Never Forgotten Past

Last Time: Finn and Sarah dealt with their dad's birthday with the help of Puck and Rachel. Sarah's old friends called and asked for a double date that she accepted despite Puck being against it. Finn and Puck realized they owe their hero more than they thought. And that's what you missed on Never Forgotten Past.

Disclaimer: I don't own Glee or any songs that I may put in here.

Mixing of Two Opposites

Sarah's Point of View

I pulled up in the driveway and smiled, "I did it! I drove to school and home!" I looked at Puck and sighed, "It wasn't that bad."

Puck opened his eyes and let go of the handle above the door, "I'm sorry, it's just, I usually drive to school, for you know, safety reasons."

I glared at him and hit his arm lightly, "I hate you."

Puck smirked and brought my head closer to his, "Love you too," he kissed me softly, "I am sorry."

I smiled against his lips, "You can make it up to me," I whispered before pulling him as close as possible against me.

"No he won't."

We pulled apart and looked towards the driver's side window to see Burt standing there watching us. I forgot that I had the window down, meaning he had heard us.

I blushed, "Sorry."

Burt nodded, "Just get out."

Puck and I nodded and got out of the car. We followed Burt up the steps and into the house.

Mom looked up from her book in the living room and smiled, "How was school you two?"

"Great," I smiled, "I got an A on my Spanish test."

Mom's smile widened, "That's great, honey, I'm proud of you. What about you, Noah? What did you get?"

I felt Puck shift next to me, "I...um...well, you know, I don't speak Spanish or write it."

Mom's smile fell slightly and Burt looked up from the newspaper, "What are you talking about Puckerman?"

The front door opened and Finn, Kurt, and Grace walked through.

"Oh, you know what, it doesn't matter," Puck smiled lightly and started walking away.

Burt put his arm out, "Not so fast kid, you live here, you tell us your grades."

"What's going on?" Finn asked.

"Noah, are you in trouble?" Grace added in.

Puck looked at them then back at Burt and Mom, "I...um, like I said, I'm American."

"That makes no sense," Kurt scoffed.

"Noah," Mom sighed and stood up carefully. She walked towards me and Puck and put her hands on the sides of his face, "What did you get on the Spanish test?"

Puck looked at me for help, but I had no idea what he got on the test so I didn't know what to do. Mr. Martinez handed it out at the end of class and as soon as Puck got his, he left the room without a word.

"I got a D+," Puck muttered and looked at the ground.

Mom and Burt sighed at pretty much the same time, "Noah," Mom said softly.

"I'm sorry, I really did try, honest," Puck told her.

"Well, then maybe you should get tutoring or something," Burt suggested.

"I could help you out," Finn added.

Everyone turned towards him with wide eyes.

"Even I know that's a stupid idea," Grace said.

Kurt laughed, "I'll help you, Puck."

"What's your grade in the class now?" Burt asked Puck.

Puck ran a hand over his head, "I would guess C range."

"That's not bad," I smiled, "So are we done here? Because I was texting Liz today in class and she said her and Aiden will meet us at 4:30 at Breadstix, so me and Puck have to get ready."

Puck gave me a look, "Fine, but I hope it's not going to be long."

"Noah actually has to do his homework before you guys go out," Mom said.

"What?" Puck and I asked at the same time.

"Mom, that's not fair," I argued, "He has to go."

"After his homework. He's not going to be able to get in to college with Cs," Mom said softly.

"What if I'm not going to college? Then I don't have to do my homework. And besides, it's just Spanish, not like I'm going to need it," Puck told her.

"Yeah, I'm on their side," Finn announced, "I'm not going to college either, so we should just be aloud to do whatever."

"I'm going to college," I said to Finn, "But that's over two years away."

Mom and Burt exchanged a look before looking back at us, "Everyone out except the two non-college goers," Burt said.

"Don't ground him, Liz will kill me if he's not there tonight," I told Mom before heading to my room. I grabbed Puck's backpack as I passed, maybe I could start some of his homework for him.

