It was just supposed to be coffee, but then the ambience music switched from generic soft pop to, of all things, Islands in the Stream. Blaine picked up the Kenny Rogers part right away, crooning to the best of his abilities. When Dolly cut in, Rachel pitched her voice in, doing her best to channel the diva.

All eyes of the Lima Bean were on them, and they fed on the attention. They were serenading and staring into each other's eyes soulfully, regardless of who they were actually dating. When they song ended, there was mixed applause and incredulous stares.