"Um, hi, Finn?" Rachel's voice sounded hopeless trough the speaker. Nothing like her. Nothing like Barbra, either.
"Hi, who's talking?" he asked, not recognizing her.
"It's me. Rachel." she mumbled. Santana was grinning in excitement, and Rachel was shaking. What if he wouldn't leave Quinn? What if he wouldn't take the risk?
"Oh, hi." Disappointment was clear in his voice, but he kept on talking "So, what do you want?" Rachel was scared as hell, what would she tell her? 'Want to get back with you' wasn't an option, and she didn't want to seem easy, either.
"I was wondering if we could meet at Lima Bean in 10 minutes? It's important." she hid all that nervousness in that invitation.
"Sure, is there anything you need to talk about?" he asked.
"Yea, actually. Meet me there, I'll explain it to you." At this point, Santana was practically jumping on the couch, and was extremely proud of her friend.
"See you there then, bye." he said and hung up. Rachel turned to Santana, her heart still beating furiously in her chest, and sighed.
"Well done, my friend." The Latino congratulated her. "I guess I'm going with Brittany, since you're going with-"
"No. Come with me." Rachel cut her off "I mean, let's go together, and then you hide somewhere so I can talk. But in case anything happens, I need you to be there." Santana listened carefully and then started deciding wether to agree or leave.
"Fine, I'll go. But I don't want anything to happen to you, OK?" she warned "If anything happens, I'll go all Lima Heights."
"Okay" Rachel laughed, and she joined.
"Park here." Rachel ordered. They were already in Lima Bean, and they couldn't find a place to park the big black car Santana was given for her birthday. She pulled into the small place near a red Ferrari and an old model of Santana's car.
"Well, I don't see his car near here, but let's go just in case." she proposed. Santana shook her head.
"I'll stay here, text me if you need something, fine? I promise I will stay." Rachel nodded "Oh, and, can you buy me a coffee, please?" she grabbed her wallet and took a 10 dollar bill out, but Rachel refused, telling she would pay.
"Okay, thanks." Santana told her as Rachel got out of the car, mentally preparing herself what she would say.
'I've been thinking lately, and I really want to be your girlfriend again. I know that you're with Quinn, but seriously I can't stand not being with you. Plus, I've heard some rumors about her and I don't want you to be hurt.' she told herself while she ordered 3 coffees: one for her, one for Finn, and the other for Santana. She knew exactly what they liked.
'Santana told me Brittany told her someone from Carmel told her that she's cheating on you... with Jesse. I know you may think I am inventing it, but I swear not. You can ask them, or even Quinn.' That information hadn't been much in Rachel's head, but it hurted not being able to tell him. Quinn was a bad person, nothing like the fake Quinn from the first day they met. Nothing.
Just when she was about to sit down, she saw him, standing awkwardly at the front door. She waved at him, with a small smile in her face, so he knew where he was.
"Um, hi Rachel." Finn said.
"Look, I'm just gonna tell it to you because I can't hold it in anymore, okay?" she asked, but didn't wait for a response, she continued talking "Santana told me someone from Carmel High has told Brittany that Jesse's got a girlfriend, a new one."
"Oh, that's okay, he's not with Chelsea anymore..." he said "... but why are you telling me this?"
"Because that girl, that girl that is dating Jesse is someone you know, and you won't be happy when I tell it to you..." she looked down.
"Rachel, please tell me you're not dating Jesse because I'll seriously tell my dad to arrest him. Right now." he slipped his phone out of his pocket, but Rachel told him he was wrong. That she wasn't the one who was dating Jesse.
"No, it's not me." Rachel softly pulled Finn's hand down, making him put his phone away. "It's Quinn. Your Quinn. She's cheating on you, Finn."
"There's no way." Finn looked around the coffee shop, confused and kind of sad "She was crazy for coming back with me. She won't cheat."
"Well, let's see." this time, Rachel slipped her phone out and dialed Quinn's number. She put it on the highest volume, so that Finn would hear too.
"Hello?" the blonde girl asked. She was gasping, and it was difficult to recognize her voice.
"Hi, Quinn? It's Rachel. I've been hearing some rumors, and I wanted to make sure if they were true, can I?" she asked politely. Finn was very solicitous, hearing the girls' conversation.
"Yes, I am dating Finn again." she practically bragged, as a guy shouted 'Babe, come back, we haven't finished our make-out session yet!' from the other side of the phone.
"Are you with Finn now?" she asked, looking at Finn. She knew who the guy who shouted was, because she had heard his voice for two years straight, but in case Finn couldn't, he asked that simple question.
"Yes, I'm with Finn. And now, I have to go back to my make-out session, bye!" she happily said and hung up the phone. Finn was astonished, though he didn't like Quinn. But she had cheated.
"Incredible." he muttered.
"Finn, I, I am sorry, I didn't want you to more hurted than now. I shouldn't have told you this, I'm so stupid." Rachel apologized, feeling the guiltiness inside her.
"No, don't apologize, Rach." he comforted her "I didn't like her anyway, I was just trying to move on, you know? Like in the movies?"
"Yea, I've been trying to move on too, but I can't." she admitted, her cheeks blushing a bit.
"Look, Rachel, I can't be without you, OK?" he stated.
"I can't be without you, too, but-" she was interrupted by a kiss that he gently planted on her mouth. They kissed for some seconds, then parted.
"If it that's okay, I want us to be Finchel again, is that possible?" he smiled, as she nodded in agreement. Everything went just as she wanted. She had her boy back, and Quinn was caught. Now, she needed to help Puck. They had a really long job to do there.
(A/N): Well, Finchel is back! Yay! I'm planning on finishing this story in two more chapters, but I'll try to make them as long as I can. I know this story kinda sucked because I didn't have a big plot twist, but I'll try to make the remaining chapters as interesting as I can, because I need some emotion lol. Also, I wanted to publicly apologize with klainebowpower because we had an argument. A public argument. But also I wanted to tell all those people who've been telling me to get a life, or that I'm a pathetic bitch that they need to know all the story before judging, and unfortunately, you don't because klainebowopower and I know each other in real life. And of course, if she tells the story without mentioning the wrong stuff she did, I would be the villain and she'd be the hero. And it's not like this, okay? We're both villains and heroes, because we're both right and wrong. Also thanks to fangirling bc of you for supporting me and listening to me, you're the best! (:
