I DON'T OWN ANYTHING SO DON'T SUE ME I'M JUST TELLING EVERYBODY HOW THIS SHOW SHOULD HAVE HAPPENED SINCE SEASON 3 & BEYOND
One Tree Hill
My Version of Season 3... But when Brooke comes back she doesn't just 'date' Lucas she wants to just be friends with him... Why? Because during the summer Peyton talked to her telling her she had major feelings for Lucas. So Brooke immediately put her feelings aside so Peyton and Lucas could be together. But Peyton has been telling Brooke that she knows Lucas has feelings for her so that way Brooke wouldn't think that Lucas wanted to be with her anymore. Lucas has tried contacting Brooke but can't get through, while busy helping Peyton with finding her birth mother. Haley James-Scott is back in town and Chris Keller has followed her! Brooke and Haley are now living together and Nathan is having a hard time adjusting to having his wife back. Meanwhile a certain face that everybody thought was gone shows back up again...
Thank you EVERYONE for reviewing! And so since many of you guys are anti-Jeyton): I guess I can do another pair. One thing! I WILL NOT PUT RACHEL AND JAKE TOGETHER. I love her and Uncle Cooper(: . But I was playing with the idea of Julian and Peyton? Of course it would be WAY later on before that happened. And in between then I was thinking she could date Owen and Chase for the time being, instead of Brooke dating them. And I was thinking Jake and Lindsey? Lemme know what you think about that... And so sorry i didn't update earlier! it was just today me and my boyfriend both were free and just decided to spend the day together(: It was nice and relaxing but tomorrow (or today?) in the morning I will start chapter six, before I go to work. It could be posted by like 9 tomorrow night? And thanks to my gay best friend, Andrew, he always wanted to write smut so I let him give it a shot. Give him some shoutouts? :p ANYWAY HAPPY READING!
PLEASE REVIEW!
Chapter Five: A Multitude of Casualties
Brooke Davis was sitting in Karen's café when Peyton walked in with a familiar little baby in a pink and purple stroller.
"Hey, P. Sawyer." Brooke said smiling at the blonde. "And hello Miss. Jenny." She said to the little girl, kissing her head.
"Hey Brooke." Peyton said sitting down across from Brooke in the booth. She was a little surprised Brooke called her, after all it was the only time they talked since that day in her apartment. "So what did you want to talk about?" Peyton asked a little worried.
"I wanted to talk about Lucas." Brooke said truthfully. "I want to know why you would lie to me about something like that, when you knew how much I was hurting over that. Why you would even think to tell me you had feelings for him." She tried to keep as much anger as she could out of her voice, but that only enhanced the hurt she was feeling.
Peyton sighed shakily and looked down, shaking her head. "I don't know Brooke. I guess it was because I love him, and he's in love with you. I thought it was just something he would grow out of since you left. And I thought if I told you all of that you would move on. Hook-up with guys again, come back with one maybe? Letting Lucas lean on me more." She told her truthfully waiting for the brunettes wrath only it never came. Causing Peyton to look up at her.
Brooke shook her head. "How could someone who has called themselves my best friend, for almost eight years do that to me?" She asked incredulously.
Peyton shrugged. "All's I know is that I was wrong and I'm sorry. I am truly sorry."
Brook scoffed nodding her head. "Right, like how you were truly sorry about cheating on me with Lucas."
Peyton frowned. "I don't understand, how can you forgive him? Even be with him right now and still be pissed at me? Shouldn't it be the other way around? Whatever happened to 'Hoes over Bros?" She asked pissed off.
"Because!" Brooke yelled causing the café to quiet down. "You were supposed to be my best friend! You were never ever supposed to go after my boyfriend, you were never supposed to cheat on me with my boyfriend! And you did." Brooke said softly, with tears shimmering. "You did it, and it hurts me so much more that it was you who did it with him. I was always so insecure when it came to you guys and you knew it! Yet I still didn't tell you guys I didn't want you hanging out alone! Hell I didn't tell you guys now."
Peyton shook her head, understanding. She had so much guilt inside of her, and she knew that she was to blame for some of it. "Brooke I understand that you are pissed at me. But just remember I didn't make Lucas cheat on you." Peyton said standing up and put her hands in her jean jacket. "Just remember that, and when you come to terms with it, give me a call. But I am sorry for my part in it."
Then Peyton put her hands on the stroller and walked out leaving a very distraught Brooke sitting in the booth by herself, with Karen looking worriedly towards her.
Karen Roe had watched the entire exchange between the two of them. And to be quite honest she didn't understand how Lucas could cheat on Brooke with Peyton. Didn't Dan show him enough on what cheating and lying could do to a relationship?
