Never Forgotten Past

Last Time: Sarah and Puck took the next step after homecoming. Sarah told this to Quinn who hoped she wasn't pregnant. Puck told Sarah not to worry about being pregnant, but was actually scared to death. And that's what you missed on Never Forgotten Past.

Disclaimer: I don't own Glee or any songs that I may put in here.

The Scare

Sarah's Point of View

"Rachel and Blaine are here Sarah," Kurt called down the stairs.

"Got it!" I yelled back.

I looked in the mirror and smiled. I had on dark jeans and white tennis shoes, but it was everything above the waist that made me smile. I was wearing a red Under-Armor long-sleeved underneath Puck's extra football jersey. My hair was in a ponytail and just barely grazed the 20 underneath the name Puckerman.

I ran up the stairs and said goodbye to Mom and Burt before going outside and climbing in Blaine's car next to Rachel.

~~~~~GLEE~~~~~

"Sarah!"

I turned around and smiled at Rory as he made his way towards me.

"Hey! I didn't know you liked football," I said when he came closer.

Rory shrugged, "Figured I'd try it out seeing as I'll be in America for a while."

I nodded, "Wanna come sit with Blaine, Kurt, Rachel, and I? I was just going to go get a drink then we can head on up."

Rory smiled, "Sounds good."

We made our way to the concession stands and I bought my drink. Quinn found us and said she'll come to sit with us during the game.

By the time we got to our friends, Tina and Mercedes were already there.

"Are you ready for our McKinley High Titans?" the announcer screamed over the speakers.

The bleachers erupted in screams as we watched the team run out onto the field. I spotted Puck run out near Finn and screamed louder. Rachel joined and it was almost as if she wanted to out-scream me for Finn.

~~~~~GLEE~~~~~

By the end of the first quarter, we were down 14-7. The weather was getting a little cold too. Actually, it was about 20 degrees colder than when I had gotten dressed. I jumped up and down to try and keep warm despite nothing happening on the field.

"Would you like my jacket Sarah?" Rory asked.

I looked at him and considered what he was asking me, then down at the field where I could see Puck's number standing out in the huddle. It was just a jacket, not like I was pledging my love to him or anything.

"Sure," I nodded.

Rory smiled and shrugged off his jacket then helped me put it on. It was warm and comfy, yet felt weird. It wasn't like when I had worn Puck's jacket, this one smelled different and not at all like I wanted it to. I was glad that I wasn't falling for Rory or anything.

"Thanks," I smiled.

"No problem," Rory smiled back. He put his hands in the pockets of his hoodie.

I looked back down at the field and sighed as I watched the opposing team score another touchdown. I sat back in my seat along with all my friends.

"Come on guys," Blaine groaned as the team huddled back up for a second before going into position on the line.

"Go Finny!" Rachel yelled.

Quinn and Mercedes rolled their eyes then went back to their conversation. Tina and Kurt each laughed at Rachel then continued to judge the different outfits the people in the stands were wearing.

"Aren't you going to yell for Puck?" Rory teased.

I laughed, "I think he knows how much I want him to win, he also knows that I don't want another slushy in my face which would happen if I scream during the silence."

Rory laughed and nodded along with me.

There were twenty seconds left until half time and I was getting restless, I wasn't feeling so hot and wanted to go to the bathroom incase my body decided I should taste my drink again. I didn't want to leave though incase Puck or Finn did something. I put my arms around my stomach and groaned softly, unfortunately Quinn heard me.

"Baby drama?" she asked quietly.

"I don't know," I whispered back, "I hope it's just my dinner or something germ related and not another person."

Quinn nodded then passed me some mints from her purse, "Here, these should settle your stomach."

I gratefully took the mints, "Thanks."

"No problem," Quinn smiled at me.

We both looked back up to the field and gasped. There were two McKinley players running towards the end-zone followed closely by about seven of the opposing players. Suddenly, one of the McKinley players was tackled from the other team and all the players jumped on them. Everyone stopped breathing as we waited to see if someone was hurt and if so, who. The referees ran over to start pulling everyone off of the dog pile.

