Finn stood at the blackboard, thinking.
He thought of all the memories he had with Rachel.
He started to realize how much he had lost.
Quietly to himself, he started to sing,
She rode in
My little sandy town
She spent the summer there
A couple houses down
Well it was magic in the air
When she caught my eye
We shared three short months
And one long goodbye
Behind him, Puck listened to him and smiled.
He started to think of Quinn and all he had lost as well.
He joined Finn in the song.
She was the one that got away
The one that wrecked my heart
I should've never let her go
I should've begged her to stay
She was the one that got away
Yeah, the one that got away
Puck took up the next verse, Finn smiling at him.
Well she kissed my lips
Down on Ocean Drive
She set my world on fire
On the fourth of July
We wrote our names in the sand
Under the star-soaked sky
But it washed away like she did
With the rising tide
They heard Sam come in and join them in the chorus,
obviously thinking of Mercedes.
Every summer that rolls around
I'm looking over my shoulder
Wishing I could see her face
Wishing I could hold her
The three men sang,
She rolled in
My little sandy town
She spent the summer there
A couple houses down
An: The one that got away as sung by Jake Owen.
The person asking for this knows who they are, (blows kisses)