Hey guys! Your reviews have been so awesome! Thank you! This is a little short but I wanted to get it out. Definitely never written anything like this before so I'm not sure what to think of it, but your reviews would be helpful!
Disclaimer: I don't own any of the characters from Glee!
Rachel kissed him back, slowly at first, but then deepened the kiss, wrapping her arms around his neck. He hungrily kissed her for what felt like minutes before he lifted her up so she could wrap her legs around his waist. Hands on her ass, Finn broke the kiss and moved his head to her neck, sucking on her skin. "Oh Finn!" she moaned quietly, not wanting to wake up Puck. A million thoughts raced through her head as his lips attacked her neck. She hardly knew him. He's her roommate! Fuck, he's hot as all hell.
She ran her fingers through his hair and pulled on it gently to pull his head back up to kiss him. Her short black dress had already begun to ride up her hips and now Finn's hands were groping her bare ass. "God I want you so bad" he murmured in between kisses.
"My room, now." Rachel directed him, biting on his bottom lip.
Finn really didn't need to be told twice. He walked into her room still holding on to her, slamming her door shut with his foot. He walked over to the bed and gently threw her down. Rachel sat up on her elbows watching him as he unbuttoned his shirt, his eyes still on her. Once his shirt was off, he climbed on to the bed on top of her, his arms propping up his weight as he leaned down to kiss her. As they kissed, Finn's hand reached underneath Rachel's dress to touch her right right between her legs. "You're so wet baby girl" He pushed her panties to the side and rubbed her lips until he pushed one finger into her. "Oh my God, Finn.." Rachel gasped, opening her legs wider for him as he fingered her. Their tongues wrestled together as he continued to finger her. "What do you want baby?"
"Ughh...I need you Finn. Now."
Finn removed his fingers from inside her and fumbled with his belt buckle, pushing his pants and boxers down until his member sprang to life. He wrapped his hand around his dick and pumped it once or twice. "You're wearing way too many clothes. Take that dress off." Rachel complied, pulling the dress over her head to reveal a matching lace bra to her panties. "God, you're so beautiful." He admired her, and even in her drunken haze, Rachel felt herself blush under his gaze.
Finn reached into his pants pocket and pulled out a condom from his wallet. Tearing the package open he slid the condom onto his erect dick. Climbing on top of Rachel, he kissed her once more before aligning his dick with her opening. He slowly entered her, hearing her whimper as she adjusted to his size. She felt fucking amazing, like fucking velvet. They kissed passionately as he began to pick up his pace until he was fucking her hard enough for the headboard to hit against the wall. "Ughh Finn! so fucking good! I'm gonna cum!" Rachel moaned, wrapping her legs around his waist pulling him in tighter to her. Finn tried to hold out as long as he could, but the moment he felt her kiss his neck and then suck on his earlobe, he lost it and found himself cumming deep inside of her. Panting hard, Finn slowly removed his dick from inside of her rolling on to his back. He pulled off the condom and tossed it into her trash can. "That was...amazing." Rachel smiled, leaned over and kissed his cheek. Within seconds, Finn was fast asleep. Rachel snuggled up next to him, pulling the blankets over their naked bodies.
The next morning, Rachel woke up feeling the sun shining in her face. "Ugh...noo, so bright." she groaned putting one hand over her eyes, and the other reaching to feel for Finn on the bed. Her hand landed on the sheets, and she peeked through her hand to find she was alone in bed. She looked around before glancing at her alarm clock. It was noon. He must've woken up early and didn't want to wake her. Not wanting to look like a total mess before she saw him again, Rachel slowly got out of bed and hopped into the shower, thoughts of last night swirling in her head.
Finn groaned the moment he woke up with a massive headache. It was 8:00 am. Shit. There was no way he was going to let Puck see him coming out of Rachel's room. Speaking of Rachel, her arm was wrapped tightly around his waist, with one leg of hers tangled in his. Knowing Puck would be up bright and early (even on days where they were drinking pretty heavy the night before), Finn tried to untangle himself from Rachel without waking her. He collected his clothes and quietly creeped out of her room, basically making a run for his room before Puck woke up.
He pulled on a t-shirt and his boxers and laid down on his bed, thoughts of the brunette girl succumbing over him as he fell into another slumber.
