Disclaimer: I do not own anyone or anything, except for Prue's kids.
Cast
(Picture all actors/actresses the appropriate age, please.)
Main Characters
Shannen Doherty as Prudence "Prue" Halliwell
Holly Marie Combs as Piper Halliwell
Alyssa Milano as Phoebe Halliwell
Rose McGowan as Paige Montana
Julian McMahon as Cole Turner
Brian Krause as Leonardo "Leo" Wyatt
Victor Webster as Coop Halliwell
Balthazar Getty as Richard Montana
Recurring Characters
Ocean Maturo as Phoenix Langdon Halliwell
Lily Rose Smith as Persephone "Seph" Amethyst Halliwell
Jason and Kristopher Simmons as Wyatt Matthew Halliwell
Chandler Riggs as Pagan Victor Halliwell
Maximillian Kesmodel as Christopher "Chris" Perry Halliwell
Clara Thomas as Melinda Prudence Halliwell
Selena Gomez as Tamora Lisa Montana
Selena Gomez as Katherine "Kat" Phoebe Montana
Sierra Paris as Prudence Johnna "P.J." Halliwell
Jack Fulton as Richard Scott Montana Jr
Maia Mitchell as Parker Patricia Halliwell
Jennifer Rhodes as Penelope "Penny" Halliwell
Finola Hughes as Patricia "Patty" Halliwell
James Read as Victor Bennett
Scott Jaeck as Samuel "Sam" Wilder
Dorian Gregory as Darryl Morris
Chris Wood as Rennek
Nina Dobrev as Neena
Rebecca Balding as Elise Rothman
Alex Black as Tyler Michaels
Emily Bett Rickards as Bailey
Ryan Reynolds as Hogan
Timothy Webber as Montgomery Knox
Lucy Lawless as Glynnis
Peter Woodward (voice) as The Source of All Evil
Minor Characters
(Will be added as they appear.)
Ksenia Solo as Mika
Dan Horton as Cal Greene
Morality Bites Back
[Scene: The Bay Mirror. Prue is in her office working on her column on the desktop computer, while Phoebe is typing up her manuscript on her laptop.]
Trust. They say it's the foundation of any healthy relationship. I certainly won't disagree.
(A woman walks in.)
Woman: Working on your manuscript, Phoebe?
Phoebe: I'm on my lunch break, Mika, not writing my book on company time.
Prue: You mean we're not always on company time?
Mika: Well, I've got something totally not work-related to talk about.
Phoebe: You're finally going to tell us about your guy?
Mika: Guy?
Prue: The one you've been secretly seeing.
Mika: It's not a secret. I just didn't want to say anything till it was serious. He's kind of… famous.
Phoebe: Movie star? Politician?
Mika: Baseball player. It's Cal Greene. (Both Prue and Phoebe's eyes widen, flashing back to when they learned that Phoebe would be burned at the stake for killing a man named Cal Greene. Mika sits down and starts going through her purse.) We met two months ago, at an MLB press event.
Phoebe: Cal Greene, the baseball player?
Mika: Yes, Cal Greene, the baseball player. Here, I have extra. (She takes a photo out of her purse and shows it to them.) Anyway, I know this is last minute, but are you two and your husbands free tonight?
(Prue nods.)
Phoebe: Tonight? We've got plans. Dinner.
Mika: Oh, it's just…. You guys are the first people I've told. He hasn't met any of my friends-
Phoebe: Yes. Absolutely. I want to meet him.
Mika: But your plans?
Phoebe: We can postpone.
(Elise walks in.)
Elise: You are not postponing the web chat.
Prue: Not that.
Phoebe: We're talking about Mika's new guy. She finally spilled the beans.
Elise: I'd rather talk about the chat.
Mika: We're all set for tomorrow night. Prue will be great.
Prue: Yeah. Everything's great.
[Scene: Halliwell Manor. Prue, Piper, Phoebe, and Paige are there.]
Piper: Did you have a premonition?
Phoebe: No, just a bad memory. A really, really bad memory.
Piper: So you don't know for sure that Cal Greene is evil? We're different people. He could be too.
Phoebe: Because we saw what we could become when we travelled to the future. He didn't have that experience.
Prue: She's right, Phoebe. We don't know what's the same and what's different.
Phoebe: I can't take that risk.
(Phoebe shows Piper the photo.)
