Omniscient POV
Everything was still a mystery to Will, how Quinn and Emma were so close, how Mercedes found out, he was just so confused. The only thing he had to do was ask. And that was why he was now here at the front door of Quinn's hotel room. He knocked twice and the blonde opened the door and allowed him to come in.
"Why are you here Mr. Schue?"
"Please, just call me Will, it's really weird you're calling Emma , Emma but calling me Mr. Schuester. I think you should call me Will."
"Okay then Mr.- I mean Will, why are you here?"
"I want to know the whole story Quinn. I want to know what happened the past 20 months."
"Huh! You know the secret already so I better tell you."
"Yeah, please tell me."
"Ok come on sit down." Quinn says, she sits on the bed while Will sits on one of the couches.
"So, I met Emma when I first went here. I had on the job training in one of the clinics here in Grundy. Since I was graduating medicine in the field of pregnancy. On my first day, Emma was there, lying down next to the doctor to find out of your baby was a girl or a boy. She tried to get away from me but she just couldn't."
"Knowing Emma she would've!" Will says laughing hardly. "I just wish I was there you know, for Emma."
"Yeah so after that, we became really good friends, I helped her out with the pregnancy stuff and she always helped me with her skills, you know of guidance. And she told me everything, everything she as feeling why she ran away. Do you know now? Why she ran away?"
"Yeah."
"To be honest, I was a bit mad at you that time."
"Yeah, I'm the be blamed, I'm such a loser Quinn. I don't deserve Emma."
"Don't worry Will."
"So moving on."
"Oh and Mercedes came when I told her about Emma and Matthew."
"I wish I was there." Will says, his face falling. He had wished he saw Emma giving birth to their first. He wished he could have took care of her and got her all the things she wanted and needed, fulfilled her cravings.
"I'm sorry Will. But you should know that you and Emma make wonderful babies. Joseph Matthew Pillsbury is the kindest and cutest baby I've ever seen."
"Oh." she noticed Will frown. "What's wrong Will? Did I say something wrong?"
"No, it's just Matthew doesn't have my last name."
"Yeah, I'm sorry about that."
"No worries. Ok moving on."
"Emma has new hobbies now like writing, reading, photography and she doesn't work here."
"Wow! But she doesn't work? Are you serious about that?"
"Yeah, her family is a very wealthy family. She's spoiled here, whatever she wants comes in a flash."
"Wow, how can I ever reach her standards now?" Will says. How could he? Emma had a great life here.
"Oh don't Worry she's not like her parents. They're very different people."
"Oh. That's great. Anyway it's getting late so I better go!"
"Ok Goodnight Will!"
"Goodnight!"
Will woke up early to see Emma. Quinn dropped him at Emma's house because they had a FIRAQUITANAES meeting today.
"Hey Em."
"Hey Will. So you decided to swing by?"
"Yeah, I wanted to talk to you."
"Oh Okay."
"Em, I missed you, you know!"
"Yeah. Come on please, please sit down."
"Ok." Will sat down the couch. Emma sat beside him.
"I'm sorry about kissing you yesterday." Will says.
"No, I initiated it so, yeah but I'm not sorry."
"I am, because I promised myself I would not kiss you if you didn't want too."
"But I wanted too."
"Oh. Well then. That's okay."
"Emma you know I should've never done what I did before." will added.
"Yeah if you didn't I should've told you about Matthew." Emma says.
"Yeah and I should've been so happy." Will smiles and nods at her.
"And we should've been married."
"And we should've been together,"
"And I should have done this." Will says, leaning in to kiss Emma. She didn't stop him, it is a good sign, right?
"Hmm yeah." Emma mutters pulling away.
Will snuggles closer to Emma.
"Did you ever regret running away?"
"No, because I wouldn't have had Quinn as a best friend. And I love Quinn as my bestest friend in the whole wide world!"
"Yeah, and you wouldn't have had therapy."
"Yeah that too. do you want to see pictures of Matthew?" Emma asked.
"Yes Please!"
"Ok I'll go get it Will!" Emma says running her fingers through his curls. She missed doing that to his hair.
Emma got the photo album and handed some to Will.
"You know I'm really jealous of you Will. Matthew got all your features except for they eyes! The big doe eyes!"
"Umhmm! The Schuester's got class!"
"Oh Will!" I say rubbing his head with my palm.
"Can I ask you more questions?"
"Yeah!" Emma smiled happy that Will was there with her. Happy that maybe they would get their happy ending back. But there was one problem right? Yes, James.
"Do you promise to tell the truth and nothing but the truth? One question one answer."
"Yes, I promise."
"Do you forgive me?"
"Yes Will, I do forgive you."
"Do you know that I love you so much?" he asks.
"It seems like it." Emma answers back.
"Do you love me?"
"I guess so. I feel like I still do. I'm confused." Emma answers him.
"Would you go out with me?"
"No."
"No?"
"No." Emma answered him blankly
"Why not?"
"I can't, I just can't."
