With True Love Anything Can Happen
By CollegeStar20
Summary
17 year old Santana Lopez was in a relationship with her best friend Brittany Pierce since they were in middle until Brittany cheated on her with Quinn Fabray now they are Juniors at McKinley and Santana hates that Quinn is all over Brittany but what happens when the new girls Rachel, Rossi and Arilyn Berry who are all triplets but there fraternal triplets, move to Lima Ohio from London England with there famous dad Hiram Berry who is a big time Famous Lawyer from England but travels around alot while their daddy Leroy Berry is a famous Fashion Designer and everybody knows there names in the world.
Santana asks Rachel Berry to fake date her to make Brittany jealous even if she's with Quinn but what happens when San figures out that she's in love with Rachel, will she let Rachel know about her feelings or will it show that Brittany wants her. Find out what happens.
Oh you all know that Rachel and Santana are in a fake relationship so I'm not going to keep saying fake girlfriend anymore every time. They are still bests. Oh Rachel, Rossi, Arilyn and there dads can speak Spanish, French, Germin, Hebrew, and a little bit of Japanese, Oh Hiram is half French, Germin and Black while Leroy is half Spanish,Japanese and white so the girls are all mixed race. Santana can speak Spanish and a little bit of French.
Over the weekend Santana asked Rachel's dads if it was okay for her to move back in and they were glad and hugged her and said that they missed her so much! She laughed at Rachel's face as her dads went crazy and started talking about plans for them to do family stuff together! Arilyn was pleased to have Santana back since they became great friends but Rossi on the other hand didn't bother taking to Santana. Santana ended up leaving that night she talked to Rachel because she didn't want to be around Rachel until Monday so she could see what her costume was going to be. She moved her stuff back at the Berry house but she was staying at Quinns for two more days.
Halloween Day.
It was Halloween and every student at McKinley was dressed up for the day. The cheerios didn't have to wear their uniforms so they were wearing costumes aswell.
Santana Lopez walked into McKinley in her costume as super hot Naughty Prisoner and looked way to hot with red bright lipstick on her lips.
Quinn Fabray walked in next to her best dressed as a sexy Vampire, she wore black lipsick as well and dark makeup and looked really hot in.
Brittany was standing next to her looking just as hot in her sexy Witch costume and she had red lipstick on aswell.
"Wow we look super hot I wonder what the famous Berry triplets are going to be dressed as?" Brittany says before pecking her girlfriends lips.
Just then they hear footsteps coming up to them as they stood at their lockers and they heard two people talking to them.
"Happy halloween girls, your costumes look amazing!" The youngest triplet Arilyn Berry says as she's dressed as a super sexy Vixon Pirate Wench and Santana saw half of the guys trying to cover up their hard ons.
"Wow I'm loving your costume aswell, I like yours too Rossi!" Quinn says smiling at her nicely loving the costume.
The second oldest triplet Rossi Berry was dressed as a hot Dark Angel that fit her figure perfectly. She says thanks smiling nicely.
Finn and Puck both stared at the younger triplets in a daze.
"Where is Rachel, did she come today?" Santana asked looking around for the girl she was in love with. Both triplets stared at each other smirking before glancing at Santana.
"She wants to see you in the choir room right now!" They say at the same time before walking off with their pinkies laced together.
Santana stood next to her best friend and her old girlfriend getting nervous. Quinn tells her to get going and that she's going to be fine. Santana nods and walks off.
In The Choir Room.
17 year old Santana Lopez walked to the choir room before class started for everybody and opened the door only to find out that she was alone. She stood there trying to breathe because she couldn't get Rachel to tell her what her costume was and she really wanted to know.
"Wow you look gorgeous as a Naughty Prisoner Sanny!" The familiar british voice said making Santana slowly looked around but she couldn't see anybody.
"Rachel where are you?" San asked looking around then jumped when she saw Mr. Shue's desk chair turns around and her eyes nearly fell out seeing Rachel.
"Oh my god what was this girl was going to kill today!" Santana thought staring at the girl that stole her heart sitting in the chair with her bare legs crossed.
The oldest triplet Rachel Berry was dressed as a stunning and super sexy Miss Mafia! Her costume showed off her perfect petite frame but it also off her curves in all the right places! It was a super short halter black dress with white stripes that showed off her cleavage. She had on black fishnet stocks that came up to her knees, she on a white tie around her neck, a black and white striped hat that was to the side of her head a little! She has on bright red lipstick and dark eye makeup. On her feet wear white heeled boots. Her hair was in ringlet curls. She was holding onto a doller sign purse. She really looked like she was in the mob with the way she looked at Santana.
"Oh god I'm going to see her like this all day?" Santana thought staring at her shocked not sure she can breathe at the moment.
