"A food fetish?" Rainbow laughed in an almost mocking tone. "That's it?"
Pinkie dug her hoof into the ground, and seemed almost ashamed. Was her fetish not good enough?
"Jeesh, Rainbow. You don't have to be such a meanie. I'm sure you have some kind of secret fetish. At least I was brave enough to tell everypony about mine."
Rainbow's ears went flat and her face lit up red in response to Pinkie's accusation. Applejack chuckled at the cyan pegasus' silent reaction.
"Looks like Rainbow's got a lil' fetish she's been hidin'." The farmer accused with a laugh.
"Shut up!" Rainbow yelled in the most threatening tone she could. "Besides, it's not like you don't have a fetish!"
Applejack gasped, and her face lit up as well. "Ah… Ya can't prove anything!"
"As if the blush on your face isn't proof enough! You're totally hiding something!"
Applejack didn't respond. She simply growled at Rainbow with disdain. Rainbow stuck her tongue out at the opposite side of the room and blew a raspberry in AJ's direction.
"Listen to you. You're all going on about something as insignificant as a fetish!" Rarity proclaimed.
"Oh, and lil' miss Rarity o're here don't got a fetish!" AJ remarked in anger.
Rarity's white face morphed into a bright hue of red. "I…I never said that. I'm only saying it's not something that's worth arguing over."
"Rarity's right." Twilight said, finally butting into the conversation. "You all are obviously hiding something, but it's not worth arguing over. Let's be honest here. How many ponies in here actually do have a personal fetish?"
Twilight tried to be a strong leader and silently raised her hoof into the air. The other's around her gasped a little, but didn't say anything afterwards. They all sheepishly lowered their heads and stared at the ground. It was Applejack to be the second to raise her hoof quietly.
"Ah do…."
Pinkie threw her left hoof in the air. "Everypony already knows mine…"
"I do as well," Rarity announced, raising her hoof and reclaiming her pride, holding her head high.
Rainbow didn't say a word, but silently raised her right hoof high. Fluttershy raised hers quietly to eye-level.
"See? We all have a fetish we've been keeping locked up inside us. It's absolutely nothing to be ashamed of." All of her friends examined the room, and all gained a little more confidence within them. "Fluttershy…. If you're too uncomfortable telling us about yours, we won't force you to, but since we all have something inside us we're holding back…why not take tonight to let it out? We've all been friends for a very long time, and we shouldn't feel uncomfortable telling each other these sorts of things."
All the ponies exchanged glances and considered it. Twilight was right. It may have been hard to admit what they were deeply thinking, but it would be worth it to get it off their chest. Maybe they wouldn't feel so bad afterwards.
"Twilight makes a valid point. If we want to ever get this heavy weight off our chest, we'll have to come clean." Rarity finally stated.
The others nodded in agreement, knowing it was true.
"But who will go first?" Twilight asked.
"Hmmm…." Rarity thought for a moment. "Alright, so there are five more of us to go. How about we draw paper to determine the order?"
Twilight gave a silent nod and trotted over to a desk in the far left of the room. The small, wooden desk had sheets of parchment neatly stacked in the center and a small cup holding quills. There was a small container of ink to the right of the paper. Twilight's horn illuminated a light purple and a shimmering glow surrounded the paper. Using her magic, she levitated the paper and tore it into five even pieces with her magic. The paper lost its glow as a quill lit up and was dipped in black ink. She then scribbled a number neatly onto each paper and folded them. Her horn lit up once more and dumped the quills out of their cup, only to fill the void with numbered scraps of parchment. She made her way back to the area her where her friends patiently waited, carrying the cup.
"Each of you take a number! This will determine what order we go in from this point on." She set the white cup in the middle of the room and each pony approached slowly. Each reached their hoof in and pulled out a small piece of paper before quietly making their way back to their sleeping bags. Each unfolded their paper slowly to reveal their number. Twilight took the remaining scrap for herself and unfolded the paper. She was number three. Not bad for only having five pieces. What unlucky sucker had number one? By now, they all undid their papers. Some were blushing, while others looked relieved.
