Title: Playing Tyler

Category: Vampire Diaries

Characters: Caroline, Tyler, Damon, Julian

Summary: All Tyler thought about while being held captive was Caroline. Now Julian, still in Tyler's body, decides he wants to have her too. To get information from Julian their friends decide not to tell Caroline that it's really Julian she's with now, not Tyler.

Status: In Progress

AN: I don't own anything if I did then a lot of things would be different. There is no Maria in this story idea. Maria was Julian's wife on the show, but here he's not married and she doesn't exist.

AN2: Thanks Forwood13 for steering me towards this idea. Hope you all enjoy it.

TC TC TC TC TC TC TC TC

Chapter 5

Caroline was standing in the bedroom trying to figure out what to wear when Julian walked in. She showed him the two outfits wanting his opinion on what she should wear. "Red or blue?" she asked holding the identical outfits up. The only thing different about them was the color of them and one zipped up the side, while the other the back. She smiled hoping that he would pick the blue one.

"Well, you are holding the blue up a little higher than the red one," Julian smiled before tossing the red outfit back on the bed. He had still not found a way to get his body back yet and Damon was being a dick at the moment. He was going to make the best of it though and that meant going out to wherever Caroline wanted to go tonight. She had been dropping hints all day that she wanted to go to this party. He was starting to think it was where she was taking him.

He had avoided another run in with Jeremy so far and he was really glad of that too. However, Jeremy had told what happened since he had gotten his ass almost handed to him by, the doppelganger that was his sister. He really was slipping and he couldn't do anymore of that with Caroline close by. He had to behave better, but it was hard to do that. He found that Tyler wasn't that well behaved when came to the Caroline front either. He would hurt anybody that tried to mess with her.

"Perfect, I like the blue one too," she said before slipping the dress on that he had picked out. There was an end of the year party at college and she was taking him. She knew that he hadn't been there, but he could have been if things were different. "You are going with me in the fall, I'll figure something out," she didn't want him to be a freshmen; it would feel weird not being in the same year. She had missed him so much this year, being alone and not knowing where he was sucked. There was no way she was going to go through that again either, she'd chain him up before he even thought about leaving her.

"I know you will," Julian said, zipping the dress up for her before wrapping his arms around her from behind, holding her close. He ran his hand up the side of her leg letting the dress go with it. His hand traveled to her center taking hold of her panties and ripping them off. "You're not wearing these," he said kissing along her neck. He pulled the ponytail from her hair letting it fall down over her shoulders. "I love your hair down," he met her eyes in the mirror noticing that they had changed to golden with amber highlights. He knew that they could also change with veins under them, but he reckoned this was just that of the wolf's and not the vampire part too.

Caroline smiled turning around in his arms, she loved seeing him so possessive. "Are you going to be a good boy tonight or a bad boy?" she asked searching his eyes before he pinned her hands behind her back bringing her up so they were an inch apart, "bad it is," she giggled before they started kissing.

She loved the time they were spending together. She didn't think things could get any better between them. The morning picnic that they had watching the sun come up had been wonderful. He had fed her the fruit and bagel not even watching the sun, he'd watched her. He had claimed he would rather watch her than something that was always there. They had ended up having sex right there as the sun rose higher. After that they had jumped into the water naked for a swim.

She had dropped hints to him all day after she'd seen the email about the party. He had agreed to go to even though she had thought she'd have to drag him. It was going to hopefully be the best night out and she might even get him to dance with her. She loved when he danced with her and held her close, he made her feel safe. His arms were her safe haven, he was her safety zone and she would pick him over anybody, any damn day.

"I like being bad more," Julian said before hoisting her up on the dresser that was on the other side of them. "Let's see if you're wet enough to leave," he smirked glad that the bottom of the dress wasn't tight so he could easily get it up. Julian moved his hand between her thighs keeping his eyes trained on hers. He massaged her thighs before teasing her southern lips with two of his fingers. Caroline hissed in pleasure when he finally brought them against her clit.

Julian worked his fingers over her clit, quick and fast a few times, the whole while kissing her. Caroline squirmed holding onto him, her fingers curling up in his hair, her eyes shifting wanting so badly to bite him. She missed biting him during sex or any time really, "Tyler," she moaned before Julian pulled her off the dresser turning her so her hands were on it. He knew that she'd been close to biting him and that wasn't happening yet. He quickly unzipped his jeans lifted her dress and thrust into her from behind. "TYLER," she screamed out in pleasure holding on tight to the dresser.

