Soooo here is the next chapter. Amy picked Reagan...M content in this chapter. Please let me know what you think. Reviews are really appreciated.
Reagan POV
I honestly tried to resist the kiss...I lasted a whole three or maybe four seconds before I caved in and opened my mouth and let her in. She felt so good. Her skin so soft. Her tongue explored my mouth hungrily and I welcomed it. In fact I pulled her in close, and without breaking the kiss, kicked the door shut behind her. I placed my arms round her back and moved them down until I was easily able to picked her up. Amy wrapped her legs around my waist and kissed me harder as I walked us down the hallway and into my bedroom. Once in the room, Amy reached out with a hand and pushed the door closed, before we both collapsed in a heap on the bed laughing out loud. I fucking loved Amy's laugh.
I climbed on top of her, but she wasn't having any of it.
"I don't think so..." She said as she rolled me over "...I've unfinished business with you!" It was such a turn on hearing her take charge. Telling me what to do. I liked it.
"Oh yeah Shrimp girl ..."I smiled "...and what exactly do you have in mind?" I asked suggestively.
"Weeeeellll... How about we start by getting you undressed..." As her hands started lifting my jumper over my head. I couldn't get enough of her kisses, each one turning me on more and more.
I laid back and let her remove item after item, grabbing kisses inbetween, pulling her clothes off in turn. Her hands brushed my skin lightly sending shivers through my whole body, her mouth bit down on my erect nipples, her tongue licked my collarbone and neck. It was all totally delicious and as I laid there giving myself over to her, I felt so happy.
Amy moved her hand down between my naked thighs. Both of us groaning slightly at the anticipation of what was coming next. Amy tentatively slipped a finger inside me and looked up at me for confirmation
"Is this OK?" She asked
"Mmm humm" was all I could managed with a smile as she moved her finger in and out of me before adding a second. Using her thumb she started teasing my clit
"That feels good" I managed to say as she built up a rhythm...only to slow it down when I looked like I was enjoying it a bit too much. She teased me, bringing me to the point of orgasm, when my hips were lifting off the bed of their own accord, and then she would slow the pace down. It was a sublime mixture of pleasure and torture at the same time!
"Shit...you feel so good" Amy said as she climbed on top of me and we moved together, her fingers still inside me. I pulled her into me so I could kiss her, as I felt my orgasm start. The pace was fast, and as she rubbed herself against my thigh I felt her wetness.
Our hips moved in tandem and I felt myself grip her fingers inside me as my body bucked up and pushed against Amy. I broke our kiss and whispered in her ear "fuck...I'm coming..oh fuck.." I heard her let out a moan and I pressed my mouth against her in an attempt to muffle my cry, aware of Courtney in the room next door. As my orgasm took hold I grabbed Amy's back and pulled her in tight to me. I felt her buck within my arms, as she experienced her own orgasm.
As we caught our breaths, I turned and looked at Amy who was staring at me. "Was...was that OK?" She asked nervously
I let out a little laugh "there is no way that that was your FIRST time!" I smiled as her face blushed slightly
"it was!" She pleaded "well..." She added as she leant in and gave me a kiss "...the first time with someone else! I may have had a bit of solo practice."
I stroked her hair "well all that practice certainly payed off! I leant in and kissed her forehead "that..." Another kiss "...was amazing". Amy kissed me back and I felt her smile through our kiss.
I wrapped her in my arms and she snuggled her head on my shoulder. "I'm glad you came." I said
"Yeah...about that" Amy started speaking "I'm sorry about earlier. I..I think I just freaked out a little bit." She admitted.
"But why?" I asked. "Did I push it too fast?"
"No...no way" Amy responded. "It...it was great. Better than great."
"SOOO why the freak out?" I asked
Amy let out a small sigh and turned on her side so we were facing each other "Reagan...I'm not like you...I'm still new at this...at all these feelings." She paused before adding "Up until you...I had only ever had feelings for one person.."
"Karma!" I interrupted her as I remembered her text message. I couldn't stop the jealous time when I said her name.
Amy cleared her throat "right. Karma. Who was...IS...still my best friend...so it's been a bit of a roller coaster trying to figure everything out. I think I found the whole thing a bit overwhelming...I mean sleeping with a girl for the first time...and it feeling so...so right".
I sat and absorbed what Amy had just said "so you think you've figured it out now?" I asked
She smiled and leant in and gently planted her lips on mine and gave me the softest kiss ever "I have TOTALLY figured it out." She whispered "couldn't you tell?" She asked with a suggestive smile.
"And what about Karma's text?" I asked. I needed to know that she wasn't about to drop me and go running to Karma now she had declared her love for her. I needed to know that Amy wanted me, so it was worth investing my time in her...I could risk opening up, risk letting her in.
"Soooo that's what made you bolt earlier right?" She asked
I nodded "that and the weirdness I felt from you...I've done this before Amy, and it didn't feel right."
"Does it feel right now?" She asked stroking my face.
I nodded "it feels right now...but I have to admit, I don't feel secure." I took a deep breath as I tried to explain myself better.
"Amy, I really like you..."
"Good. Because I REALLY like you." She interrupted
"And Karma?" I asked "do you REALLY like her...STILL?"
Amy shook her head "If that text had come three weeks ago, it would have been different. I felt different then...and the reason why I feel different is YOU. Reagan, I still really care about Karma...I always will, but the way I feel and think about her has changed. It's too late. She is too late...I...I've met you and you make me really happy. THIS is what I want. I want YOU and I want THIS.." She looked at me with those big green eyes and I felt myself melt.
Fuuuuuck I said inside my head as I realised I was totally falling for her. I knew it was risky. I knew this thing with Karma wasn't as clear cut and over as Amy was making out...how could it be? How could Amy be over her feelings for Karma SO quickly?
As I laid there staring back at her beautiful face I knew I had to either gave it a go...or walk away and save myself a whole heap of heartache.