Good muffin

The breeze from a chilly autumn stroked gently by Rarity's cheeks as she was on her way from her Carousel Boutique. When it's cold outside, most ponies sees it as a reason to be inside to hide away from it, but this unicorn only saw it as a good reason to wear her beautiful, dark blue scarf.

As she continued towards no goal at all, since it only was a nice little stroll, she thought that there was nothing that possibly could ruin her day. Nothing at all, not even if a pegasus would crash down on her and mess up the scarf around her while pressing her face to the dirty ground she walked on. Rarity chuckled when she imagined the situation actually happening to her and how low the odds would be for it. She looked down on the ground, thinking of how disgraceful it would be. But the unicorn's attention was ripped away as she noticed a black spot on the very ground growing in front of her.

She halted, looking with a question mark in her mind on the odd, circular spot. Suddenly, something fell with a splat in the middle of the circle; a muffin, completely squashed from the brutal impact to the ground. Rarity staggered when she noticed the black spot growing into her own size and slowly moving towards her, but her speed in reacting didn't reach any further. She looked up, screamed, and in the next moment felt the weight of a pegasus pony in high speed landing on her with a crash.

As the small amounts of dust from the collision cleared, the white unicorn laying on her back next to the other pony slowly opened her eyes and noticed, when she glanced on her scarf, the small amount of dust there was on it. With anger boiling up her mind, Rarity twitched her eye while turning her head around to face the maniacal pegasus who clearly didn't know the meaning of steady flying. It was a gray pony with blonde hair and bubbles as a cutie mark who now sat straight up while looking down the other way from Rarity, facing the ground and slowly crooking her back. The unicorn had already thought of several ways and hundreds of reasons why she should yell at it, but as she was about to lay her hoof on the gray pony, the noise only reminding of sorrow whimpered from its mouth. "My muffin...It's...is...", slowly passed by Rarity's ears, as she now understood it was a filly her anger had awoken to.

Nevertheless, she was still insistent to turn the pony around and completely make her feel bad for ruining the fabulous scarf and not to mention her fabulous looks. The gray filly's body trembled at the same time as she hit her hooves to the ground, still unaware of Rarity's presence. A cry from the blonde pony pierced the white unicorn's ears as she staggered out from her anger. Snivels and tears poured from the pegasus who covered her face with her fore-hooves the moment before she fell backwards to the ground, ending up in the same position Rarity just had. Suddenly, the unicorn didn't know what to do now. It just didn't feel alright to be mad at the clumsy pony anymore. All these overflowing emotions of sadness she witnessed turned her to be curious over if the gray filly was hurt.

A gentle smile dressed up on Rarity's lips when she bend over to ask nicely, "uhm...is everything okay, young lady?", and then waited patiently for an answer. She would receive it, but not in a way she expected. The crying pony uncovered her right eye to see the muddy unicorn, causing another shock before she rolled over to her stomach and hide her eyes again, "And I did bad thing to a beautiful pony! Aw nuuuw!", she screamed in despair while pressing her face to the surface of the ground and hitting it with her hooves again. As her tears soaked the ground, the other pony nibbled her lips when she heavily regretted her cruel mind for a second ago. In a try to be kind, she patted the pegasus' blonde mane, "there, there, sweetie. I'm...", then quickly looked at her dusty scarf with another eye-twitch, "...fine. Nothing to worry about at all. Now you simply must tell me what is so horrible that it brings such sorrow to you". The gray filly whimpered at first, but with another try she brought out the reason with her face still pressed down, "my...my muffin, it's broken. I worked sooo hard for it, but Ditzy is clumsy and dropped muffin. Ditzy...Ditzy try to save it...but was slow. Now it's...uhh...", then another cry continued.

Rarity understood the situation and what kind of pony she was dealing with. And since it obviously was true, there was no such thing as being judgmental when thinking this pony was simpleminded and not very clever, but actually kindhearted. So much more reasons for not being mad at her. However, Rarity felt it would be for the best to calm this tormented soul she pitied so much. And if her guess was correct, the solution should be easy.