He sucked at her neck thrusting in and out, "I'm sure you can scream louder," he ran his hand over her bottom before bringing it down spanking her. She jumped and rewarded him with a shout of his name. Caroline bucked against him as he took hold of her hips thrusting faster, connecting with all her sweet spots. She was panting, yelling his name in pleasure, clinching around him.

Julian smiled spanking her bottom again, "Tyler, please," She begged him to go faster and he did moving them once again so she was leaning over the side of her bed. He hadn't pulled out while he moved them either. He covered her back pounding into her, he didn't know what had come over him, and he needed to dominate her. He was starting to think the wolf part of Tyler was trying to take over. He growled against her ear slamming in and out of her body hearing her cries of pleasure. He pulled out thrusting back in filling her with his cum moaning her name out.

Julian pulled free of her, fixing his jeans back before helping her off the bed. He kissed her letting her fix her dress, and then took her hand before they walked out of her bedroom. He wasn't sure how he felt about dancing; he hadn't done it in so long. He knew that Tyler wasn't big on dancing, but he'd dance with Caroline. It was one of the things he did for her. There were a lot more things that he could tell Tyler did for her and he was trying to get all of them in his mind. It was hard acting like he was somebody else, but if it got him time with Caroline he would. He would do anything just to have time with her; he was falling in love with her.

Caroline smiled looking down at their hands so glad that everything was going perfectly again. She didn't want to think about what happened after things went perfect. She was already getting butterflies in her stomach. It was just something about the way the others were acting. She'd asked Jeremy where he got the bruise and he'd quickly said training session with Damon, he forgot to duck.

She hadn't even known that Damon was giving him any lessons or why that would cause Elena to borrow Tyler. She shook her head; she had to put it all out of her mind. Tyler and she were going out to a party. She would deal with the bad when they got back, if things got even more strangers. She just wanted to be in total bliss with Tyler, not worry about their possible pending deaths if they didn't stop Marcos.

"So am I wet enough now?" she asked giving him a smile.

"You're soaking wet now," Julian smiled kissing her, "you're always wet for me," he rubbed her back sending chills down it. She leaned against him as they walked out the door.

B TC TC TC TC TC TC TC TC/B

Caroline wasn't happy at all that some girl was hitting on Tyler; she walked up to them taking his hand. They had been at the party for almost an hour and it seemed like every woman just wanted him. "We're going to dance," she pulled him towards the area that everybody was dancing. She didn't care that the girl yelled at her because she was taking Tyler away. "I swear I can't leave you alone more than a minute," she sighed resting her head against his shoulder when a slow song started. It was the first slow song since they had been there so she was taking advantage of it.

"They like me, but I love you," Julian said holding her close as they danced together. He loved holding her because she felt as if she fit perfect in his arms. It was like a jigsaw puzzle and they were the only two pieces to the puzzle. It didn't matter which way you put them, they would fit together just right. He knew one way that they fit together perfectly and the time they'd been spending together in and out of bed was more than fun.

Caroline smiled, "I would be lost without you, Tyler," she said closing her eyes not wanting to cry, but the song was bringing back a lot of memoires. She started telling him more things that she had been doing while they danced. She wanted him to know everything that meant anything to her since they had been apart. She was breathing in his scent even though she didn't need to. She needed his scent though and she would do anything to keep it close to her. It had started wearing off of her covers and the clothes at his house had started smelling like the closet.

Julian held her securely telling her he was never going anywhere again. The whole time he was yelling at Tyler for being so horrible. He was letting the hybrid see what he had done to the girl he loved. That was the biggest thing of all Tyler still loved her no matter her flaws. Julian took in her scent putting it to his memory just in case. He would always be able to remember this long after he was gone.

The way things had been going he was starting to think that he might end up dead. Jeremy, Elena, Matt and Damon were all threatening him, which was making it harder to not just snap at them. He had somehow convinced Elena he was Tyler, he just wasn't sure if he had the others convinced.