Rachel Berry stared at Santana smirking at her shocked face and slowly got up from the chair fixing her costume a little at the bottom and walked over to her swaying her hips seductively getting closer but when she got closer she walked around her and stood behind her and whispered in her ear seductively.
"Can you do something for me Naughty Prisoner?" She asked in a low sexy voice like she was in the Mafia. All Santana did was nod lost with words. Rachel smirks and walked back to the chair and sat down looking right at Santana who turned to her staring at her like she looked like a Millionaire bucks and all she wanted to was hold her close.
"Can you be my Naughty Prisoner for the day and do as I say?" She asked in a sexy voice glancing at her.
Santana felt herself getting turned on by Rachel's tone of voice and how she was dressed made her even more turned.
"A-A-Are you serious?" She stuttered feeling nervous! She needed to snap out of it because she was Santana Lopez and she never stutters.
"Dead Serious Naughty Prisoner, be mine for the day and I will give you your treat tonight at Puckerman's party!" Santana's eyes widen hearing that and nods.
"Okay I will be yours!" She mumbled softly making Rachel smirk loving her plan already. She got up from the choir and walked over to her Naughty Prisoner.
"Good Girl baby, walk me to class?" Santana nods smiling and Rachel grabbed San's hand and they left the choir room.
At Lunch with Santana and Rachel.
Everybody kept staring at Rachel Berry as she walked down the hallways looking fine as she did in her costume and Daniella Carson stared at Santana in jealousy because she knew that something was happening with her and Rachel again! She knew that Santana will always have Rachel some how and she just had to move on.
"Hey Naughty Prisoner, is this seat taken?" Rachel asked holding onto her Vegan lunch and Santana shook her head no as she sings.
"Are you ready for Noah's party tonight?" Rachel asked smiling at her and San nods taking a bite of her lunch and almost choked seeing Rachel's body closer to the table.
"Damn Berry do you really have to look so fine in that?" Santana muttered as she sees Rachel's cleavage in her view. Rach raised an eyebrow and glared at her.
"Excuse me Naughty Prisoner, did I tell you to talk to me like that?" She says firmly making Santana look down shaking her head.
"What was that baby?" Rachel cooed smirking. Santana looked up at her glaring hard at her sort of girl.
"No you didn't, watch your tone with me aswell Berry!" Rachel ran her foot against Santana's making her stop moving and stare into her eyes falling into Rach's spell.
"Listen here Lopez,you are my Naughty Prisoner and you will do as I say or else!" She growled before pulling her foot away to eat her lunch.
Santana could feel herself becoming way to hot and leave soon before she shows everybody that she was wet in between her legs. She got up from her seat only to be pushed back down by Rachel.
"Where are you going baby?" She asked curiously watching Santana breathe a little too hard, she was worried about her.
"I have to go to the bathroom if you don't mind!" She mumbled making Rachel nod telling her that she can go but she had to be quick.
Santana nods before getting up and rushing to the bathroom. Rachel ate her lunch and smiles evily knowing that her plan is making Santana turned on.
Later that day in Glee club.
Mr. Shue was feeling better and he liked everybody's costumes when he taught Spanish but he wasn't there yet. Elena left over the weekend and Catalina was still here and she was dressed as a hot cop. Kurt was dressed as Beetlejuice, Finn was dressed as Robin Hood, Puck was dressed as a Vampire Slayer, Mike was Zorro and Sam was Sweeney Todd! Artie was a Zombie. Mercedes was dressed as a Devil Temptress and Tina was a Playboy Cat.
"Are you better now baby, you seemed uptight in English class!" Rachel whispered seductively in Santana's ear. San looked at Rach pouting while nodding.
"I'm better now baby, thanks for asking!" San says calmly making Rachel peck her cheek.
"When are you moving back into my house Naughty Prisoner?" Santana tells her that tomorrow after school and Rachel squeals making Santana laugh.
Rachel knew that Santana had to get herself off at lunch and didn't like that she did it alone! She squeezed her her hip tightly making Santana jump.
"I know what you did in the bathroom Sanny, not happy about that one bit!" She squeezed a little harder making Santana whimper softly.
"I-I'm sorry Miss Mafia it won't happen again, please love me next time!" She whimpered making Rach smile letting her go.
"Alright Sanny I will help you next time, I will be there!" She says pecking her lips. Quinn and Brittany stared at Rachel and Santana as they sat with each other being all lovey dovey with each other. Rachel had her legs on Santana's lap now and Santana was running her hand up and down Rachel's waist smiling at her lovingly.
"Wow gang you all look super, does anybody have a song to sing before we talk about the setlist for Sectionals and Regionals?" Mr. Shue asked as he walked in.
