Never Forgotten Past
Last Time...Finn's sister Sarah came back to town after leaving for three years because of their dad's death. When she showed up to try out for glee, Puck realized he had feelings for her despite always thinking of her as a sister. Santana threw a party where Puck almost kissed Sarah in front of everyone. The two worked on a duet together and Puck asked Sarah out after the performance. Finn doesn't approve of his sister dating the one guy that actually has a kid in glee club. Sarah and Puck went on a date to one of their old hangouts and admitted their love to each other before a kiss. And that's what you missed on Never Forgotten Past.
Disclaimer: I don't own Glee or any songs that I may put in here.
It's Different Now
Finn's Point of View
I rolled over in my bed when I heard a loud noise. It sounded kind of clangy, like pots and pans being hit together or something. It wasn't New Years Eve...someone one was breaking in.
I grabbed my bed side lamp and headed up the stairs. It smelled good, not at all like a robbery.
I walked slowly into the kitchen, excited about the sweet smells that came from it. We hadn't had any baked goods in a while making my mouth water. I sighed in relief and let down my lamp.
Sarah was standing in front of the counter looking at a recipe book.
"What are you doing?" I asked.
"Baking," Sarah said without even looking up at me.
"What time is it?" I was still kinda groggy from my sleep.
"Like noon," my sister laughed.
I walked over to where she was mixing something. In the bowl, I recognized her special, home-made cookies that were always different.
"What are these for?"
"Just because," Sarah smiled, "Why all the questions, question boy?"
I laughed, "Just because."
Sarah laughed and began to measure out some flour.
"Did you have fun last night?"
She looked up from the flour, surprised but continued as if it was nothing, "Yeah, I really did. Guess where we went?"
I thought before saying the obvious, "Breadsticks."
She shook her head and smiled, "The river bank."
A thousand memories flew through my head all at once: Puck and I teaching Sarah how to swim, the three of us eating ice-cream sandwiches, watching the sun set, Dad teaching us the different constellations, Sarah and I comforting Puck on Father's Day, Puck comforting Sarah and I the day we found out our dad died, the day Sarah told us she was leaving and we painted our names on the boulder.
"Did it look the same?"
"Yeah, brought back a lot of memories."
"I bet," I sat down at the table and watched as Sarah started forming balls of dough.
The kitchen timer went off and she glanced over her shoulder, groaning.
"I'll get it," I said and walked over to the oven, pulling out the trays and setting them on the stove top.
"Do you hate me?"
Sarah's words stopped me from grabbing one of the fresh cookies. I turned around, I wasn't expecting my sister to ever ask me that.
"Why would I hate you?" I kind of choked out the words.
"I'm dating Puck. You're best friend. The guy that has a child. The one that has slept with almost every girl in McKinley. The boy that has even slept with older women."
Neither of us turned around, just staring at the ground and counters.
"I could never, ever hate you. So what I'm not crazy on you dating him? It's your choice, not mine," I turned around and hugged Sarah, "Burt was right, Puck makes you happy and that's all I want."
"Really?" Sarah muttered against my chest.
"Really. But I do want you to be careful and stuff," I could feel her body shake a little with silent tears, "Is this why you're baking?"
Sarah pulled away with a shy smile, "Yes, I figured it would get me on your good side."
We both laughed.
"I'm gonna go get dressed," I said as Sarah wiped her tears, "And after that, we're going to rematch on Mario Kart because I deserved to win last night."
"Whatever," Sarah laughed before turning back to her cookies.
~~~~~GLEE~~~~~
"Alright, I think we figured out that we're both equally good at Mario Kart. What do you want to do?" Sarah asked after our sixth round of the Wii game, each of us having won three games.
"I have no idea," I said as I turned off the game counsel, "Want to call Puck? It's nice out so we can go to the river bank and hang out or play basketball or something like before."
My sister smiled, I knew she would appreciate me offering to bring Puck with us, "Sounds good. I'll call him."
Sarah pulled out her phone and dialed the phone number I knew by heart. Sure Puck and I had drifted apart over the years, but we eventually came back.
"Alright, see you in a few," Sarah ended the call and looked at me, "He's coming over."
