Never Forgotten Past

Last Time: Puck and Sarah spent Christmas together with the Hudson-Hummel family and Beth. Puck realized that the situation with Beth wasn't fair. Both Puck and Sarah admitted that it was the best Christmas ever. And that's what you missed on Never Forgotten Past.

Disclaimer: I don't own Glee or any songs that I may put in here.

Bring in the New Year

Finn's Point of View

Sarah, Rachel, and I walked through the doors to Santana's house. She had invited the whole glee club over for a New Year's Eve party until two in the morning. It was 8:30 right now, so we had a long night ahead of us.

"I'm going to find Puck," Sarah said before running off to find her boyfriend.

"What do you want to do?" I asked as I turned towards Rachel.

"Let's go find Kurt and Blaine," Rachel grabbed my hand then led me through the house.

We passed Sugar and Artie talking. Brittany and Santana trying to get Rory to go in Santana's bedroom with them. Mike and Tina laughing on the stairs. Sam, Mercedes, and Quinn eating in the kitchen. What we saw next made me stop in my tracks. Sarah was sitting on Puck's lap in the living room and they were having a heated make-out session.

"Just ignore them, they won't pull anything tonight," Rachel reassured me before grabbing my hand and continuing our search.

We found Kurt and Blaine sitting on the back porch talking quietly and laughing.

"Hello," Rachel greeted as she sat down next to Kurt.

I took the spot next to Blaine, "Hey."

"Hi, what's up?" Blaine asked.

"Nothing much, just got here," Rachel smiled.

"And yet somehow my sister's able to get her tongue down her boyfriend's throat in the five minutes since we arrived," I grumbled.

"She hasn't!" Kurt gasped.

I just shrugged.

"It's not a big deal you guys. Sarah's very responsible, even more so since her scare," Rachel defended Sarah.

"I have to agree with Rachel. I mean, the thought of being pregnant really freaked Sarah and Puck out so I highly doubt they're going to do anything else then make-out," Blaine said.

Kurt looked at me with a raised eyebrow and I shrugged again. I'll deal with it for tonight, it was New Year's Eve after all.

"I can't believe our senior year is half way done," Rachel whispered.

"Our life is just around the corner," Kurt added.

"I am definitely going to miss all of you next fall. It won't be the same," Blaine said quietly.

That's right, Blaine was a junior. He was going to be in Lima next fall when the rest of us were gone, not that I really planned on going that far.

"Hey, are you staying at McKinley for the next school year?" I asked Blaine.

"Planned on it," Blaine smiled, "Why? Want me to watch out for someone?" he winked.

"Sarah. Who knows what Puck's planning on doing this upcoming year, but he's not going to be in McKinley so Sarah's free to be pushed around and slushied," I admitted.

"Don't worry, I'll cover her the best I can," Blaine said.

I nodded, "Thanks."

"Let's not talk about the future," Rachel suddenly said.

We all turned towards her with our mouths open. The future was one of Rachel's favorite subjects.

"Excuse me?" Kurt gaped, "But since when do you not want to talk about the great future of Rachel Berry?"

"I just don't right now," Rachel shrugged, "No big deal." She stood up, "I'm going to get a drink. Anyone else want one?"

"I'll take a Pepsi," Blaine told her.

"Just a water will be fine," Kurt spoke up.

I stared at my brother and his boyfriend, "Do you not realize that it's New Year's Eve? Live a little."

They looked back at me then at each other.

"Fine, beer," Blaine said to Rachel.

"I'll come with you so I can mix something," Kurt stood up.

"Beer please Rach?" I asked.

Rachel looked down at me, "Not a lot, but you'll be fine with one for now."

Kurt and Rachel walked away and Blaine moved over a little.

"So, are you and Rachel ready to ring in the New Year together?" he asked.

"Yeah, I plan on making that first kiss something special," I told him, "What about you and Kurt?"

Blaine shrugged, "We'll see."

I sensed something else behind his words, but decided I didn't need to know. We sat in silence and just stared at the stars. I wondered where the "Finn Hudson" star was at.

"Finn!" Kurt's voice yelled.

I looked behind me to see Kurt and Rachel charging through the back door.

"Finn, you have to get inside now," Rachel said as she tried to pull me up.

"What's going on?" I asked. They were scaring me with how they were acting.

"Sarah's laying half-naked on top of Puck on the living room floor and he's doing nothing to stop her, I think they're drunk," Rachel blurted out in a rush.

Blaine stood up, "Do you think they're going to...?"

I pushed past Rachel and to the back door, "Where?"

Rachel pointed to the left of the house.

I walked over to where Rachel had pointed. I noticed that the time was 9:15. How the heck could Sarah have gotten drunk already?

Sure enough, there in the middle of the floor, Sarah and Puck were having some sort of gross pre-sex thing where they were half-naked and making out.

