Never Forgotten Past

Summary: Finn's sister comes back to town and brings some old memories with her. Takes place beginning of Season 3. The story will be in a lot of different people's point of views.

Disclaimer: I don't own Glee or any songs that I may put in here.

The Soap Opera That is My Life

Kurt's Point of View

Finn and I were eating lunch when we heard the pounding of 15 year old feet running up the stairs.

"Kurt! I might need your help," I glanced up at Sarah and rolled my eyes at what she was wearing.

It was so very obvious sometimes that Sarah Hudson was definitely my step-sister and not biological. She had on grey sweat pants and one of Finn's old work out shirts. Not to mention her hair was soaking wet and in a sloppy bun on top of her head.

"You look fine to me," Finn said through the grilled cheese in his mouth, "And besides, it's 11:30, didn't Puck say noon?"

"Yes, oh my God, what am I going to do?" Sarah plopped down across from us at the kitchen table.

"Are you forgetting that it's Puck you're talking about? Do you not remember when he saw you..."

"FINN!" Sarah screamed, "We promised to never speak of that again!"

Now I was intrigued, what was so tasty and revealing that Sarah wanted no one to know?

"No no no," Finn taunted, "You and Puck promised to never speak of it again, I promised nothing," he finished with a smirk.

"Ugh!" Sarah stormed off, "Mom! Finn's being stupid and unfair!"

We could hear her run through the house, trying to find Carole in order to get Finn in trouble for talking about this secret between her and Puck. Finn chuckled to himself before turning back to his sandwich.

"What was all that about?" I asked my step-brother.

There was a wicked gleam in his eyes as he answered my question, "When Sarah turned 11, we threw this huge pool party and we were going to drive Puck there with us. Anyways, she was taking forever to change into her bathing suit so Puck went to go get her."

I could see where this was going and gasped. Finn just laughed.

"Yeah, he walked in on her staring at herself in the mirror wondering why her favorite suit wouldn't fit anymore. He saw everything, I'm pretty sure that's the first time he'd seen a girl naked," Finn ended.

I felt so bad for Sarah, and Puck I guess. What could possibly be more embarrassing than seeing one of your best friends, who is a girl, naked?

"Mom said knock it off or she'll take away your phone," Sarah announced as she walked back into the kitchen.

"Whatever," Finn said, not phased by what I believed to be an empty threat.

I glanced at the clock on the stove, 11:45, "I think we need to get to work Sarah."

She glanced at the clock too and sighed, "Think you can fix me in 15 minutes?"