"I have been lost without you, Carebear," they kept dancing not even caring that the song had gone from slow to fast. Julian kept holding to her, dancing to the same pace as they had been. He could hear Caroline's tears over the music thanks to his super hearing. He was probably torturing Tyler with all that was being said, but he couldn't seem to care. Tyler's friends had tortured him; he'd do his own version of torture right back. This was worse though and he knew it by the reaction that Tyler was giving. The hybrid was trying to shut it out because it was hurting him. Julian laughed on the inside refusing to let Tyler hide from what he had done to Caroline.

Caroline smiled pulling back looking up at him, she started to apologize again for all that happened, but Julian cut her off. He wasn't going to let her keep apologizing over and over. He kissed the tears on her cheeks before following them to her lips. They tasted like salt and he let his tongue slide over her lips until she parted them. Caroline let him take control not wanting to fight with him for anything right now.

It was a few minutes before they stopped kissing since they had no use for air. They were in the middle of the dancing area with everybody around them dancing faster. They were just standing not moving, just looking into each other's eyes. Julian could tell that something had changed in his own eyes as he watched hers. "You're beautiful, don't ever change," he moved his thumb over the veins under her eyes.

"I never will, I'm only for you," Caroline said back taking his hand before leading him off the floor to find a place so they could be alone. It was going to be hard since most of the people were making out everywhere or dancing. She walked until she found an area that looked somewhat private pushing him against the wall. She giggled before attacking his mouth with her own again.

B TC TC TC TC TC TC TC TC/B

Julian kissed her back moving one of the dress straps down cupping her bare breast causing her to moan into the kiss. He couldn't get enough of touching her it was like she brought him to life even though he was dead, well sorta dead. He was starting to think he was Tyler at times since he was pretending to be. He spun her around so she was against the wall, instead of him. She was moaning as he moved his mouth to her neck, while pinching and twisting her nipple between his fingers. He pulled at it making her gasp, her fingers tightening their grip on his waist.

Caroline closed her eyes not giving a damn that people could see them. The things he was doing to her body were making her legs shake. Any reasoning to stop had gone out the window the second he'd started sucking at her neck. Julian moved his mouth down capturing the nipple he'd been punishing with his fingers as he cupped her other breast with his hand. He gave the twin the same treatment making sure his teeth didn't graze her.

He heard somebody behind them turning his head to see somebody stumbling past them. He let out a growl, glaring at them. He wanted alone time with Caroline, but he went back to what he'd been doing once they left. This time he was working on her right breast, giving it pleasure too. If somebody wanted to watch they wouldn't see anything on her. His body was covering Caroline's and the wall was blocking the view from the other side.

Julian kept moving back and forth between her breasts until she was crying out as she went over into her orgasm. He quickly fixed the straps on her dress picking her up in his arms bridal style and making his way to the first empty room he found. He laid her on the bed once he got the dress off of her thankful he'd picked the side zipper, not the back. He peeled the dress off her tossing it on the floor kissing his way up to her center.

Caroline whimpered watching him moving up her body, "Tyler, please," she didn't know if she could wait much longer to have him inside of her. Julian wasn't listening though he wanted to have her as long as he could. He had to take his time and love her the way she was supposed to be loved. He ran his tongue along her southern lips, letting it dip down just barely touching her clit. She squirmed under him and he held her hips as he pushed them apart.

"You're mine," Julian looked at her glistening opening before darting his tongue into her opening, moving it in and out like he would his fingers or cock. Caroline gripped the head board that was above her as he fucked her with his tongue. Her cries were getting louder as he picked up the pace. The music would drown them out however; nobody was going to hear them as he pleasured her.

Julian sucked her clit into his mouth using his tongue to lick at it until she was begging for him to let her cum. He looked up at her, his mouth covered with her juices giving her a grin, "Not yet," he moved back to his task pushing her legs up as far as they would go against her body before he started thrusting his tongue in and out of her opening again.

Caroline bit down on her lower lip trying to hang on, but she was so close to going over. Julian took a moment to think as he figured out which thought would bring out his claws. He wanted to taste her so badly. He had been drinking blood for days and wanted to see what she would taste like. She had said it was her blood type, but he had to find out if the bag or her tasted better. Caroline gasped feeling pain and then pleasure go through her body as he let his claws go into her. "Tyler, I'm…" she couldn't finish because she was cumming as he sucked at the spot he had punctured.

