.
"We are going to go ask the yearbook committee to let us use our gaming avatars as our photos." Ethan explained smartly with a smile.
"Really?" I smirked
"Yes." Benny said "Don't laugh, it's a great idea!"
"I know it is baby." I teased in a cooing voice.
"Hey Benny, we gotta go or we'll be late!" Ethan said, looking at the time.
"Yeah, alright. See you later, Aria." he bent down to kiss my cheek.
"Bye Benny."
"I'm getting my hair done after school, you guys wanna come?" Erica asked Sarah and me.
"Why are you getting a makeover for the yearbook photo?" Sarah asked.
"Vampires don't show up on film." I giggled. Duh!
"I know, but this would have been my first hot yearbook photo ever!" Erica whined. "The others were..."
"Not your best photo?" I asked sympathetically.
"Exactly! I don't care if nobody else can see it. I'll know I looked good." she looked at Sarah pointedly "What about you? Don't you care?"
Sarah sighed before answering. "I don't know. I kind of just wish I could forget this whole year."
"Considering you turned into a vampire fledgling, I can understand that." I mused.
Then Ethan came around the corner.
"Hey, Sarah? Um, a girl just asked me if she can trust me. What does that mean? Is it a trap?"
"What does that mean?" I asked.
"What do you mean?" he asked me confused.
"Sarah, you've got to stop hanging out with him. You too, Aria, you're getting cool. You're going to turn into the same person as them! Next thing you know you'll be reading comic books and snorting when you laugh." she rolled her eyes.
Ethan gave a sarcastic little "ha." that ended in a snort. "Hannah Price just asked if she could trust me." he continued. "Can she?"
"Can she?" Sarah questioned him back.
"I can't watch this happen" Erica turned and walked off.
"If she wants to trust you..." I said,
"It probably means she likes you!" Sarah finished.
"Really?" Ethan look shocked. "What do I do?"
"Just see what happens." I said.
"Think of it as an experiment." Sarah added.
"Good idea! I need to collect more data." Ethan said, walking off.
Sarah giggled when he left and snorted. She covered her mouth in shock while I burst out laughing.
I sat next to Benny at lunch with Ethan. Rory walked over but got hit in the head with a flying... giant pen?
"Haha, Yes!" Hannah cheered, standing up. "Now that was a three pointer." At the confused and slightly judging looks from everyone else she threatened "Who else wants some of this?!" and sat back down.
"If she asks you out, you better say yes." Benny warned. I nodded hurriedly in agreement, and so did Ethan.
Hannah stood up and walked towards our table. "Oh, she sees us!" Ethan worried.
"Just act natural." Benny said.
"Well I'm naturally nervous, so that should be easy." Ethan looked nervous.
I took Benny's hand, worried.
"Baby still crying 'cause he can't be superman in the yearbook? Getting his little girlfriend so he can cry on her shoulder?" Hannah simpered snidely.
"Superman? Please." Benny commented. "He's a little too retro, a little too old school." he leaned back in his chair. I gave him a look, trying to tell him not to get into this, but I was getting mad too.
Hannah scoffed and rolled her eyes. She grabbed Bennys lunch tray and tilted it up, dumping Benny's lunch on his lap. Oh hell no.
"Aw, and it was such a nice nerd shirt." she sneered and turned.
I stood up to go after her but both Benny and Ethan pulled me back down. "Calm down Aria." Benny said, stroking my hand with his thumb. "I dont care how much of a crush she has on you," He spoke angrily to Ethan "She just made Bennys List."
"That's my Benny-boo." I smiled, kissing his cheek. "Kick her ass."
"Benny, I don't think this is such a good idea…" I said, following him into the schools darkroom.
"Darkroom? More like, red room." he joked, laughing. "Relax Aria, it's just a prank." he stopped in front of the camera, while I stayed at the door.
"Alright, time for a little revenge photo, princess." he said, walking to the camera and grabbing the squeeze-thing you used to take the picture. "Courtesy of Thor Angerheart*." he posed in front of the camera, sticking his butt out and making a stupid face.
I giggled as the camera snapped the picture. "Okay, now can we go?" I pleaded.
"Yeah, let's go." he said, wrapping an arm around my shoulders.
"An evil twin? Dude, come on." Benny said to Ethan as we climbed the stairs at school. I followed behind.
"That does sound pretty far-fetched." I agreed, holding loosely on to Benny's hand that he had reached behind for me to hold.
"Somehow Hannah's evil side became a whole other person. One Hannah is normal; the other is a pile of angry snakes."
"Rabid snakes." I added "Did you see what she did to poor Amy?"