"Who's down there?" Kurt asked.

"Please don't be Mike," Tina muttered under her breath.

"Finn," Rachel whimpered.

"Come on Shane," Mercedes whispered as she looked around the field.

"But look, they're standing outside the huddle," Blaine pointed out.

All of their boyfriends were safe, except mine.

I jumped up from my seat and stared down at the field. I prayed that the guy laying under the pile of football players either wasn't mine or if he was, wasn't seriously hurt.

As the refs pulled the last player away, everyone stepped back to give the guy on the ground more room. Kurt's hand moved up to his mouth and Rory put his arm around me.

Laying on the ground, clear as day for all to see, the number 20 reflected off the lights. Puck stayed for another second before being helped into a sitting position by Finn and Mike. Coach Beiste ran out and kneeled next to the three of them. I watched in silence as Finn and Mike helped Puck stand up. Within seconds Puck was halfway to the ground, unable to stand properly. It looked as if he was fighting with his friends and coach before accepting the help off the field.

"I'm going to go," I whispered as I tried to move off the bleachers.

"Where?" Kurt stopped me by putting his arm out.

"To see Puck," I said as I shrugged away his arm, "He's probably not very happy right now seeing as he can't participate in the game so he needs me."

Kurt didn't argue and moved away so I could run down to the field. I ran up to the gates and looked at the sheriff.

"Please, that's my boyfriend out there," I asked.

"Family only," the man replied.

"They're not here, and even if they were, they probably wouldn't be down here right now, so please," I begged. It was mostly true, Ms. Ruth wasn't here, but I didn't know about the truthfulness of the last part.

The sheriff looked me over then nodded, "Go ahead."

"Thank you," I called over my shoulder as I ran through the gate.

I slowed as I reached the bench where I could see Puck sitting. His head was in his hands and his leg was propped up in front of him.

"Hey," I said as I approached.

"Sarah," Puck breathed when he looked up, then quickly looked away.

I carefully sat on the edge of the bench near his leg. His ankle was wrapped in an icepack brace thing.

"Is it broken?" I asked quietly.

"They don't think so, just sprained," Puck muttered, "My chest hurts pretty bad, so they said my ribs might be bruised."

I watched as his expression changed from annoyed and angry to upset.

"When can you play again?" I said softly.

"Next week maybe, definitely two weeks, but what does that matter? We're not any good so I should just give up now, they don't need me."

"Hey, come on," I whispered as I lifted up his chin to look at me, "You're probably the best football player I've ever seen. And besides, you wouldn't let me not go to Santana's party where I met all my friends so I'm not going to let you get down on yourself for a sprained ankle. So what you have to sit out a game and some practices? You'll live, I promise."

Puck stared at me while I talked, his expression was hard and unmoving. Finally, he nodded, "You're right, I'm being stupid, it'll be fine, as long as you promise to take care of me though."

Puck's smile almost melted me in an instant, "Of course I'll take care of you," I said softly.

The crowd erupted into a mix of boos and cheers, the opposing team scored another touchdown. There were only six seconds left now.

Puck shook his head then looked up at me. His mouth slacked and his hand went up slightly like he wanted to touch me, "What are you wearing?" he whispered.

I looked down at my shirt and could feel my eyes grow big, I was still wearing Rory's jacket. I should have taken it off so Puck wouldn't see it.

I glanced back up at Puck, "It's Rory's," I muttered.

"If you needed a jacket to wear, I would have given you one," Puck scoffed, "You already have my jersey on...You still have my jersey on right?"

I nodded and unzipped the jacket to show him the red jersey with 20 in the middle, "Haven't taken it off since you gave it to me in school."

The buzzer rang and everyone cheered. It was time for half time. The guys ran off the field towards the locker room. Coach Beiste stopped Finn though and pointed to where Puck and I were so Finn made his way over to us.

