Never Forgotten Past
Last Time: Sarah thought she might be pregnant. Puck sprained his ankle and bruised his ribs at the football game. Rory tried to be nice to Sarah, but Puck didn't appreciate his thoughts. Sarah and Puck decided that they have to be sure about the baby before taking any further steps. And that's what you missed last time on Never Forgotten Past.
Disclaimer: I don't own Glee or any songs that I may put in here.
I Don't Know What To Do
Finn's Point of View
"Love you," I said softly to Rachel as we walked up to my house.
"I love you too," Rachel said back before standing on her toes to kiss me.
"Are you sure your ok with walking home by yourself? I could drive you or walk with you," I asked when we pulled away.
"Finn, you don't have to worry about me, I'm fine. I love the fresh air, it's good for my lungs," Rachel replied in her matter-of-fact tone.
"Ok, just be careful."
Rachel smiled, "Of course."
She turned around and skipped down the driveway. I watched with a small smile on my face before going into the house.
"Finn?" Mom called from the kitchen.
"Yeah Mom?" I asked as I walked towards her.
"Have you noticed anything different about Sarah lately? More specific, since the football game? She came home later than I thought she would then ran downstairs and didn't come up again," Mom said when she was done stirring her chili.
I thought back to how Sarah has acted for the past two days. She was either really quiet around us or she was glued to her phone, probably texting Puck. She also looked like she could cry at any second.
"She seems upset about something," I told Mom.
I reached my finger to try the chili but Mom slapped my hand away.
"Do you know why?" Mom pushed.
"No, but it might have to do with Puck or something since she's always texting on her phone and he's probably who she's texting," I really was concerned for Sarah, I wanted her safe and sound. I never want her to be as upset as she was three years ago again.
"Could you-" Mom started.
"I'm not talking to Puck, that's more up Kurt's alley. Guys don't talk about how they feel," Mom seemed annoyed with me now, but I'm not talking to Puck about his girlfriend, especially since that girlfriend is my sister.
"Fine, but maybe you could talk to Sarah. Or is that something that Kurt would do?" Mom turned back to her food and rolled her eyes.
"I'll try and see if she'll tell me, but I'm not pushing it," I said before heading towards the basement.
I flopped back onto my bed and groaned. How was I going to get Sarah to tell me whatever she was upset about? She keeps secrets better than anyone I know so she certainly wasn't going to tell me her own.
I glanced towards her bed and was about to grab my phone when I noticed something. There was what looked like a plastic bag sticking out from under Sarah's bed. I sat up and thought about what could be in there. I stared at the bag for a minute after no thoughts came to my head and stood up. Whatever's in the bag could be the reason for Sarah being upset.
I walked quickly to Sarah's bed and looked around before grabbing the bag out from underneath the covers. I dumped the bag onto Sarah's bed and couldn't believe my eyes. Five boxes of pregnancy tests, all open, laid out across the purple sheets.
I stared at the open box, then the other ones. Why was there one missing from each box? Some boxes looked destroyed while some looked normal.
I thought back to when Rachel and I had gone to some dog movie and the lady took a whole bunch of pregnancy tests just to make sure. That's what Sarah must have done. The destroyed ones were probably when she was mad she was pregnant and wanted to be even more sure. Or it could just be because she didn't want to run out of supply and had to open the boxes really fast.
I sat on her bed and stared at the boxes next to me. What were we going to do? Being pregnant would probably ruin Sarah. I don't think glee club could handle another pregnant girl either.
I looked up and around the room as I groaned. A picture on Sarah's desk caught my eye, so I walked towards it. I picked up the picture and I felt like I could punch something. In the white frame was the picture Mom took of Sarah and Puck on their first date. This was probably it, the time that Sarah got pregnant. I knew when Puck put his hands all over Sarah that he was planning something bad. He wanted to do her that night at the river bank.
I put the picture back on the desk then kicked my bed. Puck destroyed Sarah and he was going to pay.
