Never Forgotten Past

Last Time: Finn and Rachel announced they were getting married. Puck and Sarah celebrated Valentine's Day early with a night at the river. And that's what you missed on Never Forgotten Past.

Disclaimer: I don't own Glee or any songs that I may put in here.

Together

Kurt's Point of View

"Kurt!" Grace screamed as she ran down the stairs, "Is Sarah almost done? Noah wants to know when you guys are going to be ready to go to the party."

I looked up from Sarah's hair, "One second, I'm almost done."

"Can you hurry up? This kinda hurts," Sarah whined, "And I'm sure Puck doesn't care what my hair looks like."

"Do you want to look like the cavewoman that asked for my help an hour ago?" I countered.

"I didn't look that bad," Sarah muttered.

"You're hair was everywhere," Grace spoke up, "And your shirt was on backwards. What were you and Noah doing down here while me and Kurt went shopping?"

Sarah blushed, "Just goofing around."

I laughed as I pinned back the last curl.

"Like with a pillow fight?" Grace asked.

"Yeah...a pillow fight," Sarah nodded.

"You're done," I said.

Sarah stood up and walked over to the full-length mirror to see my work. She had on a light purple dress and her hair was pulled back on the sides. On her wrist was the charm bracelet Puck got her for Christmas with the new music charms he bought her today. I was really surprised when Sarah showed me the locket Puck had given to her, it really was beautiful and looked great on her.

Grace ran back upstairs, "Noah! She's all ready!" I could hear her yell.

Sarah's hand lightly ran up the dress before grasping the locket around her neck, "Thank you Kurt," she said quietly.

"No problem," I replied with a smile as I walked over to stand behind her, "If only one of us gets to see their boyfriend on Valentine's Day, they might as well look good."

Sarah giggled, "Don't worry, you'll still have fun without Blaine."

"Maybe, but without Rachel? I don't know," I admitted.

"There is still Mercedes and if she's busy, come talk to me and Puck," Sarah patted my arm before walking to her bed and grabbing her white sweater.

"Like you two will be talking," I laughed, "A pillow fight, that's what you guys were doing down here while the rest of the house was empty."

Sarah glared at me before walking up the stairs and I followed right behind her. We turned the corner to see Puck talking quietly to Grace who was perched on the counter. He looked back when he heard the noise of our shoes on the hardwood.

"Alright," Puck said as he lifted Grace down, "Be good for the babysitter until Ms. Carole and Mr. Burt come home, then be good for them."

Grace rolled her eyes, "I know Noah, I'm not going to do anything bad."

Puck raised his eyebrows at his sister.

"One time," she muttered.

"She stopped babysitting children!" Puck exclaimed.

Sarah and I laughed at Grace's red face and Puck's smirk.

"It was a pretty good prank though," Puck said quietly as he lightly punched Grace's arm.

"I know," she smiled.

"Are you guys ready?" Puck asked us when he looked up.

"Yes," I replied.

Sarah nodded and walked over to Puck and grabbed his hand, "Never better."

~~~~~GLEE~~~~~

"I can't believe you're here," I said to Blaine once we had sat down after singing Love Shack.

He grabbed my hand, "Well, I had to come back eventually and thought tonight would be as good as ever."

I smiled, "I'm so happy you're here, I was getting lonely."

"Why didn't you talk to Sarah, Mercedes, or I saw Rachel and Finn come in before me?" Blaine asked.

"Rachel and Finn did just get here, I can't hang on Mercedes's arm the whole time, and Sarah and Puck are in their own little world," I told him.

Blaine nodded, "How is Puck, by the way?"

"Good," I took a sip of my water, "So is his sister."

"So they're not taking the whole thing hard?"

"I think the beginning was hard for Grace, but Puck just wanted to get out of there as soon as possible."

Blaine had a sympathetic look on his face, "I should go talk to him, just tell him I'm here if he needs anything," he moved to stand up.

"I don't think that's such a good idea," I said quickly.

"Kurt, Puck's in a hard place right now. His mom beat him and now he and his sister are living with their family friends. He needs a friend, someone who he can talk to when needed that can have a rational opinion," Blaine patted my back lightly and walked away.

Sarah was going to kill me. And then Finn. And somewhere in there, Puck. Dad was going to ground me from seeing Blaine ever again. Carole would lose all respect for me. Grace wouldn't want me to braid her hair and dress her up anymore. The new baby would grow up hating me.

I hurried to catch up to Blaine only to see him standing over a conflicted Sarah and a blushing Puck.

