Hey Guys! Thanks again for all the sweet reviews :) Don't worry, Sam won't be around for too long. It's really hard writing Rachel with anyone else. Finn is my absolute favorite and I love the two of them together. I had a super fun time writing this chapter and I hope you all enjoy it as well! Let me know what you think :)
Finn watched as Sam led Rachel to the bar, his hand resting on the small of her back. There was no way she'd actually even be interested in him right?
"So, Rachel. Your show was really great tonight. You've got a killer voice." Sam praised her.
"Aw, thank you so much. I practice non stop to reach this level of perfection." She smiled politely at him, her mind drifting to her nearly immaculate performance from earlier in the night.
Sam laughed. "Well it takes talent to know talent you know." He grinned at her. "My talent are these killer abs I have. Want to see?"
Rachel knew Finn was watching her. She decided it was finally time for her to turn her game up just a little bit. She giggled at Sam's word. "Uh...sure?"
Sam pulled his shirt up to show off his abs. Rachel glanced down. Well, they were pretty damn impressive. "Can I touch them?" she asked, flirtatiously.
Sam grinned. This worked EVERY time. "Knock yourself out."
Rachel ran her hands down his abs. "Wow, those are some strong abs you have there."
"I'm in the gym like every day, sometimes twice a day." He boasted. Rachel moved her hand to touch his arms.
"Well it definitely shows."
Finn waited until Sam walked off to the bathroom before he walked over to Rachel.
"Uh, what the hell are you doing?" he asked, sitting down in the stool next to her.
"What are you talking about? I'm just being nice to your friends, Finn." Rachel responded.
"You're hanging all over him."
"Finn, I'm doing no such thing. I'm just having a conversation with a nice boy."
Finn rolled his eyes. "He's not looking to be your friend, Rach. He's trying to sleep with you."
"Maybe I'm trying to sleep with him, Finn." she said, taking him by complete surprise. "You know, with no strings attached, and what not." she looked at him.
Before he could respond, Sam walked back over to Rachel. "Oh hey Hudson, how's it hangin?"
Rachel didn't give Finn a chance to respond. "Oh! I love this song. Why don't you show me some of your moves, Sam?" she got up from her stool, and pulled him off with her.
"Don't have to tell me twice." He laughed, letting her pull him along, but not before he turned back towards Finn giving him a thumbs up and a huge grin.
This fucking bleach-blonde, trouty mouthed asshole.
Unable to watch them dance anymore, Finn decided that two can play this game. He was being a super nice guy because she was his roommate and Quinn's cousin, but clearly, she didn't care that he was her roommate or Quinn's friend, now did she? He never had a problem getting girls before Rachel Berry, and it's not going to be a problem now.
Finn walked over to Puck who was chatting with Quinn, Blaine and Kurt.
"Hey Puck, why don't we go out to the main bar and see what the ladies are lookin' like tonight?"
Puck quickly glanced at Quinn before turning towards Finn. Kurt, also knowing about Finn and Rachel looked a bit surprised.
"Don't like what you see in here?" Kurt smirked.
Finn rolled his eyes. "I just realized that I haven't gotten laid in forever and it's about time. Now Puck, what do you say? You with me or what?"
"Uhh sure. I can be your wingman." Puck said after getting a small nod of approval from Quinn.
Puck and Finn walked out of the private room and into the main bar to begin their scouting.
"You're not hiding anything from me, you know." Kurt said to Quinn as Blaine chuckled.
"Huh?" She blushed slightly. "I'm not sure what you're speaking of..."
"It's okay Quinn. So how long has Noah been in love with you?" Blaine laughed as Quinn continued to turn 50 shades of red.
Rachel had really no intention of doing anything other than dancing with Sam, seeing as how it got Finn so riled up. Even if he didn't want to admit it, Rachel knew that Finn felt more for her than he let on.
She glanced around the room for Finn but he was nowhere in sight. Where the hell was he?
Sam was hanging all over her, with his hands on her hips, moving her with the beat. If Finn wasn't around to see this, there was really no point in her continuing. She excused herself from Sam and walked over to Quinn, Blaine, and Kurt.
