Never Forgotten Past

Last Time: The real reason for the death of Finn and Sarah's father came to light for everyone to know. Puck warned Rory to stay away from Sarah or else he'll be in the dumpster. Burt and Carole have a game changer for their kids.

Disclaimer: I don't own Glee or any songs that I may put in here.

I Can't Believe This

Finn's Point of View

I held open the door for Puck, Sarah, and Kurt. We had just come home from Mr. Schue's proposal to Ms. Pillsbury. It had actually given me an idea.

"Why thank you kind sir," Puck bowed in front of me.

We all laughed and I hit him upside the head, "Dork."

We started walking towards our room when we noticed Burt and Mom sitting at the kitchen table. They looked worried about something.

"Is something wrong?" Kurt asked.

Mom and Burt gave each other a look before looking back at us.

"No," Burt started, "We have to tell you guys something though."

"Let me guess, Kurt's mom died because of a drug overdose and not from leukemia?" Sarah scoffed.

Puck grabbed Sarah's hand, "Calm down," he whispered in her ear as he pulled her closer to him.

Kurt's face paled, "Oh God no, Dad please."

"No Kurt, that's not what I was going to say," Burt said.

"It's actually almost the opposite," Mom smiled at us.

"What's the opposite of death?" I asked.

"No you're not!" Kurt beamed.

Mom and Burt smiled softly, "Yeah," Mom said quietly.

"I don't get it," Puck whispered.

"I'm pregnant," Mom's smile grew. She stared at me and Sarah.

Sarah and Puck looked just as confused as I felt while Kurt looked like he could jump for joy. Did Mom really just say what I think she said?

"That's impossible," Sarah said.

Mom shook her head, "No, it's not," she had a small smile on her face.

Kurt ran over and gave Mom a hug, "This is amazing! I can't wait to decorate the nursery or pick out the clothes! We're getting a new house right?"

Burt chuckled, "Yeah, so now instead of looking for a four bedroom house, we have to look for a five bedroom."

"That's silly," Sarah said, "Kurt's going to be at NYADA next fall and Finn's going to be..." she trailed off.

"I'm going to be in New York with Rachel," I told them. I wasn't planning on going to college, it's not for me. I'll just find something in New York by Broadway or wherever Rachel was.

"See," Sarah pointed out, "Just a three bedroom house with a basement for when Kurt and Finn come home."

Mom's smile grew, "So you're ok with this?" she asked Sarah, but since she glanced at me, I was probably supposed to answer too.

Sarah shrugged, "I guess, I need to be able to trust someone in this house. Why not a baby?"

Mom's face froze, "Sarah-"

"It's fine," my sister stated before grabbing Puck's hand and pulling him downstairs.

"Congrats Ms. Carole," Puck called over his shoulder before following Sarah.

"What do you think Finn?" Burt asked.

"It'll be cool to have a baby, I guess," I said and really, that's how I felt. I'm not really going to be here to see it anyways, so I won't have to worry about babysitting or anything.

"I'm going to have to start planning!" Kurt exclaimed before running out of the kitchen and into the basement to get, what I'm guessing was, his laptop.

"How'd the proposal go?" Mom asked.

I sat down at the table, "Ms. Pillsbury said yes."

"That's great," Mom smiled.

Burt nodded, "So when's the wedding?"

"No idea," I said as Kurt ran back up stairs.

"Ok, so I'm thinking we find out the sex of the baby which will make this all a lot easier. Plus, it'll allow us to get way cuter ideas in the room," he started while loading up the computer and sitting down.

"I'm going to go downstairs and leave you guys to your planning," I said sort of to myself since everyone was now gathered around the laptop.

I started walking down the stairs when I heard music coming from them. It didn't sound like an iPod or computer, it was happening right now.

