A One in a Millionth Chance
*This is a Klaine and Blellie story. Weird combination, I know, but I had an idea. It may start out as confusing, but it'll become clearer.
*I don't think that there will be POV's, but it will focus on one of the main 4 characters in each chunk of the story. I might do POV's when something important happens though.
*So, every chapter is going to be titled. The title is going to be based off of a lyric of a song, or song title, that I think fits the chapter.
*This chapter is titled by the song 'I Just Haven't Met You Yet' by Michael Bublè
.Nellie.
The next couple days passed by and soon it was Friday night. Blaine and Nellie had had one gig since the first and Nellie was really loving her job so far. Sure, Blaine teased her about Blake…a lot. And often told her what Blake said about her, which usually made her blush beet red. But, it did make her feel flattered. She had only met the guy once (twice if you count the first time they saw each other) and he seemed really attracted to her. She had never actually felt like this since her last boyfriend…and it felt amazing.
"What are you guys doing here?" She asked as she stood frozen in the kitchen watching her two roommates like hawks.
"Eating…" Rachel said with a weird expression, wondering what the other girl was talking about.
"You said you would be going out tonight!"
"So? What do you have going on? A date?" Kurt smirked and Nellie shook her head and stole one of the strawberries from his bowl.
"No, Blaine's coming over so we can rehearse our next set"
Rachel giggled and Kurt let out a snort "How ironic"
"What do you mean?"
"We were supposed to hang out with Blake tonight but we were all tired, so we decided to just have a movie night"
"So Blake and Blaine are both coming over here?" Nellie questioned, trying to ignore how tingly she felt when Blake was brought into the conversation. Damn it! She was being cliché again, wasn't she?
"Yep" Rachel snickered "I think we should invite Puck over too so all of our boyfriends are here" She teased and then was hit by her two friends. "Sorry, Puck's my boyfriend and Blaine and Blake are your soon to be boyfriends" She corrected with a smirk
"Shut up, Rachel" Kurt mumbled and took a bite of the strawberry. "And don't pull that crap when they're here"
"I won't…if you give me my musicals back"
"No. You embarrassed me in front of Blaine"
"How?"
"You made me laugh like an idiot because you spit all over Blake. I looked ridiculous"
"I didn't do it on purpose!"
"Sure you didn't!"
"Hey, calm down. Kurt give Rachel back her musicals because she didn't mean to and I don't want her humiliating me tonight. And I know you don't want her to humiliate you"
Kurt groaned "Fine, but you say one word to Blaine about me, I will take them back and then I'll show Puck the shrine of him you have in your room"
"It's not a shrine!" Rachel says defensively "I just have a lot of pictures of us together on my wall!"
"Well, I call it a shrine!"
Rachel huffed "Fine, I won't say anything to Blaine, just give me my movies back!"
"Fine"
"This is going to be a long night…" Nellie sighed as she plopped down next to Kurt on a stool.
/
"So you had no idea that Blake was coming over too?" Blaine questioned as he strummed on Nellie's guitar as she shuffled through some of her pictures.
"Nope" Nellie replied as she turned back towards him "Kurt and Rachel told me they weren't going to be home tonight-"
"-but then they decided to have a movie night" Blaine finished "Blake told me on the way here" Nellie nodded and Blaine continued to pluck at the strings. He played a familiar song and Nellie raised an eyebrow
"Mulan?" She giggled as he played the tune of 'I'll Make a Man Out of You'
"Hey! It's a good song"
"Okay, whatever" Nellie smirked and he laughed
"So, you still in love with Blake?" Blaine asked nonchalantly. Nellie twisted around and sent him a glare
"Shut up! I'm not in love with him!" Nellie hissed "We've only known each other for a little while over a week, and you're already teasing me!"
"Hey! You tease me!"
"When?"
"All the time! About the" He nodded his head towards her closed door "situation" Nellie laughed and then glanced at the door.
"So, I'm not the only one who's in love, now am I?"
"Ha! You just admitted it!"
Nellie gave him a confused look and then her eyes widened "No! I was just-"
"You were just what?"
