Everypony motionlessly stared at their shy friend. All had their jaws practically touching the floor. All five sets of widened eyes stared directly at the pegasus in shock. Fluttershy responded by hiding under her well-kept tail.
"Wh-what's wrong?" She asked shyly. "D-did I say something wrong?"
The rest remained speechless until a certain unicorn's face grew red, not from embarrassment; but from a much stronger emotion. Anger.
"How dare you!?" She screamed from across the room.
Fluttershy shrunk back and coward as the purple librarian galloped toward her at full speed with fire and water filling her eyes. Her friends watched in awe as she leapt into the air and landed, looking her sworn enemy in her seemingly innocent, tear-swelled eyes. Her hooves shot up and covered her face. There all just so innocent aren't they?
Twilight removed Fluttershy's shielding hooves with magic and glared down furiously at her friend. She raised her hoof and let down a harsh, loud smack on Fluttershy's left cheek. A small, pink mark now stained her stinging face and Fluttershy started crying more freely. Her friends all looked shocked.
"P-p-please T-twilight… I-I'm so s-sorry…"
Fluttershy desperately attempted to bring her hooves up and shield her venerable face, but failed easily.
"Oh, and sorry just makes it ALL better, doesn't it?"
Fluttershy cried harder as guilt played with her heart and Twilight's hoof made contact with the other side of her face. It wasn't a moment later that another punch hit her square in the nose. There was soon a storm of angry punches being mercilessly delivered to the poor pony's face. Her tears ran down to the floor.
"Twilight!" Applejack finally spoke up. "Stop! You're hurtin' her!"
Twilight angrily glared back at the land pony. "That's the point!"
The unicorn delivered several more hard smacks to the pegasus' face before taking a moment to relax her hooves. Blood ran down the pegasus' face and onto the floor beneath her. She shook and tried not to make contact with her furious friend.
"How's it feel?!" She asked in a loud scream. "Huh?! Do you like being held down against your will and hurt?!"
In all anger, her horn lit up and tugged angrily at Fluttershy's mane, even tearing a clump out of her head with a loud noise. The others all cringed and Fluttershy let out a yelp.
"THAT'S WHAT I THOUGHT YOU STUPID BITCH!"
She pulled harder at her head and delivered another strong punch to her bloody, swollen face. Her purple eyes the smiled wickedly with an idea.
"Since you obviously take such great pleasure in causing pain to others, we'll see how you like this…"
Her purple horn illuminated brighter and the sound of metal rustling could be faintly heard from a separate room. The small group of friends watched in curiosity as a drawer floated into the room, detached from its former home in the kitchen. Everypony's eyes widened and wondered in dread what was about to take place. Twilight grinned wider and took a fork out of the drawer before dropping the useless, wood pocket onto the ground.
"T-t-twilight! Wh-what are you doing?"
No response came from the librarian as she lurched the fork downwards with great force. Fluttershy cried out as the fork hit her genitalia. One of the silverware's teeth pierced her sensitive clit and sent a rush of pain through her body. A bit of blood dripped from her pussy. Her friends all cringed and covered their marehoods.
"Twilight! This has gone far enough! You need to-" Rarity was cut off by a livid glare from Twilight.
"Shut up before I shove a fucking knife up your ass!"
Rarity froze and became completely silent in a shock and fear.
"That's better…." Twilighted stated calmly as she returned to her bleeding, crying victim.
"T-twiight! I'm so, so sorry! I-I've been feeling awful about this e-ever since I did it… I'm so, so sorry!"
"Oh, BOO-HOO! Cry me a river, you fucking cunt!"
Anger filled the mare and caused her to grab a sharp knife and shove it right in between the mare's marehood and plothole. It penetrated every layer of skin, along with several inches of body, forcing blood and more tears out of her friend. The remainder of her friends gasped. Rarity passed out.
"PLEASE STOP!" Fluttershy cried out. Her genitals and face were burning in hot pain. "Please… Twilight…. I'm so sorry!"
With another spark of her horn, Twilight tugged on the pink mane with full force.
"Shut it before I cut your fucking tongue out!"
Fluttershy wept and nodded obediently.
"Good! Now, time to-"
"TWILIGHT?"
A familiar voice rang from behind her, and all of her friends turned their attention to the entrance, where a small, tired-looking dragon stood. Twilight turned and her eyes watered upon seeing her little baby.
"Spike!" She cried and ran over to embrace him. Spike didn't reject the embrace, but stood there accepting it. "I'm so, so sorry Spike!"
"About what?" He asked in a confused tone. "If anything, you should be apologizing to…Fluttershy…"
He stared at the beaten and bruised pegasus. His eyes locked on the knife going through her and the fork in her genitalia. There was a small puddle of blood beneath her and torn hair on the ground next to her.
"No I shouldn't!" Twilight snapped. "She stole your innocence and made you suffer."
The green and purple dragon looked even more confused. "And…that's a bad thing?"
The other ponies, especially Twilight, all gaped in shock.
"What do you…mean by that?"
"Sure, I didn't enjoy it at first, but that's because I didn't understand it. Fluttershy taught me all about it…." He blushed, and Twilight looked back at the little, sad pegasus. "And, well, after a few more times, I started to love it."
"A FEW MORE TIMES?!" Twilight asked in surprise.
Spike nodded. "Yeah… After that, she let me chose if I wanted to or not. You know, she'd got a lot of methods to make it enjoyable. Despite her shy attitude, she is a monster in bed." A little drool fell from his lips, looking back on sweet memories.
Twilight, along with the others, remained speechless in shock. Spike then peeked around Twilight and looked concerned for his sweet, dominate friend with benefits. He rushed over to her and knelt by her side.
"Are you alright, Fluttershy?" He asked in a soft voice.
She lifted her head and nodded weakly. "D-don't be mad… I deserved it…"
Spike wrapped his arms around Fluttershy and looked at Twilight in disdain, who was still in utter shock along with the rest. Spike carefully examined her beautiful, equine body. He looked down at her genitals and gasped.
"Twilight!" He grunted. "How do you expect us to have fun if you ruin her marehood?"
Nopony knew what to say. This was all a lot to grasp at one time.
"Y-you…" Twilight started, not knowing how to finish.
All was silent for a good minute before Pinkie smiled and chimed happily.
"Ooh! Just another pony goin' on the birthday list!"