"You guys having fun?" She asked, putting an arm around Quinn's waist, who reciprocated by putting her arm around Rachel's shoulders.
"Not as much as you are." Quinn laughed. "I didn't know you had a thing for blondes."
Rachel laughed, looking over at Sam who was now continuing his dance party of 1 in front of Mike and Tina. "He's quite cute isn't he?"
"Mmhmm...definitely my type of guy." Kurt nodded his head, giving his nod of approval towards Sam.
"Kurt! Blaine is right here!" Rachel laughed.
Blaine shook his head "Oh no, I'm going to have to agree. Have you seen those lips? I'd give him my Chapstick any day to moisturize those babies."
Kurt looked at Blaine, mouth slightly open in shock. "Okay now you've taken it too far."
"Aww is my baby jealous?" Blaine laughed, wrapping his arms around Kurt's waist. "You know you're my favorite lips to moisturize."
Rachel shook her head. "You guys are so cute it's sickening."
"Anyway Rachel..." Quinn laughed, steering their conversation back on course. "So what's the deal with Sam?"
"Well we exchanged numbers..." she shrugged. "So I guess we'll see." Rachel glanced around. "Did we lose two?" referring to Puck and Finn.
Quinn shook her head. "Puck and Finn are out in the main bar. They're on a mission to get Finn laid. Apparently Finn can't do it alone." Rachel missed the slight annoyance present in Quinn's tone.
Rachel's eyes widened as she took in the words Quinn said. Was he really just going to sleep with someone else? Okay, yes she did technically call off their roommates with benefits deal but that was supposed to make Finn want her more, not drive him into the arms of another girl. She was not going to have that.
"Oh..ok" She nodded. "I'll be back. Need to use the bathroom." she said walking off. Instead of heading to the bathroom in the private bar area, Rachel ventured off to the main bar. She was quickly able to spot Finn's tall stature near the bar chatting with Puck and two other girls. She walked over to the group, cutting in front of the girls.
"Ugh excuse me!" One of the girls said. Rachel paid no mind to her. She turned to Finn, who was watching her intently. So was Puck.
"I'm tired. I want to go home." She said to Finn.
He stared at her curiously before responding. Was she not just telling him she was going to sleep with Sam? "Where's Sam?"
Rachel shrugged innocently. "I don't know." She lightly grabbed onto his shirt and pulled on it, he bent down slightly so her mouth was near his ear. "I want you to fuck me, Finn." She said in her most sultry voice.
Finn nearly choked on the air he was breathing. He glanced at the two girls behind Rachel and then at Puck, all clueless to the words Rachel just spoke.
"Sorry ladies. I've gotta go..." He said to them, unsure of what else to say. He turned to Puck. "I'm going to take her home. She's not feeling all that well. I'll just meet you home." Finn knew Puck didn't believe a word he said, but at this point, he could care less. His mind was on Rachel and there was no way to escape that.
Rachel grabbed his hand and started pulling him out of the club, leaving the girls and Puck staring after them.
As they walked out the bar, they were able to hail a cab pretty quickly.
"What was that about in there? What's gotten into you?" Finn asked after getting into the cab.
"Hmm?" Rachel avoided the question, moving closer to him and pulling his lips into a kiss.
Finn deepened the kiss. Fuck. It's been so long since they've even touched each other. He felt himself getting hard just thinking about the events to come. Rachel rested her hand on his crotch, rubbing him through his jeans as she continued her sultry assault on his lips. She alternated between sucking on his bottom lip, swirling her tongue with his and licking along his lips sensually, leaving him wanting to taste her more and more.
Their make out session continued the whole ride to the apartment, only briefly stopping for Finn to pay the cab driver (who was not so pleased) as they got to their apartment.
They stepped out of the cab and Finn walked quickly into the building. He was so fucking hard and he really didn't need anyone else seeing him like this.
As soon as they stepped into the building, Rachel kicked off her heels. "I can't walk up these stairs." She said dramatically. Finn, not one to waste time at this moment, picked her up and she wrapped her legs around his waist and her arms around his shoulders.
