Co-written by RatedrKjErIcHo.
"Jaycee? You okay in there?" They heard Charlie's voice float through the bathroom door. Jaycee looked at John who groaned a little against her skin.
"Tell her you're fine." John whispered as his lips grazed her neck again.
"I'm fine Charlie." She said.
"Are you sure? You have been in there longer than normal."
Jaycee looked at John. "I just need a minute to myself and then I was going to get something to drink."
"I'm going down. I will get you something."
"Thanks Charlie." She heard her walk away from the door. She looked at John and got down off the counter. She started to walk away when he grabbed her arm.
"Wait, Jaycee." He pulled her to him. "What does this mean?"
"It doesn't mean anything." She turned to face him.
"I think it does." He said as he backed her against the door. He leaned in closer to her and kissed her neck. He slid the strap of her cami top down and kissed her shoulder. "I know it means something."
She couldn't stop the moan from her lips as he continued. She felt his hands on the other strap of her shirt and she felt it slid down. She grasp when she felt his mouth on one of her breasts as he dropped to his knees in front of her. She moaned as he continued and brought one of her nipples to his mouth. She felt the heat rising in her and she didn't want him to stop but she knew she had to stop it before they ended up having sex right there.
"What the hell are you doing to me here John?" She whispered making him stop. "Huh? Did you think you could corner me in the bathroom and make out with me again and all would be forgiven?"
"No. Jaycee it's not like that."
"Then what is it like John? You figured my reputation is already ruined and now all you had to do was make it true?"
"I didn't see you pulling away either time. You think this whole thing is only affecting you? It's been no picnic for me either."
"Well, you reap what you sew John." She said as she started to walk away. He grabbed her arm and looked at her.
"You still have feelings for me?"
"John..."
"Just answer the question. Do you still have feelings for me?" She nodded.
"Yeah, I do."
"Then give me a chance to fix this. Give me a chance to make this right with you. With Charlie. With everybody." He didn't give her a chance to say anything else. He walked out and back to his room.
Jaycee sighed once he was gone. He made her so angry by cornering her and then kissing her. But everything he did made her wanted him so much. She finished up in the bathroom and headed back to Charlie's room. She just needed to forget what happened. She walked in and saw that Lexie and Natalie were waiting.
"Took you long enough." Natalie said.
"Sorry, I just needed some time to myself." She said sitting down by them as Charlie came back with the drinks. She gave them out to the girls.
John walked into his room and found Mike watching a movie. He looked up at John.
"Where have you been?"
"Talking to Jaycee." He said as he sat down on his bed.
"From the looks of the lip gloss on your face, you did more than talk. Did you come clean and tell her the truth?" John looked at him. "What's the matter with you?"
"She still has feelings for me. I told her to give me a chance to make it right with her. With Charlie."
"Well it's about damn time you got on that track." Mike said as Natalie appeared at the door to John's room. Mike smiled at her.
"Um, we were going to order some pizzas? You guys want anything?"
"Pepperoni and mushrooms." Mike said before John could answer. Natalie nodded.
"We will let you know when they get here." She smiled and walked away.
"You should totally go for her." John said to him.
"Maybe." Mike smiled. "So, did you just make out with the girl?"
"We didn't have sex but I did more than kiss her and I'm sure it freak it her out. So, I'm pretty sure nothing happened with Randy."
"Well that's something."
The girls sat in Charlie's bedroom after the movie had gone off. "Let's totally play a game." Lexie suggested.
"Like what?" Charlie asked.
"Truth or Dare?"
"Really? You want to play that game?"
"What? Are you scared?"
"Fine. Nat, truth or dare?"
"Dare."
"I dare you to kiss Mike." Charlie said. "It's so obvious that you want to."
"What? No way."
"Oh come on! You jumped at the chance to go ask them about the pizzas. And he did rescue you from Maryse and punch Evan in the face for you." Lexie said.
"He did what?" Charlie and Jaycee asked.
"We were at the diner yesterday and Mike and John were there. Maryse came up and was messing with us. Mike told her to leave us alone. This was after she poured strawberry milkshake all over Natalie. Maryse said geeky girls had no place there. He asked her if snotty, bitchy pregnant girls did. Evan told him to watch his mouth. Mike said he had a rule against hitting girls and if he hit Evan it would be like hitting a girl. Then he looked at Nat, said rules were made to be broken and punched Evan. He grabbed Nat's arm and we hauled ass out of the diner. He took us to his house and gave Nat some clothes to change in to. Which if I'm not mistaken, is the shirt she's wearing now." Lexie said.
"Oh you so have to do it now." Charlie laughed.
"Guys."
"You choose dare." Jaycee said to her.
"Fine." She groaned and got up. The girls followed her to the door and watched as she knocked on the door to John's room. The door opened and before anything was said, she pulled Mike into a kiss. She looked back at the girls. "Satisfied?"
"Yeah that works." Charlie laughed as they headed back into the room.
Mike stood there shocked before heading back into John's room. He sat down on the sofa in the room. John looked at him.
"Her kiss that mind blowing?"
Mike smiled. "It was pretty damn nice. But I didn't think she'd actually do it."
"You heard them?"
"Yeah, you can totally hear them through the wall."
"I wonder if that's true with every room." John asked. He had never noticed you could hear through the walls.
"You mean you wonder if anyone heard your bathroom sexcade with Jaycee."
"There was no sex."
"Yeah but you said you did more than kiss."
"Let's just drop it." John replied.
"Good idea. Now let's listen in to this very fun game of truth or dare." Mike smiled as he and John went to where they could hear.
"Okay, Jaycee is next." Lexie smiled.
Jaycee thought for a minute. "Truth." She always hated dares.
"Okay." Natalie said. "Are you still in love with John? Even after the fact that he lied about you guys having sex. Do you still love him?"
Jaycee thought about it. "Come on, Jace. You choose truth." Lexie replied.
"Alright. The truth is yes, I still love him. Even though all we've ever been is friends, I love him. And even though I'm still angry about it, I can't shut off those feelings."
"Big shocker there." Charlie laughed. "But maybe my brother isn't all bad."
"What do you mean?"
"I think John's growing up."
"Enough with the philosophical stuff. Charlie truth or dare?"
"Did you and Phil have sex during the camping trip?" Natalie asked.
"Yes, we did. And it was the most wonderful thing in the world."
"Omg! You are so in love with him it's gross."
"I am in love with him. I don't know how to explain it."
"I think it's sweet." Jaycee said. "But I don't need to hear details, please."
The girls laughed. John stood at the wall with Mike seething with anger. Charlie had sex with Phil. Mike looked at his friend.
"John, she's a big girl and can make her own decisions." Mike tried to reason with him.
"I'm going to kill him for touching her."
"John, think about it. You're lusting after his sister. Hell, you almost probably had sex with her in the bathroom tonight." Mike said. "It's like I told you. He loves her and she loves him." John sighed.
"She's my little sister. I don't want to think about her doing that stuff."
"Here's some food for thought…all those girls you hooked up with, they are all somebody's little sister or daughters too." Mike said as the doorbell rang and they all ran downstairs to get the pizzas.
Lexie opened the door before anyone else could. She smiled a little when she saw Randy was the delivery guy.
"Hey Lexie." He said to her with a smile.
"Hey. Here the money" She handed him the money for the pizza while the other girls looked on.
"Thanks for the tip." He looked back at the other girls. "Ladies, having fun tonight."
"Always." Jaycee said walking over. She took the pizza from Lexie. She had to smile. She could tell that Lexie liked Randy. Both deserved to be with someone who liked them and only them. Maybe she and the other girls could help it along.
Please Review!