I was about to close my bedroom door when someone's hand stopped it, "What are you doing with the backpack?"

I turned to see Kurt standing in my doorway and sighed, "What are you talking about?"

Kurt walked into my room, tapping Puck's backpack on the way, "Are you thinking about doing Puck's homework?"

I sat on my bed and watched Kurt look at my pictures, "Why does it matter?"

Kurt sighed and sat on my desk chair, "Because you'll get in trouble if you do."

"We only have one class together, so none of the teachers would be able to notice," I told him.

Kurt stood up and put his hand out, "Hand it over."

I hugged the backpack closer to me, "No, I'm not letting Puck miss this date tonight."

"Sarah, I'm sorry. I'll make sure he gets it done, now give me the backpack," Kurt argued and took a step closer.

"Kurt, please, let me do the homework, I don't have any tonight so I'll just do his," I moved back on my bed away from Kurt.

Kurt groaned and grabbed the backpack. We started tugging it back and forth when the door opened.

"What are you guys doing?" Grace asked.

I let go of the backpack, sending Kurt back a few steps, "Just...messing around."

"Oh, ok," Grace smiled and walked in farther.

"I'll see you two later," Kurt said and walked out of the room.

I sighed and looked at Grace, "What's up?"

"Can you help me with my math homework?" she asked.

