Never Forgotten Past
Summary: Finn's sister comes back to town and brings some old memories with her. Takes place beginning of Season 3. The story will be in a lot of different people's point of views.
Disclaimer: I don't own Glee or any songs that I may put in here.
New Decisions
Sarah's Point of View
Monday couldn't come fast enough. After Puck left, the day just dragged by. Everything turned boring, probably cause Finn was mad that his secret about eating worms was out, but whatever.
Anyways, when glee club finally came, it was time to perform our duet numbers.
"Alright, does anyone want to go first?" Mr. Schuester announced as he came in the room.
I glanced at Puck, but he just shook his head, "Not yet," he whispered in my ear.
I couldn't help the chills that came from the feeling of his breath on my ear. Secretly, I wished the prank we had pulled on Finn, and coincidently Kurt, had actually happened. That I really had been snuggled up to his hard chest as he tried to keep me warm.
I looked up from my day dream to see that Santana and Rachel had taken the floor and were about to start their own rendition of Carrie Underwood's Cowboy Casanova.
By the last note, I was speechless, it was amazing. Puck could sense my nervousness because he whispered in my ear again, "Don't worry, we'll be awesome."
He put his fist out and I bumped it lightly, "That's my girl," he chuckled and I giggled back.
Blaine and Brittany were up next followed by Kurt and Tina. I was becoming more and more nervous, but after each duet, Puck would rub my back or squeeze my knee and promise we would be great.
"Ok, who else is up?" Mr. Schue asked.
Puck raised his hand and I couldn't contain my blush, "Puck," I whispered.
"Sarah and I would like to show everyone how it's done," he stated with confidence.
"Alright, then, let's see what you got," Mr. Schue gestured towards the open floor.
Puck grabbed my hand as we walked up front, "Just keep your eyes on me."
He placed his guitar around his neck and nodded at the band.
I tried to get my breathing down but as Puck started singing, I forgot everything that was going on and that there was actually people watching us this time.
(Puck, Sarah, Both)
Girl you're beautiful
You're bout near perfect
But I bet somebody's already told you that
Name your poison
Name your passion
Cause a boy like me just couldn't help but ask
Keep on talking to me baby
I'm hanging on your every word
Keep those drinks a coming maybe
We'll both get what we deserve
How bout baby
We make a promise
To not promise anything more than one night
Complicated situations
Only get worse in the morning light
Hey I'm just lookin' for a good time
Put in a long hard week doing this 9 to 5
And you're just the girl to get that off my mind
You shouldn't 've worn that dress
You shouldn't dance like that
You got this little heart of mine in overdrive
I sure love this conversation
The band is good, the music's loud
But would you get the wrong impression
If I called us a cab right now
How bout baby
We make a promise
To not promise anything more than one night
Complicated situations
Only get worse in the morning light
Hey I'm just lookin' for a good time
Go ahead and lie to me and pull me close
Tell me that you love me even if you don't
The rule is don't you ever even talk about forever
But you never say never in life
How bout baby
We make a promise
To not promise anything more than one night
Complicated situations
Only get worse in the morning light
Hey I'm just lookin' for a good time
Hey I'm just lookin' for a good time
The music ended as Puck and I looked at each other, each trying to get control of our breathing.
Everyone clapped, some cheered. By some, I mean everyone except Finn and Santana. I would have to ask Puck about Santana sometime.
"That was amazing you two!" Mr. Schue said as he walked towards us, clapping us each on the back.
"I'm really impressed with your voice Sarah," Rachel smiled.
"Thank you, Rachel," I replied. Puck slipped his arm around my shoulders and squeezed them lightly.
"I think your's and Noah's voices are perfect together," she continued, "Maybe you guys could do a duet sometime at a competition."
The room stopped, we all stared at the petite brunette with wide eyes.
"Rachel, are you feeling ok?" Tina asked.
Finn put his hand on her forehead, which she swatted away, "I'm fine everyone, I am just saying that Noah and Sarah sound very good together and they deserve to showcase it."
"The world really is ending next year," Puck muttered next to me.
"Ok, everyone, settle down, if Rachel and Finn are willing to give a duet to Puck and Sarah, then we'll put them in the set-list, but let's wait for that to come," Mr. Schue said.
I started to walk towards mine and Puck's seats but he wasn't moving, "Come on, it's someone else's turn to sing," I teased.
"I.." he looked like he wanted to say something, but decided against it and just shook his head, following me to our seats.
~~~~~GLEE~~~~~
"Great duets everyone, I'll see you all tomorrow," Mr. Schue said before turning and following Ms. Pillsbury who had just walked past the choir door.
Everyone started filing out of the room and towards the parking lot. I was about to leave right after Finn, when Puck grabbed my hand and turned me around.
"Can I talk to you for a second?" he asked.
"Sure, of course. Are you ok?" After our duet, he had acted a little weird. Looking at me like he would want to say something with his mouth open, then turn away last minute.
"I'm fine, actually you could make me feel great," Puck smiled at me.
"Um, I'll try, but tell me what it is first then I'll see what I can do," I was really confused. I hoped he wasn't going to ask me to steal his baby back or something. (Ms. Corcoran had returned to school for a teaching job and had brought Beth with her. Puck explained how he wanted her back more than anything at lunch today.)
"I was wondering if maybe you would want to go out with me sometime? Like on a date?" he almost looked nervous and shy, nothing like the strong, confident Puck I had grown up with.
My heart stopped beating in my chest and my breath stopped. Did that just happen or was I dreaming?
Slowly I reached my small hand out and grabbed his larger one, "I would love to, Puck."
His nervousness went away and was replaced by a huge smile, "This Friday night?"
I nodded my head, "Sounds great," I smiled back.
He gave me a small hug, "I'll see you tomorrow."
