Hey guys! Here is the next Samchel one-shot . This takes place in season 3, 'Dance with somebody' with some flashbacks of 'The first time'
She knew it was wrong. So very wrong, but she had Sam to blame for it. Rachel felt like a horrible person, a slut, a guilty bitch, and a bad friend. Not only was she going behind Finn's back, but Mercedes' also. Sam claimed he felt bad, but never did he show any sign of guilt.
"How could you be okay about doing all of this, Sam! It eats me alive every fucking day!" Rachel paced the floors of the Evan's household. Sam's parents were out with Stacey and Stevie to the bowling alley.
"Rach, I know it's hard for you. But it's hard because you still love..him," Rachel could tell that it hurt him to say that she still loved Finn. How could she not? She was engaged to him and he was her first love. ", but it doesn't bother me because I love you. Not Mercedes, Santana, or even Quinn. I only want to be with you." Sam stood up from his seat and grabbed Rachel's face before kissing her.
This is how it all started…
Rachel was walking the halls thinking about what Artie had just said. She was doing a play called 'West Side Story' with her friend Blaine. Of course since Artie was the director, he was aloud to give a few pointers to the actors.
Rachel was 18 and still a virgin. Artie had just said that Blaine and her, not only lack passion, but lack on their sexually lives. Rachel didn't really know how to respond to any of it. She knew she was ready for it, but maybe it was just who she wanted to have it with? She loved Finn, of course, but something didn't feel right about any of it.
Finn and Rachel Hudson? Rachel and Finn Hudson? Rachel Hudson? Rachel Berry.
Her thoughts were interrupted when she felt a tap on her shoulder. She looked up and found that she was already in her seat in the choir room. She turned around to see Sam Evans. He was a sweet guy. Always worried about other people, never threw a slushie in his life. He took her to prom last year when he was still living in a hotel, but now his dad found a new job as a police officer and could afford a normal home. She was glad that it worked out for him. He deserved the best.
"Are you alright, Rach? " Sam had a worried expression on his face and Rachel couldn't help but chuckle at his cuteness.
"Yeah I'm fine, thanks." She smiled slightly, in return to his. She turned around and tried listened to Mr. Shue discuss the topic of the week.
-/-/-/-/-/-/-/-/-/-/-/-/-/-/-
As Finn tried to find the zipper to Rachel's dress, she pulled away from the kiss and pushed him off her.
"Did I do something wrong?" Finn said in a worried, out of breath voice. Santana wasn't wrong. They were only making out about to have sex until it felt like she was being smothered by a huge sack of potatoes drenched in body spray. But that wasn't the reason she pulled away and said 'I'm sorry, I can't do this.' and left. It didn't feel right. Don't get her wrong, she loved Finn, but she felt like they were drifting away ever since she started to hang out with Sam.
-/-/-/-/-/-/-/-/-/-/-/-/-
Rachel was laying on the floor of Sam's bedroom in a white summer dress with creamy colored wedges, which were thrown near the door. Her legs were on top of Sam's as he leaned against the end of his bed. His dad was out at work and his mom went to take Stevie and Stacey out to a movie, so they were both alone for the next 2 hours. He had his hand rested on Rachel's smooth leg and the other was playing with her hair.
It had been a week since the 'Finn accident' and they were barley speaking. Her being too embarrassed to be seen by him, and him being confused to why she just ran out of his house like she did.
Sam saw the upset look in her face and decided he wanted to be the one to cheer her up, which he always was and always did.
"This morning I woke up and decided to swallow the sun. That's my James Earl Jones impression." Sam said in a deep voice then going back to his regular. Rachel laughed and hid her face with her hand while Sam continued, "Obi-Wan never told you what happened to your father." Rachel giggled and shoved his arm playfully. He always knew how to cheer her up. Sam laughed and put an arm around her shoulder as she sat up.
"You're such a dork." She giggled. Sam squeezed her shoulder gently as he laughed.
"Aww come on, you know you love me!" He joked. Rachel rolled her eyes with a grin plastered to her face.
"Whatever helps you sleep at night, Sam." She started laughing and squirming around once she felt his huge fingers against her waist. She squealed happily as Sam was tickling her.
"S-STOP!...Please! –I'm sorry!" She laughed breathlessly between each word. He stopped the attack and was pleased to see she was happy again.
Sam stared down at her while she was under him, staring into his eyes. Sam slowly closed the gap between the two, forgetting the rest of the world and focusing on the girl he was falling deeper in love with.
