AN: Inspired by lyrics from "Open Your Heart" by Westlife.
Even though I was here with Jesse, watching Finn dance with Quinn was hard. I knew I still loved him - despite him having slept with Santana. Finn made me feel a way that Jesse never could. Finn made me feel special, and as I watched him and Quinn sway to the slow music I wondered if he did those little things for her to make her feel special. Not that she deserved it. I knew that Quinn only wanted Finn to help her be Prom Queen and I hoped that someone besides her won that honor. It wasn't fair if she got both my guy and a crown.
Jesse leaned in close to kiss me, and I closed my eyes. With my eyes closed I was able to pretend that it was Finn who was kissing. That he had forgiven me for cheating on him with Puck because I had been angry at Santana. I could see now how wrong that had been. Knew how much I had hurt hm with that action.
If only he could forgive me. Give me the second chance that I wanted so much. Finn and I belonged together and if given another chance I would make him see that. I would show him how special I thought he was. All I needed was my second chance.