Hey all, sorry for the lack of updates, things have been hectic and crazy lately but that's no excuse, I will get them to you as soon as I can please know that.

Thanks for all the great reviews I have been getting, I'm only 3 away from the big 100 now woo! Nice to see I have a few new additions to my readers as well, I hope you like what you have read so far. And I would like to take the opportunity to thank those who have stuck by the story even though it's been taking me a while to update at times. Thanks guys.

Side note: Inspirtion for this chapter was given to me by terence who rped parts of it out with me, thanks for the help.

This chapter is a little longer than some of the previous ones, which I'm sure you won't mind. Enjoy the story and don't forget to review!!

Authors note: Please be away that this chapter contain elements of sexual and physical abuse, as well as some strong language. If you are likely to be offended be this don't read.

Chapter Sixteen Truth & Lies

I'm never going to get out of here, she thought to herself as she slowly drifted back into the realms of consciousness. Unfortunately with that came back all the pain, fear, dread, and uncertainty as well. Slowly the young blonde's eyes flickered open as she hoped to find herself still in the light of her dreams, however instead she found herself to be in the cold darkness of reality.

She lifted herself slightly from the floor, winching as the pain from several beatings cursed through her body like a virus, pinpointing every possible inch of flesh it could find. At first when she had opened her eyes she had thought that she was alone in the cave, however she had not seen David stood in the corner watching her as the pain she was in shone through her face. He enjoyed seeing that, in a most disgustingly sadistic way.

Billie slowly looked around her surroundings, only to jump back further into the wall upon seeing David stood in the corner. Just the sight of him terrified her, the mere thought of what he could and would do to her. This was now her life, as she had known if for what seemed like months. Fear, pain, and despair.

"Nice of you to finally join me." David said approaching her, smirking as Billie backed further into the wall. Oh how I love the sweet bitter taste of revenge, he thought to himself chuckling.

Upon reaching Billie he grabbed her by her hair and pulled her up to her feet. He pushed her hard into the wall causing her to cry out in pain at the hard rough contact it made with her body. Then he did what Billie feared and hated the worst, he pushed himself upon her.

David looked up and down Billie's body, he loved what she had become, the way she looked with her womanly features, and the way he could control her through her fears so easily.

Billie tired to look away, she hated being close to him, having to see that smile, that smile that sent chills down her back, making even the hairs on her back shiver in fear. She tried to think of something else, something happy. She thought of the sisters coming to rescue her, saving her. It was her nicest dream, but also her worst nightmare.

She couldn't tell what was true and what was fake anymore. She couldn't tell when those fake shape shifter demons were in the room with her, or if it was really the sisters coming to save her. And that 

frightened her, but not half as much as what the sisters, the real sisters, would think of her knowing the things she had been made to do. Knowing how dirty and evil she was.

David looked up again to Billie, however when he saw that she was attempting to look away he became angry. He hated people not paying attention to him; he especially hated Billie not paying attention to him. "You will listen to me you pathetic little bitch!" He shouted loudly while slapping Billie hard across the face.

David stood and waited for Billie to look at him, when she did a few seconds after he had slapped her, he smirked at her. "Now that I have your attention, let's have some fun." David said smiling again as he stroked Billie's dirty hair.

He looked Billie in the eyes, and then moved his head downwards to emphasise that he wished for her to get on the floor. Slowly, shaking through fear, Billie complied with his wish and dropped down to the floor on her knees.

Tears started to run down the young blondes cheeks as she watched her uncle strip away his belt and undo his trousers zipper, however he stopped in his tracks and looked back up to Billie on the floor halfway through undoing them.

"Lie down." He ordered staring at her with a cold gaze. No, no I can't, at least I didn't remember it the other time, Billie thought to herself, while her body shook in fear and she stared up at David with large fear filled eyes.

"Don't you dare lay a hand on her you disgusting scumbag!" Said an angry female voice, causing David to stop still frozen, not through fear like Billie, but through shock.