Nellie looked at him and then flopped onto the bed. "Shut up"
They played a couple songs, switching who had the guitar every now and then. They were singing to 'Teenage Dream' when they heard shouts come from the other end of the apartment.
"I DIDN'T TAKE THAT ONE, RACHEL! YOU TOOK IT FROM ME!"
"NO I DIDN'T!"
"YES YOU DID!"
Nellie groaned "This is what happens when you live with two divas" Blaine let out a laugh and they both got off the bed and walked towards the living room.
"I DIDN'T GIVE IT BACKBECAUSE IT'S MINE! SO BACK OFF!"
"YOU TOOK MY COPY OF THE SOUND OF MUSIC!"
"I DID NOT!"
Nellie and Blaine walked into the room as they continued to scream at each other and they noticed Blake sitting on one of the stools. He looked up from his phone when he heard footsteps and he smiled softly and then nodded his head towards the two bickering friends. "I'm not getting in the middle of one of their 'Diva Fights' again. I learned by lesson last time I tried to help. Plus, this fight doesn't make any sense to me"
Nellie gave Blaine an 'I Told You So' look and then walked over to Rachel before she slapped Kurt across the face. "Hey, hey, hey, don't." The two remained still, staring at each other with anger. "What's this about now?"
"Kurt won't give me my copy of the Sound of Music back!"
"I didn't take it!"
"You said you took all my musicals!"
"I left some! I only took your favorite ones knowing that you'd end up apologizing!"
Rachel huffed "Well the Sound of Music is mine"
"It's mine! My name is written inside the case!"
"Okay, let's just look at the case and see if it's Kurt's" Nellie said
"Kurt probably wrote his name in their after he stole it" Rachel snapped
"Rachel, stop" Kurt handed the DVD to Nellie and she looked inside the case where she saw a faded out Kurt Hummel written in it. "his name it in here"
"This isn't fair!" Rachel exclaimed
"It is too! You stole it from me!"
"What does it matter?" Nellie exclaimed and everyone looked at her in shock "We live in the same house! You only watch it with each other anyway" Rachel scoffed and then glared at Nellie as she walked out of the room. She stopped in the doorway and then spun around with a smirk as she looked at Blaine.
"You know, your boyfriend sure has issues. He can be a real diva" Nellie bit her lip to stifle her laugh, and she saw that Blake did too. Kurt went bright red and so did Blaine and before any of them knew it, Kurt was walking towards Rachel.
"Kurt" Nellie said warningly.
"Relax, I'm not going to hurt her. I'm just going to keep my promise to her" Nellie raised an eyebrow in confusion and then smirked.
"Way to keep your promises" Kurt smirked right back at her and rushed into Rachel's room.
"He wouldn't dare" Rachel gasped
"I think he would" Nellie responded and Rachel raced after Kurt.
"What is he doing?" Blake asked Nellie as she walked over to stand by them.
"Oh! Kurt told her if she embarrassed him in front of Blaine she would take a picture of the 'shrine' Rachel has of her boyfriend and send it to him. And Kurt's just sticking to his word"
Blake and Blaine started laughing as they heard Rachel start to scream "Aren't you going to go help settle it?" Blaine asked with a smirk at Nellie who scoffed and walked towards the fridge.
"No, I'm hungry" Blake laughed and Nellie tried to hide the blush as she saw Blaine nudged him and smirked. So, instead she continued like she didn't see it, scanning through the fridge for food.
"Wow, shows how much you care" Blake teased and Nellie giggled softly
"They'll work it out. I'm sure they had to do that when I wasn't here for a year" Nellie said as she picked up a pitcher of orange juice "You guys want some?"
"Sure"
"No thanks" Blaine said, casting a glance towards the kitchen's entry way.
"You know, Kurt's got a huge crush on you" Blake said and Nellie smiled
"Told ya!" Blake chuckled and Blaine looked down at his feet with a slight blush "Ask. Him. Out."
"I barely know him-"
"So get to know him on the date you ask him out to-"
"-Because everyone knows that you guys are attracted to each other" Nellie finished
"Fine. I'll ask him out. As soon as you guys admit that you're like in love!" Nellie's head snapped up, causing her to miss the glass and orange juice to flow over the counter "See. Even just thinking about it makes you get all distracted"
"Blaine!" Blake exclaimed, clearly embarrassed as well.