She scratched her chin and patted the pony again, "I... presume your name is Ditzy?", she asked and was replied with a slight nod, "well then, Ditzy. It is without doubt really sad what happened to your baked goods, but how about if I get you a new one?", she finished with a shiny smile towards the pegasus. In an instant, the blonde pony stopped crying, dried her eyes while getting up again, then finally uncovered both of her lime yellow eyes, sending Rarity into a mortified shock.

"Really? Can beautiful pony help me get new muffin?", the cross-eyed pony replied in happiness. But the unicorn suddenly hesitated when she saw the heavily disoriented eyes the gray pony had. From Rarity's view, the left eye was in the upper right corner and the right in lower left, looking both up and down at the same time. Rarity was silent with her grimace locked in 'disgusted' for a few seconds, but when she realized what rude behavior she just expressed to the poor Ditzy, she snapped out of it and shook her head with an embarrassed smile, "uh...yes! Of course I will. Let's go shall we?", she said while turning the way she knew the confectionery laid. Suddenly the pegasus jumped up in exaltation towards Rarity with a pure smile, ending up shocking the unicorn again when she in the next moment kissed her on the mouth.

Rarity froze for a second time with her cheeks blushing, allowing the pegasus to lay her hooves around the unicorn's white neck. But when Rarity felt they both were about to open their mouths, she realized she was seconds from making out with a complete stranger in public. A few ponies along the road stayed and looked at them in wonder, causing the unicorn to start struggling and releasing herself from the grip. Ditzy looked at her like nothing happened as their lips let go with a small stain of saliva dripping from her mouth, but Rarity certainly wanted to point out the unnecessary way of showing gratitude while drying her lips, only to be replied that it was the way you thank somepony when they do something nice to you, according to Ditzy. The fashion-filly tried to understand how she meant, but ended up just saying they should go now. As she tried to introduce herself as Rarity, the pegasus just repeated quietly for herself 'beautiful pony is kind'...

After hardly five minutes of walking, Ditzy dropped her jaw when she recognized the place. "Whaaat? But this is Sugarcube Corner. How did you find it so fast, it takes Ditzy much, much longer time to get here!", she said with an amazed tone. Rarity giggled, "Oh, it's not so hard, dear. All it takes is some sense of direction and 'ta-dah', here you are", she said while gesticulating with her hooves. "Beautiful pony is smart!", Ditzy said with excitement as they walked to the entrance of the candy-decorated shop. Rarity giggled again and took for granted that the pegasus said it as a compliment and not as a try to imply Rarity looked like an unintelligent pony...

The door pushed open with the bell above it clinging out its noise to alert the currently only present worker; a pink pony who Rarity sure did know; Pinkie pie. Her hooves hit the stairs with that jumpy vibration she always had, her smile shone like the sun, and her body gently swooped her down the final step to greet the potential customers. "Oh hi, Rarity! Hi Ditzy! What's up?", she welcomed them both with. The pegasus took the initiative to answer first, "Hiya, Pinkie. Me and the beautiful pony need your help. I dropped my muffin...", she said with a sad expression when she thought of the horrible tragedy, gaining Pinkie's fully understanding and attention. With a decided nod, she skipped over to Ditzy and hugged her. "There, there. Good old Pinkie always got more muffins for her best customer", she calmed the blonde pony with while stroking her mane. Then she whispered, "shall we do the payment when the beautiful pony leaves?", which made Rarity wonder what she meant by that. However, Ditzy let go of Pinkie and shook her head, "no, beautiful pony wants to give Ditzy the muffin, Pinkie", she said and pointed at the awkwardly smiling unicorn.

The earth pony thought about it for a moment while rubbing her muzzle. It sounded like a good idea, but she wasn't sure if the unicorn would agree to it. "Hmm...I don't know. Beautiful pony is my friend, it might be kinda weirdie-weirdie for her", she said with a thoughtful face towards Rarity which almost made her nervous. What in Equestria did she talked about, the unicorn thought for herself and looked questioning at the pink pony. "But she promised me a muffin. Pinkie can't be mean to her if she's Pinkie's friend, right", Ditzy used as argument. The earth pony sighed deeply and rolled with her eyes before telling the pegasus she could walk up to her room and wait.