"Who has number one?" Twilight asked the room.
It was dead silent for a moment before Applejack raised her hoof in the air and blushed heavily, hiding half her face with her large hat. She sighed and stared at everypony.
"Ah guess mine's not too bad…. It's jus' sorta personal…."
"It's okay, Applejack…." Twilight encouraged. "I'm sure somepony in this room has a worse one than you. Just let it out and I'm sure you'll feel better."
Applejack slightly nodded. "Mine goes far back… Ah didn't get ta actually try mine 'til a couple years ago…."

Applejack thought back to that wonderful day. Around two years ago, there was a large storm. All ponies were required to stay inside. Trees were violently whipping in the harshly fast wind. Hail was plummeting to earth and rains were fierce and angry. Applejack was in the living room of her house. The moon had risen in the night sky and the sun set long ago. Everypony in her household was already asleep. She was always awake at that late hour of night, though. It was the only time she had to be alone and explore deeper into her fetish she'd had for as long as she could remember. She pulled a magazine from under her dusty couch and laid there on her belly, turning the pages and examining the same pictures over and over.
The magazine did seem odd for Applejack to own, but it wasn't pornographic or inappropriate on any level. She fantasized about the contents on the pages before her. She thought tirelessly of sucking them, licking them, cleaning them, and undressing them non-stop. She of course, was thinking about hooves. Beautiful, beautiful hooves. The magazine revolved around shoes, but she did often imagine slowly taking the shoes off to reveal the bare hoof underneath. She always felt strange about fantasizing about those sorts of things. She felt abnormal for even considering hooves 'sexy'. Even when she pleased herself, she'd imagine herself sucking on a hoof until it was clean and sparkling. Why was she so weird?
Applejack examined one of her favorite pictures that night. It was light pink, feminine hoof in a lacy, purple shoe. It looked so beautiful and elegant, yet so provocative under that lacy lingerie of a shoe. She practically drooled over the photo.
"A-Applejack…?" She heard a warn-out familiar voice ask quietly from behind.
The orange land pony quickly slammed the magazine shut. Her freckled face turned a bright red as she turned to see a small, light-yellow filly with a short red mane and baggy orange eyes.
"Apple Bloom? What are you doin' up dis late?"
"Ah… Ah had a nightmare and woke up. When Ah tried ta go see if you were awake, Ah couldn't find ya…." The small filly replied, lowering her head.
"Oh, Apple Bloom… Ah'm real sorry… Ah couldn't sleep either."
Apple Bloom approached her big sister and looked at the magazine. "Goin' through a borin' ol' magazine to try to get ya ta sleep?" She asked with a chuckle.
AJ blushed. "Uh, yeah…." She lied poorly. "Ya ready to get to bed. We got a long day ahead of us tomorrow."
The little filly yawned and smiled with nod. "Will ya come wit' me?"
Applejack nodded. "Of course…"

It wasn't until the next day that Applejack finally got to experiment with her odd fetish. She didn't think in a million years she'd ever get to try it out, but that day, she got very lucky. She was in the east field gathering a bunch of branches. The very edge of the east field was next to a path that leads into Ponyville. Occasionally, there were carriages or solo ponies that would wonder down the path. Applejack usually ignored them and diligently continued working. That day, however, a young, lavender-coated unicorn trotted down that path with a map levitated in front of her face, surrounded by a dark purple aurora. She seemed rather confused, and looked around to get directions, only to see Applejack alone in the field, picking up a whole bunch of fallen branches.
"Excuse me? Miss?" Her sweet, feminine voice called from the opposite side of a long, wooden fence.
Applejack's ears perked up and for a brief moment she stopped working and turned around. Her eyes locked on a little mare around eight yards away. She had a dark purple, wavy mane that was highlighted with pink streaks. Her eyes were light pink and a shy smile was glued to her face. Applejack galloped over to the mare, leaving her work behind.
"Is der somethin' ya need, ma'am?" Applejack questioned.
