Thank you very much everyone for your input. From what I can tell, Mystery Girl or Sheena has been chosen. But don't worry Centi fans, she'll get her turn in the future.
"I-I don't know if I'm ready for this."
"Trust me Pearl, you look beautiful. You're going to have a great night with her." Steven encourages his lovely looking Pearl before kissing her cheek, causing her to blush. Pearl currently had teal lipstick on her gentle lips, and wore a simple yet beautiful flowy seafoam green dress. Currently she was getting ready for a big date. She may love being with Steven, but after her meeting with Sheena, she knew she couldn't just stay away from her. Fortunately Steven was more than happy to help her, wanting to spread love everywhere. His pep talk though was cut short as he hears a knocking on the door.
"Oh it must be her! I'll go greet her."
"S-Steven wait I'm not ready!"
Steven runs over to the front door, although quickly made sure he had his clothes on. One time he opened the door when Connie came over for sword practice, and he forgot that he was butt naked. Of course this led to different 'sword training'. Steven nods as he sees he was currently fully dressed, then opens the door. In the doorway was the seductive yet mysterious Sheena, with her wild large pink hair, a low cut white top with the logo of an obscure band that noticeably was stretched out by the human's impressively large bosom, and ripped jeans that hugged her wide hips. Pink lipstick on her plump lips, she looks to Steven and blushes lightly before coughing.
"Um, hey is Pearl here?"
"Sheena! Great to finally meet you face to face. Pearl is just finishing getting ready. Come on Pearl!"
Sheena's attention was ripped from the handsome lad as her eyes widen at the sight of Pearl walking over, adorably blushing hard while her hands nervously play with the hem of her dress.
"Wow. You look amazing Pearl." Sheena states with a sweet smile, walking over and kissing Pearl's cheek. This only makes Pearl more flustered then smiling.
"T-thank you." She takes a deep breath, feeling more confident. "I hope we have lots of fun!" She gently wraps her arms around Sheena's bigger arm before they finally head out. Steven wipes away a tear as Pearl leaves.
"They grow up so fast."
Pearl and Sheena went out onto the bigger woman's motorcycle, riding through the night and enjoying the wind. Later on they enjoy a pleasant picnic in a beautiful secret meadow that Pearl would go to in order to relax. In the past, it was a space she shared with Rose, but she felt Sheena would appreciate it just as much. While Pearl normally didn't enjoy eating, she couldn't pass up eating at least one strawberry from their meal. What Pearl didn't realize was that her time with Steven, and the many lewd endeavors they have been a part of seemed to have become a subconscious part of her. As she takes the strawberry, she lightly sucks on the sweet fruit before taking a soft bite, the juices squirting softly on her lips. Sheena blushes hotly as she watches Pearl, never realizing fruit can look so enticing on another person.
After the picnic they go to ride the motorcycle again, but unfortunately the area was prone to strong winds. Pearl squeaks as the wind blows at her dress from behind, causing her dress to lift up high and give Sheena quite the sight. Pearl's cream colored sexy round butt adorned by light blue lacy panties, completely exposed as the cold wind blows. Once the wind dies down, Pearl hurriedly pushes down her dress, her blue green blush all over her face. Sheena had no idea how to react, only blushing furiously with a stoic expression.
"I-I'm sorry, these winds can be so strong at random intervals. L-let's get going." With the couple embarrassed and aroused, they get back into the motorcycle and drive off. Back at the temple, Sheena was about to drop off Pearl until the gem gently grasped her hand. "Um, w-would you like to...come inside?~" Sheena was surprised at Pearl's forwardness, but no one could resist the half lidded sexy look of lust Pearl had on her face.
