Never Forgotten Past
Last Time...Finn and Sarah spent the morning hanging out together. Sarah asked Finn if he hated her and he said no, he can't hate his sister. The two called Puck who brought his sister and the four went out for ice-cream. Once home, Finn saw Sarah and Puck kiss and even though it made him uncomfortable, he was happy for his sister. And that's what you missed on Never Forgotten Past.
Disclaimer: I don't own Glee or any songs that I may put in here.
Controversy
Rachel's Point of View
I was standing at my locker before glee rehearsal when I saw Noah pass behind me through my mirror.
I didn't want to be nosy. Oh, who was I kidding? I definitely wanted to know how the newest New Directions couple was doing. So I turned around slightly, just enough so I could see what Noah and Sarah were doing but not enough so they could tell I was watching.
Noah had snuck up behind Sarah and hugged her. She returned the hug and laughed at something he said. Sarah went back to packing her backpack. Noah even held it for her as she stuffed the light purple bag with her homework.
I didn't understand what Finn thought was so wrong. They were two people in love, like us. It was cute to watch them, so young and perfect and new.
"Hey," I turned around and smiled. Finn was standing behind me with a soft smile on his perfect face.
"Hello," I returned before kissing him lightly.
Finn looked behind me and I knew that he was watching Sarah and Noah.
"How long have they been together?"
"Just about a minute. I don't understand, what is wrong with them?"
He shook his head, "Nothing, just wondering. We all hung-out Saturday, so it's all good."
I nodded, thankful that Finn had finally gotten over this whole thing. I turned and watched along with Finn.
Noah was talking to Sarah softly and she was listening intently. Slowly, a smile began to form on her mouth and suddenly, she threw her arms around the stronger teen. Noah lifted Sarah up and kissed her fully on the mouth.
Finn turned around and glanced at his watch, "It's, um, time to go to glee."
"Ok," I tried to keep the mood light so it wouldn't be too uncomfortable.
"It's not like it's the first time I saw them kiss, just the way they did it," Finn said quietly as we made our way to the choir room.
"Let's go out tonight. To your mind off of everything," I hadn't really realized what I said until it was out of my mouth.
"Yeah," Finn smiled down at me, "I have to ask you something anyways."
~~~~~GLEE~~~~~
Puck's Point of View
I glanced at my watch: ten minutes until glee. Just enough time to ask Sarah to homecoming. I felt kinda nervous, sort of like when I first asked her out.
I've been fighting with myself since the bell rang five minutes ago. It's like subconsciously my brain is saying she'll say no. Sarah likes me too much, or more like, she loves me too much to say no. What if she doesn't like dances? What if she thinks they're stupid? What if she hates dressing up?
After another minute, I decided what to do. I sucked it up and walked over to where she was standing at her locker. The worst she could do was say no, right? Which I doubt would happen, I mean look at me, I'm hot.
Sarah was trying to get her homework together before glee at her locker.
I went up to her and slowly snaked my arms around her waist, "Guess who?" I teased as I squeezed her lightly.
Sarah laughed and turned so we could hug properly, "I missed you after lunch."
"Of course you did," I took her backpack so it would be easier for her to place he books in.
Sarah laughed again, I was on a roll.
"How long till glee?" Sarah asked.
"About eight minutes. Why?"
"Well, I was hoping we could make out or something."
Holy Jesus, my girlfriend was hot.
"You have no idea how awesome that sounds, but actually I have to ask you something."
Sarah turned from her locker before shutting it, "I'm listening."
"I really like you, obviously," Sarah smirked, "I love you actually and I want you to know that."
"Of course I know you love me, Friday night was perfect. If you didn't love me, it wouldn't have happened."
"Anyways, I, um, want you to know that you are the prettiest, most amazing girl I have ever met and I want everyone to know. So, now I'm asking you, will you go to home-"
I was cut off by Sarah's arms wrapping around my neck. I laughed before lifting her up and kissing her.
As I set her down, I asked the question that might have been obvious to anyone else, but I needed to be sure, "Is that a yes?"
