Author's Note
Dun dun dun du dun! I have arrived with a new chapter for my marvelous fans! Sorry my other chapter was a little shorter but I will make this one normal length about 2,000 WORD MAYBE 2,500 between that unless I feel like writing more. Thanks to all the reviews and someone asked about how imposter Lucy had Lucy's keys. Well Imposter Lucy isn't real so to make it believable she has fake keys to just so no one ask what happened to her keys while real Lucy Is Hiding her keys because she's pretending to be a light mage because it's similar to Celestial dragon magic. Confusing well I don't think so. On with the show AYE SIR!
Previously on this story
I went up to the surface and Natsu was staring at me. I tried to say something but all that came out was water. I couldn't breathe and I fainted.
Natsu's POV
Why was there two Lucy's? One was by me and one was supposed to be Lucinda. Everybody except for me and one of the Lucy's. "Why is that girl being an imposter?" the awake Lucy said. (I'm still addressing real Lucy as Lucinda just for no confusion. ;) When Lucinda woke up coughing up water she looked at me with a blank expression. "Natsu I thought of all people you would realize that I'm Lucy." Lucinda said. "You don't believe her right I mean that I'm Lucy and she's just pretending to get to you." I was so confused.
Imposter Lucy's POV
That stupid little girl thinks she can get away with this. Well I'm the stronger one so no one is going to stop me. "Lisanna I recommend you stop before I have to hurt you." Erza said. I flinched at the name she said how did she know. (From now on real Lucy is Lucy and fake Lucy is Lisanna ;) I ran over to Lucy and mixed us up so that they couldn't tell which one was me. "Flame Brain can't you tell which one is Lucy by smell?" Grey asked. For your stupidity Popsicle stick no I can't they both smell the same."
No one's POV
Well if we can't decide which one is the real one then we must take them back to the guild and have Master figure it out. He always knows what to do." Erza said. They went and collected the pay money from the mayor and headed to the train station.
Real Lucy's POV
I wish Natsu knew which one is me. Every time I tell him that I'm the real Lucy he says things like "How do I know for sure" or "I don't trust you till I know if your real or not." But shouldn't he relize it's me and not the other girl. Earlier today I wanted to tell him so bad but now they can't tell the difference right now. Erza said that Lisanna was behind all of this but is that true. I wonder how I'll ever be trusted by Nastu in this state.
Lisanna's POV
So how did Erza know that it was me? Well they don't know about anything now. I wonder how long I can keep this going since I've been using my magic nonstop. But why does Natsu Love her and not me. Whose known him longer well me and I'm much more pretty then her. With her Yellow hair that she thinks is so pretty but really all it is an ugly excuse for hair. Why does she get all the good things and I get nothing. Well she won't be here for long when I destroy fairy tail.
Two Weeks ago still Lisanna's POV
I can't believe that Fairy Tail kicked me out for that blond girl. "Hey miss are you okay?" A guy asked. I looked at him he was pretty tall and with black hair. Pretty eyes and all black clothes. "You look like you want revenge and if you do I don't mind but to help you. You are Lisanna of Fairy Tail right?" He asked. "Used to be but they all betrayed me for a Stupid girl. And what do you have in mind of revenge but first what's your name?" I asked. "My name is Naraku Sesshoumaru." (I had to take that out of Inuyasha!) "Well Naraku what were you thinking of revenge?" I asked smiling deviously. He explained to me that I will pretend to be Lucy as step one. After that I will show my true self after that breaking their hearts then I will call Naraku and he will send a dark guild called Bloody Skull that he was in and we will kill everybody in Fairy Tail. But what about Mira-nee and Elf-nee-chan. They're my only family left and I don't want to kill them." I said worried about them. "The people who betrayed you and kicked you out your own home and you don't want to kill them. It seems to me that they don't care what happens to you but only what happened to what you did. Why did you get kicked out anyway?" he asked. "I killed there dear friend Lucy who was just a replacement for me but apparently I was a replacement for her." I said darkly.
"So do you still want to save them or do you want to kill them?" Naraku asked in delight. "I want to kill them!" I said never going to regret what I just said. "I'll take you to my guild Bloody Skull and you can become a member." I followed him and the master happily accepted me. His name was Master Yukki. "Were do you want your insignia child?" he asked. I lifted up my shirt on the side and requested it on my side right above my hip. It was a bloody red skull rapped with a ripped ribbon with a arrow pierced straight through the top of the head. "I'm glad to be part of your guild." I said.
I walked out of the office and met up with Naraku. Soon we explained to the guild our plan and they all cheered. I will be so happy in this guild unlike the other guild Fairy Tail. They betrayed me so I'll betray them.