I heard the front door close then Sarah's voice talking to Mom.
I ran over to her bed and started throwing the boxes back in the bag so she wouldn't notice I was looking at them. I threw the bag under the bed as Sarah's footsteps echoed down the staircase. I jumped on my bed and grabbed my phone to make it seem like I had been there the entire time.
"Hey," Sarah said as she shrugged off her, or should I say Puck's, coat and tossed it on the chair next to Kurt's bed.
"Hey," I said and sat up, "What's up?"
"Nothing," Sarah replied when she sat on the bed, more careful than usual I noticed, "How was your day with Rachel?"
"Fine, fine," I stared at Sarah and tried to see if she had been crying, "What did you and Puck do?"
"Went out to lunch," Sarah said. She was giving me a look as if she was trying to figure something out, maybe my staring was a little obvious.
"Oh and is that all?"
"Yeah," she was starting to become suspicious, "What is wrong with you today? You've never cared about what Puck and I have done before."
"Well maybe I should start caring. Like, how is he? How many times have you kissed? Have you slept together yet?" I walked over to Sarah's bed and sat next to her.
"Finn!" Sarah slapped my arm, "Those last two questions are none of your business and you should know the answer to the first one since he is your best friend."
Sarah stood up and walked over to the desk and grabbed the picture of her and Puck.
"Sarah-" I started as I went over to her.
"No! Do you not trust me or something to make my own decisions?" Sarah screamed as she put the picture down and turned around.
"I don't know ok! Puck has a reputation and Mom says you've been acting all weird so she wanted to know what was up. I told her I'd find out what I could."
"Wait, Mom put you up to this?" Sarah's face was bright red as she marched over to me. She tried to make herself my height but couldn't quite make it.
I stuttered on my words, "Um, well, you know, she just asked how you were and stuff."
"Mom!" Sarah screamed as she ran past me and up the stairs.
I stood still for a second, I was so confused. What just happened?
"Do you not trust me?"
I winced at how high Sarah's voice went then ran up the stairs after her. All of this probably wasn't good for her baby.
"What is going on?" Mom asked Sarah.
I turned the corner and saw Sarah standing in front of Mom looking furious while Mom just looked concerned. Kurt and Burt were standing off to the side looking confused.
"Finn said you told him I was acting weird and that he should ask me what Puck and I do in our spare time."
"Honey, I told him you were acting different, but I promise that I did not tell him to ask you about what you and Puck do in your spare time," Mom walked towards Sarah, but she just stepped back.
"Just because I act different doesn't mean that there's something wrong with me," Sarah said quietly with her hands up, "You have to trust me."
"What is going on here?" Kurt spoke up, "Finn, what did you do?"
"Nothing! I swear!" I told them all.
"Finn, is something going on that Sarah isn't telling us?" Burt asked.
Everyone turned to Sarah who looked like she might cry, but there was something else too. She knew that I knew. Her eyes bore into mine as if to beg me not to say anything.
"No," I said quietly with a shake of my head, "She's fine, well except for acting different this weekend, but that's probably because of Puck's injuries."
A look of relief washed over Sarah's face and she nodded lightly.
"He's right, I'm just worried about Puck," Sarah said softly.
"But he's fine isn't he?" Burt asked.
"Yeah, I thought he just sprained his ankle and bruised his ribs. Is something else wrong with him?" Mom agreed.
"He's good, I'm just worried about how this will affect his dancing, that's all," Sarah told us.
"I do not know what is going on, Sarah are you mad anymore?" Kurt said from where he was sitting.
"Yeah, I'm still mad, Finn had no right to ask me about that."
I groaned, this was not good. Sarah is definitely pregnant, she's acting how Quinn did, all emotional and moody and stuff.
"Finn, can you please apologize to Sarah so we can get past this?" Mom asked.
"I'm sorry, Sarah, I shouldn't have asked you about sex," I mumbled.
"You asked her about sex?" Kurt yelled.