I pulled Sarah off of Puck, "What are you doing?" I yelled.

"Woah, that felt weird," Sarah slurred as she fell against me.

"You got her drunk?" I yelled this time at Puck.

Puck sat up, "I don't know what you're talking about. We were just having some fun."

I spat, "Yeah, you took advantage of her is what you did!"

"Stop yelling, it hurts," Sarah moaned.

I adjusted her so I was carrying her bridal style, "Come on," I grumbled.

I carried her down the hall where I was guessing a bathroom would be located. I placed her in the shower then turned on the cold water.

Sarah screamed, "Get me out!"

I grabbed her arms and held her under the water, "Stay still!"

"Finn!" Sarah screamed back.

"What is going on in here?" Santana yelled as she threw open the door, "I'm in my bedroom and then I hear yelling downstairs and when I arrive, Puckerman's sitting with his head in his hands and six empty beer bottles to his left next to his and Sarah's shirts! So I followed the screaming and shower noises and I walk in on some weird brother/sister shower thing!"

"He got her drunk then tried to sleep with her Santana!" I yelled, "What was I supposed to do? I can't have her drunk all night, she needs to be fixed and that can be done with a cold shower."

Sarah whimpered and we both turned to look at her. Santana seemed to soften a little.

"Towels are in that cupboard," she pointed to my right, "I'll go get some of my spare clothes and have Puck sober up," Santana left the room.

"I'm so sorry Finn," Sarah whispered. She stood shivering underneath the pounding, frozen water, "I am so sorry."

I stared at my sister. Her eyes didn't seem as glazed over and it looked like she was able to focus on her surroundings.

I sighed, "It's ok, here," I turned off the water then helped her climb out of the shower. I passed her one of the towels which she automatically wrapped around her shoulders.

"What happened?" I asked.

Sarah glanced up at me then at the ground, "I don't remember," she whispered quietly.

"What do you mean?" I prodded.

Sarah took a deep breath, "I remember finding Puck sitting on the couch with some beer. I went to grab one, but he stopped me so I kissed him. Puck got distracted so I started drinking the beer, then another, then Puck grabbed some more, so I had those. Puck had just as much as me. Next thing I know, I'm standing in Santana's shower, freezing my butt off."

"Fine, let's just get you cleaned up then," I muttered. I felt kinda bad for her, she didn't realize what she was doing. I was surprised with Puck though, usually he can control his alcohol.

There was a knock on the door, then Santana entered, "Here, you can wear these. Just return them when you're done."

Sarah nodded, "Thanks," she said quietly.

The door opened again, but this time Puck entered, "Sarah," he ran towards her and picked her up in a huge hug, "I knew I shouldn't have let you have those beers."

"Yeah, well, you did, so leave so Sarah can change," I pushed Puck away from Sarah.

Puck nodded, "Ok. I'm sorry Finn, really, I am," Puck turned and left the bathroom with Santana on his heels.

"I'll wait outside for you," I told Sarah as I left the bathroom.

Once outside, I leaned against the wall and slowly sat down against it. Rachel came over and sat down next to me.

"Hey," she whispered.

"Hey," I replied.

"How is she?"

"Wet."

Rachel laughed, "Are you ok?"

I shrugged, "Just mad. I can't believe Puck got her drunk, he knew she's hasn't had any alcohol before. I'm also kinda surprised that she fell that easily."

Rachel nodded and leaned her head on my shoulder.

Sarah emerged from the bathroom with Santana's clothes on and her's in her arms, "I'm going to thank Santana then grab some water."

I watched Sarah's walk away and sighed. I stood up and reached down to help Rachel up, "Let's go watch the New Year's Eve show with the others."

~~~~~GLEE~~~~~

Puck's Point of View

I walked outside with two water bottles. Sarah was sitting on the porch with her head in her hands.

"Hey," I said softly as I got closer.

Sarah looked up, "Hey," she whispered.

"Finn's pretty mad, huh?" I asked as I sat down.

Sarah nodded.

I passed her a water, "Drink this, it'll help with the headache."

"Thanks," Sarah leaned her head on my shoulder.

I wrapped my arm around her and pulled her closer, "What a way to bring in the new year."

Sarah laughed, "Hey, it's not ruined yet, it's only ten. We have two more hours."

I smiled down at her, "Unfortunately, we can't do too much because Finn might actually kill me this time."

Sarah laughed again and pulled me closer, "I'm sorry, I was stupid."

I shrugged, "I've been there, no big deal."

Sarah reached up and kissed me, "Thanks."

"No problem," I said softly.

There was some loud laughter that rang through the slightly open door.

"Wanna go join them?" I asked Sarah.

She smiled and nodded her head, "Come on, let's go beat them at whatever game they're playing."

I laughed then stood up and helped Sarah. She wavered a little, but then regained her balance by grabbing on my arm.

"Maybe you should lay off the wine and beer," I suggested.

Sarah laughed then punched my arm, "I'll be fine."