Billie looked up from her place on the floor to see David stood above her, his left hand raised but his head turned to the right of him where a small exit could now be seen to the before fully concealed cave.

Billie's eyes slowly followed in David's gaze to see a women coming out of the shadowed cave walls. She squinted her eyes to help her take a closer look, but gasped when she saw who it was – Paige.

Is it her, what if it's one of those demons?, she thought to herself. If it was why would she have insulted David? she challenged her first thought. Billie couldn't make her mind up, she was so unsure. This person stood only a few feet away from her looked like Paige, had the characteristics of Paige, but she couldn't help but think the demons were maybe getting better in morphing into the sisters.

"Were you planning on putting your arm back down? Or are you waiting for me to start the Mexican wave with you?" Paige said sarcastically, staring at David angrily in the eyes. David looked at Paige before lowering his arm; he then turned to Billie and smiled evilly at her. "I was almost convinced by this one too." He said laughing at the pained and fearful expression on Billie's face.

"Billie don't listen to him...It's me, Paige." Paige said approaching. "You know you can trust me. Come on lets go home." Paige said holding her hand out, hoping Billie would come to her. However Paige's hope seemed uncertain even in her own mind, as she looked at Billie she could see confusion and fear. She had no idea what David had done to her charge, but Paige promised herself there on the spot that she would find out and defiantly vanquish him, demon or not.

"I don't think she trusts you." David said grinning vindictively watching as Billie backed herself further into the wall and held her head in her hands. Stop it!, she screamed in her thoughts, the blonde was so confused. She didn't know who to trust. Who was lying? Who was telling the truth? David had hurt her, changed her, made her vulnerable...but he had never lied to her before. But neither had Paige. Paige had never hurt her, only been there for her.

"How can she when you filling her mind with your crap." Paige spat back angrily through clenched teeth. She was fed up of seeing the way that David manipulated her young charge into fearing talking to her friends and getting the help that she needs.

"Why don't we let Billie decide who to trust?" David said in a sing-song voice, as he picked Billie up by the back of her shirt and threw her onto the floor in between himself and Paige. Paige seeing this shot David an angry glare, for causing Billie more pain than she was already in. She then crouched down to the floor so that she was at Billie's level and smiled to the young blonde warmly.

Billie seeing this felt a sense of security. However she was still unsure as to whether this was the real Paige or not. There's only one way to find out, she thought to herself looking up into Paige's eyes. That was the way she could always tell who the demons were, their eyes. Their eyes held no hope for her, only fear and darkness. If this person before her really was Paige her eyes would be the same ones Billie remembered, loving, caring and full of life.

Billie stared into Paige's eyes for a long time, trying to see if what she saw was a trick, she was still unsure, she thought she saw Paige but she could never be certain. Paige seeing this as an opportunity to get closer to her charge, slowly started to move closer to her, staying low to the ground still and making sure she kept eye contact with Billie at all times.

David seeing that Paige had begun to gain Billie's trust decided it was time to stop that. I know how to make her angry, he thought to himself stepping forward. "She doesn't know if it's you or a demon, looks like four months down here really got to her head. Good work." David said clapping his hands loudly making Billie jump and divert her eyes away from Paige's and to the floor.

Paige was about to give a witty comeback like she always does, but something David had said was bugging her. "Four months?" She asked standing up straight to face him. "What do you mean four months? We have been looking for four days not months." She said annoyed

"Nice little cave this isn't it? Not only does it shield itself from those looking when needs be, it also moves in a different time frame from up there." David said pointing up to the ceiling to emphasise his point. "One day up on earth is one month down here. Billie's been down here with me for four months. And were had a lot of fun haven't we?" David said crouching down to Billie sliding his hand up her inner thigh from a large rip that was in her pyjama bottoms. Billie was still wearing the same clothes, the same pyjamas, which she had on the day David took her from Phoebe's condo.

Billie jerked away from David's touch quickly causing the rip in her trouser leg to become bigger so that large cuts and a lot of blood could be seen through it. "David!" Paige shouted loudly throwing her arm towards the cave wall, Paige had grown angry at seeing what he was trying to do to the teenage girl in front of her, and was trying to orb him into the wall, but to no avail.