End of Flashback
Still Lisanna's POV
I still want Natsu to be mine but I guess I lost that already by Lucy. Just soon and we will take over the guild. I saw Lucy sleeping right next to Natsu and he was glaring at me with hatred in his eyes. He mouthed "I can see right through you. Happy who was sleep next to the real Lucy looked up from his slumber and said "Aye" agreeing with Natsu. Grey started to speak which woke everybody who was still sleep up. "Now that we have two Lucy's we can't go picking favorites in case were wrong. And if we are wrong then what will the real Lucy think and sense we can't decide which one is which then I think we should put it up to the test at the guild." "We shall see who can use her magic and which is more into her family history which master will decide." Erza said adding on to the words Grey said.
Natsu's POV
I could tell which one was my Lucy right away. Next to me was her but I don't know who the other Lucy is so I'll play along like I don't know who Lucy really is. Happy knows about it to because he said that "Real Lucy won't say anything if I sleep on her lap just pet me although the other Lucy just kept picking me up and squeezing me like I'm a doll saying how cute I am. Lucy never does anything but punch and kick me." Erza and Popsicle stick here don't know which one is which. I would be ashamed if I had realized the two were different before.
I was too lost in my thought to realize that I had motion sickness. The train stopped and we got off. I held on to the real Lucy's hand. Her grip was tight and so was mine. "Hey Luce I know that you're the real one." I said to her quiet enough that only she could hear. "Natsu I always knew that you could tell." She said to me. As we walked to the Guild the other Lucy said "Why's it so quiet? Are you thinking who the other Lucy is?" We entered the guild and heard cheering. "We have a problem. We have two Lucy's the fake one was the one who we celebrated for and the real one is also known as Lucinda Celestian. They are mixed up so we need Master to help us find the right Lucy." Erza said with a loud voice. Everybody went dead silent. Master came out of the office and looked right at the two.
Makorov's POV
Who would the other Lucy be and why did the real Lucy uncover her secret. "The only way to figure this out is a test of Knowledge and magic. First question is about your family. Explain what there like." I said. Not many people know about Lucy's past. "The Lucy on the left is Lucy number one and the Lucy on the right is Lucy number two. (Just to let you know Lucy number two is the real Lucy ;) "Lucy number one your explaination?" she started "My mom died when I was little and my dad never cared much for me. I tried so many times to escape but the maids kept bringing me back till one day I succeded and traveled the world. I was kidnapped and was almost taken by the fake salamander until Natsu saved me and brought me to Fairy Tail." Everybody started saying that was the real Lucy.
Lisanna's POV
I knew someone was going to ask me these questions so I did my research on Lucy. I need to keep cover for just a while longer till I'm ready to attack. "How did Natsu and Lucy meet Lucy number two?" I'm so glad he didn't ask me this question or I would have been done for. "We met when he broke the charm the fake salamander was giving and I treated him and Happy to lunch although we they didn't want me to go." Lucy said. Everybody looked at Natsu who shook his head yes. "Since you both know the same amount then I guess we will go onto the magic. Who was the first spirit Lucy had. "Aquarius." Lucy said. Everybody started murmuring about how that Lucy number two was the real one. "Who gave Lucy Flev de Attoiles (don't know if I spelled that right) "Virgo gave it to me in a crises." Lucy number two said. "Now you must use a Celestial spirit starting with Lucy number one. I looked through the fake keys I had till I found and easy one to summon if only I knew how. "Gate of the clock I open thee. Horoligum!" I shouted but nothing happened. I shouted his name many times. Then I tried Plue and he didn't work. Those were the only celestial spirit names I can remember.
Lucy's POV
She couldn't even call out a spirit so I know that I will win and that nobody else could mix us up now. She even said gate of the plue like that was the name but it was Nicoli. "Gate of the Lion I open thee. Leo!" I yelled and Loke popped up. "How are you my mistress and why are there two of you?" he asked. "Loke that girl over there is an imposter who couldn't even call out a gate so I just want you to tell the guild I'm the real Lucy since I could call you out." I explained. He grabbed my cheeks and started squeezing them then he swooped me off my feet and said "Couldn't you tell that this is the real Lucy? It's not that hard." He said in a stern but serious voice.
Lisanna's POV
They knew which one was which. I tried to run out the guild but Natsu caught me. "Who are you?" he asked me. I smirked and started laughing. "You fools it's the end of your lives so you better run. Kicking me out the guild was the worst thing you've ever done for that brat who came here last! I've warned you know so get ready!" I laughed. Mira was crying and saying "What happened to my little sister." Everybody knew now. "Since you know I guess it's no use staying in this puny week body!" I said I transformed into my body and stormed out the guild with some people questioning what I said. I warned them. I ran to the guild Bloody Skull and heard hoots and cheers when I said "It's time."
Author's note
This would be a good movie to watch but you know what it's not. I'm kind of sad that it isn't a movie. I mean can't you just picture it. Well thanks for reading and review! I need more reviews and suggestions about new anime to right about only if you like me and please favorite me. See ya AYE!