"Why not? Don't you love me? You said you do. You said you're confused but maybe you could learn to love me again. What we had was special Em."
"I'm going out with someone." She almost whispered it but Will seemed to hear.
"What?!" His face fell. Gosh I hurt him. Emma thought.
"Yeah, I'm sorry Will."
"I was going to ask you out for lunch tomorrow." He suddenly found interest in his shoes.
"Um-I-I James is going to cook for me tomorrow I'm sorry Will."
"Oh."
"Sorry Will, I can explain it's just I um-I."
"No Emma you don't have to explain. I get it I was bad to you and you had to find someone else. That's totally acceptable. It is my fault, it's all my fault." Will's heart broke. Why did Emma have to kiss him. Make him feel loved. She was mending his heart and tearing it again.
"Maybe you can come for dinner?"
"But what about James?" She was trying to mend his heart again. Trying to make him feel loved.
"We aren't going on a date Will! I'm asking you to come to dinner so you can bond with Matthew, I'll cook." It's not a date Will! It echoed into his head. God, I really lost her.
"Oh okay, thank you Emma. But I have to go. The kids kept on texting me, they say they need me back at the hotel."
He walks back to the hotel miserably. Will was so mad. Why did Emma have to date someone? He thought. Why did she have to make me feel like she still loves me?
When he got back to the hotel Quinn and Rachel were there on the front door.
"So how was your talk with Emma?" Quinn asked excitedly.
"Not good."
"What? Why not?" Rachel asked.
"She's dating someone else." Will answered blankly. The happiness he had in the morning gone.
"Oh my God! Emma never told me!"
"Well, she is Quinn, but I'm coming to dinner tomorrow for Matthew. Just the three of us." Will says sadly.
"I'm so sorry Will! I don't know what's gotten in to Emmie! I'll talk to her later."
"No Quinn, I don't want to force her. If she comes back to me, I want her to want it."
"Are you sure?" Rachel asks.
"Yes, I don't want Emma to have a hard time."
"Just promise us that you'll get her back."
"I don't know guys, this isn't my call, if Emma doesn't want me to be her boyfriend than I can't be."
"We will find away Will I promise."
"No Quinn, I don't want you to do that. Please let's just let Emma do what she wants to. I'd rather see her happy and break my heart then see her not happy and me happy."
"Okay." the girls say in unison, they had Nothing else to do but tell the others.
The FIRAQUITANAES has a difficult mission, it was even harder since Emma was now officially dating someone. And Quinn was bothered to know that for once Emma didn't tell her she was dating someone.
Will hadn't had a good night's rest. He was still thinking about Emma and this James. He couldn't imagine them kissing or snuggling or doing anything couples do. It just wasn't right. It didn't feel right. His day was boring, but when it came to lunch all he was thinking of was what could Emma and James be doing?
Will came for dinner earlier than he was expected. But the sight broke his heart. She saw Emma on top of a guy he assumed was James. They were making out on Emma's huge couch. As usual Emma was just in shorts and the guy was wearing a normal t-shirt and shorts that lead up to the knees. Emma kissed James wildly and he responded to every one of her kisses. He never experienced that with Emma. They were getting married but he never did. Of course Emma had OCD then, she would just pull away and go to bed. But this time Emma was different.
The sight made him want to cry but he had to stay where he was, it's like he was glued there and he had no choice. It was torture. Soon Emma and James fell to the ground still locking lips. And Emma stood up still kissing him and let herself fall to the huge couch. Grinning and pulling James with her. He was just watching them kiss after kiss. Hoping he was the guy Emma was kissing. Emma grinned and kissed James neck. And then she finally saw Will with the corner of her eyes.
She stopped responding to James kisses and locked eyes with Will. Hurt was all she could see written on his features. James noticed and looked back and saw Will as well he stood up immediately and Emma did as well. Still shocked by seeing Will there. Emma opened the door for Will who was still in haze.
"Um-Will, this is um-this is um James, yes he's my boyfriend." Emma says smiling at James taking off some lipstick on his lips then turning back to Will.
"Nice to meet you." James puts out his hand.
"Yeah." Will says and shakes his hand.
"I better get going babe, see you tomorrow."
"Ok baby! Dinner right?"
"Yup, I don't think I'll be able to wait." James says, unaware of the tension in the air.
"Me neither." She grins and James tries to lean in and kiss Emma one more time but Emma backs away and hugs him instead. He finally leaves and Will and Emma are left in the house. Of course Matthew was sleeping in his bedroom.
"Will, I'm sorry. I'm sorry you had to see that."
"I - um - I- Erm -it's ok Em." he says handing her some flowers. "These are for you my lady." Emma blushed. She got the flowers and put it on a vase she pulled out.
"I just need to clean up."
"Ok. I'll be waiting here."
"Yeah please sit down." Emma lead Will to the couch. The couch where Will had just caught Emma kissing James. He was so grossed out by the thought of Emma kissing someone else. Regrets collected in his mind. If only he had been more careful this would never happen.