Ditzy looked sadly at Pinkie, but soon obeyed and walked slowly up the stairs. When she was gone, Pinkie smiled and crept closer to her white friend, but before she had time to say anything, Rarity stuffed her hoof inside the earth pony's mouth and glared at her. "What does this mean, Pinkie?", she asked with a tense tone while removing her hoof from Pinkie's mouth, allowing her to talk with her smile still intact. A little giggle was the first thing that passed by her lips before the explanation, "silly, it's nothing you have to worry about! I will just let Ditzy have a muffin from my personal, hidden, super-secret stash! You can go now, no worries about the payment. Goody?". She said while suddenly caressing her hoof along Rarity's neck. The unicorn still had several amounts of doubt in this situation, and even more confusion over why the hay Pinkie was touching her, but with a neat smile, she agreed and turned around with full cooperation.

"See you later then, Pinkie dear...", she said while opening the door with the same color as the earth pony who had one last thing to mention. "Oh, oh! Can you by the way take that sign that says 'closed' and hang it on the door when you leave, Rarity? Pretty please with sugar?", and finished with a unnaturally wide smile and twinkling eyes. The unicorn glanced at the sign laying next to the door on the floor and focused her horn on it. With a stain of magic surrounding it, the sign levitated next to her as she walked past the door to hang it on the doorknob outside. Pinkie hardly had time to thank her before she quickly ran up the stairs without reminding herself to actually see if the unicorn left.

As soon as the door was about to shut, Rarity stepped her hoof in the way and carefully sneaked inside again. There was without doubt something really odd going on right now. And even if it felt really unlikely to happen, she knew from her experience in understanding others behavior that the pink pony was hiding something. Something she really didn't want her to know, and her concerns floated around Ditzy the most because of her highly potential naivety. But, could Pinkie really do such things? No, there had to be some other explanation. That's exactly why she had to spy...

Feeding her hopes with the best outcomes, she carefully walked up the stairs, passed the second floor and halted the moment she was about to come up from the third story's floor. She heard Ditzy's voice before secretly peaking between the banisters.

"But Pinkie, the beautiful pony said she would get Ditzy a muffin", the pegasus said with disappointment, but the earth pony just shook her head while she raked in a coffin to pull out a black corset with more net on it then a regular one. She tossed it over to Ditzy and snickered, "but I promise you, she have paid for it, it just needs some... uhm... extra! Yes, extra. Can't get away cheap, you know", she said and then switched to giggling. The pegasus glanced at the corset laying in front of her, momentarily doubting before she picked it up to put it on. In a few moments, Rarity's worst fears became real when Pinkie laced the corset tight on Ditzy's back. And when the black stockings also were put on her hindlegs, leaving only her upper body and nether parts exposed, it was the earth pony's turn to dress up. With a bustier and the same kind of black stockings put on with help from the cross-eyed pony, it was time to start.

The unicorn didn't believe what she saw, even if it undoubtedly was a sex scene about to play off in front of her eyes. "Okay, just as the good old usual. Into be~d", she ordered Ditzy with a little tune. The pegasus obediently went to the bed and laid on it with her legs spread, still having that saddened expression on her face. In the meantime, Pinkie had already brought out several tools with different looks from her coffin, but Rarity knew they all would serve a common purpose. The things was brought to the bed and dropped to the floor in a messy pile consisting of whips, gags, blindfolds, ropes, toys and even some small boxes containing Celestia knows what inside. The earth pony stood up on her hindlegs and picked up a riding whip from the pile, smacking it in her hoof while looking evilly at the pegasus. "You know what, Ditzy? We do it differently this time. Here, take it", the pink pony said and handed over the whip.