I smiled, "Of course."

~~~~~GLEE~~~~~

I grabbed Puck's hand as he pushed the door to Breadstix open, "Thanks," I smiled up at him while walking through.

Puck nodded and walked in behind me.

I sighed and pulled him to the side of the restaurant, "I know you don't want to be here, but can you at least pretend that this is all bearable? Please, for me?"

Puck nodded and bent down to kiss me softly, "Sure," he stood up and smirked slightly, "I think your friends are already here."

I turned around to see Liz and Aiden waving at us. I laughed softly and dragged Puck over to them. They looked the same as when I left, except for a few minor things. Liz still had her long, auburn hair, yet this time it had a purple streak in it instead of the green one. Her hazel eyes were magnified by her purple glasses as she bounced up and down in her seat. Aiden's dark brown eyes were filled with excitement despite looking embarrassed at Liz. His short hair was just as black and messy as it was when he closed my car door in September.

I stopped at the front of the table, "Hey," I said softly.

Liz laughed, "Hey," she stood up and hugged me, "I've missed you so much."

"I know, it's been so long," I smiled and pulled back, "Hey Aiden."

"Hey Sarbear," Aiden chuckled and pulled me into a hug.

I hugged Aiden back, but couldn't miss the audible growl from Puck behind us. Aiden held me closer to him, "Off Aiden," I said.

"One more minute," Aiden muttered.

Liz slapped him on the back of his head, "You're with me now, remember?"

"Right," Aiden groaned and stepped away, "I'm with you, not Sarah."

I giggled softly, "I thought you learned your lesson."

Aiden sat in the booth and rubbed the side of his face, "Tried to forget about that."

Liz and I laughed, "But it brought us all together," Liz smiled as she slid in next to him.

"Wait, your the guy that Sarah slapped and then ended up with no more boyfriends?" Puck asked.

Aiden glared at me, "Yeah, that's me."

"Sorry," I mouthed and sat across from them, "Um, you guys, this is," I looked up at Puck, maybe I should just call him Noah, it might be easier for Aiden and Liz, "Noah Puckerman, my boyfriend. Noah, this is Aiden Gardel and Elizabeth Corey."

Puck raised his eyebrows at what I called him, but sat down next to me, "Nice to meet you two."

"Call me Liz," Liz smiled. She turned to me and raised her eyebrows, "Wow," she mouthed before looking down at her lap and nodding her head, our little code for 'get out your phone so I can tell you a secret.'

"How old are you? Like, what grade are you in?" Aiden asked Puck.

"Aiden," Liz looked up from her phone and glared at her boyfriend, "You don't just ask someone that."

Aiden nodded and looked down, "Sorry." Wow, she really has him trained now.

"Nah, it's ok," Puck chuckled, "I'm 18 and a senior at McKinley."

I noticed Liz take in a breath and start typing faster on her phone. I put my head in my hands, I probably should have told her.

"What chair are you now in band, Sar?" Aiden asked.

I groaned softly and looked up. I was about to tell him I wasn't in band anymore when Puck cut in.

"She's not in band, she only plays the guitar," he ended with a smile at me, "But, she's an amazing singer."

Liz put her phone away and looked up, "Noah, did you just say that Sarah's not in band and sings?" she asked slowly.

I bit my lip, this was not good, not at all. Liz was going to hate me.

"Yeah, I never knew she was in band and am pretty sure she's not in the class, but she's in glee. We both are. We've done a few duets. Are you saying you've never heard her sing?" Puck looked at me and wide eyes.

"Are you saying you've never heard her play her flute?" Aiden countered back.

Everyone stared at me and I felt my phone vibrate. Now might not be a great time to look at it, they all needed an explanation. I looked at Liz and Aiden first, "I'm not in band anymore, I figured I'd not play and try and get my life back on track," I turned towards Puck, "When I left to go live with Grandma, I took up the flute and was actually pretty good at it."

"So your saying instead of playing flute and being happy at something that you're great at, you decided to just not play?" Liz asked.

"No, Lizzie, she's saying she quit the flute and took up singing instead," Aiden glared at me.

"Hey, what's so wrong with her singing? I think that's a better choice than playing in band," Puck defended me.

"Ok, one second," Aiden told Puck.

"Whoa, ok, hold on," I put my hand on each of their arms, "Don't fight. I'm sorry I quit band," Liz and Aiden glared, "I'm sorry that I didn't tell you I was in band," Puck's hard expression towards Aiden softened as he turned towards me.

"It's ok," Puck said softly.

I smiled at him, "Thank you."

"If I wasn't so mad at you right now, I'd think you two were completely adorable," Liz scoffed, "Now Sarah," she motioned down towards her lap.

The waitress came, "Hi, can I get you anything to drink? Or are you ready to order?"

I looked down at my phone: OMG! Why didn't you tell me you were dating an incredibly hot guy! Did he just say he's a SENIOR! :D spill on how you met

"Sarah," Puck nudged my shoulder, "You want to order or should I just do it myself?"

"Um," I looked down at the menu and Puck sighed.

"She's just going to get her usual, lemonade and the spaghetti and meatballs," Puck told the waitress.

I smiled at her, "Thanks," I looked at Puck, "Thank you."

"No problem," Puck smirked and it took all I had not to kiss him right there.

"So, you're a senior, Sarah's a sophomore, how'd you meet?" Liz asked.

Puck and I looked at each other and shrugged, "We've always known each other," Puck told her.

"He was my best friend before I moved," I said.

Liz nodded with a smile, "Cute."

"I was her first kiss," Aiden muttered.

"No you weren't," I laughed, "Puck was."

"Who's Puck?" Liz asked at the same time Aiden asked, "What kind of name is that?"

"I mean, Noah. Noah was my first kiss," I stumbled.

"Didn't you say your last name was Puckerman?" Liz asked Puck.

He nodded, "Yeah, well, most people call me Puck, but you can call me whatever you want, doesn't matter."

I snorted, at the beginning of 'changing his name' he hated it when people called him Noah, which is why I thought he was just letting people call him whatever.

The waitress came with our drinks and passed them out. Aiden grabbed his and looked at me, "So, what have you been up to lately Sarah?"

~~~~~GLEE~~~~~

I wiped the tears from my eyes and took a sip from my lemonade. This was honestly one of the best double dates I had ever gone on. We could not stop laughing the whole time, at least; me, Liz, and Aiden couldn't stop laughing. Puck was just nodding along, smiling, not saying much. I felt a little bad for him, but I tried to ignore the feeling as I shared stories and remembered old one with Liz and Aiden.

