It was around 9 when Blaine left. Hiram and Leroy were dreading what they were about to tell Rachel. They didn't know how she was going to react.

When Rachel comes into the Kitchen after Blaine leaves, she notices that he dads are acting a little weird. And they have been ever since Blaine was here. She decides to see what's going on with them.

"Uhm, dads, what's up? You're acting a little weird."

Her dads look at each other and decides it now or never. Leroy speaks first. "Well, sweetie, there's something that we, uhm, n-need to tell you."

"Yeah, so uhm, c-come sit down."

They walk into the living room and Rachel sits on the couch and her dads stay standing.

"Ok, so what do you need to tell me?"

"Well." Hiram starts but then turns to Leroy and whispers "I don't know if I can do this."

"You have to, we have to. She has a right to know. We can't keep this from her any longer."

Her dads aren't very good a whispering so Rachel hears them. "Dads, seriously, what's going on?"

Hiram turns back to face his daughter. "Sweetie, y-you're not- You have a-" He pauses for a second. "You're not an only child."

Rachel looks up at her dads in shock. "Wha-What?"

"Y-You were a twin, o-only we didn't know until Shelby had you."

"I-I-I'm a-a-a twin?"

"Y-Yes."

"Well, how come you only kept me? What about my-my-my. Sister? Brother?"

"Brother." Leroy took over the talking. "A-And we couldn't keep you both. I-It was complicated."

"Complicated? What, you didn't want two kids?"

"No, sweetie, that wasn't it at all."

"Then what? Why didn't you keep my-my brother?"

It was Hiram's turn to speak up. "Sweetie, listen, you have to understand, this was a complicated situation. We didn't want to separate you two, but w-we had to. We couldn't keep both of you."

"But why? I want to know, please stop saying it's complicated. I deserve the truth."

"You're right, you do."

"Ok. So tell me."

"Well, like I said before, we had no idea Shelby was pregnant with twins until she gave birth. When we found out, we didn't know what to do. We had only planned on you. And things were tight back then, so it's not like we could afford to take care of two babies."

"So you just gave my brother away?"

Hiram looked at his daughter. He could see how upset she was, and not just upset, but mad, angry even. He couldn't keep going. Leroy was the one to speak. "Sweetie, we had no choice. We couldn't take both of you."

"Wow. Ok, so I-I have a brother. A twin brother. D-Do you know where he is?" She looked up at her dads for the first time since they broke the news.

"That's the other thing we need to tell you."

"So you do know where he is?"

"Y-Yes, sweetie. It's, uhm, your friend that just left."

"B-Blaine? Blaine's my twin brother?"

"Yeah."

"Oh my god. You have got to be kidding me? I-I can't believe this."

"Sweetie, we're sorry."

"Sorry? W-Why'd you keep this from me? How come you never told me?" With that Rachel got up off the couch and stormed up to her room.

"I told you, Hiram, we shouldn't have told her."

"No, we had to. Sh-She deserved to know. We should have told her sooner."