Before they knew it, clothes were thrown, moans and groans could be heard, and the 3 little words that both teens were holding in for months were finally whispered into each others ears.
-/-/-/-/-/-/-/-/-/-/-/-
Sam was sitting in an auditorium chair with hundreds of other people surrounding him. He watched intensly as his now secret girlfriend was singing her heart out on stage. He watched as she sang with passion and her eyes were full of love when she spotted him in the audience. He smiled lovingly at her before she turned back to her 'Tony'.
When the curtains closed, the whole room was filled with clapping and whooping. Sam stood up and clapped as a huge grin spread across his face. He knew Finn was only a couple feet away, but at that moment he didn't care. He was supporting the love of his life.
Rachel was never the one to cheat, but her love for Sam was strong. She had never felt that way before, neither of them had.
But there they were, both standing in front of a furious Mercedes and Finn. She held onto Sam's arm as Mercedes walked away angrily after telling them both off. Finn was standing tall in front of Sam before punching him in the face. Rachel tore them apart by stepping in front of Sam and pushing Finn away as hard as she could. Finn pushed both her arms into the locker beside her harshly. She looked down to see her right one bleeding already.
"I never knew you were such a slut." Finn snapped. Rachel was already crying, trying to stay strong, but that plan failed miserably. She sobbed and looked down while holding her arm, avoiding his angry gaze.
"HEY! Don't fucking touch her!" Sam yelled while pushing Finn into the lockers and punching him back. Soon enough, Mr. Shue had both boys by the back of their shirts, pulling them apart.
"Hey! That's enough!" Mr. Shue spat. He looked in between the boys to see Rachel sobbing with blood dripping down her right arm. "Rachel, are you alright?" He asked in a worried tone. Both Sam and Finn looked down to her arm, which was for sure fractured.
Sam stepped out of Mr. Shue's grip and walked towards Rachel, looking at her arm.
"Babe, you alright?"
She finally managed to stop sobbing, but tears were still going down her cheeks.
"Y-yes I'm fine."
Mr. Shue walked over after sending Finn to the nurse. He examined her arm carefully. "Yeah, it might be broken. Are you sure you're okay?" Rachel nodded. Liar. She thought.
"I'll drive you to the hospital, come on." Sam gently turned her around and walked her to his truck.
Rachel was sitting on the hospital bed as the nurse was wrapping her wrist in a cast. Sam was on her left, holding her hand tightly.
"There you go. You need to take pain killers when it starts hurting again. Okay?" The nurse said as she wrote her prescription down on a piece of paper.
"Yes sir." Sam took the paper and put it in his pocket.
"I'll be back with the papers." The nurse left after closing the door.
Sam sighed and ran a finger through his hair. "I'm so sorry." He whispered.
"Why are you sorry, Sam?"
"Cause this is all my fault. I should be the one with the broken arm, Rachel. Not you."
"This isn't you fault, it's Finn's. He has some anger issues." Rachel sighed and laid down on the bed and made room before Sam joined her.
He growled at the mention of Finn's name. "Stupid Jolly Green Giant. I'm going to kick his ass."
"Sam, don't. I don't want you getting hurt, or in trouble." He sighed and relaxed into Rachel's side.
After a few seconds of silence, Rachel shook her head and chuckled humorlessly.
"What's so funny?" Sam asked confused.
"I am a slut…aren't I?" Rachel sighed in defeat.
Sam looked up and sat up with a mad expression on his face. "Don't say that Rach! You are not a slut. Finn is a fucking dumbass."
"Yes I am. I slept with my friends boyfriend and cheated on my ex fiancé with one of his best friends. First time I cheat and I get a broken arm. I think the universe is trying to tell me something." She laughed a little at that.
"For the last time Rach, you're not a slut. And I know what you mean. I don't rock this black eye either." They both laughed. He turned on his side and faced her while taking her left hand in his. "In the end, it's just you and me. That's all I've ever wanted since I first asked if you were alright in the choir room." He chuckled. "You are a beautiful girl who I am in love with so very much. Nothing will ever change that."
Rachel smiled and sat up with him. "I love you to, Dork." Sam smiled and kissed her lovingly. She didn't want Puck, Jesse, or even Finn. Only Sam.
Who knew cheating could be the best outcome for Rachel Berry?
Hope you liked . Please Review! Thanks to all who have! And just because it turned out good for Rachel in the end, doesn't mean it will for everybody. So don't cheat. It's still wrong.
~XOXO Ashley-