Phoebe: Eight years ago, I saw myself place my hands around Cal's head. And these… these tiny bolts of electricity shot out, we levitated, and then he fell dead. That happens less than a year from now and I still don't know what I do to him… what this new power's supposed to be.
Piper: This new ability hasn't even emerged yet.
Paige: Well, she could get a new power soon. In case you haven't noticed, that's going around.
Phoebe: Yeah, and then I may kill Cal with my bare hands.
Paige: Oh my god, that's a bit dramatic.
Phoebe: Seriously. I won't intentionally attack a human, but what if it emerges while I'm protecting Mika?
Piper: We're still not sure she needs protection.
Prue: Phoebe, we can't overreact. We already saw that our actions have repercussions.
Paige: The witch trials? Witches in hiding? Panic in the streets? It all sounds horrible.
Piper: It was. And we've got more than just my daughter to protect this time.
Phoebe: Am I supposed to trade Mika's life to protect my families'?
Piper: No. But we have to be careful.
Prue: We'll go meet Cal, find out who he is now. Maybe you'll get a new premonition off him. Or some empathy vibe. Then we can figure out what to do.
[Scene: Restaurant. Prue, Phoebe, Cole, Coop, Mika, and Cal are there. Phoebe is shaking Cal's hand.]
So many times, when I met someone new, I had to hold back a part of me, too afraid to reveal myself, too afraid to take that risk.
Cal: Nice to meet you.
Phoebe: Tell me all about yourself.
[Time lapse. Restaurant. Prue, Phoebe, Cole, Coop, Mika, and Cal are there.]
Cal: I swear it wasn't a line. She really looked like an angel in that dress. You know, the one with the feathers on the….
[Time lapse. Restaurant. Prue, Phoebe, Cole, Coop, Mika, and Cal are there.]
Phoebe: That's so funny. But how did you run the bases with your pants….?
[Time lapse. Restaurant. Prue, Phoebe, Cole, Coop, Mika, and Cal are there.]
Cal: Got pregnant on your honeymoon? My aunt would break out the calendar….
[Time lapse. Outside the restaurant. Prue, Phoebe, Cole, Coop, Mika, and Cal are there.]
Cal: It was great meeting you guys. We have to do this again.
Phoebe: Drive safe!
It was the fear that held me back, that kept me from opening up to another person.
Phoebe: I got nothing from him, and I really tried. This night was a total waste.
Coop: It's not over yet. I've got a surprise. (to Prue and Cole) You guys mind?
(Cole shook his head.)
Prue: Have fun. Don't stress, Phoebs.
[Scene: Cupid's Temple. Phoebe and Coop are there.]
Phoebe: Cupid's temple! My favorite view of the Italian coastline.
Coop: That's why I chose this spot to propose.
Phoebe: Kind of hard to say no when you're at the genesis of all love on the planet.
Coop: I needed all the help I could get. We'd only been dating for a few months.
Phoebe: Do you ever wonder if we rushed into things?
Coop: No.
Phoebe: I like your conviction. Mika seems just as sure about Cal.
Coop: You can't seriously compare our relationship to theirs.
Phoebe: True. Cal wasn't sent by the Elders. But she doesn't know much about him. He could be a potential killer. This could end with Mika dead. What am I supposed to do? Tell her I'm a witch? That before I ever met her I saw myself killing Cal for her murder?
Coop: Just be there for her. Find out the truth if you can. And trust her to recognize the trouble before it happens.
Phoebe: What if he's a great guy and I ruin it with my suspicions?
Coop: I have complete faith that you will do what's right.
Phoebe: I'm glad one of us does. (A cherub flies over to them with a note.) Aw, so cute. This isn't the anniversary celebration I'd imagined.
Coop: As long as we're together, that's all that matters.
(Coop takes the note from the cherub.)
Phoebe: Wait, he's a messenger cherub? What, you guys can't send a text?
Coop: Gives the trainees something to do. I called in a favor for you. (He looks at the note.) One question answered. Mika and Cal are in love, but it's not an eternal love. They aren't fated to be together forever.
Phoebe: Because he's going to kill her?
Coop: That part's not written yet.
Phoebe: Figures.
Coop: At least we know you can break them up without altering their entwined fates.
Phoebe: It would be easier if your Cupid resources could tell me if I should get involved.
Coop: Maybe we're not supposed to use our abilities for this. Rely on your natural gifts. You're sensitive. Trust in yourself, and know that I've got your back.