Arilyn, Rossi and Rachel raised their hands making everybody stare at them surprised and Mr. Shue said it was fine and they all stood up and stood in the middle getting into their poses. The music starts making Rachel, Arilyn and Rossi move out of their poses moving to a fast pace.
The Sisters.
Calling all the monsters, calling all the monsters Calling all, calling all, calling all the monsters
Oh yea aye, oh yea aye, oh yea aye.
Rossi.
Heart thumps and you jump Comin' down with goosebumps! You dared to go there I'm a I'm a get you so scared!
Rachel and Arilyn smile at the group doing a fastpast tap dance making everybody clap for them as they sing together.
Rachel and Arilyn.
We're wanting to We're haunting you We're wantin' to Ehh ehh.
Rossi.
If you stayed and too late To be getting afraid This scene extreme... I I I I'm a get you so scared!
Rachel and Arilyn.
We're wanting to We're haunting you We're wantin' to Ehh ehh. Gonna get your body shake And wishin' you could just awake.
Rossi grabbed her sisters hands and they smirk at the group as they shake their hips really fast as they sing together.
The Sisters.
Here we go... Tonight all the monsters gonna dance We're coming to get you! Tonight all the monsters gonna dance We're comin' to get you! If you're only dreaming Why I hear you screaming? Tonight all the monsters gonna dance We're comin' to get you! We're coming to get you!
Callin' all the monsters, calling all the monsters Callin' all, callin' all, calling all the monsters.
Rossi and Rachel do their dance alone while Arilyn sings this time.
Arilyn.
You hide or you try... Kiss tomorrow goodbye! We thrill to your chill... B-B-B-Bucking for a freak-out!
Santana stared at Rachel as she sprins around dancing fast as she sings with her sister and Santana licked her lips a little.
Rossi and Rachel.
We're wantin' to We're haunting you We're wanting to Ehh ehh.
Arilyn.
We might just bite underneath the moonlight More fun if you run! I-I-I-I'm I'm already chasing.
Rachel winked at Santana as she dances and sings with her sisters and Santana blushed a little moving to the beat.
Rachel and Rossi.
We're wanting to We're haunting you We're wanting to Ehh ehh
Gonna get your body shake And wishing you could just awake.
The Berry sisters do the dance again making everybody cheer and clap for them.
The Sisters.
Here we go... Tonight all the monsters gonna dance We're coming to get you! Tonight all the monsters gonna dance We're coming to get you! If you're only dreaming Why I hear you screaming? Tonight all the monsters gonna dance We're comin' to get you! We're comin' to get you!
Callin' all the monsters, callin' all the monsters Callin' all, callin' all, callin' all the monsters!
Rachel, Arilyn and Rossi stand in a line shaking their hips as Rachel sings this time smirking at everybody.
Rachel.
Gonna paint it red, get inside your head, head, head Like a demon choir playing with fire, fire, fire
Gonna get your body shake And wishin' you could just awake.
They sing together having a great time finishing up the song.
The Sisters.
Tonight all the monsters gonna dance We're coming to get you! Tonight all the monsters gonna dance We're coming to get you! If you're only dreaming Why I hear you screaming? Tonight all the monsters gonna dance We're comin' to get you! We're coming to get you!
Oh yea aye, oh yea aye, oh yea aye.
They stand together smirking singing the last part.
We're coming to get you!
They finish and everybody claps for them. Santana jumps up and hugs Rachel telling her that she was great. Finn stared at Arilyn wanting to ask her out so badly.
Arilyn looked at Finn as she sat down and blushed slightly before talking to Kurt. Puck glanced at Rossi as she talked to Sam and he felt jealousy because they're are rumors going round that Rossi was kind of into Sam and they were dating each other without anybody knowing.
"That was great girls!" Mr. Shue says as Santana sits down and Rachel sits down next to her placing her legs back on her lap. He talks about the songs they should do for Sectionals and who should get solos and Duets. They talk for awhile then he plays music and everybody gets up dancing before the bell rings.
Finn walked over to Arilyn and smiles at her shyly. "Hey um Arilyn do you want to dance?" She stared up at him smiling but frowns.
"Oh you mean with you?" She asked raising an brow making Finn frown awkwardly about to walk away but gets pulled back by Arilyn.
"Finn I'm kidding yes want to dance with you!" She laughed and danced with him. Santana stood on the other side of the choir room with her hands on her girl's hips.
"Are you my Naughty Prisoner?" Rachel cooed making Santana nod as they dance together. Santana wanted to kiss Rachel so badly but Rachel was in charge.
"Good because tonight I want you only with me, nobody else!" She demanded! Santana nods telling her that she won't leave her side.
Find out what happens next and the song was Calling All The Monsters by China Anne Mcclain.