Puck started to walk away, but I wanted something else.
"Puck! Wait," he stopped walking and I caught up to him, "Maybe you could call me tonight?"
I paused waiting for his answer, hoping he would say yes.
Puck smiled, "I was already planning on doing so. Thanks for ruining the surprise though," he chuckled lightly.
"Well I'm sorry," I giggled.
~~~~~GLEE~~~~~
"So who had the best duet?" Mom asked that night over dinner.
We were having spaghetti and meatballs which made Finn and Burt happy. I just got frustrated because I couldn't curl the spaghetti so I was eating like a pig. I would have to remember to ask Puck not to make our date at an Italian restaurant.
"I would have to say Rachel and Santana," Finn said once he had a drink of his milk.
"Blaine and Brittany's was really good," Kurt announced.
"What about you, Sarah?" Burt asked, "You gonna vote for yourself, or team up with your brothers?"
I laughed, "I think mine and Puck's was pretty good. Don't get me wrong, the one's you guys mentioned were great, but they were just singing not actually performing the song."
"I don't get it," Finn said, "Rach was totally performing. Did you see her dance?"
"That is not what Sarah means," Kurt said, "I think she means there was no chemistry between the partners. Now her and Puck on the other hand, chemistry," he declared with a flare of his hand.
I blushed and could tell all eyes were on me.
"Is there something between you and Puck, Sarah?" my mom's eyes were caring as she stared at me across the round table.
"I don't know, maybe, I think so. I mean he asked me out and we're gonna do something Friday," I whispered. I sort of felt embarrassed to be talking about this at the dinner table.
"He what?" Finn yelled.
"Inside voice, Finn," Mom warned.
"That's why Puck held her back after glee," Kurt said in a 'Duh/Why-Are-You-So-Stupid?' voice.
"I just want to say something here," Burt spoke up and everyone calmed down, "I'm not good with this whole family thing, I think you all know that, but who Sarah goes out with is her business. I also think that Sarah deserves someone to make her happy and Puckerman seems to do that for her."
Burt looked around the table, staring into each of our eyes before turning to Mom, "What do you say, Carole? We let her go out with the boy for as long as she wants?"
"I couldn't agree more," Mom smiled at Burt before doing the same to me, "I think you and Noah would be very cute together, Sarah."
I blushed again, "Thanks," I muttered.
Suddenly my phone rang, the music for Who Says You Can't Come Home ringing throughout the kitchen.
"Go ahead, I'll get your plate," Kurt smiled.
I excused myself before walking down stairs to our room. I settled on my bed and answered the phone, "Hey."
"Hey, did I interrupt dinner or something? Why'd it take you so long to answer?" Puck sounded a little worried and I let out a small giggle.
"I'm fine, don't worry. My family was just debating whether or not I should actually date you," I explained.
"Oh really?" I could practically hear him smirking, "And what did they decide?"
"Well, after Burt's speech, it seemed like Kurt was more on board. I think it will take Finn a little while to understand," I thought back to how hurt he's looked whenever Puck and I do something together.
"He'll come around," Puck assured me.
"I hope so," I muttered.
"Alright, enough of this depressing stuff, what are you doing right this second?"
I laughed, "Sitting on my bed, talking to you. What are you doing?"
"Sitting on my bed, talking to the hottest girl I know, and staring at the homework I brought home but don't plan on doing."
"Hottest girl you know? Is Santana there or something?" I teased.
"You are so funny, you know that? You should be a comedian."
"What's up with Santana though? She was the only one not cheering after our duet, besides Finn of course."
"Don't worry about her. We've had some flings, or whatever you want to call them, in the past, but that's all over. You're all I need now."
"We haven't even been on a date yet, Puck."
"So what? I grew up with you and until Finn kills me or something, you're all I want."
It was probably the nicest thing anyone has ever said to me. I even teared up a little bit.
"Puck," Great, my voice was thick with tears.
"Oh, come on Sarah, I didn't mean to make you cry! I just wanted to-"
"It's just the nicest thing someone has ever said to me, Puck. That's why I'm crying, they're happy tears."
"Still, I hate that I made you cry."
"Don't worry, I'm fine," I wiped my tears away and took a deep breath, "So what do you think of the new Irish guy Finn brought to glee?"
~~~~~GLEE~~~~~
A/N: Ok, first I want to say thank you to everyone who has reviewed, alerted, and favorited this story or even me. Second, I hope you guys don't mind, but I don't think I'm going to have a whole scene where all the girls join the Trouble Tones. I just didn't really like that part of the season, even if the music was good. There will still be a Trouble Tones, that won't really be a topic of discussion that much though. Next, Quinn has joined New Directions and so has Rory as you can see above. They might be talked about next chapter, but they might not actually have a scene till Chapter 7. And regarding the summary at the top, should I keep it there, take it off, or change it to something else (i.e. put shout-outs up there, a 'What Happened Last Time,' things of that nature). Thanks again and PLEASE REVIEW with any questions, comments, or concerns!
By the way, Lady Antebellum owns the song Puck and Sarah sing called Lookin' for a Good Time. It's a really good, fun song, just like Rachel and Santana's Carrie Underwood song, Cowboy Casanova. You should check them out.
~~~~~GLEE~~~~~
Shout-Outs: REDROBINS007 - I think that I'm going to have Sarah and Rory become friends and then Puck be jealous, but Finn be supportive. I actually completely forgot about Rory until you said so, so thanks!
stephpb1298 and LizzyAwkwardTurtle - Thanks for the reviews! I'm glad you like it!
~~~~~GLEE~~~~~
Sneak Peak: We pulled apart and all that went through my head was, 'Wow' and 'Holy Crap!' It was probably one of the best kisses I had ever received, not to mention, definitely one of the best kisses I had ever given.
Date night next!
