Title: Playing Tyler
Category: Vampire Diaries
Characters: Caroline, Tyler, Matt, Jeremy, and Julian
Summary: All Tyler thought about while being held captive was Caroline. Now Julian, still in Tyler's body, decides he wants to have her too. To get information from Julian their friends decide not to tell Caroline that it's really Julian she's with now, not Tyler.
Status: In Progress
AN: I don't own anything if I did then a lot of things would be different. There is no Maria in this story idea. Maria was Julian's wife on the show, but here he's not married and she doesn't exist.
AN2: Thanks Forwood13 for steering me towards this idea. Hope you all enjoy it.
TC TC TC TC TC TC TC TC
Chapter 3
Caroline picked the two bags out of the fridge, of blood, before going back upstairs to the kitchen area. She wanted to warm them before she drank any of the blood. It tasted a lot better than when it was cold. She had gotten her blood type and Tyler's so that it would feel like they were maybe drinking from each other. It didn't take long and she got two cups before finding a tray. She stacked everything on it she had already and then got a bottle of whiskey. She then went to the fridge finding some left over pizza putting it on a plate and heating it up. It had been five hours since she had eaten anything. She didn't know when Tyler had gotten to eat anything since he had left that morning.
"Hey Caroline," Matt said walking in the kitchen, "You and Tyler back together?" he asked since he'd caught some of the show earlier. He just hoped it was Tyler and not Julian, not sure if she knew about Julian yet. He wanted to tell her too, but if Julian was close by and could hear like Tyler could then he would be in trouble. Julian was starting to learn how to use Tyler's body to his advantage.
"Yes," Caroline gave him a big smile before she pulled the pizza out of the microwave, "We patched things up this morning actually," she told him about Tyler coming to her house and apologizing for everything. She picked up the tray, "He's waiting on this right now, if you need anything we're upstairs," she wanted to get back up to Tyler so they could have some more alone time together.
"That's good, just if he acts different, let me know," Matt said trying to hint about Julian, but Caroline was gone before he got a chance to. She hadn't even heard him when he gave her the warning of Tyler acting different. "It might be Julian," he said out loud hoping maybe she could hear him still. He had to at least take the risk, even if it meant getting attacked. It wasn't Tyler in control if Julian attacked him and Caroline would know that.
"You could have shouted it," Jeremy said giving Matt a look, "I think that is Julian because even though Tyler said he still loved her," he trailed off knowing that Tyler wouldn't go straight back to having sex with Caroline that quick. He needed a little more time to forgive his own self for the stupid mistake he'd made. He also remembered that Tyler said he wanted to make it up to Caroline. Take her out on a real date, something they rarely ever had, and start their friendship over first. He'd screwed up so badly that he didn't know how quick she'd be to forgive him.
"I don't want to think about it," Matt didn't know what to do as it was; his best friend was possessed by a traveler. He knew what it was like because he had been in the same situation. However, he hadn't had to deal with the other half of him trying to get with his girlfriend. The girl that he really liked was hundreds of miles away in another state. "If it's Julian what are we going to do? Caroline will feel like hell all over again,"
"If Tyler wakes up and finds Caroline above or below him think about that," Jeremy said back, but he knew that Matt was right. Caroline was already feeling like hell because Tyler hadn't believed her at first. They had been trying to patch things up between their friends for months now. "He has saved her plenty of times even if they weren't really talking," he added thinking about what Caroline told him about Tyler biting Nadia for her.
"I guess, but we should be prepared in case Tyler does wake up and freaks," Matt said, "We might have to knock him out for a while," he didn't want to do that to Tyler, he was like a brother to him, Jeremy was too. If he had to he would though because it would be for their safety, Caroline's too. It wasn't like he could call Rebekah and ask for some of her brother's blood. Rebekah was running from her brother at the moment from the last phone call they'd had.
"I'll make the stuff up," Jeremy said as they left the kitchen going back to the basement.
Matt nodded, "Please let it actually be Tyler and not Julian," he said out loud following Jeremy.
He already hated the first round of vervian and wolfsbane mixed up together. Pouring the mixture down Tyler's throat had been hell on him and he wasn't even the one getting sick. Tyler had been his best friend since kindergarten when some other kid had picked on him because he didn't have a dad, Tyler had defended him. They had both ended up without recess for a week, but he hadn't minded. He got to talk to Tyler that whole week and they became best friends. They might have ups and downs at times, but he was like a brother to him and he'd never turn his back on him.
B TC TC TC TC TC TC TC TC/B
Caroline got back up to the room putting the tray down, she wondered for a moment if Tyler was asleep or not. However, when he opened his eyes looking at her, she got her answer. "I brought some whiskey and pizza too," she pulled his shirt back off of herself then slipped out of her panties before getting on the bed. Once she was nice and comfortable she set the tray on her lap. "Our favorites, blood, whiskey and pizza," she kissed him.
He kissed her back wrapping one of his arms around her, "Please tell me that the pizza doesn't have any fish on it," Julian hated pizza with fish on it, he really didn't understand the need to combine the stuff with pizza. He hoped that Tyler didn't like them either; he hadn't tapped into the food memories yet, just the main stuff; the ones that really would matter if he screwed them up.