~~~~~GLEE~~~~~

Everyone was gathered around the flat screen in the Lopez living room at 11:58.

Sarah squeezed my hand and jumped up and down, "It's almost here!"

I laughed. Sarah always loved New Year's Eve and I was happy that we were spending it together again.

Rachel screamed when the clock on the tv chimed 11:59. Everyone laughed and started getting our pots, pans, whistles, and blowers together so we could run outside.

Ryan Seacrest started the 20 second countdown on the tv. Finn punched my shoulder and smiled as Rachel clung to his waist. Santana and Brittany started jumping around. Rory smiled as Sugar grabbed his hand from where she was sitting on Artie's lap. Quinn grabbed Sam and Mercede's hands and started jumping. Mike and Tina hugged each other tightly. Kurt and Blaine were just enjoying each other's company on the couch. Sarah started jumping up and down, trying to bring me with her.

I grabbed her waist and pulled her close against me, "Calm down," I laughed.

Sarah giggled, "Sorry, I'm just so excited."

Santana turned up the tv.

"Ten!"

We all started screaming and yelling along with the tv.

"Nine!"

The smile on Sarah's face was as big as the party in New York.

"Eight!"

I smiled back down at my girlfriend.

"Seven!"

I don't think I've ever been in a room this loud.

"Six!"

Sarah grabbed my hand and squeezed tightly.

"Five!"

I laughed at how happy she was.

"Four!"

Sarah's eyes shined with tears of joy.

"Three!"

My voice felt hoarse and it wasn't even 2012 yet.

"Two!"

All the girls let out an ear piercing scream.

"One!"

I picked Sarah up in my arms.

"Happy New Year!"

The room erupted into screams and yells as the huge ball on the tv hit the ground. Sarah's arms tightened around my neck as she kissed me.

"I love you!" she yelled over all the screams.

"Love you too!" I laughed.

I swung Sarah around then set her down. She ran over to Finn and jumped in his arms.

Rachel tapped my shoulder, "Happy New Year Noah!"

"Happy New Year Berry!" I said back.

She gave me a quick hug before running over to Kurt and Blaine.

Quinn ran over and hugged me tightly, "Happy New Year Puck!"

I laughed, "Happy New Year Quinn!"

"Everyone outside!" Santana screamed.

Sarah ran back to me and grabbed my hand as she dragged me outside with everyone else. Fireworks littered the sky in celebration of the new year. We all started running around, screaming and banging our pots and pans together. There were flashes from the various cameras going off across the yard.

"Puck! Sarah! Get together! I want a picture!" Kurt yelled at the two of us.

Sarah and I smiled brightly as we were blinded by the flash of Kurt's digital camera.

All of us continued to run around for another few minutes before we got tired and filed back inside.

I sat on the couch and Sarah plopped on my lap. She moved down a little so her head was under my chin.

"Best New Year's Eve ever," she said quietly.

I laughed then turned her around so I could see her face, "We've had the best Christmas ever, the best New Year's Eve ever, I'm ready to have the best year ever. What about you?"

Sarah smiled then kissed me.

Finn and Rachel sat down next to us with a small laugh.

"Hey," Finn smiled.

"We good man?" I asked.

Finn glanced at Sarah who pleaded through her smile, he chuckled lightly, "Yeah, we're good."

"Yay!" Sarah exclaimed as she threw her arms around Finn's shoulders.

"Who wants a game of spin the bottle?" Artie announced.

Everyone nodded and laughed as we all gathered around the bottle in the center of the room. Sarah fell into my side so I wrapped an arm around her. She smiled up at me which I returned.

"Happy New Year," I whispered quietly.

"Happy New Year," Sarah said softly.

~~~~~GLEE~~~~~

A/N: I love New Year's Eve so much and was so excited to write this. Next chapter will be the Yes/No episode, or at least some of it. I've been waiting to write it since the episode aired. I'm thinking about dropping a little bomb, sort of, either next chapter or the next. It'll add a little twist on the whole thing I think. I hope you're enjoying the story so far, so if you are, or even aren't, PLEASE REVIEW with any questions, comments, concerns, or suggestions. I really enjoy reading them, they make me smile.

~~~~~GLEE~~~~~

Shout Outs: Ace5492 - Thank you so much!

Midnight LeAnn - Thanks! I'm glad you like it!

~~~~~GLEE~~~~~

Sneak Peak: I pulled away from Puck and slid off his lap. Finn looked furious at Mom and Burt, who in turn looked concerned.

You might realize what Sarah's going to find out if you remember what secret Finn discovered during that episode.