Fluttershy, as well as the rest of the ponies, were in complete and total shock. Why would Pinkie ask something that deep and personal? Especially to a shy pony like Fluttershy! They all understood Pinkie was outgoing and could be very strange at times, but this was far more than anypony had expected. Fluttershy stammered with a half-agape mouth. She was blushing heavily at the question.
"Pinkie!" Rarity snapped. "Why would you ask something so personal? How do you think Fluttershy feels about that?"
Pinkie examined her shy friend. She was still in complete shock.
"I don't know…" She now looked shamefully at the ground.
"I-It's alright Pinkie…" The butter-colored pegasus reassured. "I-if everypony else had to go through with their dare or question, then I will…"
Pinkie still felt guilt in the pit of her heart. "I-If you want me to I'll go first…"
Fluttershy looked up. "What do you mean?"
"I-I mean, if you would feel more comfortable with me telling you my fetish first, then I will."
Fluttershy smiled a little. "R-really..?"
Pinkie nodded. "It's the least I could do… Anyways, my secret fetish isn't too strange…Let me tell you the story. "

Pinkie thought back to the time she first discovered her fetish. It was the same year she lost her virginity. Yes, it was weird, but she never thought of it being too out there. She was just turning nineteen. She had only been working at Sugar Cube Corner for a couple years, and the Cakes hired a colt around her age soon after she started working there. His name was Ginger Snap. He had a light blue coat and a brown mane with a cute, freckled face. His cutie mark was a ginger bread man. Pinkie fell in love with him very quickly. They lasted more than a year, and it was Pinkie's nineteenth birthday when it happened.
Pinkie was working her usual shift helping to make the treats while Ginger Snap worked the cash register. She was mixing eggs, flour, water, vanilla, and butter into a large orange bowl with a wooden spoon. Her curly pink locks were tied back into a chaotic bun under a hair net. She hummed a joyful little tune as she stirred the ingredients together.
"Pinkie!" a high-pitched, but masculine voice called from the cash register. "We need another order of chocolate cupcakes done by 2pm!"
"Okie dokie, baby!" the pink earth pony chimed from the kitchen. She continued to hum as she gathered a few more eggs and butter from the fridge, and some flour, coco powder, baking soda, and oil from the pantry. She grabbed another large bowl as the oven preheated for the treat she was working on prior to that one. She poured the batter from her other project into a large cake pan and waited for the oven to ding. She started putting the other ingredients into the large bowl and stirred them together. Her coltfriend took a break from the register for a moment and made his way into the kitchen. Passing his little marefriend, he brushed against her and smiled.
"Look, I know I already got you somethin' for your birthday 'n' all…" Ginger Snap started. Pinkie looked at the heart-shaped pendant dangling around her neck and smiled. "But, I still have something for you a little later tonight."
Pinkie's blue eyes lit up and a wide grin formed on her face. "Really? What is it?"
Ginger Snap giggled. "Oh, trust me; you'll like it a lot. It'll be waiting in your room after work." He smiled and winked at his pretty little marefriend. Pinkie looked a bit sad and her eyes lowered to the floor.
"Why do I have to wait?"
Ginger giggled in response. "You're so silly, Pinkie."
Pinkie was confused on why she had to wait, but she desperately wanted to know what her present was. She quickly threw in the rest of the ingredients and got all of her tasks for the day done as quickly as she could. She had to admit, it wasn't her best work. She sloppily splattered on the frosting and threw on the sprinkles for the cake and cupcakes she baked. She even undercooked the cupcakes a little, and they were extra-soft on the inside. She finished other orders as swiftly as she possibly could.
"Mrs. Cake!" She called, galloping out of the kitchen with a quickly thumping heart. "I know it's not closing hours yet, but I've worked so, so hard and Gingy says he has a present for me after work and I'm so excited and it's my birthday! Can I please, please have the rest of the evening off?" She smiled widely at her boss as her blue eyes sparkled.
The blue earth pony flinch at first sight of the optimistic baker and stood motionless through her little rant.
"Uh… sure, Pinkie… Just make sure the kitchen is cleaned before you go."
"Oh my gosh, thank you thank you thank you!"
Pinkie didn't even take a moment to check if she actually had turned the oven off, cleaned up, or anything. She ran out of the small bakery and up to the nearby apartment her and Ginger were living at during that time. They lived on the second story, which she ran straight up to. She retrieved the key from under the mat and unlocked the front door before stepping inside.
"I'm home, Gingy!"
She heard a familiar voice coming from her bedroom at the end of the hall. Although it was muffled she understood it clearly. "I'm in here, Pinks!"
She galloped happily to her room, where she knew a surprise awaited her. Her heart thumped with love and anticipation. She took a breath and hesitated a moment before opening the door. She wanted to savor each little moment. Finally, she wrapped her hoof around the doorknob and opened the wooden slab with a grin. Hey eyes grew large at the sight before her. Her precious coltfriend laid on her bed with his legs opened, revealing his full stallionhood. It was the first time she saw a stallionhood in real life. She blushed heavily from the sight.