It all changed when I finally met the man that I could finally be honest with, about everything. I lucked out because he already knew the big things before we even met. But it was the little things we learned together that really mattered.
[Scene: The Bay Mirror. Phoebe is there going through the company computer. She is doing research on Cal Greene.]
Phoebe: Nothing…. Nothing…. And a very suspicious nothing.
[Time lapse. The Bay Mirror. Phoebe is speaking to a woman.]
Woman: You're going to need to talk to Burns about that.
Phoebe: The crime reporter?
[Time lapse. The Bay Mirror. Phoebe is speaking to Burns.]
Burns: You need to speak to Elise.
Phoebe: Seriously? You can't tell me anything?
Burns: Talk to Elise.
[Time lapse. The Bay Mirror. Phoebe is speaking to Elise in Elise's office.]
Phoebe: Why did Cal Greene mysteriously disappear from our newspaper last May?
Elise: Guess he's not having a great year. You know I don't follow baseball.
Phoebe: You love baseball, and Cal is having a record-breaking year. He told me so last night. Why aren't we covering him?
Elise: You'd make a great investigative reporter.
Phoebe: Elise, tell me what's going on.
Elise: It was right after spring training. A woman - a girl, really - came to me. There's always been talk about Cal's anger issues. Trashing a locker room. Breaking a fan's camera. But this girl was beaten. Badly. She wanted us to tell her story. I begged her to go to the police. Insisted on it. Without an official report, it would have been too easy to discredit her. I brought her straight to the district attorney to make an official report. Once it was filed, we'd run the story.
Phoebe: It never ran.
Elise: She recanted everything. Cal must have paid her off, or threatened her.
Phoebe: You just let the story go?
Elise: No. I told Burns to dig deeper. He found more rumors about more women. But no proof. Cal threatened us. First with lawsuits, then actual threats. Again, nothing we could prove. I know it was him, but we were forced to keep it quiet for legal reasons.
Phoebe: You have to tell Mika.
Elise: I gave her his file as soon as she told me about him. She was a mess, had to go home to think.
Phoebe: Elise, how could you let her leave? She's going to go right to him.
Elise: Calm down. You know Mika better than that. She won't-
Phoebe: Yes, she will. I'm sure of it.
Elise: Phoebe, if you know something, you need to tell me. You have to go to the police. You can't just go tearing out of here like you always do.
Phoebe: I don't know anything. It's just a feeling. I can't explain it.
Elise: You never explain anything. This isn't the time for your secrets.
Phoebe: I've got to go.
[Scene: Phoebe is in her car talking to Prue, Piper, and Paige.]
Phoebe: Cal has a history of violence! He's still on his path! Mika isn't safe, and she's not answering her damn phone!
Prue: Okay, slow down. Is Cal going after her right now?
Phoebe: That's what I'm going to find out if these people would drive!
Paige: Phoebe, getting yourself killed is not going to solve anything. Do you want me to orb you?
Phoebe: No need. I'm almost there.
Prue: Then what's the plan?
Phoebe: We stop Cal.
Piper: How? We can't hurt him. He's human. We can't use our powers for vengeance, Phoebe. If we learned anything-
Phoebe: It's not vengeance if I'm protecting an innocent. I'm here. I'll call you when I know more.
[Scene: Outside Mika's apartment. Phoebe bangs on the door.]
Phoebe: Mika, are you in there?! Mika!
(Mika opens the door.)
Mika: Let me guess. You heard the news?
(Phoebe walks in and Mika closes and locks the door before leading Phoebe into the living room.)
Phoebe: You have to believe Elise.
Mika: I do. I wanted to talk to Cal in person, but he called first, and it all just came out. (Mika starts crying.) He didn't even deny it, just started screaming about me not trusting him. The things he said, the way he…. I never heard…. It doesn't matter. It's over.
Phoebe: Cal doesn't seem like the kind of person that lets things go that easily.
Mika: But I am. When I'm done with someone, I'm done. Right now I'd rather focus on work. You need to call Prue. We need to get to the office for the web chat. She goes live in a couple of hours.
(They leave the apartment and Phoebe sees a car parked outside a window.)
Phoebe: Let's take the stairs.
And okay, I admit. I had some inside information. A little bird told me that this guy was right for me. But do any of us really know the future for certain?
[Scene: The Bay Mirror. Piper and Paige are there talking.]