The pegasus got up from the bed and grabbed the tool with her teeth as Pinkie bended over to raise her exposed behind in the air. "And remember; harder and harder, no matter what I say", Pinkie said a few secodrnds before Ditzy rose her head to swing the whip from her mouth. With a strong lash, Rarity twitched when she heard her friend's cry. She could imagine what pain it had to be, and what disgrace Pinkie experienced every time the whip hit her.

The punishing continued, leaving red stripes on the earth pony's rump as her forelegs dropped. "No, daddy! I don't want this, please stop! I want my mommy! Sisters, help me! Why do you stand there and laugh at me?", Pinkie hollered out while the smacking noises continued to violate her. Rarity covered her eyes with her hooves at fist, but slowly peaked between them to see more for reasons she didn't know herself. "You hate me, don't you? You never loved me, never!". Slow but steady, she uncovered her eyes to see the procedure, looking more amazed over the innocent screaming. "Well, I hate you too!", the earth pony finally roared out with tears soaking the floor as her imagination became real inside her head. Then something Rarity only witnessed once before happened again.

The poofy, pink mane and tail suddenly lost all it's fluffy shape, instantly falling down in a flat formation like she had combed them for hours. Her happy aura was gone, frightening the skulking unicorn when she couldn't recognize her glad friend without the smile and sparkling eyes. Ditzy stopped the spanking, frightfully dropped the whip to the floor and backed when she realized what horrid monster that just got released.

The floor trembled slightly by Pinkie's hooves as she stood up on all four to turn around with her annoyed expression against the pegasus. "Well, well. What do we have here? Looks like somepony wants to get raped...again", she said with a creepy voice to unnerve Ditzy. The pegasus fell to the floor on her back with tears starting to squeeze out from her crossed eyes when she recalled the images of what happened last time they did this...

As the moments passed, Rarity now witnessed the pink pony as she had tied Ditzy's forelegs with a rope, forcing her to hold them above her head while resting on the only bed in the room. With the whip in her hoof, the flat-haired pony raised it as high as she could before letting it fall from its height, leaving traces of its presence with a blow on the tied up pony's labium. Without any form of gag, Ditzy cried out in pain from the violent treatment she had to suffer. And as the whipping proceeded, leaving several red stripes both on and around her marehood, Pinkie soon switched target from the soft and sensitive area to a slightly bit harder place.

Ditzy only had time to open her lazy eyes from the torture before she was stricken blind. With a crack, the whip lashed up a burning red bruise along her eyelids , forcing her to keep them closed while hollering out the cruel act. No matter how much she struggled, she just couldn't break loose from the ropes around her forelegs, twitching and shouting from the panic in her mind. The earth pony hushed and covered the pegasus' mouth, "aw, it wasn't that bad, now? It's not like I actually took away anything useful from you, ehe he he", she then said while letting go of the riding whip.

An evil snicker passed by both Ditzy's and Rarity's ears when Pinkie bend down from the bed and started digging in her pile for the next tool to use. A small box in the pile was opened and freed from its content. It wasn't a beautiful sight, but a dreadful one when the sharp steel in her mouth reflected the sun's rays. A carving knife with a crimson colored handle now rested between the mean pony's teeth, waiting to be used in any way she desired on the helpless pony. Ditzy's eyes became wide open when she slowly realized the upcoming pain. "No, no, no! I don't want that! Please, Pinkie, not again! You promised you'd never use it again on Ditzy", she yelled with begging brought from horror.

The corset-dressed earth pony just smiled and grabbed the knife with her hoof to ensure a more precise aiming. Rarity sweated when imagining what terrifying experience the pegasus was about to live trough, but she was shocked herself. This feeling; it wasn't just only fear. The warmth between her thighs told another story as her breath went to panting. Never before had she been so excited over something so distasteful and brutal. Her thoughts didn't concern Ditzy anymore; instead it all went down to her own crotch with her hoof gently rubbing it.