"Oh my gosh! You got your ears pierced!" Liz exclaimed when she noticed the aquamarine jewels in my ears.

I laughed lightly and touched the earrings, "Noah got them for me for my birthday."

Puck gave me a side smile before going back to playing with his apple pie. I bit my lip to try and put my hand on his knee, squeezing it softly.

"And you didn't freak?" Aiden laughed.

I glared at him, "No, I was fine. Why would you think I'd freak?"

"Because remember when you went to get your ears pierced the first time and freaked out at the lady?" Aiden teased.

I blushed, but laughed all the same, "Even though I didn't get my ears pierced then, at least I didn't get the wrong one pierced."

Liz laughed harder and my smile widened at Aiden's blush. Suddenly, I felt movement next to me, so I stopped laughing and looked to my side, Puck was gone. I bit my lip and noticed his retreating figure heading away through the restaurant.

"I'm going to the bathroom," I said softly and stood up.

Liz saw Puck walking into the bathroom and smiled at me, "Have fun," she winked.

I rolled my eyes and walked as fast as I could to the men's room. I paused before pushing the door open and going in, "Puck?" I whispered.

The toilet flushed and Puck walked out of the stall, "What are you doing in here? You realize that most guys go to the bathroom in those right there," he pointed towards the urinals.

I rolled my eyes and walked towards him, "Why'd you come in here?"

Puck pushed past me to wash his hands, "What did I just say most guys do in here? I went to the bathroom."

I stared at him through the mirror, "Puck, what's wrong?"

Puck groaned and turned around, "Why does it matter?"

"Because today kinda sucked for you with failing your Spanish test and Mom and Burt getting on your case about college and crap and then I bring you here where you obviously don't want to be and-"

Puck cut me off in a kiss, "Would you just be quiet?" he muttered and pushed me against the sink.

I melted against him, "I'm so, so sorry."

"I told you, none of that matters," Puck sighed and kissed my neck.

I felt my breathing accelerate, "Let's go home, come on, please."

"Your friends," Puck said.

"Liz will understand," I breathed, "Aiden needs a wake up call, I'm yours."

"Yes, that's right," Puck lifted me up onto the sink and continued kissing me.

"Seriously, Sarah? I thought you were better than this?"

I pulled away from Puck in time to see Aiden leaving the bathroom. I groaned and set my forehead against Puck's shoulder, "Knew that would happen."

"I'm sorry, I shouldn't have done that," Puck whispered.

"It's not your fault," I told him as he lifted me off the sink.

We walked back in the restaurant and I breathed a sigh of relief at the sight of Liz sitting in the booth and Aiden standing over her. They looked like they were arguing softly.

"Hey," I smiled.

"Hi," Liz replied.

Aiden played with a stray thread on his shirt and didn't look up at me.

"Can I talk to you?" Puck asked Aiden.

He looked up in surprise, "Um, sure."

They walked over to the side of the room and started talking softly. I slid in across from Liz.

"Aiden tell you what he walked in on?" I asked.

Liz smirked, "What do you think? He came out and demanded that we leave."

I smiled and played with my bracelet, "He's pretty mad."

Liz snorted, "Obviously, but don't worry, I'm not mad. I just want to know the details."

I laughed, "What details?"

"How great of a kisser is he? Have you guys done it yet?"

I felt my cheeks turn red as my face grew hot.

"Oh my God, you have!" Liz exclaimed, "You have to tell me! Please tell me you've made sure you can't get pregnant?"

I shrugged, "I...I don't know...I mean...It's kinda personal." I really don't think she'd be happy to know of our little 'incident' earlier this year.

"Hey, I'm sorry Sarah," Aiden said as he and Puck approached us, "I shouldn't have gotten mad at you."

I stood up, "It's no problem, really."

Aiden smiled and gave me a soft, one-armed hug, "We're good?"