The unicorn flipped the map over to show Applejack the finer details. It was a map of a large portion of Equestria, covering Ponyville, Canterlot, Manehatten, and a few cities beyond that.
"Where am I…?" She asked in a soft voice.
Applejack's green eyes grew. How lost could she have been to not know where she was? She must have come from a ways away.
"Yer right outside Ponyville…Here!" She pointed to Ponyville on her hoof-drawn map and smiled in a friendly manner.
"Thanks." She smiled and rolled her mad up with magic before tucking it away in her saddle bag. "I got caught in last night's storm and kinda got blown around a lot before waking up in an unfamiliar area. I've been lost ever since."
"Man, that's gotta suck… Mah condolences to ya… I hope you find your way to where yer goin'."
The unicorn chuckled. "That's okay, I'm a traveler and love seeing new places."
Applejack smiled. "Well, I'd better get back to mah work. Nice meetin' ya."
The orange earth pony turned around get back to her work. The young mare's eyes widened as she suddenly remembered something she needed to ask for.
"Wait!" she called. Applejack instantly turned around to respond. "Is there any place I could maybe wash up? It's been a long trip, and well…" She lifted her hoof to reveal it was densely covered in mud. "I've been walking through a lot of mud to get here. If you have a bathroom or hose, or anything really."
Applejack's eyes widened at the sight. Her pretty little purple hooves were covered in mud. She tried not to drool at the sight, and very desperately wanted to take her muddy shoe off and have a little lick. If she could come up with any possible lie, anything in the world to get just one little lap, she'd be happy. She knew lying was wrong and honesty was always the best policy, but she also knew what her deepest craving was.
"A-actually… We er… Apples have a different way of cleanin'. Ya see, in these parts we, uh… this'll sound really nasty, but…" Applejack blushed as she saw the impatient expression on the mare's face. "We lick clean…."
The mare did nothing but giggle. "Really? I've seen lots of strange things in Equestria, so I'm not surprised."
Applejack couldn't believe she bought the lie, but she wasn't disappointed at all.
"So, I could, uh… clean ya off if you'd like." A bright blush smeared across AJ's face as she smiled awkwardly. The mare thought for a moment.
"Yeah, I guess. I mean, I can't say I haven't done weirder things."
Applejack's heart began to thump. She couldn't believe what was actually about to go down. She lead the mare down several yards to an area where the gate would open. There, she undid the stubborn lock and let her in with a warm smile.
"Wow…." The unicorn stared in awe at the seemingly endless fields of apple trees. "This place is amazing…."
"Thank ya kindly. It's been in mah family for generations."
Applejack always took great pride in her family and what they did, and receiving compliments meant tons to her.
"Now, uh… Just lean against that tree o're there, and I'll get started."
The unicorn went to the nearest tree and laid against the trunk. The wood was hard and uncomfortable against her back, but she wasn't about to say anything. Applejack knelt down before her hind legs. Her hooves were right there. Even caked in mud, they were gorgeous.
Applejack blushed and her heart heavily throbbed as she brought her hoof down and eased off the mare's small, pink shoe. She slowly took it off to reveal her hoof clean underneath it. Her mouth practically watered at the sight. There was now an odd horizontal stripe of mud she knew had to be cleaned off before she could really get into what she'd been waiting years for. Applejack lowered her head to the strip of mud and gave a long lick. She tasted the grimy dirt and felt a little disgusted, but knew it was worth it. She licked all around the filthy ankle, making sure it was completely clean before wiping the sediment off her tongue. She then lifted the leg closer to her drooling mouth and placed her tongue at the bottom of her hoof and gave it a long stroke. She thoroughly felt the dent in the bottom of the hoof with her small pink tongue and blushed as she accidentally let out a short moan. The mare's pink eyes went wide and a bright pink blush was seen through her light purple fur as her mind suddenly realized what was going on.
"Wait… this isn't about a tradition of anything is it? You just…. Want to."
Applejack lifted her head and took her hat off, using it to shield her red-tinted face. "Ah…uh….. You can go now, if you'd like."