"What? You guys told me the truth, so I told you the truth. You just so happened to be in the same room when I said it" Nellie turned away to go and grab a towel from one of the drawers, trying to control her fiery red cheeks. "So, I'm going to go take your advice so you guys can talk"
"Wait, seriously?" Blake questioned as Blaine walked towards the entryway. "You're just going to ask him out?"
"Well, I'll talk to him first" Blaine winked "You have fun you two"
.Kurt.
Kurt raced to Rachel's room and dug out his phone on his way. He rushed in and quickly slammed the door to give him more time. He put his phone on picture mode and moved over towards Rachel's 'Puck Shrine' and snapped a picture just before Rachel flung the door open and jumped on his back. Kurt struggled and made sure to hold his phone away from her.
"Get off of me!"
"No!"
"Rachel!"
"No!"
"NELLIE! HELP!" Kurt groaned when he didn't hear footsteps. "RACHEL! GET OFF!"
"Give me your phone!" She exclaimed into his ear and he winced
"No!"
"Delete the picture!"
"No! Puck needs to know that you have a shrine of him"
"No!" Kurt felt to the floor and Rachel tried to get his phone but he quickly laid on top of it so she couldn't get it. "Kurt give me the damn phone!"
"No!"
"KURT!" Rachel shrieked and Kurt groaned as she sat on him "NELLIE HELP ME!"
"She's obviously not going to come and help us!"
"Well, how about we solve this?"
Kurt struggled to get out from under her "And how do you propose that?"
"I'll get off of you if you delete that picture"
"No! We had a deal! I said that I would talk a picture of your creepy shrine if you embarrassed me in front of Blaine…which is exactly what you did!"
"Ah, so I see Nellie was right" Kurt and Rachel's heads snapped towards the doorway and Kurt blushed bright red as he saw Blaine standing with a small smirk as he leaned against the doorway.
"Hiya Blaine!" Rachel smirked and then looked down at Kurt and patted his cheek "Looks like you simply embarrassed yourself instead"
"I hate you" Kurt glowered and then flipped onto his side, causing Rachel to fall onto the floor with a thump and a squeal.
"Kurt!"
"You deserved that!" Kurt snapped and then quickly grabbed his phone and sent the message.
"You did not just send that"
"Oh but I did"
"Get out of my room, I have to call Noah"
"I bet you do" Kurt sniggered as he stood up and started walking out of her room.
"Have fun with your new boy toy!"
Kurt stopped and turned back to scowl at her "Don't worry, I'll share if your boy toy dumps you because you're obsessive" Kurt smirked and took a bow "Burn"
Rachel gasped and then grabbed her phone and quickly scrolled through it. Kurt snorted and then walked out of her bedroom, trying not to blush as he realized that Blaine was behind him. "I'm sorry about her…she's…crazy" Blaine laughed
"It's okay. I kind of like it, makes me feel like you're attracted to me" Kurt flushed at Blaine's words and then tried to rummage up all of his courage.
"Well, you are quite handsome" Kurt said boldly, shocked that he had said that.
"I should be saying that about you" Blaine said flirtatiously and Kurt smiled. Why Blaine really flirting with him?
"Really?" Kurt raised an eyebrow
"Yes. I actually came to find you because one, Blake and Nellie needed to talk by themselves" Kurt nodded in agreement "And because I wanted to ask you out"
"Oh, really? And why is that?"
"Because you seem amazing" Blaine smiled
"You don't know that" Kurt said as he walked over to the couch. "You don't even know me, I could be a serial killer"
"Nah, if you were a serial killer, you'd probably have killed Rachel and Nellie by now"
"Nellie I don't know, but yeah, Rachel would definitely be dead" Kurt winked and Blaine let out a laugh. "So, when exactly did you realize that you wanted to ask me out?" Kurt asked seriously and Blaine smiled softly at him.
"Well I thought you were adorable when I first met you, and I knew that I should ask you out, but it didn't. Then in the kitchen after you and Rachel ran off to kill each other, Blake said that you have a huge crush on me-"
"Does he realize I can fire him?" Kurt said, clearly embarrassed and Blaine laughed and patted his arm.