I laughed softly, "Yeah, we're good."

I got Puck's eye and realized he noticed my red face and neck. 'You ok?' he mouthed. I nodded as I stepped away from Aiden and grabbed his hand.

"I guess we should get going," Liz said as she stood next to me.

Aiden nodded and wrapped an arm around her shoulders, "It was great seeing you again Sarah. Nice meeting you Noah."

"You too," Puck stuck his hand out and despite being a little hesitant, Aiden shook it.

The four of us started leaving the restaurant when the two people that I absolutely didn't want to see tonight came through the door.

"Daddy!" Beth screamed from Shelby's arms.

Puck and I froze. Puck knew that I didn't want Aiden and Liz knowing about Beth or earlier this year, even if I never said it.

"Did that little girl just call you 'Daddy'?" Liz asked.

"Um...no...well yeah, but I must just look like her dad or something. I don't know who she is, never seen her before," Puck said as he tried to avoid looking at his daughter.

"Sar!" Beth yelled over Shelby's shoulder as the latter paid for their takeout.

I winced and leaned farther into Puck's shoulder. This could not be happening.

"How do you two know her?" Aiden asked.

Shelby chose that moment to turn around. She smiled at us and walked closer, "Hi guys," she paused at Puck's wide eyes and, what I'm guessing was, my look of terror.

"How does your daughter know Sarah and Noah?" Liz blatantly asked Shelby.

"They're her babysitters," Shelby didn't miss a beat. It was if she had to say it many times before. I wonder if her neighbors have asked about us. Puck and I breathed a sigh of relief.

"Then why does she call Noah 'Daddy'?" Aiden replied.

"I'm not married, so Beth doesn't have a father figure, making Noah the only male in her life. She just calls him 'Daddy' seeing as she has no one else to say it to," Shelby explained.

Puck and I nodded along, it could actually be true.

"Oh, ok, well she's very pretty," Liz smiled before grabbing Aiden's hand and walking out the door.

Puck and I smiled at Shelby as we followed them to the parking lot. Liz gave me a quick hug and a 'Promise to call or else' before climbing into the car. Aiden did the same and Puck and I watched as they drove off.

"Ready to go home and finish what we started?" Puck smiled down at me.

I nodded and climbed into his truck, "Of course, but first, I have two questions."

"Shoot," Puck started the car.

"What did you and Aiden talk about? He was so calm and normal when you guys came back," I asked.

Puck smirked, "I told him to suck it up, you're my girlfriend, not his."

I gasped softly, "You did not."

"You're right, I didn't," Puck chuckled, "But, I did tell him that I love you more than anything and that he should let me love you without him interfering. I also said that you might be upset or something, so he should go easy on you," he said quietly.

"Why would I be upset?" I asked. I couldn't think of a reason where Puck would think I was upset about something.

"It's nothing," Puck muttered.

"No," I argued, "What is it? Why would I be upset?"

"I just thought since you throw up everyday that you should be taken easy and stuff," Puck whispered.

"It's not a big deal," I said through my teeth, "Just a little throw up."

Puck sighed and ran a hand over his face, "Do you understand what it could mean though?"

"No!" I exclaimed, "I'm not sick!"

"I know! But you're having morning sickness!"

I felt my heart drop at the same time my hand went down to my stomach, "What?" I whispered.

Puck was breathing hard, "You have mood swings every two seconds. You throw up everyday between seven and twelve."

"I'm not fat," I said quietly.

"I know," Puck whispered, "But look at your mom, she didn't get fat until a couple weeks ago."

I turned and looked out the window, blinking back tears.

"Sarah, I'm not saying it to be mean," Puck said softly, "I'm just saying, maybe you should get checked out. I don't want anything bad to happen to you...or the possible baby."

He put his hand on my shoulder, but I hit it off, "Don't touch me."

Puck's hand left and instead turned up the radio. We sat in silence until Puck drove up in our driveway. Stiffly, we walked into the house.

