Never Forgotten Past

Last Time: Puck and Sarah went on a double date with Sarah's old friends. Throughout the night, some of Sarah's secrets were revealed from both sides. On the drive home, Puck told Sarah he thinks she's pregnant, making Sarah upset and angry. She forgave him later that night when she realized she needed him more than she thought. And that's what you missed on Never Forgotten Past.

Disclaimer: I don't own Glee or any songs that I may put in here.

The Different Directions To Take

Kurt's Point of View

"So if this means shopping, then this means...?" I asked Puck. We were upstairs at our desk where I was helping him with his Spanish homework.

Puck groaned, "Why do I care?"

"Because otherwise you won't pass high school, now come on," I urged.

"I don't know," Puck leaned back in the chair, "Center. As in shopping center."

"That's," I sighed, then stopped, "Right. That's right."

Puck looked up, "Seriously? Awesome," he smiled and I sort of understood how he could get so much control over Sarah when he gave her the same one.

There was a knock on the wall and the two of us turned around. Carole stood at the top of the stairs, "You're dad and I are going to the doctor's. We'll be back in probably an hour or so."

"Are you finding out the sex of the baby?" I asked.

Carole nodded with a smile, "And you're all going to be the first to know after the appointment."

I got up and gave her a hug, "I can't wait."

Puck came over and did the same, "Good luck Ms. Carole."

"Thanks you two, I'll see you later," Carole turned to leave, but stopped and looked back at us, "Finish your Spanish homework and then you can go downstairs. I want your next test grade to be better, Noah."

He nodded and looked down, "Ok."

Carole left and I could hear her go in Sarah's room. I turned towards Puck, "Ready to get back to work?"