"Relax, I've heard a lot about you from Nellie and Blake and I have to say that I have a crush on you too" Kurt looked at him in shock and then the corners of his mouth turned up.
"Seriously?"
"Why do you find that hard to believe?"
"Usually guys aren't interested in me…unless I happen to be at a bar and they're drunk"
"Well…I met you at a bar and I wasn't drunk"
"I'm glad you weren't" Kurt smiled
.Blake.
"Here, let me help you" Blake said as Nellie started dragging the rag over the counter to clean up the juice.
"You don't have to" Nellie said softly
"It's fine, really" Blake placed his hand on the other side of the rag, accidently brushing his fingertips across hers. Nellie tried to compress the shiver that went down her spine. They looked at each other for a second but then Nellie quickly looked down, trying to calm down.
"So…" Nellie said
"So…tell me about yourself…I don't know that much" Blake smiled and then Nellie couldn't help but smile back.
"You don't want to know about me…" Nellie trailed off
"Wanna bet?" Blake asked with a playful smile "I find you incredibly interesting so I want to know more"
"Okay…I like to sing…obviously. Um…I met Kurt at Starbucks, we worked together. Then when I thought I'd have to move back to Tacoma because I didn't have enough money to continue to live alone, Kurt offered his extra room. I lived here for about 6 months, and then my grandma got really sick and only had a couple months to live, so I moved back"
"Kurt mentioned that you lived there for a year…why'd you stay so long?"
"Well, at first it was because of my family, but then…" Nellie sighed, wanting to open up, but not wanting to relive anything. "I met this guy and we started going out…we dated for a while but then I found him ch-cheating on me"
"Nellie" Blake placed a hand over hers "You didn't have to tell me that"
"I wanted to" Blake smiled softly at her and kept his hand on hers, softly rubbing patterns into her skin. But Blake didn't seem to notice and Nellie wasn't about to point it out.
"Well, if it makes you feel any better, I haven't had the best luck in relationships either" Nellie raised an eyebrow. "I dated a girl that was sleeping around behind my back" Blake sighed "Thought I loved her, but I realized I didn't when I found out about her cheating"
"That's how I felt. This guy even told me that he didn't feel the same as I did, but I stayed with him, even though he didn't reciprocate my feelings"
"I don't know why a guy wouldn't feel the same way" Blake smiled "You're actually the coolest girl I've ever met" Nellie blushed "Don't tell Rachel I said that" Nellie giggled
"Why, do you say that to all of the girls?"
Blake chuckled and then smiled softly at her. "Nope. Only girls like you, and luckily for you I've never met anyone like you" Nellie gave the counter one last wipe and tried to not to blush.
"Now it's your turn to tell me about yourself" Nellie grinned, trying to take the focus off of herself.
.Blaine.
Blaine and Blake were walking back to their apartment. It was about 10 and they figured that they should probably leave. Neither of them had stopped smiling since they left their friends' apartment.
"So, what did you and Nellie talk about?"
"Well we talked about ourselves and our past relationships"
"Really?" Blaine smirked "Already on the past relationship phase? Man you work fast"
"Shut up" Blake exclaimed "Did you ask Kurt out?"
"I…um, I told him I was going to…but then we got to talking and I forgot…"
"So you guys aren't going out on a date?"
"We are…we turned the tables on me and asked me out" Blake barked out a laugh
"Kurt would do something like that" Blake smirked "So, when's this date?"
"Tomorrow" Blaine grinned dopily. "We're having coffee" Blaine then turned towards Blake "When are you going to ask Nellie out?"
"Blaine!"
"What? It's a legitimate question!"
"I hate you"
"Whatever, I have a date with your boss so you better be nice to me!"
"Whatever Blainers" And then Blake's eyes widened "No! I didn't mean to call you-"
"Oh, I know you didn't mean to, Blakey," Blake smiled evilly "But you did" Blake groaned as Blaine continued to walk with a cruel smirk etched on his face.
Wow…this one took some time! Hopefully it was worth the wait :)