Karen walked out from behind the counter and took the seat Peyton had previously vacated. "Brooke are you alright?" Karen asked concerned.
Brooke shook her head sniffling wiping the tear that had escaped. "Want to talk about it?" Karen asked.
"It's just I really wanted Peyton to not love Lucas." Brooke said shaking her head, but then looked up at Karen. "Not because Lucas isn't loveable or anything because he totally is but maybe just a fringe much." Brooke explained to Karen.
Karen chuckled a little. "Brooke, it's okay you don't need to explain yourself to me. In fact I do not condone what Lucas and Peyton did to you. That is not how I wanted my son to be raised."
Brooke nodded a little. "It's just, you know how I feel. How did you feel when you found out about Dan and Deb?"
Karen considered this for a moment, her and Deb hadn't really known each other when he did cheat on her. "Well, I was hurt. But I also didn't have any feeling towards it either. I didn't know Deb that well, and Dan and I had been drifting apart for months and Keith and I had been becoming closer."
Brooke didn't say anything. "I just don't know what to do. I've talked to Lucas about this and I really want to tell him I don't want him and Peyton friends or ever alone together but how can I do that? I don't have that right." She told her getting upset again.
Karen switched seats and sat next to Brooke wrapping her arms around the poor girl. Her son had broken this girl and the worst part? He didn't even know it.
Haley James-Scott was incredibly excited, to say the least. Nathan would be over any minute to help her move back in. She couldn't wait to go home. When the doorbell rang Haley jumped up and ran to the door with a smile on her face.
"Hey." She said enthusiastically.
Nathan stood there smiling down at her and kissed her softly. "Hey, you ready to start?"
Haley nodded quickly. "Immensely. I don't know how many more Brooke and Lucas make-outs I can stand to walk in on." She told him shuddering as they each took a suitcase.
Nathan agreed with her. "Well I'm just glad that they won't walk in on us anymore." He said truthfully, loving the blush that came onto her face.
"Nathan!" Haley yelled but smiling slightly.
Nathan took her suitcases and put them in the trunk. "Wanna go get the box?" He asked her while getting going around onto the drivers side.
Haley nodded. "Yeah, give me a minute."
Haley quickly went back into the apartment and got her box of pictures and figurines, and walked back outside locking and shutting the door. She opened the back door and put the box down onto the floor before getting in the passenger seat.
Nathan smiled at her. "Ready to go home?"
Haley nodded. "More ready then ever." She told him holding his hand as he started driving.
Lucas Scott was sitting down in his room on his computer typing. He was starting to write again. More and more ever since Brooke Davis, his Pretty Girl, came back into his life. He loved the feelings she gave him, and because of that he could put all of his feelings into his story.
His mother coughing at his opened door had him pause in his writing, save and shut down his computer.
"Whatcha need, Ma?" Lucas asked her spinning around to face her, where she was leaning against his door. With a frown etched on her face.
"Lucas, whatever is going between you and Peyton needs to end." She told him seriously.
"What are you talking about?" Lucas asked not having a clue what she was talking about. He hasn't been with Peyton since he cheated on Brooke. A mistake I will never make again,he thought.
"I am talking about you, Brooke, and Peyton." Karen snapped at him. "Lucas you can not keep playing both of them. And you cannot have both of them in love with you. Choose one and let the other go." She told him angrily. She's had just about enough of his love triangle crap, and although she promised herself she wouldn't get involved, after seeing Brooke... she just had to do something.
"Ma, I love Brooke. So much." He said with a little smile. "Peyton? I love her like I love Haley. I see that now. It's just we have so much in common and she's always needing help and saving and I can't help but fill in those shoes." At his mothers disapproving look he quickly said, "Not anymore. Somebody else can do it. I'm worrying about Brooke."
Karen saw the determined look on her son's face and nodded. She walked the rest of the way into his room and kissed his head. "Lucas just to let you know. If you did love Peyton or want to be with her and broke up with Brooke. I would be okay with it. As long as you're happy." Karen told him, although hoping to God he was telling her the truth. She's always gotten along better with Brooke than Peyton.
Lucas nodded. "But I don't want Peyton. I want Brooke and she knows, Peyton knows, and I know."
Karen shrugged. "I'm not to sure if Brooke knows." She told him starting to leave the room. "Dinner will be done soon."
Brooke Davis was sitting in her now empty apartment that night. She always thought that when Haley left she would be glad to have more of the room, but that wasn't the case. Brooke missed her so much. She had nobody to talk to right now. Lucas was at home, Peyton was being Peyton, and Haley was reuniting with Nathan.
Peyton's words to her just kept coming back to her. That she didn't make him cheat on her, he did it because he wanted to. Which did make sense to Brooke she just didn't want to admit it, but she knew Peyton was right. Peyton didn't force him to kiss her, he did it on his own. Because even though he would deny it forever, a part of him did want Peyton more than he wanted her. And she knew that, so why in the world was she holding onto this relationship?