Paige: What about the spell to discourage a lover? If he loses interest in Mika-
Piper: He'll move on to the next woman. This is a human monster. A spell might not be enough.
[Cut to Prue's office. Prue, Phoebe, and Mika are there.]
Mika: Nothing like throwing yourself into work to get over a breakup. I can't believe that he really did those things. That he's like that. I thought I knew him. I thought-
Prue: Some people are really good at keeping their secrets. You would have found out eventually. Better that it was this way.
Mika: Your sisters don't have better things to do on a Friday night than hanging around outside my office?
Prue: They're here for moral support. It's my first live web chat.
Mika: You sure they're not here to protect me in case Cal comes by?
Phoebe: What could the four of us possibly do?
[Cut to Piper and Paige.]
Paige: I know! I can glamour myself to look like every woman he's hurt and scare the crap out of him in the middle of the night.
Piper: Maybe something a little less Dickensian.
(Prue and Phoebe walk over to them.)
Phoebe: Thanks for this. I don't know if Cal is going to show up, but I feel better with us together.
Piper: Of course. We screwed up this future once already. We'll get it right this time.
Paige: I'm just here for a night off from crying babies. Kidding. But, why are you doing this chat on a Friday night?
Prue: Mika's idea.
Phoebe: She's calling it 'girls' night in'.
Mika: Five minutes!
(Phoebe suddenly clutches her heart as she has a premonition. It's of herself crying at a funeral.)
Premonition!Phoebe: She was a very dear friend, one of my best friends, outside of my sisters. (Elise is shown inside of a coffin, dead.) I only wish I would have been there in time to help her.
(The premonition ends.)
Phoebe: Oh my god! It's Elise! (Phoebe takes off running. Prue, Piper, and Paige run after her.) Elise was pressuring Cal. Pushing the article. Telling Mika.
Paige: Is she still here this late?
Prue: She won't go home till the paper goes to press.
Piper: I froze Mika so she doesn't come after us.
[Cut to Elise's office. Prue, Piper, Phoebe, and Paige run in. They see Cal inside.]
Phoebe: Cal! Piper!
(Piper freezes him.)
Piper: Got him!
(Phoebe raises her hands up to Cal's head.)
Phoebe: I can feel it. I can feel it. There's so much hate, and anger. Even frozen, I can feel it inside him. It's inside me. I know what I did. I used his own rage to kill him, flooded his mind with his reflected emotions, overloaded his brain with the memories of the women he hurt, what he was feeling when he attacked them. The fear they felt. I think I can do it. I can stop him.
Piper: Not like this.
Prue: Let the police deal with him.
Phoebe: The police won't help. I saw it. He gets- (They finally see Elise on the floor, badly beaten and unconscious.) Elise!
Prue: Is she…?
Phoebe: Still alive? Barely. Paige, can you heal her?
(Paige starts to heal Elise.)
Paige: It's okay. She's going to be fine. We got here in time.
Phoebe: Only because you were here. If you weren't, Elise-
Paige: Don't think about it.
Phoebe: I want to hurt him. I want to kill him.
(Piper embraces Phoebe.)
Piper: I know.
Prue: How do we make sure he's punished if we already know the system is going to fail?
Phoebe: I've got an idea. Think you can glamour yourself into a convincing bastard, Paige?
(Elise wakes up.)
Elise: What happened? Where's Cal?
Phoebe: Gone. You're safe. But there's something Prue and I need to tell you. Something we should have told you long ago. Then we're going to need your help.
Trust isn't a single issue. It doesn't just happen in one day. It's a constant process. You have to know when you can trust your friends with your deepest secrets.
[Scene: The Bay Mirror. Elise is watching a news broadcast through a glass. She looks as if she was badly beaten, but her reflection shows her perfectly fine.]
Reporter: D.A. Nathaniel Pratt is charging Cal Greene in the attack on Bay Mirror editor-in-chief Elise Rothman that streamed live over the internet.
[Scene: The "A Glamour to Change One's Appearance" spell is shown in the Book of Shadows.]
Trust that your family will be there to protect you. And trust yourself to take the risk.
[Scene: Phoebe's apartment. Phoebe is there closing her laptop.]
But that trust can't be blind. You have to take care to protect yourself from the unknown. To guard your heart.
(Coop walks over to Phoebe and hands P.J. to her.)
Until one day you realize that someone else is guarding it along with you. Because once you find the strength in yourself, you will be able to find your love and turn it into something greater: Trust.