(Puck, Sarah, Both)

I thought that dreams belonged to other men

Cos each time I got close they'd fall apart again

I feared my heart would beat in secrecy

I faced the nights alone, oh how could I have known

That all my life I only needed you

Oh, almost paradise, we're knocking on heaven's door

Almost paradise, how could we ask for more

I swear that I can see forever in your eyes

Paradise

~~~~~GLEE~~~~~

Puck and Sarah stood in front of us singing with Puck playing his guitar. Rachel grabbed my hand and smiled.

"I can't help but think of us," she whispered in my ear.

I nodded and smiled before looking back up at my sister and friend.

It seems like perfect love's so hard to find

I'd almost given up, you must have read my mind

And all these dreams I saved for a rainy day

They're finally coming true, I'll share them all with you

Cos now we hold the future in our hands

Oh, almost paradise, we're knocking on heaven's door

Almost paradise, how could we ask for more

I swear that I can see forever in your eyes

Paradise

And in your arms salvation's not so far away

It's getting closer, closer every day

Almost paradise, we're knocking on heaven's door

Almost paradise, how could we ask for more

I swear that I can see forever in your eyes

Paradise, paradise, paradise

Sarah and Puck smiled at each other as Mr. Schue walked over to them.

"Wow, that was amazing you guys!" he clapped, "Where'd it come from?"

"I guess everything's changing and I hated it. That's when I realized there's one thing that isn't changing, so we sang about it," Sarah explained.

Puck looked embarrassed as he nodded. He took his guitar off then grabbed Sarah's hand and led her to the chairs.

"Wonderful job," Rachel told them.

"Thanks," both Puck and Sarah said.

"You know what? I think it's actually time to go," Mr. Schue announced with a glance to his watch, "So I'll see you guys tomorrow," he walked into his office as everyone stood up.

"Finn."

I turned towards Sarah, "Yeah? Is Puck driving you home?"

She shook her head, "No, I wanted to go home with you."

"Oh, ok," I stood still as Sarah put on her jacket and grabbed her purse.

"I'll call you tonight," Puck smiled at Sarah before leaning down and kissing her forehead.

"Bye," she said softly.

Puck walked out of the room and Rachel turned towards me.

"I'll catch a ride with Noah," she said.

"Are you sure?" I asked, "There's enough room for three people in my car."

"It's fine, you guys need to talk. I'll talk to you later," Rachel went on her tip toes and kissed me lightly before heading out the door, "Noah!" I heard her yell.

Sarah pushed me forward, "Come on, let's go, I'm hungry so let's get some shakes at McDonald's."

I laughed, "And who's paying?"

Sarah rolled her eyes, "You, now walk."

~~~~~GLEE~~~~~

Sarah and I were sitting in the corner booth drinking our shakes and eating some fries.

"What's up?" I asked, "You always go home with Puck, why not today?"

"What do you really think of Mom and Burt having a baby?" Sarah countered.

"Um," I wasn't expecting that, "Well, it's good for them...I guess."

"I think they're too old," Sarah shrugged.

"So you don't think they should have a baby?"

"I just don't think it's possible. Plus, it'll be weird."

She had a point. I took another sip of my shake and stared at Sarah. She was the baby in the family, but soon...

"You're jealous," I declared with a wave of a fry.

"What?" Sarah looked at me like I grew two heads, but I could see the blush rise in her cheeks.

"You're realizing that a baby is going to take away any attention from you," I told her.

Sarah glanced down at her shake and stayed quiet.

"Come on Sars, it'll be fine. Mom and Burt will stay pay attention to you. Even more since Kurt and I won't be there."

"Maybe I should tell them I thought I was pregnant," Sarah looked back up at me.

"Sarah," I groaned, "I don't want to think of that. Why do you need the attention? They're trying to get on you're good side after the other day, don't do anything to ruin that."

"Fine, maybe I should forgive them," Sarah muttered.

"That's my girl," I smiled.

Sarah laughed, "It's like I'm your pet or something."

"I could fit you in my pocket, midget," I laughed back.

Sarah threw a fry at me, "Moron."

"Come on, let's go home," I stood up.

Sarah and I walked to the doors, tossing our trash out on the way. I was about to open the door myself when it was pushed open and smacked me in the head.

Sarah started laughing, but stopped when she realized who pushed the door.

"Oh my goodness, are you ok?" Ms. Corcoran asked. She had Beth in her arms who went into a fit of giggles and started clapping when she saw Sarah.

"Yeah, I'm fine," I muttered. The little girl looked like a mini Quinn, except her eyes, she had Puck's eyes.

"Hi Bethie," Sarah smiled, "What are you guys doing here?" she asked Ms. Corcoran.

"Just getting some ice-cream," she explained as she readjusted Beth, "We'll get out of your way so you can go," Ms. Corcoran moved over and Sarah walked through the door.

"Bye," Sarah said.

"Bye," a small voice said.

I looked up and realized Beth had said it, "Um, bye," I muttered before following Sarah to the car. I unlocked it then hopped in the driver's side.

