Hanna's POV

Ok, maybe Emily was right and we all over reacted a little, but who could blame us? Spencer likes Toby! I still don't understand why. Maybe they had this "connection" that we didn't notice? No, that doesn't make sense, before Ally went missing we never went near that creep Cavanaugh. But maybe she did it secretly without telling us? But Alison knew all our secrets, and she always found a way to spill them in front of us. Or she would hint it when we were all together. But either way, I don't think Spencer actually saw Toby in the past… or did she?

E- Hanna!

H- what is it?

A- you have been really quiet and like lost in thought. What gives?

H- I was just thinking-

E- thinking what?!

A- let her finish!

E- sorry.

H- anyway, I was think about how on earth Spencer could like Toby.

A- and?

H- well what if she liked him before she had to help him?

E- you mean before the Jenna thing?

H- I know it sounds crazy, but what if she did it secretly?

A- you mean date him? Without telling us?

H- exactly. I mean, it is possible!

E- it is, but why would she want to do it secretly and not tell us?

H- duh! Because no one likes Toby! Especially Alison! If we are right, and she did see him before the Jenna thing, then something must have happened between them.

A- you mean like a break up?

E- or maybe he did something that made her scared of him!

H- like what?

E- I don't know what.

A- guys! We might not even be right!

H- true, but there is only one way to find out.

E- wait, you don't mean-

A- confront her?

E- Han, are you sure?

H- nope, but if we never do, we will never know.

A- should we call her?

E- yah, but let's get out of her house first. It is kind of awkward.

H- (laughs)I know right? She runs out of her own house and then we stay.

A- (laughs too) we can go to my house.

E- I'll drive alone and you guys can go together.

H- are you ok?

E- I just need some time alone for a couple of minutes.

A- is it Ben?

E- yah.

H- what about Ben?

E- I don't really like him as much as I used to. But never mind. (walks out the door and gets in her car)

A- you know? All we have talked about today is boys! Like, can we please talk about something else?

H- (teases) umm no.

A- thought so.

H- laughs. Come on, let's go. (walks with Aria to her car and Aria starts to drive)

Emily's POV

I drove slowly on my way to Aria's house. I wanted time to think about Ben. Ever since I kissed Alison in the tree house, I haven't had that sparky kind of feeling with other guys. I started dating Ben about a couple of months ago. And we never really fought about anything. This would make sense since we are both into the same kinds of things like running and swimming. But every time he kisses me or hugs me, it doesn't feel right. I feel wrong. Like I am doing the wrong thing. Like I need to be with someone else. But not another guy. Another girl.