I couldn't help but roll my eyes again at the young girl who had no idea what I was capable of, so I grabbed her hand and led her to the bedroom.

~~~~~GLEE~~~~~

I walked up the stairs with Sarah right on my tail.

We, or more I, picked out her outfit perfectly. She was wearing a light blue, silky t-shirt and a pair of dark jeans that hugged her legs in all the right places. I curled her hair and clipped back the top part. After all that, she still had three minutes left before Puck promised to be here.

"There's my pretty girl," Carole cooed as we walked into the living room.

Finn didn't even bother looking up and Dad just glanced before turning back to the tv.

"Thanks Mom," Sarah smiled, "But I can't take credit for this, Kurt picked out the clothes and did my hair, I just sat still."

"Well Kurt, you made my daughter look very nice," Carole said to me.

"It was my pleasure, Carole. It was like a challenge, a blank slate. Literally," I laughed, thinking back to 30 minutes ago when Sarah had charged in the kitchen, fresh from the shower.

The doorbell rang and we all turned to look at the door, yet none of us moving. Suddenly Sarah ran passed me followed closely by Finn.

"No Finn!" She turned and tried to push her 6'3" brother away, but failed having done nothing at all.

"But he's my friend," Finn argued.

"But he's here to see me," Sarah said back.

Finn pushed past her, but Sarah jumped on his back.

The two of them started arguing as Finn spun in circles to try and get her to loosen her grip.

"Everything's different with another kid around," Dad said.

Carole moved to get off the couch, "I'll go stop them."

"No, I can do it, Carole," I assured my step-mom as I walked over to Finn and Sarah.

I walked past them, sort of wondering how they would react to what I was about to do. By the time my hand was on the door knob, the doorbell had rung another four times. I opened the door to see Puck standing on our front porch with his hands in his pockets and a guitar at his feet.

He looked confused to see me, but shrugged it off, "What the heck took you so long, Hummel? I've been waiting for hours out here."

I nodded back at Finn and Sarah who had stopped fighting when I opened the door, "How's that for an explanation?"

Sarah slowly climbed off Finn and walked over to where Puck and I were standing.

"Hey," she said.

I rolled my eyes, if she truly was starting to like Puck like she had told me while we were picking out her outfit, then she'd have to learn how to flirt. I put that in the back of my mind for later.

"Hey," Puck smiled back before staring at her and not making anymore noise.

My God, Noah Puckerman was at a lost for words and it was all because of my work, I felt satisfied with myself.

"Well, welcome him in, Sars," Finn muttered from behind me. I could tell he was getting uncomfortable with how Puck and Sarah were staring at each other.

"Right," Sarah muttered back and we both stepped back to let the mohawked boy into our home.

"So, where to? You got your own room?" Puck asked.

"No!" yelled Finn, making us all jump.

"Finn, your sister can bring her friends anywhere in this house that she wants to," Carole said as she walked over to us.

"Thank you," Sarah whispered to her mom.

As much as I thought Carole was right, I couldn't help but agree with Finn. Puck had a reputation. He was a father for Pete's sake and I didn't want that to happen to Sarah.

"Hi, Noah," Carole smiled at the teenage boy who she used to consider a son. That was when he had been around everyday, but that all changed three years ago. He would still come over, but the absence of her daughter had made it hard for both Puck and Finn.

"Hi, Ms. Carole," Puck smiled back.

I was slightly taken aback by the known bad boy's new change in manners. I think my mouth was even hanging open a little.

Puck was the first one to notice, "Yeah, that's right, Hummel, I know my manners. Especially around Momma Carole," he smirked at me.

Sarah, Finn, and Carole laughed.

"I forgot you used to call Mom that!" Sarah said.

Wow, I guess I didn't really realize how close the little family was with Puck. He was one of them. His last name might as well have been Hudson.

"You guys can go practice in the basement," Carole said.

"Mom," Finn warned.

"For goodness sake, Finn, they'll just be downstairs. Noah wouldn't try and pull anything on her anyway," Carole said before turning and heading into the kitchen to start dinner, "Are you staying for dinner, Noah?" she called back.

"Um, well, it's Gracie's birthday tomorrow and I promised I'd take her out to her favorite restaurant tonight."

"Oh my gosh! I forgot it was Gracie's birthday today," Sarah exclaimed.

Puck laughed lightly, "Yeah, she's pretty excited, double digits and all that."

Did Puck have a sister? Kinda sounded like it. Sarah living here was opening up a lot of doors I had never even bothered looking at.

"So, want to go practice?" Sarah asked Puck.

"Of course," Puck smiled. He picked up his guitar and then followed Sarah to the bedroom.

"Maybe I'll just call Rachel or something," Finn muttered once they were gone.

"She went to the mall with Mercedes," I stated and then went to go see what Carole was cooking. Maybe I could make dessert or something.

~~~~~GLEE~~~~~

"So what are you doing now?" Blaine asked me. We had been talking on the phone for the past half hour, each asking what the other was doing to keep the conversation going when it died a little.

"Well, I'm walking through my house and I see," I stopped above the stairs and saw a tall figure sitting on them, "Finn spying on his sister, I gotta go."

As I hung up the phone, I tried to think of what to say to Finn to get him to get off the stairs and away from Puck and Sarah. They deserved privacy, that's what I want with Blaine.

"Finn, what are you-" I started but was cut off.

"Shut up," whispered Finn, "If you talk, they'll know we're here and will stop."

"You really shouldn't be doing this," I whispered back, "Have they even done anything that is questionable to our sister's innocence?"

"No, they've just practiced the song a few times, but they have laughed a lot," Finn's jaw set when he mentioned the laughter.

"Sarah likes to laugh and they probably have a lot of inside jokes, which you probably know," I was trying to reason with my brother, but knew it was a losing battle.

"No, well yeah there's inside jokes, but he's flirting and she's doing it back. I've heard the laugh girls give Puck when he flirts with them and she's giving it," Finn seemed really upset about this whole thing.

"Finn, is there something your not telling me?" I wanted to find out why he was acting this way.

"I trust Puck and my sister, but I've seen how guys look at her and how Puck looked at her in glee and at Santana's. I just don't want her to get pregnant," Finn swallowed and blushed a little at the thought of his little sister and his best friend together, "She can get married to Puck eventually, but not until they've both graduated."

"I guess I can't argue with that," I muttered.

"So now I'm just listening to make sure nothing big happens."

"I"ll join you, then," I agreed.