"Like it?" He asked in a teasing manner.
Pinkie was left dumb. She couldn't get a word off her lips.
"Oh, and if you like that…" He said before reaching under the bed and pulling out a box. It was small, white, and made of cardboard. He gestured her over with a smirk. She trotted to the side of the large bed and looked inside the box. Inside was a whole dozen of cupcakes, three cans of frosting, a tub of whipped cream, a bottle of strawberry sauce, a bottle of chocolate sauce, and a container of multi-colored sprinkles. Her eyes widened and her mouth watered at the sight.
"What are you waiting for, Babe?" He patted the spot on the bed next to him. "I thought you'd be a little more eager for your birthday present."
Pinkie giggled lightheartedly with a hue of red covering her face. She crawled onto the bed next to her dear colt friend and planted a loving kiss on his lips. Her returned the kiss and broke away with a smile. Ginger's hoof ventured into the cardboard box and pulled out a bottle of strawberry sauce and winked at his marefriend. He undid the cap and poured some of the strawberry liquid onto Pinkie's chest. She placed her hoof in the expanding puddle and licked it off.
"Mmmm…. Tasty!" Pinkie scooped up some more in her hoof and took another lick. Her coltfriend smiled at her.
"Now, now… Wouldn't want to eat it all before we get to the good stuff?
Ginger poured more of the sticky syrup onto Pinkie's lower belly. It slowly ran down, nearing closer to her marehood. Ginger placed his hoof in a small puddle of syrup and forced it down quicker, then smeared the gooey strawberry sauce onto her virgin marehood. Pinkie let out a soft moan as he squirted more sauce directly onto her clit and pressed his strawberry-caked hoof onto her slit, forcing some of the sauce inside of her. She blushed heavily and shudder in pleasure as her privates were touched for the first time.
"Don't be shy." Her coltfriend tilted the box in her direction, encouraging her to take out a desert item of her choice.
Pinkie giggled with a snort before taking out a can of chocolate frosting. She popped the lid open and scooped some of the frosting up with her hoof. She smeared the sweet, thick substance onto her coltfriend's chest. He smiled and removed his hoof from her marehood. It was wet with a bit of Pinkie's excited juices and thickly coated in strawberry syrup. She didn't like simply being teased like that, but she was definitely in the mood now. She took another scoopful of frosting and rubbed it all over her coltfriend's chest, turning his blue body sticky and brown. Ginger only responded by dumping a good portion of the strawberry sauce all over Pinkie. She laughed as the sauce ran down her sides and tickled her. The red, sticky substance covered the bed and the majority of Pinkie's stomach. Pinkie scooped a little up and licked it from her hoof.
Her coltfriend then tossed her a mischievous grin. He sweetly spread Pinkie's legs opened and gazed upon her strawberry-caked marehood. He licked his lips and felt his mouth starting to water with lust.
"Likey?" Pinkie asked in a cute voice.
"Mmhm!" her coltfriend replied with his tongue out and his body growing hornier by the second.
Finally, Ginger couldn't resist a second longer. Her lowered his head to Pinkie's marehood and gave it a long, tender lick. Pinkie shuddered as he licked it a few more times, savoring the taste of sweet strawberries. Her slit grew wetter with her own fluids as he continued. Finally, he looked up at his pleased marefriend and thrusted his tongue inside her. The moment he did, Pinkie grew extremely wet and blushed. He twisted his tongue around, licking up all the sauce he previously forced inside her. He thrusted his tongue in and out and Pinkie let out soft moans of pleasure.
"I-It feels….good!"
Pinkie was ignored and her coltfriend continued to eat her out happily. After only around a minute more of continuing, he pulled his head up and smiled at her. She was then extremely moist, and she wanted more than anything for his tongue to go back inside of her. She seemed almost disappointed, but didn't say anything.
"Don't worry, Sweetheart. I want your orgasm to come when I'm actually inside you. I was just getting you ready." He winked at her and she simply nodded, both eager with lust.
Her coltfriend pulled the box back over to him and looked inside. This excited Pinkie a lot. She didn't know why, but she loved decorating her coltfriend in sweet, edible deserts. He chuckled and pulled out the container that held the dozen cupcakes. There was an even combination of vanilla and chocolate, and the icing was all multicolored. They all had small, pearl-shaped sprinkles on top. Ginger Snap opened the container with his hooves and licked his lips. All of the lust built up in Pinkie forced her to grab a chocolate cupcake and crumble it onto Ginger's lower stomach, smearing the frosting and cake part, and forcing it lower. She giggled and grabbed two more, one in each hoof. She forced her sweet lover down and smashed the two treats in random areas on his torso. He giggled, loving Pinkie's naughty, lustful side.
Pinkie didn't know what had compelled her to do it, but she did. She took another cupcake from the container and put it at Ginger's stallionhood. She then crumbled it, and smeared the remains onto his sheathe. He loved it, and slowly, he became erect. Her hooves glided up and down his shaft as she smeared the chocolate cake and rainbow icing. She licked her lips at the sight before her. His now fully erect cock was masked in cupcake remains. It looks so delicious.