~~~~~GLEE~~~~~

Sarah's Point of View

Puck brushed the hair out of my face after we danced to Love Shack, "How's your Valentine's Day so far?"

I giggled, "Wonderful."

Puck nodded and smiled as he grabbed his pop and took a sip, "This might be the best Valentine's Day ever."

"Really?" I smirked.

"Really," Puck said quietly as he leaned in and kissed me.

We pulled apart after a minute to see Blaine standing over us.

"Hey," he greeted.

"Hey," Puck replied.

"It's good to see you," I smiled.

"Yeah, it's great not having to wear that eye patch," Blaine smiled back.

Puck and I nodded. I kinda wanted Blaine to leave so we could get back to what we were doing.

"I actually wanted to talk to you for a second, Puck," Blaine said. He sort of sounded hesitant.

"Sure, what's up?" Puck asked.

"I just wanted you to know that with everything going on in your life right now, I'm here if you need someone to talk to," Blaine told him.

My heart dropped, he knew about Puck and Grace. No one was supposed to know, we never said it out loud, it was just implied.

"What are you talking about?" Puck whispered.

"It probably sucks with your mom treating you like crap and now having to relocate your sister, just know that I'm here for you," Blaine smiled lightly.

Kurt walked up behind Blaine, "Hey guys." He looked out of breath and worried. He told Blaine about Puck and Grace!

I felt anger flow through my veins, but I just smiled and nodded at Blaine before turning to Kurt. How dare he! I know this past week has been crazy, but Puck and Grace deserve more than this.

Puck stood up and walked over to Finn and Rachel where he pulled Finn off to the side and started talking fast, frequently pointing over at us. His face was a light red color as if he was getting over a blushing attack.

I looked back up at Kurt, "Seriously?" I turned towards Blaine, "Thanks for offering help, the first thing you can do is promise no one else finds out about this. No one was supposed to find out in the first place, but that must not have occurred to Kurt."

I stood and turned on my heel towards my brother and boyfriend.

"If Kurt told Blaine, he had to have told someone else!" Puck whispered angrily to Finn.

They looked up at me as I approached. I put my arms out and pulled Puck in a hug as best as I could.

"Let's just get past this and forget about Blaine and Kurt," I said quietly as I pulled away.

"I can't believe he would do this," Finn groaned while hitting the wall behind him lightly.

"I never said that it was a secret, but I know that if anyone else found out, they'll go all glee on me," Puck muttered.

Blaine and Kurt walked over.

"Not in the mood for you Kurt," Finn told our step-brother.

"I'm sorry Finn and Sarah for disappointing you, but I'm mostly sorry to you Puck. Inside I knew you didn't want anyone knowing, but I went and told Blaine anyways," Kurt said.

"You can trust me, I promise I won't tell anyone," Blaine added.

Puck nodded, "Yeah, I know."

"What's going on?"

We all turned to see Rachel standing behind us with a confused expression on her face.

I groaned and put my head in Puck's chest. We're, or more likely Puck is, screwed. Rachel was going to tell everyone.

"It's nothing," Finn quickly said.

Blaine pulled Kurt away before he could say anything. Puck nodded at him then looked at Rachel, "It's fine Berry, we're good."

Rachel looked weary but nodded anyways, "We moved the wedding up to May," she finally smiled.

"That's great," I smiled back at her, "Can't wait."

"Yeah, we figured that we should start the married thing sooner than later," Finn told us.