Rachel came out of her room, wearing shorts and a t-shirt, her face lightly applied with makeup. She expected to see Finn on the couch playing video games but instead she was welcomed to silence. "Anybody home?" she walked around the apartment, seeing Finn's door slightly open. She walked over to the door and knocked softly. When she didn't hear anything, she pushed the door open just a little wider to see he was not there. She walked into the room, looking at the way he decorated (or lack thereof) and she couldn't help but feel like his room smelled just like him. Lost in her own thoughts, she barely heard the front door open followed by Puck and Finn's loud laughter. "Oh my god!" she panicked, quickly running out of the room and into the guy's' bathroom, which was luckily right across from Finn's room.
She gave it a moment before she walked out of the bathroom, trying to keep her cool. "Oh hey guys. Did you go to the gym or something?"
Puck and Finn both looked at her weirdly. "What were you doing over there?" Puck asked.
"I was just using the bathroom! Is that such a crime in my own apartment?!" she exclaimed, not making eye contact with either of them, and walked into the kitchen to get a soda.
"Uh okay weirdo, you know you have your own bathroom right?" Puck said, walking in the direction she just came from. "I'm gonna take a shower."
This left Finn and Rachel alone together. "Hi." he said softly.
She glanced over at him, feeling a blush in her cheeks. "Hey." There was clearly a very weird tension in the air, and she really wasn't sure why she was all of a sudden so nervous in front of Finn. He did look pretty damn good right now in his basketball shorts and his t-shirt. He still had little sweat beads on the sides of his face, giving her mental images of him on top of her last night.
"Sorry that I uh...left this morning. I really just didn't want to give Puck any ideas that something happened..I mean he'd kill me I think."
Rachel looked at him curiously. "Why would he be upset?"
Finn shrugged, leaning against the counter in the kitchen, his arms crossed. "You're Quinn's cousin. I'm pretty sure there's some rulebook out there saying that I shouldn't have done what I did last night."
"You mean what we did? Finn, I'm not a child...just because I'm Quinn's cousin doesn't mean anything. I don't understand why this would even be an issue or why Puck would care." Rachel was very confused. Finn wasn't THAT much older than her.
"Look...Rachel...I'm just...I'm not looking for anything. I don't want to give you the wrong idea. Maybe we should just forget this happened." The words come out of his mouth before he even realizes what he's said.
Finn's been in this position hundreds of times. You could replace Rachel with any girl he's ever been with. They always want something more. Why couldn't he just want sex? Of course he knew he had to be more delicate with how he handled this situation with Rachel. It wasn't that he didn't like her...but she freaking lived with him. He couldn't just like, ignore her. Puck would definitely know something was up.
"Did you ever think Finn...maybe I'm not looking for anything either?" Her response surprised him, she can see it in his eyes. He was totally ready to give her the it's not you, it's me speech. Well no way, Finn Hudson! You haven't met Rachel Barbra Berry, the soon to be broadway star. It was time to put her acting skills to the test.
"You're not?" He looked at her curiously.
"No." She walks closer so she's standing right in front of him.
Finn stared at her, his mouth turning into a little half smile. "Well, if you're not looking for anything...and I'm not looking for anything..."
"Then maybe this could be our little secret...no strings attached." She ran her fingers down his arm seductively, and he can feel himself getting hard already just at her touch.
Finn smirked. "Are you serious? You're not gonna like, tell your cousin?"
Rachel shakes her head and moves in even closer, standing on her tip toes, and gently tugs on the front of his shirt, making him lower his head closer to hers. "So what do you say?"
Finn licks his lips and rests his hands on her hips, "Fuck yes." He goes into kiss her but stops right before they touch as Puck calls his name from the bathroom. "Huddy! Pass me a roll. I'm all out!"
Rachel laughed as Finn rolled his eyes. "Seriously?! Worst timing ever."
Rachel backed away from him. "Looks like we have a deal, Mr. Hudson." she smiles at him, and walks out of the kitchen, swaying her hips with each step, knowing fully well he was watching her.
Finn stared after her. Best. Roommate. Ever.
"FINN!" Puck yelled from the bathroom snapping Finn out of his thoughts.
"I'm coming! Geez, calm your shit."