I couldn't believe I was doing this, staking out on the stairs to my sister's bedroom. But if I thought about it, it was my bedroom so I really wasn't staking out, just pausing before going in. Yeah, that's what I was doing. And I kinda enjoyed this, it was like a radio show was being held in my basement.

We just sat there on the stairs, never hearing much accept a few whispers or a practice run through of Puck and Sarah's duet. After about 10 minutes, we heard something interesting.

"Come here, Sars. Sit on my lap if you're getting cold," Puck's strong voice echoed through the stairwell. This was happening, if Sarah obeyed, I don't think I'd be able to hold Finn off of Puck.

"Okay," Sarah whispered. Her voice sounded out of breath

"No," Finn gasped.

"You're so cold, maybe I should warm you up a little," from the sound of Puck's voice, you could tell he wanted to sleep with her.

"I didn't think it was possible for someone's chest to be this strong and hot," Sarah was doing nothing to stop Puck's advances making Finn hyperventilate a little.

And then the talking stopped.

"What's happening in there?" Finn's voice was high-pitched.

"I don't know," the words barely came out of my dry mouth.

Suddenly, we heard two different moans and the ruffling of sheets on the bed.

At that Finn jumped off the stairs and through the curtained opening, "Aha-what?"

By the time I had gotten through the doorway, Sarah and Puck were laughing so hard, they were in pain with tears coming from their eyes.

Neither one of them was within four feet of the other either. Sarah was sitting cross-legged on her portion of the bed while Puck was in the opposite corner sitting on the desk chair. They clutched their sides as the erupted with laughter again when I walked in.

"So you guys weren't going to do each other?" I asked. I could feel my cheeks start to burn red from embarrassment.

Both nodded through their tears. Finn just continued to stand in place in front of the doorway.

"What is so funny down here?" Carole asked as she made her way down stairs.

His mother's presence seemed to awaken him because Finn turned to his mom and said, "Puck and Sarah pulled a really mean prank on me." The innocence in his voice was definitely there, making him resemble an over-grown seven year old.

Sarah and Puck laughed even harder, now both practically rolling on the ground.

Carole's mouth turned up as she tried to hold back her own laughter, "That's what you get for not listening to them, then."

Sarah contained herself a little to sputter, "Yeah, but last time he did listen to us and he ended up sick with a sprained ankle!"

The two teenagers doubled over again, cackling so loud I could barely hear myself think.

"What do you mean?" I asked and Puck wiped the tears from his face before answering me.

"When Finn and I were 14 and Sarah was 11, we convinced Finn that if he ate three worms, he would be able to fly because that's what birds eat," Puck's face scrunched up in laughter again and even Carole giggled a little.

"You guys are terrible people!" Finn screamed.

I couldn't help but laugh as well, how could Finn have believed them.

"Now, now, Finn, just apologize for listening in on Noah and Sarah and they'll apologize for teasing you," Carole was trying really hard to not burst out laughing at what her daughter and her pretend son had done now and four years ago.

"I'm sorry, but that was really-" Finn was cut off from the glare his mom gave him.

"We're sorry too man," Puck hiccuped.

"Yeah, and to you Kurt, but we didn't think you would be listening to," Sarah wiped her face and sat up.

"It's fine, I knew it was wrong, but I followed Finn anyways," I said. In a way, I knew Finn and I deserved the joke that was pulled on us. I made a note to never follow Finn's steps when it comes to spying on his sister.

"Good, now everyone's happy," Carole smiled and walked back up the stairs.

"You really ate three worms, Finn?" I asked, laughing.

"Ugh, yes, ok yes! I ate three worms then tried to jump from one of our trees," he muttered, "This never leaves the room, either."

I nodded, but continued laughing along with Puck and Sarah. Maybe with Sarah here, and even Puck, I could find some interesting stuff out about my step-family.

~~~~~GLEE~~~~~

A/N: This was actually one of the first ideas I had for the story, worms and all. Next chapter will be glee practice where they all perform duets, but I'll probably just show Puck and Sarah's song. I hope you're enjoying this as much as I am. Any ideas for future chapters are welcome. As well as questions, comments, concerns. Go ahead an REVIEW! I would really appreciate it.

~~~~~GLEE~~~~~

Sneak Peak: My heart stopped beating in my chest and my breath stopped. Did that just happen or was I dreaming?

This sneak peak is shorter than the rest, but I figured since this chapter's could have been easy to figure out, you guys needed a harder one. Their point of view next chapter.