"Well aren't you just my knight in shining armor." She smirked at him, giving his lips a kiss before moving to his neck. She sucked on his skin lightly as he started to walk up the stairs.
"Fuck, Rachel. What are you trying to do to me?" He groaned, his hands tightening his grip on her legs.
He got up one flight of stairs before pressing her against the wall, attacking her lips with his. Their tongues tangled together in a deep, heated kiss, leaving each other more and more hungry to taste each other.
He finally got up to the apartment and fumbled for his keys to get in. He finally got into the apartment and moved quickly to the couch. He sat down with Rachel still on top of him. Her dress at this time was hunched around her waist and her wetness was pressing right against his crotch.
Rachel's hands were on Finn's face, holding him in a deep kiss. Finn reached behind her and unzipped her dress. He pulled the dress up and over her body. His hands then moved to her bra, unclasping it quickly. His hands wasted no time cupping her breasts into his hands. Rachel moaned into his mouth. "Oh Finn..."
He broke the kiss and reached down to grab one of her nipples in his mouth. He sucked on her nipple while playing with the other in his hand. He switched to the other nipple, twirling his tongue around the hard nub. She grinded herself against his hard cock.
Rachel reached for his shirt, pulling it up and over his body. "Fuck I want you so bad Finn." She moaned, unbuttoning his pants, trying to pull it off with herself still sitting on his lap. She lifted up slightly and was able to pull his pants down to his mid thighs.
"Oh yeah? How bad?" Finn moved his hand to in between her legs, rubbing her through her wet thong at this point. She moaned loudly as he slipped one finger inside of her. "You're so wet for me baby." He added another finger, pumping them faster in and out of her.
"Ooh Finn, fuck me. Now...please!" she moaned.
Finn removed his fingers from inside of her and pushed his boxers down a bit, revealing his hard cock.
He grabbed on to her hips and rubbed the head of his dick up and down her lips until he lined up his dick with her opening. He pushed her hips down on to his dick and she sank down on to his full length, moaning loudly. "Oh my God.." She rested her hands on his shoulders and began moving up and down on his bare dick. Very quickly in their trysts, they gave up condoms with Rachel being on the pill.
He watched as her breasts bounced up and down as she fucked him. "Fuckk you feel so good, Rach."
He grabbed her hips and slammed her body down into his, picking up the pace of their fucking. Rachel threw her head back in utter pleasure. It seemed like his cock went deeper and deeper with every thrust into her. "Ughh Finn." She moaned loudly, feeling herself building up an orgasm quickly.
He pulled her off his dick and quickly changed positions. He let his jeans and boxers fall to the floor. Rachel was on all fours on the couch, while he had one knee on the couch, with his other leg gaining support from the carpeted floor. He slammed into her pussy from behind. Her moans got louder with each thrust. "You think Sam could fuck you like you this?" He mumbled between his moans.
He was pounding into her, all of his emotions of the night and the frustrations from the past few weeks pouring into his actions.
She screamed she was cumming and soon Finn was too, holding onto her hips as he exploded deep inside of her. They were both panting hard as they came down from the intensity of their fucking. He slowly pulled out and sat down on the couch. "Holy shit." He wiped off some sweat from his brow.
Rachel's legs trembled slightly as she laid down on the couch. She looked over at him and started giggling uncontrollably.
"What? What are you laughing about over there?" He reached for his boxers, putting them on, realizing Puck could get home anytime now.
"You're so jealous of Sam." She sat up, grabbing her clothes off the floor.
"I'm not jealous of that big mouth." Finn shook his head, face turning slightly red, as he recalled his words from earlier.
"No? So you questioned me about him earlier, and just told me Sam would never fuck me like this." She slipped on her dress over her body.
Finn smirked. "Well he can't."
"And why's that?" She climbed on to his lap, one leg on either side. His hands immediately rested on her hips. Her chocolate brown eyes stared deep into his ambers.