As the door closed, I turned and looked at Puck's feet, "I don't want you to be in my room tonight."

"Ok," Puck nodded.

I walked past him into my room. Slowly, I put my pajamas on and climbed under my covers. As my head hit the pillows, tears ran down my face. Why would Puck say that? I'm not pregnant. I can't be. But I could be. No, he's wrong.

My door opened, "Bad date?" Mom asked.

"No, it was great. A lot of fun," I muttered as I flipped over towards the wall.

"Are you telling the truth?" Mom sat on the edge of my bed.

"Yes Mom, the part I'm upset about was the drive home," I said as another round of tears came.

Mom ran a hand through my hair and down my back, "Want to talk about it?"

I shook my head, "No."

Mom sighed and kissed the top of my head before standing up, "I love you. Always have, always will."

I smiled at Dad's old words, "Love you too."

I heard the door close and flipped onto my stomach. I screamed into the pillows. This could not be happening.

~~~~~GLEE~~~~~

I flipped my eyes open and looked at the clock with a groan. 12:23. About three hours since I got in bed, yet three hours without sleep. I had no idea why. That's wrong, I did. At first I thought it was because I was mad at Puck. And then I figured that wasn't it, it was the fact that he said what he did. But no, that wasn't what was completely keeping me up, it was how I was alone for the first time in weeks at night.

I rolled over and sat up, maybe I could just lay on the floor in the boys room by Puck's bed. It'd almost be the same. Not really, but if it gets me to go to sleep, I'm not complaining. I could wake him up, though, and pray he doesn't hate me.

I quietly stepped out of my room and towards the stairs. I walked upstairs, trying not to make any noises. I went straight to Puck's bed, past a log-like Kurt and a snoring Finn.

"Noah," I shook his shoulder.

"Grace," Puck muttered and turned over, "What do you want?"

"I'm not Grace," I told him.

Puck opened his eyes, "Why'd you call me 'Noah'?"

I paused, "I guess it just stuck from saying it all night."

"Are you ok?" Puck whispered and sat up.

I bit my lip and sat on the edge of his bed, "Is there room for me in there?"

Puck smirked, but nodded and moved over, "Come on."

I breathed a sigh of relief and smiled, "Thank you."

His bed was warm and worn in. The dark blue sheets felt soft against my legs. His pillows had curves in them from his head.

Puck's arm wrapped around my waist, "I was actually thinking about going downstairs and sleeping in your bean bag chair just to be closer to you since I couldn't sleep."

"I'm sorry about freaking out on you," I stated.

Puck took a deep breath, "I shouldn't have said what I did."

"No," I shook my head against his bare shoulder, "You just said what's been on your mind."

Puck sighed and nodded his head, "Ok."

I turned my face into his chest, "I love you."

"I love you too," Puck replied and ran a hand down my hair before ending it on the small of my back.

~~~~~GLEE~~~~~

A/N: So now Sarah knows what's been on Puck's mind, but first, what do you think of the new characters? Want more of them? Or should I just leave them here? And within the next chapter, the sex of Carole and Burt's baby will be revealed. One thing though, I haven't completely decided on what I want it to be. Your opinion, boy or girl? And, just wondering even though I already decided, but should this baby have a tiny niece or nephew? I thought Dance With Somebody was ok, the music was really good though. Alright, so PLEASE REVIEW with any questions, comments, concerns, or suggestions! I love each and every one!

~~~~~GLEE~~~~~

TheAwkwardTurtle13 - Haha, well, you never know what could happen.

Ace5492 - Thank you!

FinchelFan728 - His was the last chapter, but I'll try and fit another one in soon. :)

REDROBINS007 - I know! I'm still singing the songs! And you're right, she looked amazing. I hope this is a soon enough update :)

~~~~~GLEE~~~~~

Sneak Peak: All breathing stopped in the room as the soon-to-be new parents looked down at the paper in their hands.

I'll take votes on boy or girl! :)