"So, you got twins crushing on ya." Benny said appreciatively, patting Ethan on the shoulder.
"Yeah!" Ethan said happily. "But, one of them is evil, we've got to do something."
"Yeah, you're right." Benny agreed. "I'll come over tonight, we'll play some Hackbot Rebellion, and we'll take care of it tomorrow. She is still just a girl."
"Hey!" I cried.
"No offense Angel!" He said quickly, hugging me from the side as we continued to walk.
"Get off me..." I pouted, pushing him lightly, but quietly giggling.
"Yeah, you're right." Ethan nodded "What's the worst she could do; make fun of someone's shoes on Facebook?" he joked.
Benny said "exactly." and I rolled my eyes.
"Aria! Hey Aria!" Sarah's voice called down the hall.
I turned to see her rushing down the hall to catch up with me.
"Hey Sarah," I slowed down for her "What's up?"
"Your boyfriend was flirting with me!" She accused.
"What?"
"Benny came to school this morning on a go-kart and just started flirting with me!"
I was dumbfounded. "Are you messing with me?"
"No, I swear!"
I grew angry, furious even. "Sarah, I'll be back. I've got an asshole to find." then I stalked off.
I found Benny by some lockers "Alright Benny, we need to talk!" I stalked up to my boyfriend and tapped him roughly on the shoulder. He spun around to face me. He leaned against the wall and gave me a smirk.
My mouth froze open at the sight of Benny. Dark sunglasses, and a leather jacket (which, actually, was really sexy) his smirk wasn't like the usual silly ones he gave me. This one screamed "sexpot" and "bad boy". It was really hot.
But I was on a mission, and no matter how good-looking Benny was right now, I would not stop.
"Hey babe, how you doin'?" he did that guy-nod thing at me.
"Don't 'babe' me, Benny! What's wrong with you?!" I cried, frustrated.
"Whoa-ho, babe-"
"Don't call me Babe! Sarah told me you were flirting with her! How could you do that to me?!"
"Whoa whoa whoa, babe-"
"Don't call me Babe!" I all but screamed.
"Listen sweetness, you've got it all wrong. A hottie like you," he looked me up and down appreciatively "Well, a girl like her can't compare." he gave me another bad boy smile.
He leaned in and gave me a slow kiss. I let out a surprised "Ah!" when he did that.
He pulled away and smirked.
"This doesn't mean-" he kissed me again "-I'm not-" another kiss "-still mad at you!" I rushed that last part in before he could kiss me again.
He leaned in one more time and gave me an extremely passionate kiss.
Involuntarily I let out a moan. Benny had been a pretty good kisser, but when did he get this good?
He pulled away and stared down at me with a look that showed that he knew he had me. "Come on babe, let's go somewhere more... Private." I shivered. The way he said private made it sound so... naughty.
"Okay." I breathed.
"Mmmmm!" I moaned into Benny's mouth as he kissed me. He had me pressed against a stall in the boys bathroom, with my hands pinned above me in one of his. His other hand roamed my side and my back. He pressed into me harder, running his hand down past my butt and lifting me up. I was surprised at his strength, but pleased, and wrapped my legs around his waist.
Benny groaned at the contact of our hips. He let go of my hands to wrap his arm around my back, and I wrapped my arms around his neck, tangling my fingers in his curly hair. His tongue battled with mine in a (hopefully) never-ending war for dominance. He just tasted so good today.
Suddenly the door opened. "WHOA! WHOA- Aria?!" cried a familiar voice.
I pulled back from Benny to see- Benny? "Benny? What are you- but then who- wha?" I was so confused. Why were there two Benny's?
"Alright double negative, you may look cool, but you can NOT touch my girlfriend!" Benny yelled.
The Benny I had been kissing put me down and turned fully to face Benny that had just walked in.
"She didn't seem to mind." he said smoothly, putting a toothpick in his mouth.
"Benny," I asked both of them, not sure which to talk to "What's going on?"
The Benny that just walked in answered me. "That old camera we gave to the yearbook club makes evil twins when you take a picture of yourself!"
"Oh." that actually explained a lot. "So this is... evil Benny?" I gestured to the Benny I kissed.
"What makes you think I'm the evil one?" Evil Benny asked me. He looked back at good Benny. "Maybe I'm normal and you're just a goody-goody."
"Yeah, I don't think either of us is smart enough to make any sense of that." Good Benny said shaking his head. "Only one of us is leaving this washroom."
"What if I cook ya?" Evil Benny threatened, raising his hand out towards good Benny "use the magic you never had the stomach to use, eh. Turn ya inside out maybe?"
"No!" I cried out. Shit, what did I know about spells to make evil twins?
