Blaine could feel nothing but the warmth of the kiss, their bodies, and the hand that was bringing pleasurable sensations to his groin. Blaine took his hands away from behind Eli and unbuttoned and unzipped his own pants, pulling them down, lips still locked. Eli took his other hand, slid them under Blaine's vest and shirt, and began feeling his abdomen and chest with warm skin-to-skin contact.
Blaine hadn't felt this way in quite a while. He missed the closeness and the intimacy of being with someone. He missed the thrill of messing around, to feel sheets against bare skin, to have someone wanting to please him, and wanting to return the favor, but most of all, he missed the feeling of being sought after, wanted.
Eli had slipped Blaine's underwear completely off, while Blaine had stripped his vest and button-up in a rushed manner. All guilt had left his being, all regrets, all restraints, all inhibitions came off with his clothing. "Your boyfriend must be one happy guy, I didn't expect you to be so large down here." Blaine blushed, never before had he received a compliment on his manhood, not even with Kurt, who was self-conscious about sex as it was.
The boys began to passionately kiss again, as they moved each other from the wall to the mattress. All clothing came off as their warm, bare bodies meshed together on the fabric. "Turn yourself over.", Eli said, parting their lips. Blaine had followed this order obediently, albeit without a strange feeling in the back of his mind. He had never bottomed during sex, as Kurt had always taken that responsibility quite enthusiastically.
Eli has risen and opened a drawer in his nightstand, from which he retrieved lubricant. Blaine watched him slowly open the bottle through a mirror on the opposite side of the room, their eyes met in the glass. "Why don't you do me the honors?". Blaine turned to look at him, forgetting that Eli too, was naked. Blaine took the bottle and poured the lubricant into his palm. He began to spread it on Eli's penis, blushing while doing so, as Eli had become even stiffer than when they were locked in the kiss.
As this was happening, Eli leaned in, to Blaine's surprise and they locked lips once more. Blaine did not loosen his grasp as the boys fell onto each other once again. Eli had turned Blaine over, but did not enter, for he started to kiss the back of Blaine's neck and trail downwards, passed his spine, and onto his tailbone. "You're so tense here.", Eli spoke, rubbing his fingers to Blaine's orifice.
This had surprised Blaine, as he had not realized how warm Eli's fingers had become. He expected the insertion of the fingers to be painful, but they were quite the contrary. Eli just knew where to massage, push, and rub within him. Blaine had never experienced this type of stimulation before, but he was spiraling into a state of ecstasy. He let out brief groans as Eli inserted another finger, digging deeper inside. "You've never had it up here, have you?", said Eli with an amused giggle. "No. I haven't.", Blaine replied. "Well, you're going to have to give your boyfriend some pointers." Then reality struck him. This was cheating. In the act of removing clothes, and passionately kissing another man, Blaine had completely thrown out the idea that this was cheating.
Blaine laid silent, as the sensations of pleasure began erupting furiously as Eli began to pick up speed. Then once again, the feelings of guilt and shame left him, like the heat emanating from both of the boys' skin.