Puck nodded, "We'll talk to you guys later," he pulled me over to one of the corner booths.

I moved as close to him as I could in the booth. Puck's arms automatically went around me and his chin rested on my head while mine went against his chest.

"This is so crazy," Puck whispered.

"I know," I whispered back.

Puck sighed and pulled away, holding me at an arm's distance. His hand ran over my hair and ended on the locket where he grasped it lightly, "Let's deal with this tomorrow," he said quietly before looking up at me.

I nodded, "Of course. What do you want to do?"

Puck smirked, "Let's get back to what we were doing before Blaine came and ruined the moment."

I smiled and leaned forward to receive a soft kiss. One of Puck's hands went in my hair while the other went on my waist. My own slid down his chest before going back up and settling on his shoulders.

"Excuse me?"

Puck and I pulled away and looked at who had interrupted us. Sugar stood at the end of the table with her hands on her hips.

"Yeah?" Puck asked since I couldn't talk from lack of air.

"Would you two mind doing that somewhere else? I know it's Valentine's Day, but this is my party and you should dance instead," Sugar stated.

I nodded, "Sure, we'll go dance," I smiled at her before grabbing Puck's hand and pulling him out of the booth.

We stood up and were about to follow Sugar to the dance floor when I changed direction and pulled Puck to the bathroom.

"What are we doing?" Puck chuckled as I pushed us through the door.

I ignored him and walked to the sink and mirror. I stared at myself and the hair that Kurt worked so hard on doing before I reached up and started pulling out the bobby pins.

"Sarah? What are you doing? Didn't Kurt spend, like, an hour doing that?" Puck asked while stepping forward.

"It kind of hurts and besides, Kurt doesn't deserve to look at my hair like this after what he's done," I stated as I pulled out another bobby pin, "Can you help me? There's probably 20 in here and my arms are getting tired."

Puck nodded and walked forward. His hands and fingers were gentle against my head as he tried to undue the pins. I leaned back against him and sighed. My arms fell to my sides since they were starting to fall asleep from lack of blood flow.

"What the heck?" Puck muttered, "Why do you need so much crap in your hair? You look fine when you're all normal."

"It's just Kurt," I giggled, "He doesn't have his own long hair to do, so he does mine, and now that Grace lives with us, hers."

Puck groaned, "If I have to do this for Grace too, I will be even angrier at Kurt than I already am."

I laughed and reached my hands up to help him. After another minute, we had managed to get all the bobby pins out of my hair. My chocolate curls fell down a little past my shoulders.

"That feels so much better," I smiled as I ran my hand through my hair.

"What do you want me to do with these?" Puck asked, referring to the 20 plus bobby pins in his hand.

"You can just leave them here," I said while turning around.

"I'm sorry, but you look so much better with your hair down," Puck said softly while twirling my hair in his fingers.

The door opened and Quinn walked through.

"Am I walking in on something?" she asked wearily.

"Nope, just detangling Sarah's hair," Puck smiled at her.

Quinn eyed the amount of bobby pins on the sink counter and smirked, "Yeah, Kurt went a little overboard with those."

"We'll leave you to the bathroom," I said while grabbing Puck's hand and walking out to the party.

We headed towards where everyone was dancing. Puck spun me around and I laughed.

"Hey, you changed your hair," Rachel said as she and Finn danced their way over to us.

I shrugged, "It was starting to hurt."