Good Benny just laughed. "Great, I bet you're no better at magic than I am!" he took in Evil Benny. "Nice jacket though. Looks so real... pleather. You like that stuff Aria?" he asked me.
I shrugged apologetically. "It's a good look for you sweetie."
Evil Benny suddenly lunged for Good Benny and shoved him against the wall.
"Benny!" I screamed, getting up and running over.
"Stay back!" both Benny's yelled, one concerned and the other forceful.
They kept pushing each other against the wall. "You're such a jerk!" Good Benny yelled.
"I know you are but what am I?" Evil Benny taunted.
Good Benny found his strength and pushed Evil Benny into the stall Evil Benny and I had been kissing against. He managed to pin Evil Benny and dig through his jacket pockets and find the picture negatives.
"Haha!" he laughed. "You dropped something!" He then shoved Evil Benny to the floor and dashed into the stall - but Evil Benny grabbed his ankle.
Good Benny struggled to get out of his grip. I stood up just as Sarah stormed in. We shared a look before going over to Evil Benny.
"Times up, Babe/Sweetness!" we said together and kicked Evil Benny. He hit the wall and stopped moving.
Free, Good Benny dropped the negative in the toilet and flushed it. Different colored lights burst out crazily from the toilet. A ray of light shone from Evil Benny's chest and he disappeared. Benny came out of the stall, sighing.
"Are you ok?" Sarah asked. I stood back not sure about my boyfriend's feelings towards me right now.
"I just flushed myself down the toilet." he looked at her "I'm gonna need some time."
Sarah nodded and left. Now it was just me... and Benny.
"Benny?" I stepped closer.
He sighed again. "Just answer me one thing, Aria."
I nodded.
"...Why did you kiss him?"
"I thought he was you!" I defended myself.
"But he was evil!"
"I didn't know that! He looked just like you!"
"How could you not know it was me?!"
"I-I don't know!"
We stood in silence then, unable to look at each other.
After a few awkward, quiet moments I spoke up. "That was two questions."
Benny still didn't look up. Instead he asked "Did you like kissing him?"
I was quiet for a few beats. "...Yes." I answered truthfully. He growled and slammed his fist against the stall door. It went back and slammed against the stall's wall. The noise made me jump.
I shook my head to clear it. I started talking again. "Evil Benny's kisses were hot and sexy, and lustful." Benny groaned and closed his eyes, leaning his head against the stall. I stepped towards him. "But... Your kisses are amazing, and sweet, and full of passion. When I kiss you, I feel like nobody could ever love me as much as you do. You fill me with so much emotion; I just don't know what I would do without you." I moved until I was right in front of him. I took his chin in my hand and turned his head to face mine. I stared into his brown eyes. "You, Benny Weir, are the only guy for me." I stood on the balls of my feet to close the distance between is and kissed him lightly. "I. Love. You." I kissed him in between each word. Shock filled me at the three little words that hadn't been spoken between us before. But I couldn't hesitate now, and I knew I meant them. I sank back down to my feet and stared up at Benny. He stared down back at me. I tried to decipher any emotion from his eyes. Suddenly he enveloped me in a tight hug. I circled my arms around his neck and held him close.
"I thought... When I saw you with him… I thought I wouldn't be able to compare, to satisfy you like he was." he whispered in my ear. "I honestly thought I was gonna die when I walked in and saw you... Canoodling with him like that."
I giggled and drew back as far as he would allow. "Benny, I can't believe you just said canoodling."
He pressed his lips to mine, and we kissed for a few minutes. No tongue or anything, just sweet kisses. "I love you too." he said, looking in my eyes after he pulled away.
I smiled, which turned into a smirk as an idea formed in my head. "Are you still feeling bad about flushing yourself?" I teasingly asked.
"A bit." he pouted.
"I know how to fix that." I murmured huskily, tracing a finger on his thigh, dangerously close to his groin.
One of his eyebrows quirked up as he looked down at me, smirking. "Oh really?" he said back just as huskily.
"Mmhmm." I hummed as I got down on my knees and started to unbutton his jeans.
Benny gasped tightly, but said "I love your plans."
Sarah, Benny and I walked up to Ethan after school just in time to hear Hannah tell him that her boyfriend loves movies. Ouch.
"Boyfriend? That rots dude. At least I got my camera back." he smiled, hoisting it up. "That means grandma won't spank me." his smile faltered. "With lightning." he added, and walked away. I followed.
"She might not spank you, but I can't say the same..." I said suggestively biting my lip with a smile and looking up at him through my eyelashes.