"I know I promised, little Ditzy, but promises...are made to be broken", Pinkie said while picking up a piece of cloth to tie around the blonde pony's mouth. To ensure not a single too loud noise would appear, she tied the knot behind her neck extra hard, causing Ditzy to whimper when she felt the burning squeeze to her skin. Everything set, Pinkie sat up again and placed the knife over the gray filly's nose, beholding the tearful staring at either her or the blade, since she couldn't know by those twisted and yellow eyes where she actually looked. None the less, the edge carefully caressed Ditzy's nose, sliding pass her gagged lips and gently ending up on her bare chest.

The hidden unicorn behind the banisters panted heavier, almost begging her to do the first cut. And as the blade's tip made the first carving, Ditzy threw her head back and desperately tried to cause loud noises, but the muffled scream only reached as far as to Rarity's ears, causing her pussy to drip its fluid to one of the last steps on the stair. Even if she knew it was wrong of her to think so, it didn't really matter anymore. All she wanted was to see pony blood on the sharp edge in Pinkie's hoof while the naive, innocent pony begged for her to stop. The torture continued with the pegasus as the receiver of some thin scratches on her chest, leaving the earth pony restless for some more just like Rarity. Pinkie heavily exposed her teeth as she thought of a new 'fun' thing to do.

"Okay, time to write a diary, don't you think?", she said without dropping her mean smile to the pegasus. Ditzy violently shook her head to reject the idea, but the pink pony ignored this as she already had begun. While scratching letters on the 'naked' gray skin, she loudly read the text being marked on the blonde pony with the muffled screams in the background; "Dear diary. Today, I was raped by...", she then halted while biting her lip to get the big p correct, thus causing more noises in the background from the tied up pony, "...Pinkie, who cut me up like I always want her to do. Because I'm a whore!", and then finally laid aside the knife, "that sounds correct to me", only to moments later get another plaything from her collection. Ditzy could finally relax, but some of the scars actually made her bleed a little.

Rarity, however, almost came during the entire carving. The unicorn's nether soaked her shivering hindlegs to the point she could feel it all down to her hooves, by that causing her to release lesser moans as her lips almost bled from the chewing she brought upon them. Pinkie moved on to the next step, flashing the grotesque, beige, 18-inched, double-ended dildo in her mouth. Rarity almost cried out an 'yes' when she saw it, tightening the space between her thighs and almost crushing her hoof in between as she dug for more love juice inside her love hole.

The corset-dressed Ditzy was more relaxed now even if her jaw was tired from all the screaming, because now she was sure it was about to end. The first end of the toy cuddled the pegasus' labium with Pinkie holding its other side. As she was about to actually start enjoying the fake cock tickling her with a slight blush and almost-appearing smile, it was suddenly forced inside the other hole instead.

Ditzy hollered out her muffled voice again, feeling the fat thing brutally ripping her rectum with at least three inches in distance reached. And without any form of lubricant, it sure did burn inside the cross-eyed pegasus as the dildo slithered deeper another inch. Like it was about to tear her apart, she couldn't hold back the tears anymore from her lashed eyes. Pinkie enjoyed to see the suffering pony, but narrowly did she knew that competition was just a few meters away from her; the white unicorn with a fetish-based excitement as her own ecstasy aroused even more. Thus the pink pony now decided to place the other end of the dildo inside her pussy unlike she did with Ditzy. With her knees still on the bed, she lowered herself to arch the sex toy, getting closer to the pegasus' nether as she enjoyed every inch the fake cock crept deeper inside her flower.

"This wont hurt... when it's over... so much", she scared the gray pony with before thrusting up and down the first time to push the toy deeper into Ditzy's rectum. A concentration of mixed pleasure and suffering struck her every time the other pony almost jumped with the dildo rubbing everything behind her pink lips. Everything to enhance the pain while improving her own satisfaction. Rarity loved everything about it. The way Pinkie dragged her hooves across her partners' torso, whenever she moaned with a holler, straightened her flat hair while riding her blonde mate, the stockings and corsets, everything! But the without doubt best part, and the most exciting part of them all, was when Pinkie suddenly pulled up the carver knife again, holding its cutter along Ditzy's throat.