"Oh my stars!~" Pearl screams out in pleasure as Sheena's skilled tongue works her magic, maneuvering with ease as it explores the inside of her wet pussy, Sheena fingering herself as she listens to the harmonious moans and screams elicited from Pearl. "T-this is fantastic~ I-I don't know how I can get any better~"
"I think I may know how~" Sheena raises an eyebrow as she hears someone behind her, but then just squeaks and moans loudly in surprise as something thick and hot penetrates her soaking wet pussy, making her moan loudly and double her efforts on Pearl's pussy. Pearl screens in pleasure, her vision adjusting as she looks to see her young man Steven taking the initiative and ravaging her date's cunt as hard as he can.
"S-Steven?! W-what are you, ah~ doing?"
"Garnet said that if I joined in, it could help your date be much more fun and leave you both extremely happy!" Steven smiles happily as he grabs Sheena's wide hips and began pounding her harder and faster. Sheena couldn't think straight, her body working on its own, her pussy tightening around the handsome man's cock, and her tongue swirling inside her sexy beautiful date's pussy.
"W-well she seems to be right once again~ I-I'm close to cumming!~" Pearl screams in pleasure, her hips shaking as she finally reaches her climax, her love juices squirting onto Sheena's tongue.
"Don't tell me you're done already Pearl, didn't you teach me it's always good to return kindness and love?~" Steven grins as he lifts up Sheena into the air and began ravaging her tight pussy harder and faster with the help of gravity, Pearl getting a show of Steven's cock sliding in and out of her tight cunt.
"Fuck!~ W-why is this kid so good?~" Sheena thought out loud as she had mini orgasms with every inhumanly pleasurable thrust into her pussy. She thought it couldn't possibly get any better, but then she was greeted with the sight of Pearl diving in and licking and kissing the area where Steven's cock entered Sheena, Pearl doing an exceptional job of using her tongue to tease Sheena's clit and worships Steven's shaft and heavy testicles.
"I have to be honest Sheena, I've been f-fucking with Steven for quite some time, and I really was hoping you would join us. I promise you will feel pleasure every day~ you don't have to make a decision now, but we'll give you a taste of what you will get by joining.~ Finish her off Steven!~"
"Of course Pearl~" Steven reaches around and spreads Sheena's legs wider so he can have more access to fuck her. His cock speared the deepest parts of her pussy, the tip hitting her cervix and making a large bulge in her stomach with every hard thrust. Sheena couldn't hold herself back anymore, with a dazed blissful look on her face and her eyes rolling up, she screams out into the air from the pure ecstasy as she finally cums, her pussy tightening and seeming to try and pull Steven's cock deeper inside her, while Pearl eagerly lapped up her juices. However, it was far from over as her next bout of pleasure would be coming in a few seconds. The feeling of her tight pussy clenching and milking Steven's cock, pushed the young man over the edge as his cock pulsates and began firing massive spurts of his hot delectable sticky seed directly into Sheena, effectively painting her insides white and bringing her to another intense orgasm.
Sheena lays on the bed, face down and ass up with her overflowing cum filled pussy on full display, her mouth drooling lightly as she tried to regain her senses.
"Whoops, I think we went a little overboard on her." Steven chuckles softly, rubbing the back of his head before letting out a small gasp, then looking down to see Pearl looking up at him with her lust filled eyes as she gives his cock a big wet kiss.
"I'm sorry for being greedy Steven, but I'm still horny~"
"No problem Pearl, it's my pleasure~" Steven happily pounces on Pearl, eliciting an adorable squeak from her as he began fucking her exactly as she liked it, tender and loving, but rough and passionate as well, all in complete view of Sheena.
I can't believe it, 100 followers and favorites for this story, I'm completely astonished. I'm glad so many of you are enjoying this story. Thank you all so much. And who's ready for Memorial Day? More Steven Universe equals more ideas for chapters. Heck, I'm tempted to even try Aquamarine (as a shortstack, not a loli, don't worry) and Topaz, but I'm gonna wait to see what info they're gonna offer in the special first. Next chapter should be Centipeetle and her crew, or Nephrite as so many of you suggested, thanks again btw. And other plans include Ruby and Sapphire, then maybe attempt fusions. Until next time, I hope you all manage to enjoy.