Caroline giggled, "I swear I won't ever do that to you again," she kissed his shoulder, "I am just glad when you became a hybrid you couldn't die from anchovies or any other kind of fish," she also had found out the reason he would never touch the pizza casserole she'd made when they had been in middle school. She had told him to eat it and if there were then she'd be rid of him because he'd been being mean to her that whole week.
Julian took in mind now why Matt had looked at him like he was crazy when he asked for some shrimp. Tyler was allergic to fish, it was going to be a big thing to remember, but then again he was a hybrid now, so food didn't bother him either. "I am just glad you didn't kill me years ago with them," he kissed her before picking up the whiskey bottle using his teeth to open it and downing some of it.
"Tyler Lockwood," Caroline slapped his arm, "We talked about this, you were not raised in a barn," she couldn't help but smile though glad to have him back. She loved the little things that he had done that she missed, even if they annoyed her. She hadn't thought about the way he'd open a beer or bottle of whiskey in a while. It got on her nerves because she didn't want him to hurt his teeth, she loved them. She loved what she could do with his mouth and other body parts too.
"I was chained up in a cellar for while by you," Julian said giving her a grin before handing her the bottle. "I think you jumping me before I turned that night proves I got some…"
Caroline quickly covered his mouth with hers not wanting him to go talking about that. "Jeremy and Matt might not be able to hear or Bonnie, but there are three other vampires here," she didn't need Damon, Elena or Stefan finding out she had in fact slept with Tyler during his first full moon. They had been flirting all week and she'd been single, there had been no crime committed between them. "I might however, tie you up in the cellar again, well here," she gave him the sexiest look she had biting down on her bottom lip.
B TC TC TC TC TC TC TC TC/B
"Keep that up and we won't be eating anything," Julian said pouring some of the blood into the glasses. He didn't like the thought of needing blood to live, but if he was going keep up this body and appearances, he had to. He found that he liked it, or maybe it was that Tyler had to have it. All he knew was his fangs came out and his eyes were shifting while he drank it down.
"When's the last time you ate?" Caroline asked a little worried about him the way he was drinking the blood down. She now knew he hadn't eaten anything that morning for breakfast. Ever since he had confessed to killing that girl their senior year she'd been supplying him with blood bags or her blood. She still wanted to kick Rebekah's ass for that, but the Original had given him back to them, well Matt.
"Sorry, guess I forgot to eat with everything that's been going on," Julian said quickly, which he had forgotten to eat and he hadn't been offered anything either. Damon wasn't the best host on that front, even if he was being shockingly nice to him. He hadn't thought that would be the case with the memories he had.
"Well no more of that forgetting stuff," Caroline said filling the cup up again, she shook her head mumbling about him really losing it without her, "You would forget yourself if it wasn't for me," she kissed him tasting the blood on his lips before licking it off of him once he finished the second cup.
Julian moaned pulling her as close as he could get her with the tray and whiskey between them. He kissed her like crazy threading his fingers into her hair. Caroline whimpered, moving her hands over his body, touching all she could get to. "I need you so badly," Julian pulled away looking at her.
"We eat more, then we have more sex, we have like three months to make up for," Caroline was breathing heavy as well moving her hand over his cock. She dipped her head down for a moment sucking on just the head of it. She needed to taste him so badly and she needed more of him inside of her.
"Can't wait," Julian held her head to him letting his head fall back against the head board, "Caroline," he drew out her name as she continued sucking, her tongue running over the slit, worrying it. His fingers tightened in her hair jerking his hips being careful not to spill the whiskey that was between his knees.
Caroline bobbed her head up and down his cock a few more times and she sucked at the head of his cock each time. She moved her hand down to his balls cupping and massaging them just the way he liked them. When he was ready to cum she stopped pulling back, "Now we eat and drink, think of that as the months of hell I been in without being able to cum," she took the whiskey bottle turning it up.
Julian let out a growl, he was going to kill Tyler for this, not Caroline, she was innocent; he was going to murder Tyler. It was his fault he had just been denied the right to cum. For a split second he let Tyler feel the pain his body felt not able to cum. He was yelling at the hybrid too, the whole while he was giving Caroline an eyes half opened half closed look. Tyler was going to get it good for this he thought, "I'll pay you back later for that, Care," he said though taking the whiskey from her.
TC TC TC TC TC TC TC TC
TBC
NEXT TIME ON PLAYING TYLER
"So are you going to see Vicki any time soon?" Jeremy asked just dropping it into the conversation. He knew if he said yes or anything that meant he thought Vicki was alive, it would be Julian and not Tyler.
Julian thought about it for a moment, he had messed up on the phone the first time with Caroline. She hadn't noticed it though, but Jeremy would know if he messed up. "No, there is no way I am screwing things up with Caroline," he said searching Tyler's mind for any hints on Vicki.
Jeremy got up spinning Julian around, "You're not Tyler," he said it really low not wanting Caroline to hear, "What do you think you're doing?" he asked knowing that he couldn't get Tyler back up front. Matt could only pull Julian to the front with whatever it was he said. "How long have you been in control?" he asked because last night he had told Damon it was him, as in Tyler, not Julian.