"Beiste wants you to go to the locker room and see the doctors or whatever," Finn said upon arrival.

Puck nodded and I stood up. Finn helped him stand properly, but Puck put his arms out.

"I got this, no need for touching," he protested. Puck gingerly put his weight on his ankle and immediately fell to the side in pain.

Finn caught our friend, "Yeah, whatever, I'm helping you walk."

Puck groaned, but leaned on Finn for help and sucked in breath with each movement due to either his ankle or sore ribs.

I sat back down on the bench and sighed as I watched the cheerleaders run out on the field and start their routine.

~~~~~GLEE~~~~~

I heard the football team yell as they ran out onto the field and to where they started warming up. I smiled softly and stood as I waited for Puck to come over on his new crutches. He had something under his arm and looked determined to get here as fast as possible.

"Here, I'll take those," I said when Puck finally got to me. He passed me the crutches and carefully sat on the bench.

"What'd they say?" I asked when Puck was situated.

He looked up at me and grimaced, "Just sprained, but they're pretty sure my ribs are bruised so I have to get x-rays or see a real doctor or something."

I gave a sympathetic smile and nodded, "What do you have in your hands?"

Puck looked down and smiled, "Here," he handed me a dark blue jacket, "It's mine, that way you can take off Rory's and wear this."

I giggled and slipped off Rory's jacket to replace it with Puck's, "How sweet of you."

"I try," Puck shrugged.

I laughed and hit his arm, "Way to not be big-headed."

Puck looked up at the game and watched as it played out while I looked around at the stands and people watching the game behind the fence. I saw a lady with a stroller and a baby. My insides froze as I turned back to Puck. I needed to tell him what was happening or at least what I thought was happening to me.

I glanced around to make sure no one was near before leaning toward my boyfriend, "Puck, I need to tell you something."

Puck looked up at me, "Yeah, what's that?"

I swallowed and glanced at the ground. My fingers lightly danced on his ankle brace as I tried to steady myself.

"Sarah, what's wrong?" Puck said softly.

"I think I might be pregnant," I whispered as my head rose to look at him.

Puck's face paled and he nodded gravely, "Why do you think that?"

"I feel all emotional and crappy and like I need to throw-up or something. Quinn said it's how she felt at the beginning with Beth," I felt the tears spring to my eyes and I gripped the sides of the bench to stop from full blown crying.

Puck grabbed my hand and held it tightly, "We're gonna be ok," he said softly.

"I need to take a pregnancy test before I'm sure," I said.

Puck squeezed my hand, "I'll buy one for you, maybe even a few to be sure. I can do it tonight after the game."

I nodded and moved closer to Puck. He put his arms around me and gave me a soft hug.

"I love you," Puck whispered in my ear, "So much and I know this is all going to turn out ok."

I felt a tear slip down my face as I held tighter onto Puck and nodded.

~~~~~GLEE~~~~~

A/N: Alright, I hope you liked it. I've decided what direction I'm taking with this storyline. I'm happy with what'll happen and hope you will be too. There wasn't that much football, but if anything sounded too weird, I'm sorry. Also, I'm not completely sure on pregnancy symptoms because all my information is based on what I've seen on tv. Oh, and I didn't see Quinn's pregnancy storyline because I didn't watch Glee then so I don't really know what happened to her. Ok, so I'm always open to questions, comments, concerns, whatever you want to say so PLEASE REVIEW! It makes me so happy!

~~~~~GLEE~~~~~

Shout-Outs: TheAwkwardTurtle13 - Thanks! And don't worry, there will be some drama with this whole thing in the next few chapters.

REDROBINS007 - Thanks, thanks and of course, I like to read the different ideas and try to fit them into my own thoughts!

pizzalover1000 - Thank you so much for the review!

~~~~~GLEE~~~~~

Sneak Peak: I stared at the open box, then the other ones. Why was there one missing from each box? Some boxes looked destroyed while some looked normal.

I'm debating whether or not this will be the only point of view, but it might span a few days which is something new for me.