Hello everybody! Thank you all for favoring and following. And thank you for 282 views on this story. I'm really happy that everyone seems to enjoy it. I'm still looking for baby names by the way. I don't want to pick names that you guys won't like so I need some suggestions if you will. Let me know how you're all liking the story so far.

*Four Years Later*

Sam was pacing around his room nervously. He held a pregnancy test in his hand, it clearly read positive. He took a few tests to make sure, each one turning up positive just like the first. How would Gabriel and Lucifer react to his news? Let alone how would Dean react? He decided not to tell anyone for the time being, at least until he could figure what to do first. Sam hid the pregnancy test somewhere no one else would find it before making his way to the war room. Castiel was sitting at the table watching Bay play with her toys on the ground. Bay was four now, still mainly looking like a miniature Cas with a little bit of Dean thrown into the mix. Sam knelt next to Bay and played with the toys with her. He would play with his niece or lay down and let Bay play with his soft hair for hours. Sammy loved Bay and did everything he could to help take care of her. He was preoccupied playing with Bay that he hadn't noticed Cas staring at him.

"Sam." Cas said, finally getting the hunter's attention. Cas had noticed something was off with Sam today, but he couldn't place exactly what it was. "Are you alright? Something seems different with you today."

"Yeah, Cas, I'm fine." Sam lied, he didn't want anyone to find out about what was actually happening. He decided to come up with a lie until he was ready otherwise. "I think I'm just coming down with the flu."

Cas seemed to accept the answer. The angel didn't know much about humans and how the human body works, so he didn't question Sam's lie. Sam was hoping Cas would leave it at that and not bring anything up to Gabriel or Lucifer. Sam made a mental note to call Dr. Robert and set up an appointment. He was the only doctor he could go to that wouldn't question a pregnant man.


*Two Months Later*

Sam was sitting in another run down motel room waiting for Dean to return with their dinner. They had just finished a case involving werewolves and vampires. Dean made sure to make a Twilight joke during the investigation. Sam had found that he wasn't of much help on the case other than researching. Gabriel ended up helping Dean kill the unlucky werewolves and vampires, while Sam stayed in the motel worrying for his brother's and angel's return. Sam was frightened when they both returned covered head to toe in blood, but luckily neither one was injured. Now Dean was at a local diner getting them dinner, and Gabriel had flown off to help Castiel look after Bay. Dean walked into the room, pulling Sam from his thoughts.

"I got your rabbit food, Sammy." Dean said, handing his brother a foam container. Dean could see a hint of disappointment in Sam's eyes. "Did you not want the rabbit food?"

"Huh? Oh, uh, no, thank you Dean." Sam said, stumbling slightly with his words. He started to have cravings about a week ago, but he did his best to hide them. What he really wanted was a hot fudge sundae and carrots, but he couldn't give in to his cravings. "Are we leaving in the morning?"

"Yeah, back to the bunker." Dean watched Sam pick at his food. He noticed Sam was eating the carrots before anything else. Sam had been acting different for quite some time now. He first covered it up with the flu, then food poisoning, and now exhaustion. Dean knew something else was bothering his brother and intended to find out. "Hey, Sammy, what's going on? You've been acting strange lately."

Sam wanted to tell someone about his pregnancy, but was his brother the best person to trust with delicate news? Sam thought about it for a moment before sighing and turning to face Dean.

"Just don't get mad, okay?"Sam watched Dean nod his head, encouraging Sam to continue. Sam swallowed hard and took a deep breath, preparing for any anger and yelling to come from Dean. "Two months ago I found out I was pregnant."

Dean was completely shocked, he hadn't expected something like this. He took a few minutes to let it all sink in before speaking again.

"Why haven't you told anyone?" Dean asked, now worried about his younger brother. "Does Gabriel and Lucifer know?"

"No, the only other person that knows is Dr. Robert." Sam said, shaking his head a little. He knew Dean would question why Sammy hasn't told anyone. He was prepared for the questioning, but he wasn't prepared how calm his brother was. "I was scared when I found out, Dean. I didn't know how Gabriel, Lucifer, you, or even Cas would react. I didn't know what to do, I still don't. What am I going to do if Gabriel and Lucifer don't want this child, Dean?"

Dean watched as fear crept into Sammy's eyes. He knew how scared Sam was and he could understand Sam's point of view on the situation.

"I'm gonna have to keep this a secret, aren't I?" Dean watched as Sam slowly nodded and avoid eye contact with Dean. Dean silently agreed to keep Sam's secret. "So, any cravings or morning sickness yet?"

"No morning sickness yet, thankfully." Sam answered, he was glad he didn't have to deal with the morning sickness just yet. He was sure it would come soon and he dreaded it. "I've been craving hot fudge sundaes and carrots, but I haven't been giving in to the cravings. It would draw too much attention."

Dean knew Gabriel would have fun if he knew Sammy was wanting a hot fudge sundae. Dean let the thoughts of becoming an uncle cross through his mind and couldn't help but smile. He was going to be an uncle. He was excited and wanted to tell the whole world, but he would keep the secret for Sam's sake.

"I think I can help with that, Sammy." Dean said, smiling and bowing his head. Sam knew Dean was about to pray, but was unsure who his brother was praying to. Dean cleared his throat before speaking again. "Hey Cas, I don't mean to bug you this late at night, but I need a favor. Can you pick me up a hot fudge sundae from the diner here in town and some carrots. I forgot the carrots for Sammy's rabbit food."

A few minutes later they were greeted by the flutter of wings, signaling Castiel's presence. Dean greeted his angel with a soft kiss, causing a faint blush to find its way to Cas's cheeks. He handed Dean a plastic container containing the sundae and a plastic bag of carrots.