"What was that?" Sarah asked.

I knew exactly what she meant, "Sore spot," I said as I started the car and pulled out onto the road.

Sarah nodded then stayed quiet. She knew when to talk and when to just leave things alone, something I appreciated.

I can't believe Beth was that big. If she had been mine, we would have kept her...I think. Would she have my eyes instead of Puck's? Or would those have been soft brown curls on her head instead of blond ones? Would her name even be Beth?

"Maybe having a baby around won't be so bad," Sarah eventually spoke up as I turned onto our street.

"I'm glad you came around," I smiled at her.

I pulled into the driveway then jumped down from the car. I walked through the door after Sarah.

"Mom, Burt, I have something to say," she said as we walked into the kitchen where they were talking while making dinner.

"What's that?" Mom asked. She put down her knife and looked up.

"I'm sorry for the way I've been acting. You know how much Dad meant to me, so to suddenly hear he didn't act the way I thought he did, it hurt. And I really am happy that you're pregnant, it'll be fun," Sarah said softly.

Mom stared at her for a second before rushing forward and giving her a hug, "I love you honey."

"Love you too Mom," Sarah said into Mom's shoulder.

Mom looked up, "Come here Finn," she smiled.

I chuckled and walked over to my family. I wrapped my arms around Sarah and Mom and squeezed hard.

"Stop Finn! That hurts!" Sarah whined.

I laughed.

"Ok, everyone off, family moment over," Mom said as she pulled away.

"Nice going Finn, ruin everything," Sarah scoffed before pushing my shoulder.

"Hey," I pushed her back.

Sarah fell back a little then looked up at me, "That's it," she lunged at me and I took off towards the basement.

"Don't break anything!" I heard Mom yell, "Bones included!"

Sarah pushed me onto my bed, "Idiot."

"I am not an idiot," I replied with a soft kick to her stomach.

Sarah rolled her eyes, "Sure," she said as she sat on her bed and took her jacket off. She reached into her purse and pulled out her phone.

"Who are you calling?" I asked as I sat up.

Sarah smirked at me before turning back to her phone, "Hey, one sec, let me put you on speaker," she set the phone on her bed, "Ok."

"What's going on?" Puck's voice filled the room.

"Seriously Sarah?" I rolled my eyes, "What are you doing?"

"Hey babe?" Sarah asked.

"Yeah, what do you need?"

"Is Finn an idiot?"

I threw my pillow at her which smacked her on the top of her head.

"Why?" Puck asked.

"He doesn't think he is, but I know I'm right," Sarah smirked at me again.

"Finn's not an idiot," Puck started.

"Ha!" I yelled.

"He's just slow," Puck finished.

Sarah laughed and rolled around on her bed.

"I hate you Puckerman," I yelled at the phone.

Puck's laughter added to Sarah's.

"Ok, I'll turn off speaker phone now. Thank you," Sarah picked up the phone and hit a button before putting it up to her ear, "Yeah, we're home now," she said as she stood up and walked towards the stairs.

I smiled and was about to lean back into my pillows when my phone blared Faithfully. I picked it up and saw Rachel's face staring up at me.

"Hello," I greeted after hitting talk.

"Are you home yet?" Rachel asked.

"Yeah, what's up?"

"Oh, nothing, I just wanted to talk to you."

I smiled, "Well, here I am, all yours. I don't think I'll get interrupted."

"Good, I like when you're just mine."

"Hey, will you be honest with me?" I asked. I wanted Rachel's opinion on something.

"Of course."

"Do you think I'm an idiot?"

~~~~~GLEE~~~~~

A/N: What do you think? So when it comes time, you guys can vote for gender, baby names, stuff like that. The song Sarah and Puck sang was called Almost Paradise from the Footloose cd. You should listen to it, I love the song which is kinda why I just threw it in there because I wanted them to sing it. I'm open to all suggestions, questions, comments, concerns so PLEASE REVIEW! I love them!

~~~~~GLEE~~~~~

Ace5492 - Thank you!

~~~~~GLEE~~~~~

Sneak Peak: I couldn't help but laugh a little at the sight in front of me. The tissues, towels, water bottles, glasses of juice, it all looked too familiar to a few months ago, only now the roles were reversed.

I remembered Puck wasn't in the beginning of the Michael episode, so I came up with my own explanation.