"Deeper, you slut" she said while grinding her hip to keep the dildo in movement even though she stopped thrusting. The gagged filly shook her head with fear over feeling more intense pain inside her anal, but the rough sexist proved to be an even rougher negotiator as she lowered the blade to her marehood. The cold steel caressed her clitoris, causing the pegasus' to yelp. "I said: deeper!", she roared with that evil smirk on her face. Ditzy might be slow, but she wasn't retarded, thus trying to relax her behind with all her focus even though her most precious parts were held hostage.

The images inside the cross-eyed filly's head remained a mystery for Pinkie, even though she really would like to know what the hay the pegasus thought of to remove all tense in her sphincter so fast. However, now her part of the dildo could reach further in, allowing the pink pony to slide closer to her forced friend. "Ye~es, that's fucking good, you cross-eyed whore, take the cock inside you, take it!", Pinkie yelled at her, keeping up the thrusting again to press the dildo another inch deeper. Ditzy whimpered even more as the slippery thing itched and ached her sensitive hole, forcing out more pleasure and distress again with the small movements it made. Rarity was still a bit disappointed over the lack of blood on the pink pony's knife, but she found compensation in relishing over the gray filly's pain.

Drool dripping from Pinky's mouth, sweat soaking Ditzy's body, love juice pouring from Rarity's marehood, the knife laying next to Ditzy with a very small stain of blood on, it all boiled together in a hot concoction they all enjoy and suffered. The white scrawls covering most of the pegasus' upper body turned Pinkie on one last time, the final drip for her to feel the sweet tingling inside her crotch. With a piercing hollering, "fuck yeah! Yes, yes, ye~es!", Pinkie reached her peak in pleasure, covering her part of the dildo in wet, sticky cum. The cross-eyed pegasus, however, only felt some drips of the pink pony's ejaculation soaking her sphincter, nothing more.

It was pure luck that the sadistic pony screamed out so loud precisely at that moment , otherwise she would have heard Rarity's too. Laying almost passed out on the stair, a soaking wet unicorn with her best orgasm ever could be found gasping for air. It was finally over for all of them, leaving two out of three ponies fully sexually satisfied.

White hooves carefully stepped down to the bottom level's floor. Rarity, still dizzy from the experience of finding sexual pleasure in the torture scene she just left, slowly walked to the door in front of her. It was finally time to go home and never speak of this again. If she would, leading questions could bring her to her very own downfall. In other words: go, forget it happened, pretend like nothing, and just smile when you see Pinkie Pie again. A confident sigh left Rarity's mouth, allowing her to use new found courage to keep up with the regular day after exiting the door while holding the bell above it still with her magic. However, she recently had some plans on getting the same kind of carver knife Pinkie had...

Pinkie Pie's hair had exploded, returning her poofy and glad personality again. Ditzy's gag and ropes laid still on the floor, letting the corset-dressed earth pony passionately kiss her equally dressed lover as they stroke their hindlegs against each other. With their forelegs around each others necks, they temporarily paused the kiss and looked each other deeply in the eyes. Ditzy was no longer cross-eyed, and her way of talking had changed when she whispered, "I think she liked it...", then passed the word to her love. "Yeah, that's why I planned this, silly", Pinkie replied and thought for a moment. "What do you say we do it for real now, Ditzy?", she asked and smiled. The pegasus smiled back, "you know I do", and brought her hooves to the pink pony's cheeks to continue the kissing. Even if the taste she always loved was capturing her mind, Pinkie looked at the coffin she brought her toys from. A poster with the names of all ponies in Ponyville, which you only could see from the bed, hanged on it. Several were crossed, like for an example; Mayor Mare, Big Macintosh, Lyra, Fluttershy and more. She reminded herself to cross off Rarity's name too before soaking her tongue even more inside Ditzy's mouth...

END

The third. Admit the taste of this fic is REALLY in the darkest corners, even if it happened to end quite well

Not much to say here, just gonna add that the fourth one will come soon (after I'm done proof-reading it)

The review! Oh, goodness don't forget the review if you have time :)