A/N: Inspired by two of my favorite movies Freaky Friday and It's A Wonderful Life. May become a series, I'm not sure it all depends if people like this or not. First time writing a Glee Fan Fiction so please try to go easy on me. Any flames will be used to make my smores!

Summary: David Karofsky made a wish to redo his High School years and rewrite some major regrets. What if he had a sister to help him on his way?

Eventually: Whatever the Glee Characters who are writing this story decide on.

Chapter One: The Wish

Well we go not choice

All the girls and boys

Makin' all that noise

'Cause they found new toys

Well we can't salute ya

Can't find a flag

If that don't suit ya

That's drag

School's out for summer

School's out forever

School's been blown to pieces

No more pencils

No more books

No more teachers' dirty looks

Well, we got no class

And we got no principles

And we got no innocence

David couldn't help but smile fondly in front of the garage door from the kitchen. How in the world did his sister, Cassidy, manage to convince their father in letting her and her band practice in the garage was beyond him. David opened the garage door and flicked the lights.

"Lights Out! It's time for Dinner, Cassidy!"

"Alright, girls. Pack it up; because tomorrow we are gonna Rock! The Battle of the Bands!" Cassidy said.

(Later That Night)

Cassidy walked out on to the deck, with a drink in hand. She sighed deeply breathing in the late summer night air. This was the last weekend she had with her brother, David, before the "Big Move." Don't get her wrong, she was happy that her brother got into NYU and will be studying business. David had his heart set on being a Sports Agent. Truth be told, Cassidy, didn't know anyone who was more of a Sports Encyclopedia then David.

After everything he went through and their family had finally gotten back on their feet. He really did deserve this. Cassidy would just have to get use to the fact of just seeing him during the holiday breaks. But at the same time she was sad to see him leave.

'Speaking of the Devil.'

"David? What are you doing out here so late?" Cassidy asked taking a seat right next to her brother.

"Taking a breather, sis." David said. "You know, I'm kinda goin' to miss this place."

"Why? You're moving to the Big Apple. The City of Dreams. Why would you miss this place? A small town that nobody knows is on the map except for when they breeze by here." Cassidy said looking at her brother.

David came out the closet earlier this year and at the same time they almost lost him because everyone in this gated homophobic cow town couldn't seem to grasp what being different really was, or what it truly meant to be yourself. Not what society says was the right way to be.

"I said kinda, sis. I'm goin' to kinda miss this place," David said. "You know, you, Dad, all the times we had together, me finally being happy and proud of who I am. Those kinds of things I'm going to miss."

"I'm going to miss you too David," Cassidy said smiling at her brother. "But at least you'd be in a city where people don't care. Be able to be yourself and maybe find a boyfriend to bring home as well."

"I know sis, I know." David said with a sad smile.

When David finally admitted to himself that he was gay and started to embrace the fact that it wasn't bad and there wasn't anything wrong with him. Was also the darkest and the scariest part of his life as well. Meeting up with a former torment-tee that David used to bully because he was gay. This made David realize that maybe he, David, could find someone that would like him and quite possibly love him. But unfortunately, it didn't go as well as he had hoped. The guy David was crushing on was out and proud and didn't even bother to hide the fact that he was also in a relationship. Albeit, a rocky relationship but in a relationship. David (and even his sister Cassidy) couldn't understand why Kurt would choose a guy like Hair Gel, but it is what it is.

When David met up with Kurt to reveal how he felt. Someone from David's new school saw them together and all Hell broke loose. David's locker was sprayed painted in pink with the word FAG on it. The Comments, the Posts, the Tweets and other things on his Facebook, Twitter, and phone. Their own mother saying that he was diseased and that he needed to be cured pronto because she didn't give birth to or raised a fag of a son. But the worst came from him. The "supposed" brother from a different mother and best friend, Azomio. Instead of supporting David and helping him through everything like a true friend. He told David that he didn't want anything to do with him and that David should have stayed in the closet or should have tried harder to not be gay.

But, through it all David came out of it, sitting here with his sister, and now off to the Big City. He couldn't be happier. Well, except for one thing . . .

"Do you think wishes could come true?"

"What?" Cassidy gave David a confused look. "Where did that question come from?"

"Well," David thought for a minute. "You know how you did something that you really regretted later on in your life and you just wish you could do it all over again?"