"Because I've seen him in a locker room before. He definitely doesn't size up well." He continued with a smug look on his face, before turning a little more serious.
"And...because you're mine, Rachel." He said softly.
"I thought you weren't looking for anything serious. No strings attached, remember?" She ran her fingers through his hair, playing with the ends of his hair on the back of his neck.
"I think we both know there are strings here." He gently squeezed her hips in an affectionate manner.
Rachel leaned in and kissed his lips softly. "Let's go to bed. I miss my snuggles."
"Mmm me too." He kissed her back. They gathered the rest of their clothes and walked to her room. Finn behind Rachel, started laughing.
"What's so funny huh?" She put her hands on her hips, turning to look at him.
"You were so jealous of those girls. You like threw yourself at me." He laughed as she rolled her eyes.
"I'm tired Finn. I want to go home." He mocked her playfully, walking into her room.
She rolled her eyes and laughed, closing the door behind them. "I was NOT jealous. You know why?" She walked over to him, wrapping her little arms around his waist.
"Why's that?" He glanced down at her, wrapping his arms around her waist, clasping his fingers together behind her.
"Because you're mine."
Finn smiled, never thinking he'd like hearing those words come out of a girls mouth. He leaned down and captured her lips in a sweet kiss.
Puck walked back to the room where his friends were after Rachel and Finn left.
"The weirdest thing just happened." He said, causing his three friends to look over at him.
"Where's Finn? Did he get himself laid yet?" Quinn rolled her eyes.
"Uh...quite possibly." Puck nodded. "But I'm not sure you're going to want to know with who."
Kurt raised his eyebrows as Quinn looked confused. "Who?"
"Hey remember that cousin of yours who you wanted to live with us? Yeah...pretty sure she's about to give Finn more than just her share of the rent."
"No way!" Quinn's eyes widened. "She's never even said one word about him..she was just here with Sam! I don't believe that."
Kurt laughed. "Honey, those two have been going at it since she moved in."
Puck and Quinn's eyes widened. "What?!"
"How do you not know this?" Kurt asked Puck. "You live with the both of them."
"I'm her cousin. She would have definitely told me." Quinn said, still in disbelief.
"Yes...because you've been so honest with her, too?" Kurt tilted his head to the side, as Quinn slightly blushed, averting eye contact with anyone.
Sam, Mike, and Tina walked over to the group. "Hey Guys, we're gonna head out. Thanks for inviting us - we should definitely get together soon." Mike said.
Puck nodded. "Yeah man, definitely."
"Where's Rachel? I didn't get a chance to say goodnight." Sam looked around.
Before Puck responded, Quinn quickly jumped in. "Rachel wasn't feeling too well. She went home."
Sam nodded. "I'll text her then. This was fun...I'm sure I'll see you guys around more often." The smirk on his face was very apparent.
As the group walked off, Puck turned to Quinn. "Why didn't you just tell him his girl is getting it on right now with Finn?"
"Uh because why would I? Rachel needs a good man in her life. How long have we known Finn, Noah? He's only going to break her heart."
"Hey now, give Finn some credit." Blaine chimed in. "He did look pretty jealous earlier tonight when Rachel was dancing with Sam. AND he came to dinner with her dad's. I think he actually does like her."
Kurt nodded. "I love Finn, and I think Rachel may be good for him. But...he does have a tendency to screw things up. I will say though, I've never see him just buy a girl some flowers. I had to drag him to Blaine's show...sorry babe. He willingly came to hers. I just think there may be something more for him here...and I think he knows it."
Puck shook his head. "I'm gonna get to the bottom of this. Come on, let's get out of here." He grabbed Quinn's hand without even really thinking about it. He dropped it quickly when he felt all eyes on him.
"It's okay." Quinn gently grabbed his hand. "They know."
Puck looked over at Kurt and Blaine, who both had the biggest smiles on their faces.
"Our boys are growing up!" Kurt laughed, as they all walked out of the bar.
So, what did you think?! Quinn's not very happy with the idea of Finn and Rachel. We haven't really seen the last of Sam just yet. :D