Never Forgotten Past

Summary: Finn's sister comes back to town and brings some old memories with her. Takes place beginning of Season 3. The story will be in a lot of different people's point of views.

Disclaimer: I don't own Glee or any songs that I may put in here.

The Best Night Ever

Puck's Point of View

I slowed my truck as I pulled up to the Hudson-Hummel household. As I turned off the engine, I took a deep breath and looked in the rear-view mirror. I could do this, it was just Sarah. She shouldn't be able to blow my mind too much since I told her to just wear casual clothes. Yeah, it was going to be great.

I knocked on the front door, taking another deep breath as I did so. I could hear talking, or more like screaming and yelling, on the other side. Finally, Burt opened the door.

"Hey, Puck," he smiled at me, "Come on in."

"Thanks," I smiled back.

"Um, I'm just gonna say this real quick, the ground rules. Don't fool around too much and have her back by 11 in one piece."

I laughed, "Sounds easy."

"I hate you Finn! You're a stupid moron!" my date's voice rang out from the living room.

"Is he still against this?" I asked.

"They're not fighting about what you may think," Burt gestured for me to walk into the living room.

I laughed at the sight. Finn and Sarah were standing on the couch jumping up and down with Wii remotes in their hand. Blaine was standing on the ground next to Sarah, yelling and jumping just as much. Kurt was the only one who looked sane, sitting on the chair, steering his own remote like it was nothing. And on the screen? Mario Kart.

"Blaine Anderson, you are going down!" Finn yelled.

"Hey! Lay off my partner, giant!" Sarah screamed.

"See. They've been like this for the past 30 minutes," Burt explained.

The screen chimed, signaling the end of the game. It went black before showing the winning team.

Blaine and Sarah screamed in victory, jumping up and down and hugging. As the points came up, Finn and Kurt yelled in protest, they had only lost by two points.

"Rigged!" Finn yelled at the tv.

"Alright, I think it's time for Sarah to go now," Burt announced.

Sarah turned and despite what I said in the car, I still couldn't believe my eyes. Her chocolate curls were pinned half way back, similar to when I had come over last time. She had on white capris and a flowy, yellow tank-top covered by a white sweater. She was so beautiful.

"I see you like my work, Puck," Kurt spoke up.

"You look so..." I couldn't think of the words, "You...I...Wow."

How stupid was that? I'm an idiot.

Sarah giggled, "You look very handsome, Puck."

I glanced down at my own outfit: a light blue button down not even tucked in and a pair of dark jeans. Nothing special.

"Are you ready?" I asked.

She nodded, "Where are we going?"

"Surprise," I teased.

"Hmph, you're mean," Sarah pouted.

"Oh no, I almost missed it," Ms. Carole ran into the room, "I wanted to see you guys off."

"This isn't prom or homecoming, Mom, it's just a date," Sarah blushed slightly.

"It's your first date! I need a picture!" Ms. Carole fumbled around in a nearby closet.

Finn, Blaine, and Kurt laughed at Sarah and me. Probably because we were both blushing.

Ms. Carole emerged from the closet with a camera, "Ok, Noah, Sarah, get together!"

I thought of how I could bug Finn the most and decided I would put my arm around Sarah's waist but have my hand drift a little.

"Smile!" Ms. Carole said.

Finn glared at me and I smirked, it worked.

"Alright, can we go now?" Sarah pleaded.

"Yes, yes. Be back by 11," Ms. Carole hugged Sarah then me.

"Have fun," Burt said.

We walked out of the house, but I stopped Sarah before she could get in the truck.

"Wait, let me blind fold you," I laughed at her panicked face.

"What?"

"Come on, just trust me," I pulled an old tie from my pocket and turned her around. I was careful to not pull her hair as I tied a small knot.

I helped her in the car then climbed in myself.

"Why am I blind folded?" Sarah turned towards my direction as I backed out of the drive way.

"Because I don't want you to know where we're going," this was probably the most romantic thing I had ever done and I hoped she liked it.