Benny smirked down at me as we walked. Then he stopped when he noticed the go-kart, and raced back to tell Ethan. They both ran back and started it up. I heard Sarah yell "You're welcome!" from behind. As the boys excitedly raced off, I went back and joined Sarah.
"My boyfriend." I sighed, shaking my head.
"Yeah. Wanna hit the mall?"
"Yeah, let's go."
Later on Benny and I lay curled together on his bed.
"Mmmm... You know, you're really sexy when you're dominant." I purred, tracing circles around his arm.
He propped his body up on his elbow. "What?"
"I want you" I purred seductively "to show me whose boss." I could tell he was getting turned on because his voice turned deeper.
"I'll show you whose boss around here." he got on top of me and pinned my shoulders against the bed.
I skirted my nails across his arms and moaned out in pleasure when he began to suck on my neck.
"You've been working out." I noted breathlessly, admiring the small, toned muscles on his arm.
"That's what fighting vampires will do to you." he answered from my neck.
"I like it."
He pulled away from my neck looked down at me appraisingly "I like you." he removed his arms from my shoulders and slid one under my back, pulling me up against his chest. The other he used to hold himself up on an elbow.
He pressed his mouth to mine and kissed me passionately. Our lips moved quickly, and he used the advantage of my open mouth to dart his tongue in. I fought with him, but let him win the battle between our tongues.
His arm around my back moved down, grasping my butt and eliciting a gasp from me, and continued down to my thigh, where he pulled it up to hook around his waist. He pressed against me on the bed and I removed one hand from his hair to slide up his shirt, reveling in the hard, lean, flat surface. "Shirt. Off. Now." I demanded past the kissing.
"No." he growled. I pulled back to look at Benny in surprise. A mischievous and lustful look gleamed in his eyes. "Your clothes. Take them off." he ordered.
"Mmm. Yes sir." I purred, pushing lightly on his chest so he would move and I could sit up. Smirking, I crossed my arms over my shirt and grabbed the hem. Pulling the tank top slowly over my head, I arched my back to push out my boobs. Then I stood up off the bed and pulled down my pants, kicking them off my ankles.
"Is that good enough for you, Benny?" I asked, crawling back down to lay on the bed.
He stared at my mostly-naked body and took me in his arms, murmuring in my ear "You are so perfect."
He took hold of me and began to kiss down my neck, taking special care of my breasts. His hands were stationed at my waist, and as they travelled more down south, he faltered. Even though I wanted it, and I could feel his want pressing against my thigh, I knew we both weren't ready yet. I sighed and pulled away, sitting cross-legged in front of him.
"You don't want to do this, do you?" I asked in a small voice.
"I do!" He claimed.
I giggled "I can see that." I pointed to the bulge in his pants.
Embarrassed, he pulled his blanket over on top of his pants. "I want you, but… I just…"
"Don't think we're ready for it yet?" I supplied.
"Yeah… are you mad at me?"
I shook my head no, smiling, and stood up. I rummaged through his closet and pulled on one of his shirts. Climbing back into his bed, I cuddled up next to him and said "No, I'm not mad. I know we aren't ready. And that's okay! To be honest, I was a little scared. But we'll get there someday."
"Then I will hold out for that someday." Benny smiled, leaning down to kiss me softly.
AN: Oooooh I know! I suck for not making them have sex... or maybe I don't, to those who don't want to read lemons. Don't worry, no lemons in this story! Probably not until the sequel, and even then it's slim. I have trouble writing smut xD How do you guys like Aria's new hair color change?
So, what do you guys say to a super cute christmas chapter? I wanna do one for this story :D
BTW, do I have any Kickin' It fans here? I'm currently working on a Jack/OC story (I know it's usually Jack/Kim, but there's enough Kick stories out there!) I'm just wondering if anybody would read it, or if you guys think pairing Jack with anyone else would be a waste of time?
Anyhoo, as always, review! I will love you forever
SHOUT OUTS!
MsWildfire97: It makes me so happy to hear that you love my story! It gives me warm happy feelings in my tummy 3 hahaha! and I swear, I didn't copy Aria off of you... because, you know, I'm totally not stalking you ;D JUST KIDDING!
MeganRoseMaslow: I missed your reviews! But I'm happy you liked the last few chapters. I hope this one was satisfactory? I would DIE to see Cody again live 3 best experience EVER! But my real dream is to not see him on tour, but to tour WITH him! Ahhh! 3
Dusker101 (Guest): Thank you sweetie! I'm super duper happy you like the story :) I'm so glad somebody shares my opinion on Rory! It's like, he's either super annoying or the love interest! I'm trying to work on Ethan and Aria's friendship... So I hope you continue to like my story!