Just then there was a knock on the door and Brooke got up an answered, looking less then presentable in sweat pants and Lucas' old sweatshirt, no make-up, and hair not done. She felt like she didn't need it after the day she had.
"Chris Keller?!" She gasped. "What the fuck are you doing here?"
Chris Keller stood outside of her apartment looking sheepishly around. "Is Haley here? I heard she was living with you." He told her politely yet getting directly to the point.
"Um, no!" Brooke yelled. "She's with her husband. Say it with me husband."
"Oh." Chris said looking a little down.
"What are you doing here anyway?" Brooke asked curiously leaning on the door.
"Well I really like Haley, and I thought things weren't going well between her and Nathan so I figured, you know I'd have a shot." Chris told her smiling at the brunette standing at the door.
"Well you just better back off! Her and Nathan are finally in a good place." She told him angrily. "And we don't need you ruining it." Brooke snapped at him, and she kind of felt bad, it's not his fault Lucas cheated on her with her best friend. Ex-best friend, she thought to herself.
"You okay?" He asked.
Brooke nodded. "I'm fine and you can leave now." She told him shutting the door.
Without looking back she went back into her room and just got under the covers when somebody knocked on her again. She groaned and rolled of the bed angrily.
"Chris I swear to God, if you do not leave in five seconds..." She trailed off as she opened the door angrily only she stopped when she saw Lucas was standing there.
He frowned. "Who's Chris?" Lucas asked confused and jealous.
"Oh. Chris Keller, the one who followed Haley here." She told him letting him come in and shutting the door behind her. "He came back here because he really liked her."
Lucas shook his head, as much as he wanted to find Chris and bash his head in for ever trying to break up his best friend and brother's marriage, he needed to focus on the girl in the room with him. "Whatever, we'll talk to them tomorrow about it."
She was shocked he would put something like this off. "No, Lucas you need to call Nathan and Haley or do something." She told him.
Lucas shook his head again. "No, you're more important." He told her firmly, taking her hand and bringing her into her room and laying down on the bed with her.
She was laying down and his head was resting on his hand that was upright by his elbow looking down at Brooke. "Pretty Girl, I have a question for you." He told her quietly.
Brooke frowned. "What is it?"
"Why are you constantly making this about Peyton?" He asked her softly. "I love you.What part of that don't you understand?"
Brooke shrugged. "It's just, I know we've talked about this before. But I think it doesn't matter how many times we do talk about it. I'm always going to be insecure about your relationship with her." She told him playing with his hand that resting on her belly.
"Brooke..." He groaned. "You don't need to be. I don't know what else to do to prove that to you."
Brooke didn't know either to be honest. "It's gonna take some time." She told him, giving him the only answer she could think of.
He sighed nodding. "I love you."
Brooke smiled up at him. "I love you too."
Lucas leaned down connecting their lips. Brooke sighed against them loving how he felt against her. He leaned back up and pulled her sweatshirt over her head. Leaving her in a white lace bra. He immediately took off his shirt, and leaned back down connecting their lips.
He traveled down her neck and she gasped his name. What a delicious sound. "Relax Pretty Girl." He whispered into her skin, as he started to pull down her sweat pants.
Brooke shivered as he did so, loving how slowly and tenderly he did it. He had boyish grin on his face, like a little kid who was in the candy store, and she loved it.
Lucas kissed up her stomach, to her chest, up her neck, before settling on her mouth. His hands went underneath her back and un-hooked her bra. She smiled as he threw it on the floor with the rest of her clothes.
Brooke was staring at his pants where a tent was brewing. "Broody, take them off." She whispered leaning up to unbutton them.
Lucas shook his head. "Brooke, the minute I do that I'll be inside you." When she just stared at him he laughed.
But before she could protest he put his mouth back on hers before slowly moving it back down her body right before her underwear. Brooke moaned wriggling her hips up to him. He pulled her underwear down and threw it on the floor, looking at her body possessively.
Lucas leaned down and kissed her inner thigh, as he slowly moved up to the apex of her thighs. She gasped when his tongue touched the most intimate part of her. Brooke's hands tangles in his hair as she scraped her nails against his scalp.
"Luke..." She moaned widening her legs wanting him to go deeper. She gasped when he added his fingers, and arched her hips but he held them firmly to the bed.
But just before her climax he pulled back. "What the fuck?" Brooke asked pissed off.
Lucas didn't answer he just pulled off his pants and boxers. He took the condom out of his pocket and rolled it on.
She nodded at him and he entered her in one swift motion. Making them one instead of two...