Chapter 5

Peyton woke up to feel her pillow wasn't as soft as it was opened her eyes to see dean's chest pressed up against felt a blush creep onto her looked around the room to see sam awake quietly reading on his computer.

Peyton slowly lifted dean's arm from her waist crawling out of she was out of his vice like grip she made her way toward had three coffees sitting on the table handed Peyton hers but kept reading."so what have you found"she asked taking a sip of her coffee.

"well all of the people seem to be killed with a metal curved weapon like a sickle..but get this there's a legend about a hook man that people have been posting about all over the town's website," sam said looking up at her.

"Do you think that it's worth checking into"she asked tilting her head."well we should but just to be sure,let's get ready and go check it nodded before grabbing her FBI clothes and headed to the bathroom.

Once sam her the shower turn on he headed over to dean and shook him opened his eyes in confusion until sam handed him his coffee before returning to his computer and packed it up.

He went to his duffle bag getting dressed followed was almost done buttoning up his dress shirt when Peyton came out of the was wearing a pencil skirt with a white button down dress shirt and a woman's suit hair was down and wavy down to her back still damp from her shower.

She turned to him and smiled lightly."we ready" she asked turning to all got into the impala,dean driving,sam in the passenger and Peyton in the pulled out her ipod and scrolled through her found the song hard to love and played it,singing quietly.

She loved to sing it wasn't really out loud it was when they had long car rides and she gets restless.

Deans POV

I watched as Peyton sang quietly to had become a regular thing would sing quietly and i would sneak glances at her then sam would catch me and question me...which i didn't need sam prying into anything stupid.i just brushed my feelings off as brotherly love not wanting to admit that i could care for someone.

But everyone dies around was singing a song that kinda sounded alot like his chuckled quietly.

I am insensitive, I have a tendency

To pay more attention to the things that I need

Sometimes I drink too much, sometimes I test your trust,

Sometimes I don't know why you're staying with me

I'm hard to love, hard to love,

Oh I don't make it easy,

I couldn't do it if I stood where you stood

I'm hard to love, hard to love,

You say that you need me,

I don't deserve it but I love that you love me good

I am a short fuse, I am a wrecking ball

Crashing into your heart like I do

You're like a Sunday morning full of grace and full of Jesus

And I wish that I could be more like you

I'm hard to love, hard to love,

Oh I don't make it easy,

I couldn't do it if I stood where you stood,

I'm hard to love, hard to love,

You say that you need me,

I don't deserve it but I love that you love me good

Love me good

Girl you've given me a million second chances

And I don't ever wanna take you for granted,

I'm just a man,

I'm just a man

Hard to love, hard to love,

Oh I don't make it easy,

And I couldn't do it if I stood where you stood

I'm hard to love, hard to love

And you say that you need me,

I don't deserve it but I love that you love me

Hard to love, hard to love,

Oh I don't make it easy,

And I couldn't do it if I stood where you stood

I'm hard to love, hard to love

And you say that you need me,

I don't deserve it but I love that you love me good

You love me good

You love me good

I loved the way she would glance out the window looking at everything,so aware of the things long wavy black hair waving some what as the wind pulled it back exposing her neck,there was a scar i never noticed want from her collarbone to the back of her ear.

I tilted my head curiously,i brushed it off as a battle scar and turned my attention to the was staring at his computer."so sammy found anything else"dean asked."no and don't call me sammy"i heard him say gruffly.

I reached over to the radio and put in a tape the first song on it was simple man by Lynyrd smiled and started singing loudly to the music.

Peyton's POV

I watched as dean sang loudly to the looked so funny tapping his hands on the steering wheel to the would always do this when there was awkard silence or when he was bored.

i had noticed a lot of things lately with when he has to fix the impala and bends over the staring hood i catch myself staring at his but or even when he lifts something heavy his muscles get taunt and bulge abit.

The impala stopped and came up to a big house,there were police cars every where,caution tape riddled the street, it looked like they shot off a cation tape confetti gun.i giggled to myself as i thought this.

We walked inside showing our police explained that they have had two deaths already.i walked up to the girl who found the body."are you alright"i asked looking at her.

"I'm alright just a little shaken up"she said pulling her sweatshirt closer to her."do you know what happened"i asked lightly."i already told the police everything i know"she said defensively."i know but i really need to know and i have a few of my own questions"i said giving her a reassuring smile.

"I came home from studying from the library,the light was off so i didn't turn it on because i saw she was sleeping...or what looked like was sleeping,i got dressed and went to bed, the next morning i saw her blood on the floor….that's all i know.

"Sigh"alright thank you for your time"i said getting up and walking over to the boys."hey find anything"i turned to me."ya there are claw marks or something on the wall"i heard dean say as i went to inspect them.

"Hey didn't that legend have a sharpened hook,she said smirking."don't even get me started it's not a legend"dean said gruffly."oh come on dean what if it is"sam said mockingly."we have to look over all of the possibilities"i said looking over the message written in blood on the said "aren't you glad you did not turn on the light"written in blood and carved into the wood,it also had a symbol carved under it.

"Hey guys look at this i think i saw this on a church in town on our way here"i said looking over the symbol.i walked over to the girl."do you know what this symbol is"i asked her pointing to the wall."yes um my dad is the pastor of the town's church and that's the church symbol"she said eyeing it."thank you for your time"i said walking away.

"Let's go guys"i said them as we started to got in the impala."the girl said that it was part of the church"she said to the guys."we should talk to the pastor then"dean said."me and Peyton will do it you call bobby"sam said looking at dean.

"Alright that's fine"dean turned to the hotel got out and went into the room,sam got in the driver's seat and Peyton got into the took off down the road to the church.

Once they arrived at the church they went through the doors to see the pastor was sitting on a pew walked over and lightly tapped him on the shoulder."excuse me father we have a few questions"sam looked up confused."of course please ask away"he said standing up to face them.

"we were at a murder scene and the killer left behind a little note for people to see"sam said handing him a picture of the words." but on the bottom as you see here it had a symbol,we asked around turns out this symbol is linked to your church"Peyton said crossing her arms.

"Well yes it is from my church but i don't know anything about the murder"he said looked him in the eyes making him more always had that effect on people."do you think it would be anyone from your church"sam asked."n-no of course not"he said dismissing it.

"Alright thank you father for your time"sam said walking they were back in the impala sam turned to Peyton."i could get close to the pastor's daughter,i could see if there's anything going on"he said."ok that's fine just don't get yourself in trouble."she said smirking.

they got out of the impala and walked into the motel room to see dean sitting at the table on the phone with took off her heels and threw them by her duffle then got some street clothes and took them into the bathroom.

She got on black skinny jeans,a black t-shirt, and a pair of grey put her hair in a high ponytail putting it over her walked out to see sam looking on his computer yet again.

"The pastor was kinda iffy when we asked him"she said putting in her opinion."ya he was"sam agreed."ill look up what i can about him"sam added."me and dean will scope out his house and see what we can find"Peyton said pushing her bangs out of the way.