She sat back in the passenger seat, realizing I wasn't giving the location of our first date away.

~~~~~GLEE~~~~~

"Are we there yet? I feel like we've been driving forever!"

We had only been driving for 15 minutes, but the spot where we were going was getting closer. Throughout the ride, we had sung along to the radio and laughed at old memories that went along with the music.

"We're here," I announced, pulling up to a clear area.

I slowly reached over and untied her make-shift blind fold.

"Take a look."

Sarah looked around and I could tell she was surprised. I had brought her to the river bank where we had hung out during endless summer days - swimming, joking around, playing games.

"I can't believe you brought me here!" she yelled, wrapping her arms around my neck.

"You're welcome," I laughed.

I ran out the truck and over to her side, helping Sarah down. I reached behind her seat and grabbed a picnic basket my sister had helped me prepare. Looking up, I saw Sarah making her way to the large rock where the two of us, along with Finn, had sat and ate lunch almost every summer day three years ago.

"Hey, look!" Sarah was bent down, looking at the boulder, "Our names are still here!"

I looked down at where she was pointing and sure enough, there in three different colors and three different handwritings were our names: Finn Hudson, 15 in blue; Sarah Hudson, 12 in purple; Puck Puckerman, 15 in green. At the bottom was a date, September 4th, 2008, painted in black.

"Wow, when I came to check this place out for our date, I forgot about this," I watched Sarah trace our names with her pointer finger.

"Puck Puckerman, you are so weird," she laughed.

"Hey, what was I supposed to put? Noah? Don't think so." I pulled a blanket out from the basket and laid it on the ground, sitting on it and pulling the basket of food closer.

Sarah followed suit and sat closer to me than I could remember her ever doing, "So, what'd you make?"

"Well, they're just little stuff that Gracie insisted on packing," I showed her the packages of fruit, popcorn and M&Ms.

Sarah laughed, "Isn't that all of her favorite food?"

"How'd you know?" I laughed back, "But I did buy a little something extra on the way to your house."

"And what is that?"

I pulled out a small container of chocolate covered strawberries, "They're for dessert though, so not now."

She pouted and even though she was trying to look mad, I still thought she was cute.

We ate the food in a comfortable silence. The sun was starting to set making the sky a light purple and orange.

"It's beautiful," Sarah spoke up.

"Yeah," I whispered. I didn't realize I was staring at her till she laughed.

"You are so corny."

"What are you talking about?" I teased.

She rolled her eyes, "What's beautiful?"

"The sky. You. Right now."

Sarah leaned in towards me and I put my arm around her.

"You're freezing! Why didn't you say anything?" I looked at the small brunette under my arm.

She shrugged, "I didn't think it was a big deal."

I stood up from my spot on the ground, making Sarah open her mouth in protest, "Nope," I said, "Wait here."

I ran to my truck, grabbing my varsity jacket from the back seat before going back to the boulder where Sarah was waiting.

I helped Sarah get her arms through the large holes, "There, now you can be warm."

She smiled up at me, "Thank you."

"No problem," I smiled back, "Now how about those strawberries?"

Sarah giggled and nodded, "I thought you would never ask."

I lifted up the biggest one, "Open wide."

She laughed and in the middle of it, I shoved the strawberry in her mouth. Her eyes widened as she tried to chew through the strawberry the size of a tennis ball.

I laughed at the juice coming from her mouth. I quickly grabbed a napkin and wiped the sticky red before it could stain her clothes. Sarah continued to try and eat the strawberry.

After a minute, I grabbed it from her mouth and she quickly grabbed another napkin, wiping her mouth then taking a drink from her water bottle.

"I hate you," Sarah said, but her eyes gleamed with laughter.

"Yeah, I don't-" my mouth was cut off from the placement of a strawberry in it.

I chomped down, enjoying the chocolate and letting the juice drip from my own mouth.

"You are disgusting," Sarah laughed and she wiped my chin just as I had done to hers.

I swallowed, grabbing the leaves before they could be chewed in my mouth, "Yeah, but you love me," I smiled, showing my red teeth before drinking from my own water.

"Yeah, I do," she laughed.

Sarah looked up at the sky and sighed, "The stars make me feel so small," she whispered.

"I don't know, I think they're kinda cool. All bright and making different pictures."

She looked at me and smiled, "This is one of the best nights I've ever had, Puck."

"Me too," I whispered back.

Slowly, we leaned in towards each other. Our lips met and I put my hand in her hair at the same time Sarah put hers at the base of my mohawk. It was quiet, the only noise being the nearby river. We went on for about a minute before we ran out of breath.

We pulled apart and all that went through my head was, 'Wow' and 'Holy Crap!' It was probably one of the best kisses I had ever received, not to mention, definitely one of the best kisses I had ever given.

The look on her face was priceless. I've never seen her so beautiful, all out of breath, bright eyes, lips a bright pink, hair slightly ruffled from my hands.

"Wow," Sarah whispered.

I just nodded in agreement. Nothing could come through my mind to say to her.

Her hand went up to her lips, lightly tracing them. "That was my first kiss," if I wasn't paying so much attention to her, I would have missed it.

"What?" I didn't believe her. How could she have never kissed anyone at all?

"I've had one boyfriend before you. He tried to kiss me on the second date, but I didn't feel anything towards him so I stopped him. He probably still has my hand print on his face," Sarah smirked when my eyebrows shot up, "He kept trying so I just slapped him and that was it, no more boyfriends for Sarah Hudson."

"And here I am, kissing you on the first date yet I have no hand prints on my face. Why?"

She laughed a little, "Because you actually mean something to me."

I paused before looking into her eyes and saying the thing that's been on my mind since I saw her walk through the choir door, "I love you."

Sarah smiled, "I love you too."

I leaned closer to her, pulling her as close to me as possible. Trying to get every part of her body to touch mine.

She climbed on my lap, never breaking the kiss. She certainly didn't kiss like a newbie.

I fell backwards as she put all her weight on my shoulders. We laid on the ground, kissing each other for an hour, easily. Never saying much except the occasional 'I love you.'

~~~~~GLEE~~~~~

A/N: Alright, I'll admit, this was pretty fluffy, but I thought it was cute. I hope you liked it. Next chapter isn't going to involve Quinn or Rory or anyone else from school, sorry. Last night an idea popped in my head and it seems like it fits best as the next chapter that way it can be a little more interesting than if it was somewhere else in the story. Questions, comments, and concerns are welcome so PLEASE REVIEW!

Who watched Yes/No? It was one of my favorites even though there wasn't any of my favorite person. I think I'll put everything that happened last night in a chapter later on when the story gets to that point.

Regarding the summary at the top, should I keep it there, take it off, or change it to something else (i.e. put shout-outs up there, a 'What Happened Last Time,' things of that nature)?

~~~~~GLEE~~~~~

Shout-Outs: belleblu13 - Thank you! I really wish they would have him have more scenes where he is sweet and different from the original bad boy. Though they are doing that with him and Beth now, which makes me really happy.

~~~~~GLEE~~~~~

Sneak Peak: I walked slowly into the kitchen, excited about the sweet smells that came from it. We hadn't had any baked goods in a while making my mouth water.

This next chapter is going to deal with some bonding between the characters who are involved.