"You idiot, of course it's a yes," Sarah laughed and hit my chest lightly.
I chuckled, "Just wanted to make sure."
"Come one," Sarah grabbed my hand, "Let's get to glee before it's too late."
~~~~~GLEE~~~~~
Quinn's Point of View
I sat on the top red chair in the choir room waiting for Mr. Schue to start glee. I looked up and saw Puck and Finn's sister, Sarah, walk in the room. They were holding hands and each had a huge smile on their face.
The two made their way to two chairs in the front and started whispering. Puck would say something then Sarah would laugh, messing up her hair, so Puck would fix it. It went on for a whole five minutes.
I watched the two lovebirds and had to try and avoid gagging. It was disgusting, how Puck was all over her and Sarah thinking he was the sun. Suddenly, Puck said something that caught my ear.
"Hey, so I was wondering if maybe you would want to go see Beth sometime. We could go out to dinner and then head over there, but that might be too late..."
How dare he! That was my daughter too and he was just advertising her as if she was some dog.
I stared forward as Mr. Schue talked about the mash-off we were going to have with the Trouble Tones. We were going to split the parts among us, which was fine, I kinda liked my lyrics.
"Hey, since Rory's gonna have a part in this, I think Sarah should too. Ya know, to show them what they're missing," Puck spoke up.
"Yeah, that is a good idea. Nice one Puck. What do you guys think? Rory? Sarah?" Mr. Schue asked.
"Sounds good to me," Rory said from my left. He was too sweet, it was going to kill him one day. For now, he was good. The whole Irish exchange student thing was kind of neat. It was probably scary to be a whole continent away from your family though.
"Alright!" Why was Sarah so perky? Of course she would agree to something Puck suggested she do.
"Ok, so Sarah, Rory, here's your guys' parts," Mr. Schue handed out the sheet music with lyrics highlighted on them.
Puck was reading the song over Sarah's shoulder and Finn was doing the same to Rory. It was just a song, not like they've never seen one before, this was glee after all.
~~~~~GLEE~~~~~
An hour later, Mr. Schue dismissed us to go home. Everyone started filing out, except for Finn, Puck, and Sarah.
"Puck said he'll drive me home since you have Rachel, Kurt, and Blaine in your car," Sarah told her brother.
"Yeah, sure. Just please don't come home in handcuffs because you guys were steaming up the car," Finn said.
Puck laughed, "Please, like I'm stupid enough to get caught."
"I mean it," and with that, Finn headed out after Rachel.
"Hey, Puck, can I talk to you for a sec?" I walked over to where Puck was about to kiss Sarah and stood a little bit away from them.
Puck pulled away and Sarah bit her lip lightly, "Is something wrong?" Puck asked, slightly annoyed.
"Could we talk in private?" I sort of glanced at Sarah, something Puck caught.
"Um."
"I don't mind, I'll just wait in the hallway. Probably call and Mom tell her you're driving me," Sarah backed out of the room while pulling her phone from her pocket.
"What is it?" Puck turned towards me.
"Why so hostile? I'm helping you get your daughter back."
"Yeah, I guess," Puck looked like he was feeling some sort of guilt over what had happened, "So what's up?"
"Are you sure you really want to take Sarah to go and see Beth? I mean, she might get confused with who her mom is or something," I thought about what I was going to say during glee and was hoping I would get him to change his mind.
Puck just laughed, sending me for a loop, "My God Quinn, are you seriously that worried that Beth is going to hate you when you're older?"
"No. I just don't want my daughter to question who I am. With you, it's pretty obvious. You're the only man she knows and I heard you call yourself 'Daddy' the other day."
"So you heard me call you 'Mommy' the other day too then?"
I nodded, "And for Beth's whole life Shelby's been calling herself 'Mom.' Our daughter's going to be confused by the time she gets to me." I could tell Puck was thinking really hard about what he was going to say next and what I had just said.
"Listen," Puck began, "There is no doubt that you're Beth's mom. Have you seen her? She looks just like you! And I'm pretty sure, since I was there when she was born, that she came out of you;not Shelby, not Sarah, you. And I bet that somewhere in her little heart, Beth knows that."