"This protects me from your powers." David said holding up an amulet while smiling at Paige's confused face. The amulet was a small brown square with a blue stone in the centre that was now shinning red as it protected it's wearer from Paige's good magic.

David then turned his attention to Billie who had been quietly and slowly attempting to crawl away from him, seeing this David turned to follow her, but was stopped by Paige who was now standing in his way. "Keep away from her." Paige said angrily at him. David smiled and went to walk around Paige who kicked him in the stomach, causing him to bend over and hold onto his stomach.

David looked up to Paige through angry eyes. "You shouldn't have done that." He stated matter-of-factly, throwing his arm out towards Paige who was thrown telekinetically into a wall on the other side of the cave. David then held his hand out and lifted it upwards towards him causing Billie to be telekinetically lifted into the air. Holding her in place with his one hand he created a fireball in the other and threw it hard at Billie. Even though it was only a small fireball it still made quite an impact to the small witch's already bruised, bloody, and battered body.

The fireball hit Billie on her right thigh causing her to fly backwards into the wall. Paige hearing her young charges scream of pain, as she was hit with the fireball, looked up from the floor, of the wall that she had slid down, barely conscious to see David approaching Billie slowly.

My powers may not work on him, but they should work on Billie, Paige thought to herself as she held her arm out in Billie's direction. "Billie!" She shouted out with all her strength and will power that she had left. She watched hopefully as her young friend quickly turned into blue and white orbs before David could reach her.

Paige thought her wish had come true as she saw the familiar blue and white orbs appear once again in her arms and take the shape of Billie, however that wish was short lived as the scared once so confident witch started to struggle in her arms. "Billie, its okay...it's me Paige. You're going to be okay." Paige calmly said to the frantic girl, tightening her grip on her so that she could not escape and do herself more harm than that had already been done to her.

Please be Paige...please be Paige, Billie thought to herself as she tensed her body muscles when she looked up to the person who was holding her down. She stared into Paige's eyes, just as Paige did hers for what seemed like forever.

Suddenly Billie noticed Paige's eyes were no longer looking at her, instead Paige was looking over her shoulder. Slowly Billie turned around to see what it was that had caught her white-lighter's gaze – David.

Paige noticing that Billie had begun to tremble violently with fear, pulled the small blonde girl closer to her wrapping an arm around her stomach gently in hopes to make her feel safer as she watched David approach making a fireball once again in his hand.

David launched the fireball at Billie who closed her eyes tight and backed further into Paige.

"Fireball!" Paige shouted loudly throwing her arm out towards David. She knew throwing the fireball back at David could cause for it to bounce back towards her and Billie, so instead she threw it at the ceiling just above David, causing rocks and boulders to fall down from it on top of David covering him with a large pile of dust and boulders that no mortal would survive.

However David was not a mortal anymore. That won't keep him down for long, Paige thought to herself as she pulled her arm out from around Billie and quietly made her way around to face the blonde.

"It's okay Billie. I'm not going to let him hurt you." Paige said gently while stroking Billie bruised cheek with her thumb lightly removing the dried tear stains from her face. She waited as Billie opened her eyes nervously and looked up to her fearfully. Paige sighed in relief to see that Billie was not cowering away from her.

"It's okay... I'm not going to hurt you." Paige said smiling warmly at the frightened child in front of her. "Come here sweetie." She said as she picked Billie up in her arms and slowly stood up placing the fragile girl gently on her hip.

It was only when Paige had Billie in her arms that she could feel how underweight her friend now was, and that worried her. She's still got that fever Pheebs was talking about, Paige thought to herself after she felt Billie's forehead touch her neck from where the young blonde was resting her head on Paige's shoulder.

As Paige turned around she could feel Billie tense in her arms as buried her head further into Paige's loose hair. "Let's get you home." Paige said rubbing her free hand, which was not being used to hold Billie up, along the blonde's back gently, before the two disappeared in a swirl of blue orbs.