"Ok," I smiled at her, "Are you going to change into clothes to impress your boyfriend with?"
Sarah glanced at down at her outfit, an old pair of jeans and one of my old sweatshirts, "Nah, this is fine. He doesn't care what I wear and besides, Kurt isn't here to make me change anyways."
I laughed, "That is true."
There was a knock on the door before it opened.
"Hey," Puck said as he walked into the living room, "I hope you don't mind that I brought the monster."
"I'm not a monster, Noah," Grace Puckerman looked out from behind her older brother. The ten year old looked exactly like her sibling, but in a younger girl form.
"How did you guys get here so fast?" Sarah asked.
"We were coming home from the store," Puck answered.
"I had birthday money to spend," Grace stated proudly.
All of us laughed. Grace reminded me of the young Sarah, the way she acted day to day as if nothing was wrong. They even sort of looked alike with their brown hair, bright eyes, and ability to always laugh it off. Except when Dad died, she couldn't laugh that off, but that's kind of obvious I guess.
"So what are we going to do?" I asked the group.
"I want ice-cream," Grace said, making us all laugh again.
"That sounds like a great idea," Sarah said.
"Well then, let's get in the car," Puck announced.
~~~~~GLEE~~~~~
The four of us were sitting inside the local Dairy Queen enjoying our different ice-creams, laughing and telling stories.
None of us were paying attention to the time and before we knew it, Mom was calling on my cell-phone at the same time Ruth Puckerman was calling her own kids home.
"I can't believe we've been gone for an hour and a half," I said.
"We've been gone for two hours, what with the store and all," Puck added.
"I don't want to go home," Grace told us on the way to the car, "I haven't seen Sarah in a really long time and you go to Finn's house, not the other way around."
Sarah, Puck, and I all exchanged a look. It was sort of true, Puck and I had grown apart and when we went back to normal, Puck would come to my house to hangout and play video games. The Sarah thing, though, was because of her leaving, not really something neither Puck nor I could control.
"Well, we'll have to do this again sometime. Right Gracie?" Sarah said.
When we got to our house, Grace said good-bye before climbing into Puck's truck. I noticed Puck and Sarah stalling and knew they probably wanted some privacy.
"I think I'll go inside and tell Mom we're all good," I walked inside the house and noticed an open window in the living room. I sort of felt guilty sitting beside it, listening to their conversation, but they would understand someday.
"I had a lot of fun today," Sarah said.
"Yeah, me too and I'm pretty sure Gracie did as well," came Puck's voice.
The two laughed lightly and let it fade.
"I'll call you tonight."
"Ok."
The talking stopped, but I didn't hear Puck's door close. I slowly turned my head, but turned back as soon as I saw what was going on.
Puck and Sarah were in a full-blown make-out session in the driveway. Sarah's hands were around Puck's waist while his were in her hair. As much as I hated seeing the two actually proving that they were in love, I was happy that my sister really did finally found someone that made her happy.
~~~~~GLEE~~~~~
A/N: This chapter seemed kinda like a filler and for anyone who wanted some Rory, this could have seemed like a waste. I just wanted to show that while Finn doesn't really approve of the whole thing, he will accept it. This was pretty short compared to the last two as well, which I hope you don't mind. Next chapter, I promise, will have everyone in it. It'll take place during school and glee club. Alright, so that's my little rant for this chapter. I'm welcome to any comments, questions, or concerns especially if you REVIEW!
~~~~~GLEE~~~~~
Shout-Outs: belleblu13 - Thank you so much! And lol, I was baking cookies when I came up with the story as well. :)
~~~~~GLEE~~~~~
Sneak Peak: I didn't understand what Finn thought was so wrong. They were two people in love, like us. It was cute to watch them, so young and perfect and new.
I sucked it up and walked over to where she was standing at her locker. The worst she could do was say no, right? Which I doubt would happen, I mean look at me, I'm hot.
I watched the two lovebirds and had to try and avoid gagging. It was disgusting, how Puck was all over her and Sarah thinking he was the sun. Suddenly, Puck said something that caught my ear.
Ok, so next chapter is going to be in three different people's point of views to add
a little something new. (Hint, you've only heard from one of these people before.)