As Puck spoke, I couldn't help but tear up a little. I sort of agreed with him, but I didn't want to admit it.
I just nodded at him and he squeezed my shoulder, "I'll see you around."
'Darn,' I thought as Puck left the choir room, that was not what I wanted to happen.
~~~~~GLEE~~~~~
Puck's Point of View
I glanced over my shoulder before pulling out of my school parking spot.
"What did Quinn want?" Sarah's voice seemed smaller than usual, "You were in there a while."
"Don't worry," I grabbed her hand, "It was just about Beth."
"Oh, ok."
"Yeah, Quinn's worried Beth won't know who were real mom is with all the women around her."
"Well that's dumb. From that picture you should me of Beth, Quinn is just an older version of her."
"Exactly."
We sat in silence for a minute, listening to the radio play some Journey.
"Does she not want me around Beth?"
I turned and looked at Sarah, not completely sure what to say. Sarah was so vulnerable and one thing like this could destroy her.
"She just doesn't want Beth confused."
"So that's a yes," Sarah barely whispered.
I pulled into a parking lot and stopped the car.
"Look at me," I held her face in between my hands softly, "Quinn thinks and says a lot of things and you just have to ignore them. She's been through a lot, you saw that at the beginning of the year. What Quinn thinks is that Beth doesn't love her and it's a little true because Beth just met her, but do you think Quinn realizes that? No."
I felt proud of my speech, I thought it was deep. Yeah, I've got emotions inside.
"Can I still see her though?" Sarah seemed as if she was coming back to normal.
I smiled, "Yes and you know when?" Sarah shook her head, "Tomorrow."
Sarah smiled, "That sounds great."
I started the car and went back on the road, "You don't think I wouldn't introduce my daughter to the most amazing girl ever do you?"
That made Sarah laugh, making me proud of myself again. I was good.
I pulled up to the two-story home five minutes later.
"Love you," I said as I leaned in to kiss my girlfriend goodbye.
Sarah put her hand over my mouth, stopping me halfway towards her.
"One second," she looked determined.
"Ok," I sat back in the driver's seat, never taking my eyes off of her.
She thought for a second before taking a deep breath and asking, "Purple or blue?"
"What?" My girlfriend stopped me from kissing her to ask me about a color?
"My homecoming dress," Sarah looked a little annoyed, "We have to match, you know."
I chuckled, "I really don't know, ask Kurt."
"But you're my boyfriend!" She hit me lightly on the shoulder.
I stopped, Sarah had never called me her boyfriend to my face and I had never did the same to her's.
"You're what?"
Sarah seemed to catch on, "You're my boyfriend, right?" she said softly.
"As long as you're my girlfriend," I said back.
We stared at each other for a minute before we both leaned in for a kiss. After a heated make-out session, I pulled away.
"Light blue or light purple, so you can be my Cinderella," It was probably the gushiest thing I've ever said and I could feel myself blush because of it.
Sarah laughed and I joined in, "That never leaves this car," I warned her.
"Got it," Sarah giggled.
She kissed my cheek before opening the car door, "Love you."
"Love you too."
I watched Sarah walk to her house, pausing and looking back at me before going through the door.
I started my truck with a small smile on my face. How did I get so lucky?
~~~~~GLEE~~~~~
A/N: Not a lot of Rory, but we're getting there. He'll be at their homecoming group and you'll see some jealous Puck there. This chapter was a little different and I hope you don't mind. It was kinda sad, well at least to me and there were the three POVs. Did you like that? I thought it might be kind of fun to change it around a little. Ok, so thoughts? Comments? Concerns? All are welcome so PLEASE REVIEW!
P.S.: This is being added along with Chapter 7 as a celebration to myself for my good grades this semester.
~~~~~GLEE~~~~~
Sneak Peak: I stared at her. She was perfect. So sweet and innocent. Not knowing anything about this crazy world. I wanted one.
Next chapter is going to be a fun one.