B TC TC TC TC TC TC TC TC/B

Julian growled out loving the taste of her juices and blood mixed together. "You're better," he stated and it took everything in him not to bite into her flesh. The memories of what had happened to her before from Tyler and Klaus kept that thought at bay. He drank down everything she was giving him before pulling away moving up her body. He kissed her letting Caroline taste what he had before she flipped them over. She slammed down on him moving at a quick and fast pace sinking her fangs into his neck as well.

Caroline ran her fingers through his hair as she drank from him. She lifted herself up slamming back down onto him. Julian flipped her back onto her back hoping that her drinking from him wouldn't cause her to realize he wasn't Tyler. He hadn't wanted her to drink from him yet in case it did trigger something. Caroline pulled free looking up at him trying to figure out why his blood tasted different. It was like a completely different type of blood and she almost didn't swallow.

"Tyler?" She didn't know why she was asking, she had seen something and it had scared her. She'd seen Tyler squatting over her mom and somebody behind him. She'd then seen him talking to that guy who Damon said went through Bonnie. She thought his name was Marcos or something. She'd felt like people weren't telling her everything when it came to Tyler, but this couldn't be real.

"It's me, Caroline," Julian knew that he was running out of time, if she started questioning things he would have to stay away. He didn't want to stay away, he wanted to be with her, "I love you, you're my everything," he just hoped that he wasn't saying anything wrong because she was pulling away.

Caroline smiled, but she wasn't convinced that everything was okay. She kissed his cheek, flipping them over, before getting up, "I need something to drink, I'll be right back, don't you go getting dressed," she hoped that nothing sounded off in her voice as she grabbed her dress putting it back on. She needed to call Bonnie or Damon; hell maybe Matt could tell her what was going on because something was wrong.

"Don't go," Julian took her hand before she could get out of the room, "I love you, Carebear, I know it took me time to crawl out of the hole I was in," he had to convince her it was Tyler or she was going to bail and find the truth. He cupped her face looking into her eyes, he knew he couldn't compel her, but maybe he could reason with her. "It has been a while, maybe the bag taste different than me," he knew she'd been drinking Tyler's blood type from bags since they has split up.

Caroline looked down not wanting to think about that, "Maybe," she wasn't a hundred percent sure, but she had to believe in Tyler. She couldn't doubt him when he had forgiven her and they were back together. She had forgiven him for his wrong in the whole mess too, "I'm sorry, I guess I just missed you so much," she wrapped her arms around him. She held onto him hoping that she wasn't doing the wrong thing. She had to believe in him and not get scared every time something felt off. It was Katherine's doing that she felt this way right now, it was Tyler, she said to herself, in her head. She figured the Marcos part was from when they had kidnapped him, which had to be the only reason Tyler had been near the guy.

"It's okay," Julian knew he had to make sure she didn't drink from him again. She would know the truth if she did. He had convinced her it was where they had been apart, he just didn't know what he would say if she questioned him on anything else. She'd had a look in her eyes that said it was more than the taste of his blood. He hugged her back rubbing her back wishing he could do anything to make her see he was Tyler.

TC TC TC TC TC TC TC TC

TBC

NEXT TIME ON PLAYING TYLER

They were worried that somehow Julian, thinking he was Tyler, would find out and go after it at some point. It was a good reason to be worried, because he was going to find his body and destroy it. It had finally come to him to do just that, he didn't want to let Caroline go. After maybe a year or so he could tell her the truth, the other side would be gone by then and Tyler would forever be gone. The only thing he had to worry about was keeping Bonnie from telling Caroline when Tyler's spirit had to cross over into her.

...

"He can't," Julian looked panicked, "Please, I need more time with her, Bonnie," none of them owed him anything because of what he had done. He took Tyler's body as his and locked their friend so far down inside he couldn't get out much. "This body is better than mine; I'll share with him," why did he have to be screwed over yet again, "Katherine killed the woman I loved years ago, don't take Caroline too," he asked what would happen if somebody took Jeremy from her, "How would you feel?"

...

Liz didn't say a word until they were a good mile from the house though. She knew that vampires had good hearing and Tyler could always hear twice as good. She wasn't risking anything on this, "Caroline, Tyler's possessed, and I have proof," she glanced to the side seeing Caroline's stunned look as she kept driving towards the place that her ex-husband had kept their daughter.