Sarah's face turned bright red. She walked over to me slowly before slapping my arm, "I. Hate. You," she said dangerously.
"Sarah, do we need to talk?" Mom said softly as she walked towards Sarah.
"No!" Sarah screamed, "Would you all just leave me alone?" and with that, Sarah ran down to the basement where we could hear her making loud, banging noises.
"Oh my God," Burt groaned and rubbed the top of his head.
"Quite a mess you made Finn," Kurt said with a smirk.
I wanted to punch him.
Mom rubbed the side of her head then walked over to the cabinets and pulled out a glass with some medicine.
The basement door flew open and a duffel bag was thrown onto the ground with Sarah right behind it. She picked up the bag then walked to the front door.
"Where do you think you're going?" Mom asked.
We all stared at Sarah as she put on her coat and opened the door. She pulled out her cell-phone and started dialing a number as she grabbed her backpack.
Sarah rolled her eyes, "I don't know and even if I did, I wouldn't tell you because I just want to be by myself."
Sarah slammed the door behind her, but we could still hear her talking.
"Can you come pick me up?" her voice was thick with tears, "Thanks."
I looked over at Mom. She looked like she was about to cry herself.
"Mom, I-"
"Now's not the time Finn," Mom muttered before turning and walking towards her bedroom.
Burt followed after her, patting Kurt on the shoulder as he passed.
Kurt and I stared at each other for a second.
"What's going on Finn?"
"I have no idea," I said quietly.
"Well, you should fix it because it looks like Sarah's not coming home tonight," Kurt whispered before turning on his heel and going downstairs.
I groaned and sat at the table. I had no idea what was going on. One second I'm with Rachel, then I find out Sarah's pregnant, then Sarah goes and yells at Mom and makes a whole scene, and then she stormed out the house.
I had two things that I needed to take care of now. Get Sarah home and kick Puck's butt for getting my sister pregnant.
~~~~~GLEE~~~~~
Sarah's Point of View
Puck was at the corner of our street within two minutes. He got out of the car and put my bag and backpack in the backseat without asking any questions. He was silent the whole way to his house, only holding my hand tightly as we drove.
When we pulled up to his house, Puck and I walked in silence to to the door. Ms. Ruth and Grace looked up when we walked in the living room to get to the stairs.
"Hey-" Grace started but stopped from the look from both Puck and Ms. Ruth.
Ms. Ruth nodded at Puck and gave me a small smile. She was letting me stay here as long as I needed.
When Puck and I got to his room, I sat gently on the edge of his bed.
"You wanna tell me what's going on?" Puck said quietly as he sat next to me.
I was silent and Puck sighed.
"You didn't tell them you're pregnant did you? Because we don't know for sure, we were waiting for tomorrow remember."
I shook my head, "I couldn't stand it anymore, they don't trust me to be responsible. But, I'm a liar, Puck, I am, because I tell them I am responsible, but look, there's a chance I'm pregnant. How responsible is that?"
There were tears running down my face by now and I was having a hard time breathing. Puck pulled me onto his lap and held me tightly as I cried. He gently moved back so his back was against his wall. I curled as small as I could in his lap and cried until I fell asleep.
~~~~~GLEE~~~~~
A/N: Drama! Haha, yeah so it was little everywhere, but I hope it was easy to keep up with. I've decided what's going to happen with either pregnancy or no pregnancy and I think you'll like what's ahead. I'm always up for more suggestions, so what would you like to see? I'll try my best to make it work. PLEASE REVIEW with any questions, comments, or concerns!
~~~~~GLEE~~~~~
Shout-Outs: Neith4Weiss - Thank you so much for the review!
REDROBINS007 - Lol, I loved your review! And yeah, for some reason I like to read stories about pregnant people too.
~~~~~GLEE~~~~~
Sneak Peak: I felt the tears come from my eyes as I watched it all play out. This couldn't be happening.
Big glee club moment coming up next!