Puck grimaced and I laughed before heading back to the desk.

~~~~~GLEE~~~~~

I walked into the living room and sat next to Sarah, who was on her laptop on the couch, "What cha looking at?" I asked.

Sarah snapped her laptop closed, "Nothing."

I raised my eyebrows and reached towards the small computer, "Doesn't seem like 'nothing.'"

"Well, it is," Sarah moved away from me.

Puck walked into the room and sat on the other side of Sarah, "Hey babe."

Sarah smiled and leaned into him, "Hey. How was your tutoring session?"

Puck barked a laugh, "Joyful."

I smirked at him then turned towards Sarah, "It was great bonding time."

Sarah nodded with a smile, "I hope this means your grade will go up," she said to her boyfriend.

He ran a hand over his head, "Yeah, me too. Next time I fail a test, I'm grounded. No dates. No sleeping in the same bed as you, not even the same room."

Sarah looked at me then back at Puck, "You're kidding, right?"

Puck shook his head, "Nope, only comfort is Finn gets the same punishment."

"This sucks," Sarah whined and leaned back. She turned to Puck, "I will kill you if you fail another test."

Puck chuckled softly, "I wouldn't doubt you would."

My phone buzzed and I pulled it out. Hey. Anything going on? ~ Blaine

Nope, just waiting to find out if I'm having a sister or brother ~ Kurt

"Who ya texting?" Sarah asked with a knowing smile.

"Nobody," I smiled back.

"Is it Blaine?" Puck teased as he put an arm around Sarah.

"Maybe," I replied at the same time Sarah said, "Don't ever use that tone to another guy again."

Puck smiled down at her before standing up and throwing her over his shoulder, "Don't tell me what to do."

I rolled my eyes at them as Puck took off down the hallway despite Sarah's protests. I turned back to my phone.

Can't wait to find out :) excited? ~ Blaine

Of course! I can't wait to dress her in little outfits ~ Kurt

She might be a HE though ~ Blaine

Never know ;) ~ Kurt

Finn walked into the room, "Please tell me that Puck had Grace over his shoulder and not my sister."

"Sorry," I smirked.

"They're so gross," Finn muttered as he sat on the chair flipped the tv on.

"Trouble in paradise?" I asked.

Finn shook his head, "Rachel has a cold, so she's sleeping as much as possible to get rid of it."

"Sounds like the future Mrs. Berry," I nodded.

"When's Mom and Burt coming home?" Finn asked.

I looked at the clock, "Any time now."

"Yeah, they're finding out right now if it's going to be a boy or a girl," Grace walked into the room, talking on the phone.

I smiled, she sounded so cute.

"I can't wait to be a big sister," Grace added in to her conversation.

Finn gave me a look of confusion. Grace was sort of acting like-

"Mom and Dad said if it was a girl, she could sleep in my room."

Finn groaned and put his head in his hands. I stood up and put my hand out, "Grace."

She looked up with wide eyes, "What?" she whispered.

"We need to talk," I whispered back.

"I have to go, my brother said so," Grace muttered. She set down the phone, "What?"

"Grace," Finn started, "I...um...well."

"What Finn is trying to ask is, what are you doing?" I said softly.

"Talking to my friend," Grace said with raised eyebrows, "What's wrong with that?"

"Nothing, it's what you were talking about that was wrong," Finn muttered.

"The baby?" Grace asked.

I bit my lip and tried to think of how to say this. Maybe Puck should talk to her.

"Do you think the baby's your's?" Finn bluntly asked.

I groaned, "Finn."

Grace sat down next to Finn on the couch, "Why would you think that?"

"Because you said you were going to be a big sister and you said 'Mom and Dad,'" Finn told her.

Grace's eyes widened and she stood up, "I'll see you guys later."

Finn caught her around the waist and pulled her down next to him. I sat next to Grace, "What did you do?"

Grace stared down at the ground, "I'll told Jenna, that girl that was on the phone, that me and Noah got adopted."

Finn nodded, "Oh, ok."

"No, Finn. We didn't adopt her," I told my step-brother. I turned to Grace, "Why would you lie? And don't say you didn't know, because you did."

"Everyone was talking about what their families are doing for spring break next week! They asked me what I was doing and I told them I didn't know because I'm not with my real family. Then they all laughed at me saying I was probably in some home or orphanage, so I told them I was adopted," Grace was crying now, "I'm sorry," she got up and ran away without an intervention from Finn. We winced as we heard a door slam.

"I had no idea," Finn muttered, "She's ten! How can they just make fun of her for not living with her 'real family'? Mom and Burt love her way more than her real parents ever did."

"People are mean, no matter what age," I said simply.

Finn stood up and started pacing, he kicked the chair, "She's like my sister, always has been, so when I find out some kids are giving her crap about not living in her house, well, I kinda want to hurt them."

"You can't hurt fourth graders, Finn, you'd get sent to juvie," I sighed. I know how Grace felt, she just wanted to stop it all, so she lied. The easy way out, but it could come back and hurt her.

"Juvie sucks, don't go there."

I looked up to see Sarah and Puck walking back in the room each looking slightly undone, with Sarah's hair loose compared to her earlier ponytail and the top of Puck's shirt unbuttoned. They sat on the love seat across from me.

"What was wrong with Grace?" Sarah asked.

Finn and I exchanged a look, not really knowing what to say.

"What did you do to her?" Puck stood angrily, "I'm not afraid to hurt you."

"We found out about a lie that Grace has been telling her fourth grade class," I told them.

"Oh," Puck sat back down, "Was it a good one?"

Sarah sent a disapproving look towards her boyfriend before turning to me, "What'd she say?"

"Everyone was laughing at Grace because she doesn't live with her mom and dad, so she told them she was adopted," Finn muttered.

Puck stood up again, this time so fast the love seat actually moved backwards a little, "I'm going to kill them."

"Kurt said we can't," Finn glared at me.

"I'm not letting you two go to jail over some bullying," I said.

Sarah pulled Puck down next to her, "Why don't you just go talk to her and tell her lying's not worth it or something like that?"

"If I'm going to talk to her, it's going to be about different ways to hurt people," Puck said sincerely.

The door opened and Carole and Dad walked through, "We know what we're having," Dad smiled.

"Where's Grace? I want you all to hear this at the same time," Carole added in.

"I'll go get her," Sarah stood and left the room.

"Is something wrong?" Carole asked.

"Some punks are bullying my sister," Puck muttered.

Dad's face went red and he shot me a glance, "Who do I have to hurt?"