"David, I'm going to give you the same advice as Grandma May. Be careful what you wish for." Cassidy advised. "Look, it's late and I need to head to bed if we have any chances of winning the Battle of the Bands. Which we will." Cassidy stood up and head to the house. She paused when she entered the house and looked at David. "You know David. Sometimes, if you really want it. Wishes can come true."

David smiled and saw Cassidy disappeared to her room. David knew that sooner or later he needed to head to bed too. David looked back up at the sky, the stars and the moon shining brightly. He really did made some bad choices when he was in high school and like many people really did regret a lot of them. He just wished . . .

"A Blue Star. Star light, star bright, the first star I see tonight. I wish I may I wish might have this wish I wish tonight." David smiled and chuckled to himself. Man, how long has it been since they sat around and watched that movie together? But Grandma May's words ran through his head.

Be careful what you wish for . . . "Because it might come true but not in the way you wanted it too." David recited. He looked backed up at the sky. "I wish . . . I wish . . ."

What are you so afraid of? Do you not know how special you are? That it doesn't matter what those Neanderthals' think? Because they won't have an education! That won't go college! They will be stuck here in this god forsaken cow town for the rest of their lives! Why are you so determined to be like them?! Can't you see how special you are?

His words still fresh in David's mind when he went too far. David still wanted to make things right with the Gleek kids. No. That was a total lie. David wanted to make amends and redo everything he did to the one person he targeted because he, David Karofsky, was too scared to be.

"I wish . . . I wish . . . I wish I could go back in time and redo my high school years. I really, really, wish I could have made some better choice and rewrite some regrets." David said not realizing the silent tears running down his face.

David stood up and headed back inside the house. Not seeing the Blue Star he made a wish on twinkle, sparkle and shown more brightly then the others.

Beep. Beep. Beep. Beep.

David groaned as he rolled over and slammed his hand on the annoy alarm clock. David groggily got up and got ready for the day. It was the weekend before the "Big Move," the last weekend before the last week of school aka parents dragging their kids to stores for "school shopping," the last weekend to spend with his sister. It was also Rising Star: Battle of the Bands show down.

The Battle of the Bands have been an underground tradition: Unknown bands trying to get notice. The winner of Battle of the Bands gets a week's time of cutting a Demo in the Studio and an interview with the local Radio Station (if they like you that is). David knew it's been his sister's dream to win Battle of the Bands and to hopefully get her band, The Hex Girls, a Record Deal.

And now Rising Star was hosting it. Rising Star was the TV Show kinda like America's Got Talent or American Idol. Only it's for Bands and Singers, to compete and the winner gets a one year deal recording contract. It may not seem like much but that one year could mean someone having their dreams come true (a one hit wonder or not) or too keep trying and hoping an opportunity like this knocks again.

David knows that his sister's band good. Really good. And he also knows how hard it is for an all-female band to make it. If you're not the next Britney, Madonna, Christina or someone like them. Then its thanks we'll call you. Hopefully, this was just what his sister needs to get notice.

David's ready and looks at his alarm clock. Plenty of time to get breakfast. He looks at the calendar and sees the date circle. David was about to leave when he does a double take. It reads August 15, 2009. Wait, what? 2009? It was the summer of 2012. How did he get back to the start of his sophomore year? Then the memory came back to David as though it was a dream.

He was outside on his deck, he and Cassidy talked. Cassidy went back inside to get some sleep for the Battle of the Bands. He saw a Blue Star and made a wish. Holy shit! The wish! David made a wish to redo his high school years. To rewrite some major regrets he had with the poor and bad decisions he had made. That means . . . He was given a chance. Some sort of second chance to get it right this time. Maybe, he could join the Glee Club this time around without feeling like he had to choose being a jackass to stay cool. Maybe this time around he could come out to his friends and family without the hard backlash. Maybe this time around he could get up the nerve to ask out the guy he secretly had a crush on for so long, even if he only liked David as a friend. At least it's a step in the right direction.

Maybe . . . Ah, David will figure out the list later on what to do this time around. Right now breakfast.

A/N: So what do you think? I am going to change a few episode names around and quite possibly have some episodes from different season be in the different time frame. But I will let you know which ones they are. Working on Season 1 of Glee. So, hopefully updates won't be so far and in between.