Without further hesitation she dipped her head down and cleaned off his messy member. She had never had sex, and didn't know how to give a blowjob, but easily maneuvered her way around the hard beast to get the tasty cake off. The vanilla frosting tasted sweet and rich. Her tongue instantly craved more of the sweet, delicious frosting and chocolate cupcake. Her tongue caressed and massaged his hard cock as she licked and scraped up every inch of the delectable desert. Ginger laid back, relaxing and moaning at the earth pony's efforts. He almost drooled and could barely speak as she continued.
Pinkie made her tongue to the very bottom of the shaft where the most cupcake had gathered. She lapped up the remains that landed down there, some even very close to his balls. Some large chunks landed and she nibbled those away which made Ginger shudder in pleasure. Her adorable blue eyes shimmered as she looked up at him. It was with one, long, final lick getting the last row of frosting in her mouth that he finally began to pulsate. A small amount of precum dripped out of the head and Pinkie gladly licked it up. She finally raised her head and smiled at her coltfriend.
"Are you ready?" He asked with a confident smile.
"Not yet…" Pinkie answered. She grabbed the bottle of chocolate syrup and undid the cap. "We need a little lubricant."
Ginger's green eyes widened as she poured the sticky coating all over his cock. He blushed heavily as the rich chocolate ran down into the area in between his legs, all over his balls, and onto the bed beneath him. She didn't stop pouring the sauce out until it was nearly almost gone. She held the bottle to her lips and took a large gulp out before finally tossing the plastic bottle to the side. She smiled as she plopped onto the bed, and widely spread her legs. She was increasingly moist and well-prepared for intercourse. Ginger mounted his eager marefriend, placing his chocolaty member at her slit. He pressed the head against her. Pinkie's eagerness grew by the second. She moved her hips up and forward, trying to force the syrup-coated cock inside her. Her coltfriend smiled.
"You're so adorable, Pinkie…"
He leaned down and kissed her on her chocolaty lips and pressed the first three inches of his slippery stallionhood into her. She gasped and blushed as it went in her virgin marehood. It did expand her a little bit, but it slipped in easily with the thick coating of chocolate. She let out a long, satisfied gasp as her coltfriend slowly pushed all the way inside her. Pinkie relaxed as Ginger started thrusting his hips, going in and out of his precious little mare. The chocolate combined with Pinkie's juices as he quickened the pace. Pinkie motioned her hips a little, as well. The stallionhood filled her hole completely, and she barely felt a thing when her cherry popped and she bled a little bit. The friction between Ginger's cock and Pinkie's inner walls felt amazing for both of them. Pinkie occasionally let out a short wine of pleasure and Ginger grunted a little.
"TH-this feels SO good!" Pinkie announced as she moved her hips with Ginger's rhythm.
The intense pleasure left Ginger dumb, and he only gave a slight nod and grunt. Both of their speeds increased and their pleasure grew. Although bullets of sweat formed on their foreheads and breathing became a bit of a challenge, they didn't slow down one at all. In fact, they sped up.
After only three minutes, they were practically drowning in their own lustful pleasure. Every time Ginger's stallionhood pounded as deep as it possibly could, a rush of pure pleasure pulsed through Pinkie's body. Every second their pleasure increased. Each moment, their heartbeat throbbed faster.
"I-I'm about t-to finish!"
Pinkie looked up at her coltfriend and shook her head, barely able to speak. "I-I can't get… pregnant!"
Ginger sighed, and with her request, pulled out with a pop. He lifted upward, to cause a little bit of friction between his stallionhood and Pinkie's clit. The sensitive bubbled caused a strong rush of wonderful sensation throughout her body. She let out a groan and a strong release onto her coltfriend's throbbing member. His cock was covered in chocolate and Pinkie's fluids. He was heavily panting and Pinkie felt a hard pit in her stomach; an emotion she recognized as guilt.
"You didn't get to finish did you?" Pinkie asked.
Ginger shook his head and Pinkie frowned. It would have been wrong to get off, but not allow your partner to orgasm. She smiled.
"Let me help…."
Pinkie moved her hoof to his very wet cock and rubbed his staff. Her hooves slid up and down very gently, but still intense enough to bring the desired sensation. It wasn't long until her coltfriend let out a strong stream of sticky cum with a grunt. She giggled and grabbed one last cupcake from the box. She scraped off the hill of frosting off onto her coltfriend's belly. She then proceeded to scrape up his cum and place it in substitution for the frosting. Pinkie smiled and took a large bite out of it. It tasted like sweet vanilla with a bit salt.
"Mmmm! Salty and sweet! The perfect combination!"
Her coltfriend laughed at Pinkie for taking pleasure in tasting his cum.
"It's not funny!" Pinkie scolded. "It's good! Try some!"
Before the stallion could say a word of rejection, the pink pony stuffed the cupcake into his mouth, giving him a taste of his own medicine.