Puck and Finn exchanged a smile at the proposition.

"You will not be hurting any ten year olds," Carole scolded, "Did she say why they were bullying her?"

"They thought it was funny that she didn't live with her real mom and dad. Prompting Grace to say she got adopted and doesn't live in one of the homes they were saying she did live in," I told her.

Carole nodded as Sarah and Grace walked back in. Grace ran over and buried her face in Puck's neck, but not before we could see the tear tracks down her cheeks and her red eyes. Sarah sat next to me with a sigh and Finn sat on her other side.

"Alright! Are you guys ready?" Carole smiled.

We all nodded and Grace turned to watch. She looked so upset, it was breaking my heart.

All breathing stopped in the room as the soon-to-be new parents looked down at the paper in their hands.

"According to the sonogram," Dad started, he paused and looked up with a smile, "We are having..."

"Please, you're killing me," Grace pleaded.

Everyone laughed. "I'll take over then," Carole smiled, "The newest addition to the Hudson-Hummel-Puckerman family is going to be a girl!"

"Yes!" Grace and Sarah yelled. They stood up to give each other a high five.

I smiled, "Just picture all the adorable dresses I can buy!"

"Another little sister? Cool," Finn said with a grin.

"Do you have names picked out?" Puck asked. He looked like he was trying to not be excited, but was failing at it.

"Actually, we want you guys to come up with a name," Carole said as she sat next to me.

"Let's start with some ideas," Dad sat in the chair.

I quickly grabbed out my phone to look up top 100 names.

Grace bounced down next to her brother, "Ariel! That's my favorite Disney princess!"

"Grace, you can't name a baby after a Disney princess, that's weird," Finn told her.

Sarah sat next to him with her back against Puck's legs, "Then what's you idea, oh great one?"

Finn shrugged, "When I thought Beth was mine, I wanted to name her Drizzle."

Puck gave him a look of terror, "You were going to name my daughter Drizzle? That's not a name!"

Sarah laughed, "It's Finn, would you expect anything else?"

"I like the name Isabella," I announced, "Not only is it the top girl name for 2010, but it's a pretty name with a good nickname too."

"Nope, not happening," Puck said with a shake of his head.

Sarah laughed and I looked at them, "Is there something wrong with the name Isabella?"

"Too close to Belle," Sarah giggled with a glance up at Puck.

"I had the idea first," Puck muttered, "That name is for my daughter, your sister can have a different name."

"You planned out your kids' names already?" I asked with a smirk.

Puck threw a pillow at me, "Whatever, just come up with a different name."

I nodded and looked back down at my phone. I let out a laugh, "The name Olivia means elf army."

Grace laughed, "I know a girl named Olivia, but she's really tall."

By now, Finn had his iPod out and was doing the same thing I was doing. Sarah and Grace each had a baby name book in their hands. Puck noticed Sarah's laptop and grabbed it.

Sarah looked up, "No!"

"What?" Puck asked with wide eyes.

Sarah bit her lip and looked around at us, who were all watching the two of them, "Um...well, it's just I was doing homework and don't want you to mess it up."

"I won't," Puck muttered as he flipped open the top. I noticed his eyes grow wide and face pale slightly at the screen.

"Is something wrong?" I asked before looking back at my own screen.

Puck cleared his throat, "Nope, everything's great."

I nodded and scrolled down the list. What was Sarah doing that had Puck freaked out? She was pretty protective of her laptop earlier.

Out of the corner of my eye, I could see Puck squeeze his legs around Sarah before he started typing on the computer.

"How's Emily?" Sarah asked.

Carole smiled, "That's a good one."

"Gabriella," Finn said.

Dad nodded, "Ella, that's pretty."

I smirked, never really thought I'd hear my dad say a name was pretty.

"Sophia," I looked at Puck, "Is that acceptable? Can I suggest that?"

Puck rolled his eyes, "Yeah, that's not on my list."

"You have a list?" Finn asked while Sarah laughed knowingly.

Puck glared at him, "You know what? Every name on my list is way better than Drizzle."

Finn glared back, "It's an interesting name."

"For a dog," Sarah said under her breath.

Everyone laughed while Finn blushed.

"Paige is a cute name," Grace said, "But it means page..."

Carole laughed, "How about we just go for names that sound nice, then worry about what they mean later?"

Grace nodded, "Ok."

"You haven't come up with a name yet Puck," Dad observed.

"Just making sure it's perfect," Puck told him.

Carole smiled, "I know we're having you guys come up with a name, but I like the name Summer."

Dad nodded, "I'm going to throw in the name Allie, short for Allison."

"Abigail," Puck announced and we all turned towards him, "But if you guys don't take it, it's going on my list."

Sarah looked up at him, "Triplets now?"

Puck shook his head, "She can be an extra."

"You guys are weird," Finn muttered.

"I like the name Samantha," Sarah told us, "We could call her Sammie."

Carole stood up, "These are all great. Could one of you write them down for me? Because I'm going to go take a nap."

"I'll do it!" Grace grabbed a piece of paper and started writing down all the names.

Dad stood as well, "I'm going to head into the shop to try and get a few things done."

I changed my screen from baby names to nursery ideas that would match Grace's purple room.

Finn's phone rang out with the song Faithfully, "Rachel's calling," he smiled before answering, "Hey Rach, Mom and Burt just came home from the doctor's...A girl...Yeah, we're all putting in names now...Fine," Finn pulled the phone away, "Rachel nominates Barbra."

I laughed, "The woman's an icon, but my baby sister's not going to be named after her."

Finn repeated my words to Rachel then looked up, "She said Ava then."

Grace nodded and put it down on the list. Finn got up and left the room to talk to Rachel.

"Grace, can I have a piece of paper? I'm making a list of things we'll need to make your room still look like your room, but with some baby stuff," I told the small brunette.

"Sure," Grace smiled and ripped out a piece of paper, "It can still be purple right?"

I laughed, "Of course."

"We need to talk...like now," Puck whispered in Sarah's ear.

She nodded and stood up, "Does anyone need anything?"

Grace and I shook our heads. Sarah grabbed Puck's hand and led him out of the room. They were starting to make me worried. I shook off the feeling and decided to focus on Grace right now.

"So, everyone in school thinks you're adopted?" I asked.

Grace looked up and blushed, "I'm sorry."

I patted the spot next to me, "Let's talk."