Rachel nodded and Finn grabbed her hand and spun her around as well. The four of us laughed and talked the rest of the night that we spent at Breadsticks.

~~~~~GLEE~~~~~

Puck ran his fingers through my hair while we sat on the couch in the living room. We drove home with Finn and Rachel, leaving Kurt to drive Finn's car. After dropping off Rachel, we went home to find Grace asleep on the couch with Mom and Burt on either side of her. While Puck carried Grace downstairs to put her to bed, Finn and I filled our parents in on everything that had happened at the beginning of the party. To say Mom and Burt were disappointed would be an understatement, they said we needed to have a 'family meeting' as soon as Kurt came home.

"Where's Kurt?" Burt asked to himself for probably the fifth time.

As if on cue, Kurt walked through the front door. He paused at the sight of us all in the living room still in our dress clothes, "What's going on?"

"Sit down, we're having a meeting," Mom told him.

Kurt nodded and sat on the armchair across from us, "Is something wrong?"

"You're a betrayer!" Finn finally shouted.

"Finn, calm down," Mom scolded, "But Kurt, yes, you didn't have the right to tell Blaine about Noah and Grace."

Kurt looked at Burt and Mom before turning to Puck, "I apologized and I meant it, you said you trusted Blaine."

"And the more I thought about it, the more I started to understand Finn and Sarah's side better than my own," Puck said through his teeth, "My sister deserves better than to have her life out in the open for all to see, especially when it sucks as bad as it does."

"Your sister, or you?" Kurt shot back.

I growled and Puck put his hand on my shoulder.

"You know what?" Finn yelled and pushed off the couch. Kurt cowered back in his chair.

Puck stood and grabbed Finn before he could lunge at Kurt.

"Everyone calm down!" Burt yelled.

Puck and Finn sat back down while Kurt sat up a little straighter and smoothed down his hair.

"What Kurt did was wrong," Burt started. Kurt opened his mouth to interrupt, but Burt put his hand up, "But Finn, you cannot kill him," Finn's face contorted in anger and he shook his head.

"I'm actually surprised Noah isn't as angry as he is," Mom said softly.

"Don't worry, I'm seething," Puck muttered.

I put my hand on his arm and squeezed softly.

We all sat staring at each other for another ten minutes in silence. Eventually, Mom stood up and walked to her bedroom with Burt right behind her. Kurt took a deep breath and left to change as well.

"Blaine won't tell anyone," Finn said quietly.

"I know," Puck replied.

"Do you think anyone else knows?" I asked.

"I don't think Rachel does, she would have said something if she did," Finn told us.

"What does it matter?" Puck groaned, "Everyone's going to find out anyways. Quinn's probably going to be mad that I didn't say anything to her. Artie will wonder why he didn't figure it out. Shelby will be pretty concerned."

We sat in silence again for another few minutes before I stood up, "We should probably go to bed," I said softly.

Puck and Finn nodded and the three of us went downstairs. Grace was passed out on her bed and Kurt looked asleep. Puck and Finn started changing while I paused before deciding it didn't matter and just slipped off my dress.

"Hot," I heard Puck whisper.

I rolled my eyes and slipped my shirt on quickly and turned around, "Oh shut up," I smirked.

"No, it's fine by me, go ahead and be shirtless" Puck smiled and walked closer.

"You guys are weird," Finn said softly while climbing into his bed.

"You and Rachel are weirder," Puck retorted as he pulled me down on our bed.

I laughed and curled into Puck's side as his arms wrapped around me.

"Whatever, we're getting married," Finn muttered.

"We'll get married, when we're older and better prepared," Puck said back.

"Alright, let's go to bed," I said, stopping this before it could get worse.

"Happy Valentine's Day Sarah," Puck whispered in my ear, "I love you."

"I love you too Puck," I whispered.

~~~~~GLEE~~~~~

A/N: I hope you enjoyed. I swear I'm not a Kurt hater, sorry if it comes off that way. It seems like you guys like certain chapters more than others, so is there something that you'd like to see happen? Since I'm almost at On My Way, there will be a lot of free space where I can say whatever for a month. Next chapter involves some dress shopping and I think one more person will find out what's going on. PLEASE REVIEW with any questions, comments, concerns, or suggestions! They're much appreciated and always welcome!

~~~~~GLEE~~~~~

Ace5492 - Thanks!

~~~~~GLEE~~~~~

Sneak Peak: Everyone stopped moving like we were caught doing something wrong. Finn and Puck paused their game of Mario Kart. Kurt looked up from his phone call with an open mouth.

Don't worry, it won't be all drama next chapter.