Oliver is completely opposite from Sophie, he cries all the time and rarely stops, despite being born with his lungs not being fully developed. He barely sleeps through the night but does not have any tummy troubles so far, later they discover he is allergic to carrots. Sophie begins to take up the habit of yelling over the baby when he cries and she wants to talk, sometimes Blaine isn't sure how to make it through the day. During the night Kurt said he would get up the first half but asked Blaine to get up the second half since he has to get up early for work. Blaine quickly agreed glad he would finally get to shut his eyes. When the second half of the night approach and Oliver continued to cry Blaine also continued to sleep. Kurt was amazed that Blaine could sleep through such noise. He tried to gently nudge Blaine awake but that didn't work so he gave in and stayed up the second half of the night as well. When morning came he was a zombie ready to eat whoever tried to communicate with him first, which would be the reenergized and chipper Blaine. Blaine promised to get up this night. He didn't. Kurt nudged Blaine a little harder to try to wake him up and even tried to beg but Blaine just stayed pleasantly asleep. The third night Kurt literally kicked Blaine out of bed to wake him up and pulled the covers all the way up while burying his head under the pillow.
After Oliver's immune system was ready to handle more people Burt and Carole had to fight with Blaine's mother on who would get to visit their grandson first. Blaine's mother argued it should be her because they still didn't want too many people around Oliver just yet. Burt won, but only because he cheated and got on the first flight after the conversation. Pam arrived the next day, and with what little sleep Kurt was getting Blaine was ninety-seven percent positive Kurt may actually kill his mom this time, especially when she started questioning why they chose adoption instead of getting a surrogate and using Blaine's sperm again. It wasn't long before their nonstop bickering woke Oliver from his nap. Blaine was positive he had a murderous glare that rivaled Kurt's. Then they argued over who would hold the baby first. By the time Blaine returned from getting Oliver and calming him down Kurt had laid out a scheduled for all the grandparents to follow. They would get equal times with Oliver and Sophie, and Kurt and Blaine would finally sleep.
Pam got to hold Oliver first since Burt and Carole had a chance to hold Sophie first. Burt still ended up being the favorite grandparent when it turned out he was the only one who was able to get Oliver to settle down from one of his crying fits. Kurt considered asking his dad to move in until his baby boy grew out of this crying phase.
When Cooper wants to visit he makes a phone call, specifically to Kurt, he would not make that same mistake twice. He again, like the others, came with gifts for both children. Things seem to go well this time between him and Blaine until Cooper brings up the title of Godfather and that though he was disappointed to hear that Sam had been both Blaine's best man and their first-born's Godfather he is willing to accept the offer as Oliver's Godfather. Blaine first gently broke the news that both he and Kurt wanted Sam to be Oliver's Godfather as well. Cooper didn't take it well. Blaine then pointed out that Cooper was already their Uncle, but then Cooper asked who would get the kids if they died tragically and unexpectedly. Blaine explained that he wanted to choose Cooper but Kurt felt that his life was too unpredictable and unstable for a child. Kurt has no choice but to defend himself with the fact that he heard about the time Cooper "accidently" left Blaine at the mall. Blaine had never actually heard that story before.
This time when Kurt and Blaine broke the news about Sam being Oliver's Godfather he simply stated that he told Blaine in high school that Blaine wanted him to have his babies. Kurt tried begging the story out of them but both remained tight lipped, but Kurt knew all the methods of dragging secrets out of Blaine so he wasn't too worried. Sam had also been a wonderful help with Sophoe. She had not taken to her new sibling well until he taught her being an older sibling could be great. He showed her ways she could help her brother that their daddies didn't or couldn't do, like sneaking an extra cookie, or hanging upside down on the monkey bars. During Sam's visit when Oliver woke up from his nap Blaine went to go grab him, Sam insisted that when he returned he would get to hold his Godson. However, once Oliver was out of his Daddy's arms and into Sam's he started screaming his head off. Kurt rushed over to console him just explaining to Sam that he gets scared around strangers. Sophie, the clever girl she is, pointed out that the baby was scared because he couldn't see Sammy's pretty eyes. From then on Sam, with the assistance of Sophie, would pull his hair away from his face whenever he was around the baby.