~~~~~GLEE~~~~~

Puck's Point of View

I closed Sarah's door behind me before sitting next to her on her bed, "You need to explain your laptop right now because that seriously scared the crap out of me."

"Before I bought a test or went to the doctor, I just wanted to make sure that I have symptoms and stuff," Sarah muttered.

I groaned and laid back so my legs were still hanging off the bed but my head was against the wall. I thought back to the screen when I first opened the computer, a picture of some pregnant lady with the heading Did This Happen To You? Before changing it to look at baby names, I actually scrolled down and read some of the stuff only to see Sarah had most of them, well, the ones that I knew of, some of that stuff is her business.

"What do we do now?" I asked.

Sarah laid back next to me, "I don't know, buy a test?"

"This sucks," I mumbled.

Sarah sat up real fast.

"Are you going to get sick?" I asked as I sat up.

"Do you not want me to be pregnant?"

I raised my eyebrows, "Like I said before, it's not ideal, but I'll take what life throws at me."

"Not ideal?" Sarah repeated.

"Sarah, what are you doing?" I sighed, I wasn't ready for the sudden mood swings, that's for sure.

"I thought months ago we said we'd be able to handle it and now you don't want to?" Sarah asked.

"You're twisting my words, I never said that," I begged.

"It sounds like that to me," Sarah stood up and faced me, "What if I am pregnant? Huh? What are you going to do? Beg me to get an abortion?"

"I never said that!" I yelled back. I groaned, I hate yelling at her, but she's being irrational.

"I'm scared! Do you not realize that?" Sarah asked as she started pacing the room.

"Yeah, I realize that. How do you think I feel?" I stood and grabbed her hand to stop her from making a rut in the carpet.

"Right now I think you feel like you don't want this baby," Sarah snapped and pulled her arms away.

I bit the inside of my mouth, not again, we can't fight like this again. Last time I ended with an icepack on my arm and a different address. "We don't even know if you're pregnant," I said softly.

"The chances are kind of high," Sarah said.

I looked at the ground and tried not to think that she was pregnant. It would ruin her life. She'd want to keep the kid, which I would prefer, but by the time the baby was born, she'd still be 16 in the middle of her junior year. The school would eat her alive. What would I do? I'm still not sure what I'm doing after this summer, but if I have a kid, I'd have to stay here.

"I need to go," Sarah whispered while walking to her desk.

I looked up to see her throw on her NorthFace, grab her keys, and her purse, "I'm going with you," I said.

Sarah shook her head, "I have to be by myself."

"I don't want you to be by yourself when you find out," I whispered and walked towards her, "Please, let me come with you."

"No, I'm still confused on how you feel about this whole thing and until I figure that out, I'm doing this alone," Sarah stepped past me and started for the door.

I grabbed her hand and pulled her against my chest, "Please."

Sarah hugged back for a second before pulling away, "I need to do this alone, trust me."

I watched her walk out of the room and groaned before kicking her beanbag chair. This could not be happening.

~~~~~GLEE~~~~~

Sarah's Point of View

I climbed into my car and buckled the seat belt. I took a deep breath and pulled out my phone. The number I wanted was right on top, they would be able to help me right now.

"Hello?"

"I need you to meet me at Target."

~~~~~GLEE~~~~~

A/N: It's a girl! I was really hoping you guys would want a girl, so I was really happy. But now the name...I know it's going to be a while, but which one did you like? Emily, Gabriella, Sophia, Paige, Summer, Allison, Abigail, Samantha, or Ava? At the beginning of the chapter, I know which one I wanted, but after a while, I changed my mind and now have no idea what I want her name to be. Anyone think Sarah's pregnant? It's revealed next chapter. Who do you think Sarah called after saying she was doing it alone? I've actually had this planned for a while, her calling this person and asking for help. Oh, their going on spring break in a few chapters, where should they go? Should it be just Finn, Kurt, Sarah, Puck, and Grace? Or should Burt and Carole come too? PLEASE REVIEW with any questions, comments, concerns, or suggestions! I love each and every one!

~~~~~GLEE~~~~~

TheAwkwardTurtle13 - I'll see how things turn out and stuff. They might be in a chapter in a while.

Ace5492 - Thanks for the support!

Madie - That was why I wanted the baby to be a girl!

FinchelFan728 - Thanks! I'm not a guy, so it's kinda hard, but I'm glad to know it's good!

RaeMarieM - Lol, I know. All the little dresses are so cute.

~~~~~GLEE~~~~~

Sneak Peak: I followed Sarah over to the pharmacy section and felt my heartbeat quicken. Now I understood what we were doing here.

Any idea on who's with Sarah?