You called Brock first thing the next morning. You did get home rather late after all after enjoying dinner with Jensen, JJ, Rose, and your sister. You guessed by Brock's happiness to hear from you that he hadn't seen anything yet, but he was slightly suspicious you wanted to see him so soon.

You headed to his place with some coffee and muffins in hand as he opened the door with a smile.

"Good morning beautiful," he placed a quick kiss on your cheek as he emptied your hands to place them down at his table.

"Morning…"

"What's wrong y/n?"

"Wha-…what makes you think there's something wrong?"

"The way you just said 'morning' and you look worried."

You let out a sigh. Damn you for not being an actor yourself and not having the ability to easily hide your emotions.

"Well…I…uh…shit! I don't even know how to phrase this."

"Are you… wanting to break up with me?" You looked to see a sad, disappointed expression on his face.

"I thought things were going well…why?…why do you want to-"

"It's not that! I don't WANT to end things with you…but you might want to end things with me…"

He grabbed your hands and made you sit on the couch with him, but you kept a slight distance wanting to be able to look at him as you spoke.

"I…we, we never said we were exclusive, right?"

"No, we never did, but I've been enjoying seeing you so much, I've never really had the notion to see anyone else lately…"

This made you feel even worse.

"Well…I don't know how much you've been in contact with Gen and Jared lately to know what else has been going on or how much you talk with Jensen, but…"

"He's left Daneel hasn't he?" His head hung low already knowing where this was going. He had hoped he would be able to sweep you off your feet enough that by the time Jensen would be available, it wouldn't matter, but the time had come and he had not succeeded.

"Brock…" you took his hands back in yours as he looked at you, "I have loved spending time with you and getting to know each other. I don't want that to end if you don't, but…you know how I've felt about Jensen even before I wanted to admit my feelings myself and he, he wants to give us a shot. I feel like I would regret later on not at least trying. I-"

"Y/n, stop. It's ok. I knew this was bound to happen. I had just hoped I would have had you be mine enough by the time he separated, that it would have been too late for him. Don't get me wrong, Jensen is a great guy, but you're even more amazing."

You didn't know what to say. You now had 2 men wanting to be with you when just about a year ago, the one guy you wanted didn't want you enough.

"I just don't feel like there would even be any competition between us. You…you've adored him since you first met him, you've already built a friendship, and been there for each other for different things…do I even stand a chance?"

You honestly didn't know how to answer that. Ever since you were 15-16 watching the show from the beginning, you had a crush on Dean and then once you got to know more about Jensen and his real self, you wanted to get to know him more. Then you actually met him, befriended him, and now he actually wants to date you?!

Brock is an amazing guy and you didn't want to hurt him, but what if you kept dating them both? You did have to admit he was right that Jensen did already have advantage, but did that really mean that Brock wouldn't have a chance of making you happy too?

"Look y/n. I know you don't want to hurt me and I definitely don't want to lose you, but I feel it just won't be fair. If things don't work out between you two though, don't think for a second I won't be the first one at your door."

You couldn't help, but laugh a little, but still felt sad as tears started stinging your eyes.

"Hey, hey. Y/n, don't be sad. I will always care for you and although a part of me really wants you to end back with me, I really do hope he makes you happy. And if he hurts you, I'll be there to kick his ass and whisk you away forever."

You started crying not believing how amazing he was being about this and it just tore you up inside even more.

He just held you for a moment before you collected yourself and rubbed your nose off on your sleeve.

"You are going to make some woman very lucky someday." You smiled at him whole heartedly.

He cupped your cheek in hid palm as he looked deep in your eyes, "I hope so y/n."

And you felt it strike a chord within you. You knew in that moment that he had had feelings for you more than either of you had expressed before. You could only hope he wouldn't hurt too much from your decision.

"I know this is selfish, but…do you think that maybe we can still be friends?"

"Well I can't promise you that I won't still picture you naked, nor that I'll be eager to answer your call at first, but I don't want to lose you entirely either. You're special y/n. And anyone who doesn't recognize that, doesn't deserve you. Promise me you'll remember that."

"I promise."

He placed a light kiss on your cheek before dragging you up to a standing position.

"Now go before I change my mind and never let you leave and keep you all to myself…and Rose of course."

"Bye Brock. I'll see you around." You placed a light kiss on his lips before departing and heading home.

(Later that evening)

*Ding-Dong*

You heard Rose start to bolt for the door from upstairs.

"Don't you dare open that door little lady!"

"But Mo-om! It's probably JJ! It has to be!"

"Well, you know that mommy has to be the one to answer the door. You never know if it could be a bad person."

"Ugh! Mom!"

"Don't 'ugh!' me! Now go set the table while I get the door."

"Fine…"

"Excuse me?"

"Yes mom."

"Thank you…"

You waited 'til she was out of view to let out a frustrated sigh.

You peeped through the peep hole to see Jensen and JJ waiting outside and before you could open the door, JJ rang the bell again getting anxious.

"Whoa whoa! Just hang on a minute darlin' I'm sure y/n is on her way to answer the door."

You only smiled as you opened the door to see a smile light up on both of their faces as well, "Well I'm glad to see we aren't the only anxious ones. Come on in."

You stepped to the side to let them in and JJ ran straight past you calling out for Rose who called back to her to find her in the dining room. You chuckled to yourself at the 2 girls to be shaken from your thoughts by a pair of lips placing a soft kiss on your cheek.

You turned to look at Jensen who had a playful smile on his lips. "I missed you," he said as he wrapped his arms around your waist pulling you in closer to him.

You placed a light kiss back on his lips, "I missed you too."