A/N: I've already gotten a great response, thank you!

The answer was Firestar.

I have my winners: First place goes to Snow that Falls from the Sky! Second is BlazingSunrise, and Third is Robincall22. Congrats to all!

Honorable Mentions: Callie the Cat Goddess guessed Crowfeather, which could work because he loved LEAFpool and Feathertail (brother of STORMfur) but only raised a family with Nightcloud. And Brightfrost123 guessed Clear Sky, which could work because he's dead and wasn't accepted, loved more than once (Storm, Bright Stream, Star Flower), but only raised a family with Star Flower.

I am making a new rule. If you don't PM me within a week with your answer, I will use my own cat. This wasn't necessary this chapter, but just for the future.

And, obviously, if you are a guest I can't contact you, so I will ask the second or third (if they are members) winner for them to pick a cat. Sorry!

Now: here for the description.

Once a pelt of iron - his original name was Rusty

Now in StarClan - died in The Last Hope

At first not accepted - many cats didn't think a kittypet would be cut out for Clan life

I then lead my Clan - he became leader

I loved twice - first Spottedleaf, then Sandstorm

But lost the first twice - Spottedleaf died, then died again in the Dark Forest battle

They were the leaf and the storm - SpottedLEAF, SandSTORM

But only with one did a family I form - only had kits with Sandstorm

Now my life is over - again, he died

I'm happy with my mate - he's in StarClan with Sandstorm

At least with one love dead - Spottedleaf died

The two I would not have to debate - one of the Erins, Kate I think, said that they killed Spottedleaf "so Firestar wouldn't have to choose between her and Sandstorm."

And here's today's poem, suggested by Snow that Falls From the Sky.

I had my heart broken once

Because of a Sedge

And I got my name

From a moor hedge

Finally, I loved again

To someone in my Clan

Now we have two young kits

One gray, the other tan

I'm happy with my mate now

Some of our past decisions were wrong

But if StarClan forgives us

Our lives together will be long

A/N: There's my second one. Fast update, right? Anyway, hopefully that was okay, and once I get enough reviews, I'll put the next one up. Thanks for reading!