The unicorn took a moment to stare at AJ and smiled. "You know what? I honestly don't mind. Do what you'd like. You don't even have to clean up the muck, if you don't want."
Applejack placed the hat on top of her head again. "Really…? Ya mean it?"
The unicorn gave her a slight nod of approval and lifted her hind hoof to AJ's mouth. Applejack smiled and blushed cutely. She grabbed the hoof and gave a few more long, sweet licks. The bottom of her hoof was nice and smooth. She loved the feel of the soft fur against her tongue. She gave another long lick before resting her jaw at the top and lovingly sucking the top of her hoof. It felt amazing, and Applejack could feel herself getting moist. She let out soft moans as she continued to suck. Although the unicorn did feel a bit uncomfortable, she allowed the farmer to do her thing. Applejack broke away and blushed.
"Could Ah try a front leg?"
The unicorn giggled at the earth pony and happily lent Applejack her front hoof. Applejack once again slowly removed the shoe from the pony's hoof. There was another layer of grime, but AJ decided to scrape it off with her hoof this time, leaving her with a succulent, sweet hoof to suck. She teased the bottom of this one with her tongue once more, sliding her tastes buds across the surface and leaving long trails of saliva. It tasted so, so good. She started sucking the top of the hoof again, but this time with more suction, and she allowed her tongue to fondle with the top of the hoof. She moaned more and more as she continued sucking tenderly.
After a long while of sucking, AJ got bored and decided to try something more daring. She opened her mouth as wide as she could and stuck the first inch of the entire hoof into her mouth. She had to admit, the pressure on her jaw did hurt a bit, but she didn't care at all. She started to suck it as if her life depended on it. Her mouth caressed and massaged the hoof as she tried to get a few more inches in. The hoof was too big for her mouth, but she forced as much of the hoof down as she could take and continued to tenderly suck and moan. She felt her marehood starting to drip in arousal. She adored sucking the hoof and craved more of it than she knew she could handle.
Soon, the unicorn took notice to Applejack's moist genitalia and smiled. She slid her saliva-frosted hoof out of Applejack's mouth. A sudden look of disappointment came across AJ's face. Her eyes almost seemed saddened and her heart lowered.
I blew it. Applejack thought to herself. I had one chance to live out my fantasies, and I abused my power. Now, I've weirded her out, and there's no way in all of Equestria this'll happen again.
A bit of hope repossessed AJ as her green eyes met the unicorn's ravishing pink ones. She looked at the earth pony with a smile.
"If you liked sucking my hoof, then you'll love this!"
Before Applejack could question what was about to happen, she was forcefully tilted onto her back. The unicorn spread AJ's legs and shoved her wet hoof into Applejack's marehood without any prior warning. Applejack let out a shrill squeak and the lavender mare simply smiled as she began to thrust her hoof. Applejack's vaginal walls squeezed tightly around the large hoof inside of her. It was far larger than anything she'd ever felt. She knew her marehood wasn't meant to take such thick objects, but it felt good. Actually, good was an understatement. The large hoof inside her at that moment felt fantastic. She let out long groans of pleasure as the hoof thrusted in and out of her. Her eyelids fell and her head faced skyward. She was deep in pleasure at this point and her body wasn't far from an orgasm.
"You like this, huh?"
Applejack nodded as her hoof expanded her marehood and increased her heart rate. The top of the mare's hoof scraped against her clit. She felt an orgasm approaching very quickly. She didn't want to cum, though. She wanted to squeeze every moment out of this she could. She held back her release and allowed the hoof to go in and out of her another minute. She moaned louder and blushed. The mare quickened the pace and Applejack finally gave in. She couldn't take it any longer. She orgasmed as a large jolt of pleasure ran through her body. She let out a deep sigh. She hadn't even realized that she forgot to breathe during the wonderful hoofing. The unicorn pulled her hoof out and licked a bit of Applejack's juices off the top with a giggle.
"This is why I love traveling…." She started. "You get to meet new ponies and try lots of new things."