"I do not understand why you wanted the ice cream." Cas said, watching Dean take both items eagerly before handing the carrots to Sam. "Normally you ask me to get you pie. Is there a reason for the ice cream, Dean?"

"I like to change things up, Cas, so that I never get sick of my glorious pie." Dean lied, covering up the truth quite perfectly. He gave Castiel a quick kiss before the angel flew back to the bunker where their daughter was waiting his return. Dean handed the sundae to Sam, grinning wide. "Here is your hot fudge sundae, mommy-to-be." Sam gave Dean a confused stare as he took the ice cream from the older hunter.

"Did you just call me 'mommy-to-be'?" Sam asked, curious as to why Dean would call him such a thing. Dean nodded his head to answer the question while smiling. "Why?"

"Well, you are the one carrying the baby." Dean answered, sitting on his bed after removing and tossing his jacket on the back of a chair. "The baby already has two dads, so you get to be the mom, Sammy."

Sam just rolled his eyes, but couldn't stop the smile forming on his lips. He was happy that Dean was being so supportive of the pregnancy and Sam's decision to hid it from the others. He sat back in his chair smiling and finally giving in to his cravings.


*Month Three*

Sam was now three months into his pregnancy and he now had a small baby bump. It wasn't that hard to hide since it wasn't so big. Dean has been continuing keeping his secret and helping him indulge in his cravings. He couldn't be more thankful for his older brother's help, and every chance he had he was thanking Dean. Sam had also started getting morning sickness again, which was a bit harder to hide than the baby bump. He had to lie to the others about it constantly, he didn't like to lie to them but he didn't have much of a choice.

They were all gathered in the kitchen. Dean was making breakfast for himself, Sammy, and Bay. Gabriel conjured up candy and happily munched away, occasionally trying to sneak some to Bay only to be helped at by both Castiel and Dean.

"She's getting so big." Gabriel said, watching Bay eat her breakfast Dean had made special just for her. Dean made her some oatmeal with a little bit of chocolate chips sprinkled in, which she absolutely loved. "Let's hope she doesn't get daddy Dean's attitude." He started joking around, everyone laughed along with him.

"You just wait until you have children of your own." Dean replied to the joke, serving bacon and eggs with some orange juice to Sam. It was Sam's current craving and to his luck it wasn't out of the ordinary to cause any suspicion. "You better hope they don't act like you."

"Hey, I'm great with kids." Gabriel stuck his tongue out at Dean in a mocking manner, causing the hunter to roll his eyes and smile. "But I don't want kids of my own, at least not yet. I'm not ready for that."

"What about you, Lucifer?" Castiel piped up, quite curious about how his brother would respond. He knew Lucifer still grieved over the loss of his and Sam's son Noah. "Do you want anymore children in the future?"

"I don't know." Lucifer answered Cas honestly. He had loved being an uncle to Bay, but he hadn't put any thought into having any more children. "I don't think another child would be the best right now. Maybe sometime in the future."

Sam could feel his heart ache at the confessions from his angels. This was how they truly felt, they would be so disappointed and possibly anger if they were to find out about Sam's pregnancy.

"Sam?" Cas turned his attention to Sam, who was spacing out until hearing his name. "Do you wish to have any children?" Sam wasn't quite prepared to answer after hearing Gabriel and Lucifer answer.

"Uh, no." Sam obliviously lied, but no one was aware except for Dean. Dean had a pained expression as he listened to Sam speak. "I'll stick to being an uncle."

Dean could hear the hurt in Sammy's voice, and it seemed he was the only one. He quickly changed his expression back to normal before anyone else could see the pain showing clearly. Sam excused himself from the conversation. He could feel his stomach churning and he could the his breakfast working its way back up, and quickly made his way to his bathroom. He knelt in front of the toilet and let himself throw up everything he had just eaten. Tears started streaming down his face, but it wasn't from him throwing up. He was crying because now his worst fears had come true. Gabriel and Lucifer didn't want any children. Sam was stuck carrying around a child that wasn't wanted by two of his or her parents. So many thoughts raced through his head that he just couldn't ignore.

'What am I going to do now? I definitely can't let them know now. They would hate me! They would hate the baby! I won't be able to hide it much longer. Should I go away for the rest of the pregnancy? Does this mean I'll have to give the child up after he or she is born? Will I even be able to do that?'

The hot tears continued to stream down his face, come faster the more the same thoughts raced through his mind. He was now sitting against the bathroom wall, not caring or even paying attention when Dean walked in. Dean knelt next to Sam, placing his hand on his little brother's shoulder to comfort him. He hated seeing Sam cry, but knew it was only reasonable after what had just happened.

"Sammy..." Dean paused, not knowing if anything he would say could comfort Sam. "Look, man, I'm sorry. I didn't things would go that far. I'm still going to be here for you, okay? Whether they want the baby or not, I'll be here for you to lean on and depend on."

Sam stayed quiet, letting his sobs be the only thing to be heard. Dean rubbed Sam's back, soothing his younger brother. Sam was finally able to calm down with help from Dean.

"Dean, what am I going to do?" Sam looked to his brother, tears threatening to fall again. He was hoping from the bottom of his heart that Dean would have an answer. "I'm going to have to give the baby away, aren't I?"

"Sam." Dean knew that isn't what Sam had wanted, but what was his brother suppose to think after hearing how much Gabriel and Lucifer opposed the mere thought of having children? Sam had felt that he was alone, but Dean made sure to reassure his little brother he was there and wasn't going anywhere. "It all depends on what you want to do, Sammy, and no matter what it is I'll be there to support you through the whole thing."